r/academia • • 3h ago

Venting & griping i might be offered a TT job, but have no money to move

18 Upvotes

it’s hard climbing the academic ladder being poor with no generational wealth, it feels like.

i moved to the US eight years ago to pursue my PhD, ended up staying when i’ve got a job as an adjunct.

as of now, i have debt from previous summers when i wasn’t paid… on top of that, i spent some money moving to a different city for a lecturer position.

i’m still recovering financially, and will live for the next months like a tibetan monk to save money and pay everything i own.

meanwhile i applied for another position: a TT. it’s
still in the works, and i might be worrying unnecessarily, but if i get the offer i simply don’t have any money to move…

the city is expensive and i would not have money to afford a couple of months there with no emergency fund, since i’m still paying the bill from my last move. what would you do?


r/academia • • 44m ago

Mentoring What are your top tips for early-career academics?

5 Upvotes

If you were to start your career again, what tips would you hope someone would give you?

Personally, I am more focused on teaching and supporting students.


r/academia • • 4h ago

Job market Anyone who moved to Saudi Arabia for a postdoc? Any regrets?

0 Upvotes

For those who moved to Saudi Arabia for a postdoc, are you satisfied with your decision or do you regret it? How is the research environment, work culture, and treatment by PIs and colleagues? Are the salary, benefits, and overall quality of life worth the move?

Would really appreciate hearing honest experiences, both positive and negative.


r/academia • • 1d ago

Have your parents ever been disappointed at you since "you work in academia"?

53 Upvotes

Can anyone relate:

"You are one of the most highly educated people on the planet, you deserve a 200k industry job."

"Industry is the frontier, you are wasting your life in academia."

"Why haven't you applied for Anthropic? They are hiring."

"You are teaching cutting-edge knowledge to your students, you will definitely earn a meager salary as compared to them."

"Teaching is not a career"

"You have wasted your degree and your potential."


r/academia • • 1d ago

Research in the era of AI

26 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m an economics researcher, and I used to be genuinely passionate about my profession before the rise of AI. Lately, however, I’ve been feeling increasingly discouraged. On the one hand, it seems that AI can do almost anything (except, perhaps, for identifying and refining meaningful research questions). On the other hand, I realize that the challenge may simply be finding the right balance between using AI and doing research independently.

My main concern is about the intellectual satisfaction that comes from solving complex problems. I’ve tried to use AI primarily for writing specific chunks of code, based on pseudocode that I carefully develop myself, while continuing to work through mathematical derivations and theoretical problems independently. However, I’m increasingly realizing that this approach is much slower than relying more heavily on AI, and I worry that the future of academic research might consist of an overwhelming amount of work that even its authors don’t fully understand.

This also makes me question the future incentives in academia, whether we will still need as many researchers, and even what the role and value of researchers will be if AI becomes capable of performing most of the intellectual work. After all, even carefully verifying AI-generated results can be extremely time-consuming.
I would really like to hear what fellow economics researchers think about this. Are there people who are genuinely enthusiastic about the future of research with AI? Or do others share my concerns, particularly about the potential loss of intellectual satisfaction and the changing nature of academic research?

Thanks!


r/academia • • 5h ago

Academic politics Russian studies as the tool of Ukrainian political strategy

0 Upvotes

The whole purpose of US and European Universities' Russian culture/history departments, who support Ukraine, is the specific dismantling/destruction of Russian culture/history for the purpose of maximum benefit to Ukraine and

  1. Its cultural appropriation campaign - reclassifying elements of Russian culture into the Ukrainian cultural sphere.
  2. The destruction of remaining Russian cultural elements that Ukraine considers not its own. This has a broader purpose of demeaning and fragmentation of Russian cultural identity with the additional task of promoting ethnic/regional separatism within the Russian state.

Their main objective is to promote and advance Ukrainian political objectives/interests/goals at maximum capacity.

A noticeable feature of their work is also advocacy and promotion of "decolonization of Russia" i.e. physical dissolution of the Russian state into many territories.


r/academia • • 7h ago

How are you catching "Frankenstein citations" (real DOIs attached to wrong papers) and retracted preprints before submission?

