r/Outlander • u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Jul 05 '21
6 A Breath Of Snow And Ashes Book Club: A Breath of Snow and Ashes, Chapters 8-16
We open with a letter from Lord John Grey dated April 1773. William is in England and LJG has in his employ a soldier involved in the Boston Massacre. Bobby plead clergy and was branded with an M on his face. LJG sends that soldier, Bobby Higgins, to the Ridge with a delivery of goods and asking Claire to do a medical exam on Bobby. The Browns show up threatening to take Bobby as they are now leaders for the Committee of Safety. Lizzie has another attack of malaria forcing the Beardsley twins to trade with the Native Americans for medicine, with which Jamie goes along.
Roger Mac is dispatched to Cross Creek to gather up the new batch of tenants for the Ridge. They are Protestants so Tom Christie goes along as well. We learn that Stephen Bonnet found Jemmy while in town causing Roger to go on alert. Jamie successfully negotiates with the Cherokee, and after a misguided attempt of a “gift,” returns home to Claire.
- What do you think about Claire’s thoughts towards Lord John and his possibly taking advantage of Bobby?
- Jamie tells Claire how he offered himself to LJG in exchange for watching over Willie. Jamie said if LJG had agreed to the offer he would have killed him. What do you think of that?
- Why does Jamie not want to become an Indian Agent?
- Do you think there is merit of the fortune tellers words to Jamie that he will die 9 times before he finally “rests in his grave.”
- Who do you think fixed Duncan Innes’s lip? Was it a fellow time traveler?
- Any other thoughts or comments?
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 05 '21
Please do not reveal events from future books, or from later chapters of the current book the club hasn’t covered yet. Show talk is okay up to the current book.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
8
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 05 '21
16
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 05 '21
I have a somewhat controversial opinion about Claire’s assumption regarding John’s intentions in becoming Willie’s guardian, so please just hear me out.
I don’t deny that this general assumption—that a gay man would rape a child—is homophobic and something that is very much still as present in our time as it was back then (I live in a country rife with homophobia so I’ve heard it often enough). But I don’t think Claire is inherently prejudiced against John because he is gay, she just doesn’t have the advantage of knowing him as well as Jamie does (and definitely not as well as we do).
Re: ignorance; I also disagree with an interpretation of this moment I’ve often seen, namely that Claire’s jealousy over what Jamie and John shared during her absence compels her to “blacken LJG’s character” like that. I don’t think Claire is jealous at all; even Brianna realizes in DoA that Claire’s initial distrust and uneasiness around John stem from what happened to Jamie at Wentworth. Claire was within her rights to worry that another English officer would take advantage of Jamie—and if LJG had been any less honorable than he is, he could’ve taken advantage of Jamie easily, both at Ardsmuir and at Helwater. But Claire doesn’t know him, beyond the fact that Jamie is the only person he has feelings for, so she’s understandably suspicious of his character.
Now, I would never assume that John “would bugger a child for the sake of his father’s bonny blue eyes,” as Jamie put it, but after reading the LJG novellas, it’s evident that LJG is attracted to Jamie’s physical characteristics. He’s prone to comparing his lovers to Jamie and wondering whether their resemblance to Jamie is what draws him to them. And it’s not something that he’s able to control, especially when he’s a bit the worse for drink or provoked.
There is a scene in Lord John and the Private Matter, where John is at a brothel, gathering intel, without any intention of actually being a customer there. The madam sends a 14-year-old Scottish girl to his room, and this is what happens:
If he’s able to “project” his attraction to Jamie onto a 14-year-old girl, who’s to say what he might’ve seen in a child that is basically Jamie’s carbon copy, that would grow up to become Jamie’s doppelgänger, if he hadn’t loved him for his own sake? (which I am sure he does and always has, don’t get me wrong!) And I’m not saying that an echo of Jamie in Willie would instantly make John want to rape him, but that echo could make him have some thoughts as easily as a 14-year-old Scottish girl’s voice had, if it’s out of his control.
That, along with the threat to “teach Bree to play with fire” in DoA—an idle threat, but a threat nonetheless, provoked by her resemblance to Jamie—has enough of a subtext that makes me uncomfortable enough and able to find Claire’s assumption not completely unwarranted or as preposterous as I found it without reading the LJG novellas.
Now, I don’t personally think that John would ever be capable of abusing/raping Willie, all I’m saying is that DG has deliberately included things like that in LJG’s character that introduce the doubt, which is enough for me to feel uncomfortable. He’s a multifaceted character, with as many flaws as virtues, some are just not as evident in the main series.
7
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 05 '21
6
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 05 '21
9
u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Jul 05 '21
“He let ye look at them?” Jamie had flushed up himself at the mention of buggery; he disliked me being indelicate, but he’d asked, after all.
LOL I like that Claire's lack of sense of propriety still takes Jamie by surprise every now and then. I love all the moments where Claire is being "indelicate" and Jamie gets all hot and bothered. Erm, the incidence of the sperm and the microscope. And this entire conversation about Bobby's backside is hilarious, a tad juvenile, but hilarious nonetheless. Do you think we get Bobby in S6?
5
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 05 '21
5
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 05 '21
5
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 05 '21
5
u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Jul 06 '21
Morning friends! We were out of town visiting my in-laws for the holiday, so I'll be working on getting caught up on the discussion and rewatch today!
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 05 '21
Were you surprised Stephen Bonnet has shown back up already? /u/jolierose /u/Kirky600
3
u/Luisaa1234 Sep 19 '21
I took it as a test because in the Scottish Prisioner Jamie is concerned that LJG " buggers boys" and there is a discussion about this. He is not truly appreciative that men can love men deeply and romantically. I think Jamie gradually begins to understand this. I think J. Is seeing if LJG's morals and values are congruent.
2
u/88zz99zz00 I eat Spoilers for Breakfast 😋 Jul 09 '21
I have not read all the comments about Lord John, but quickly I want to add that gay men were not open with each other about their sexuality, most of the time not even to themselves. Imagine having such a personal secret that you can to be caution sharing even with other people who you knew were just like you, it would be just too much of a risk for his family and himself. Nevermind not being able to discuss a broken heart, longing for a lover, etc. I mean I bet that if john had a friend he could confide his feelings to, he would have moved on a lot quicker. Yet Jamie is the only person in the entirely who he can be completely honest to. I mean, if I was in john's place, I would also cling to jamie like there's no tomorrow.