0 Upvotes

We have been noticing a specific reference error showing up more often in co-authored manuscripts and student drafts lately. Instead of completely fake DOIs that 404, drafts are coming in with real, resolving DOIs attached to the wrong paper title, wrong year, or a preprint that was later retracted.

A basic script that only checks whether a DOI URL returns HTTP 200 passes these every single time. We ended up having to compare title, first author, and publication year separately against Crossref and OpenAlex records, and run a second check against Retraction Watch relation metadata, before anything goes to peer review.

For faculty, editors, and researchers reviewing multi-author .bib files or student manuscripts, what is your current workflow for catching mismatched DOIs and retracted citations before submission? Are your journals or departments running automated metadata checks yet, or is it still mostly spot-checking by hand?


r/academia • • 1d ago

Venting & griping Feeling down on myself after an academic conference

42 Upvotes

Just wondering if anyone can relate to this or has any advice. I am a PhD student and have just come back from an academic conference and am feeling quite hopeless and dejected. I feel like I wasted time and money attending this conference as I didn't get much out of it.

I presented a talk at this conference which I spent a lot of time preparing for. For my talk, the room was quite empty, and I was so nervous my whole body was shaking but I recieved quite a few questions from the audience which is always a positive sign (I definitely flubbed my answer to one question though since it was so off-topic I had no idea how to even frame my answer- in the future I would answer by bringing things back on topic). I later got feedback from the panel judging student talks by email, and the feedback was really positive (I didn't win any of the awards though).

I was at this conference 100% alone, I didn't know anyone at all. I approached many people at this conference to specifically talk about their research. I always start out complementary- "I really liked your talk [insert specific question/talking point]" and had some semi-productive conversations this way. But NO ONE came up to talk to me about my work, none of the folks I talked to had come to my talk or if they did they didn't have anything to say about it. Before the conference I made a list of 5 people I really wanted to talk to but only managed to talk to 3/5 of those people, I just couldn't find an "in" for the other two. I am disappointed with myself for not talking to all 5. Well, actually, I walked up to one of the 5 and said something like "great talk" to which they replied "thanks" and walked away. SO embarassing. Especially considering that I gave a talk on a similar topic to their research, which they attended, yet they didn't return the complement or stop to chat. Of the connections that I made, nothing tangible arose.

If you can't tell- I have extreme social anxiety and am super introverted so this took a lot of energy and bravery for me, and I would come back to the hotel and just stew over the many social faux paus I'd made that day. I felt like I was constantly putting myself on the line and making a fool of myself. I tried really hard (maybe not hard enough) to have open body language, and never stood in the corner on my phone like I saw many others doing, instead I would just walk up to a random student/junior scientist also alone or in a small group to chat (I would take at least one break per day to go stand in the sunshine by myself). I find myself thinking that if I can't manage conferences, I don't have a future in academia. And maybe I don't, since I don't have the drive or self confidence or networking skills (evidently). Maybe I need to consider medication to manage my anxiety, just for conferences?

On reflection, I think that my specific research topic isn't actually a good match for the conference I attended. But I needed/wanted to use up funding earmarked for conferences by the end of my PhD, and the timing of this conference was the only one that worked out. And my supervisor said it would be good timing for me to network since I'm almost finished my PhD. Hah.

Any words of wisdom or advice? Or similar stories to share? How do you assess whether you've made a successful connection/had a productive conference?


r/academia • • 1d ago

Venting & griping LLMs have ruined my advisor

131 Upvotes

Just venting. Stories and posts keep popping up about how people are going to be weary of PhD's that are graduated in the couple years around right now because of LLM reliance. I get it. Hiring a PhD who doesn't understand the fundamentals because they just used some model to write their code seems like a complete waste. So, I'm doing everything I possible can to not use chatbots for anything. There's also the angle that I'm paranoid about feeding some model all of my research for free and basically giving it a pass to go and spit that out to someone else like its a new idea, but that's semi-unrelated.

The problem is that my advisor isn't even trying to make sure I learn the fundamentals anymore and is just feeding my research into a bot and giving me the output. Every week I meet with him and whenever I ask about a derivation I'm stuck on or a process I want HIS EXPERTISE on, he literally turns around to his computer and reads the output of a bot. Or in the increasingly rare case that he tries to actually look at the problem he responds with "I'll have to think about that a little bit". Without fail, the next day I get an email that's just a chatbot answer to whatever I asked. Doesn't even have the fucking decency to start the email with a "Hey here's some info I think might help" just copy paste the bot response. How in the world am I supposed to learn anything when the people who are meant to teach it to me are turning towards bots for everything?

I can tell he's frustrated that I'm not making more progress than I am too, but what am I supposed to do?? Maybe there's a world where he can use LLMs to be more productive because he already has the fundamental expertise and has already developed the research skills needed. I don't like that approach but I could bring myself to tolerate it if he actually tried to teach me those same skills and expertise instead of passing it to the great mean regression machine. Feels like I'm doomed.


r/academia • • 1d ago

Job market How do you handle cold emails from candidates asking for jobs?

7 Upvotes

I have a PhD in epidemiology. I work as non-faculty staff for a department at a top 5 US medical school. While I am not faculty yet, I am on track for a non-tenure stream faculty position. I do not make hiring decisions in my current role.

Staff members in the department have public profiles that list their email addresses along with brief bios, including job titles and degrees. Recently, I have seen an uptick in the number of emails from parties interested in joining the department. They are often international visa-requiring candidates whose qualifications are either irrelevant or not competitive (or both) to the work my department does. The emails are obviously written by LLMs.

At first, I tried to be helpful by directing candidates to the university job posting website. Then, they got to be so many that I started ignoring them. Now, I get so many that I’m tempted to rip senders a new one for wasting my time.

I guess I’m just venting. But I’m curious if anyone else faces the same issue.


r/academia • • 23h ago

Academic politics How to send a letter to a Researcher for acceptance in a master's program?

0 Upvotes

Hello,

I'm a recent graduate who is interested in pursuing a master's degree at an elite university in China. I'm a computer science major, and I'm planning on doing a master's in Applied Computer Graphics. For me to get accepted into the program, I kind of need a researcher at the university to accept me onto his team.

The researcher I'm interested in has published amazing papers on the physics of virtual clothes and how they move on both high-performance PCs and efficient CPUs. How do I contact him in a way that improves my chances of being accepted into his research? Master's programs work differently in my country, where we basically take a test to measure our knowledge of computer science and then send the results with a study plan and a letter of recommendation from a professor or two.

I believe that, as good a researcher as he is, he must receive a lot of emails. How do I improve my chances? What do I even say?

(Also, what is the name for this type of letter? or interaction, i think im having trouble finding examples cuz i do not know how this whole asking for permission to enter a research is called to search on google)

Thanks for the attention!


r/academia • • 1d ago

Unhinged But Appropriate Quotes and Email Signatures/Sign offs to use at work

18 Upvotes

I am looking for a silly and light quote to add to my email signature as a leader in the IT space at a university. Anyone got a funny/silly/wild examples of quotes or signoffs they have used or seen. For a sense of scope, I really want to add this as a commentary on the exponentially expanding use of ai and technology as the solution to problems.

- “Once men turned their thinking over to machines in the hope that this would set them free. But that only permitted other men with machines to enslave them.” - Frank herbert


r/academia • • 1d ago

Struggling to balance family and career

4 Upvotes

Obviously the title expresses a classic, age-old problem that is not unique to me at all. But still, I want to know how others in academia do it. For context, I am a woman in my late 20s, soon finishing my PhD and looking for postdocs. I want to have children, ideally starting in the next few years, but how on earth can I have a baby when I don't have any job security? And I don't even know where I'm going to live in a year from now? Older adults tell me "there is no perfect time to have a baby, you just have to do it." There may not be a perfect time, but academia makes it feel like it is always an imperfect time. Any advice??

Edit just to say that I'm getting married soon, so the problem is not finding a partner, it's just about achieving the stability (geographically, financially, professionally, etc.) needed to have kids.


r/academia • • 2d ago Heartwarming

To the Younger Woman in Academia: You Are Not Behind

98 Upvotes

This is a letter I wish I received 5 years ago, but I am writing to all those female academics who were made to feel guilty of your ambition and delaying or not choosing motherhood.

Dear younger academic,

I want you to know something: you are not selfish for choosing yourself, your education, your career and your ambitions. And you are certainly not behind.

There will be moments when you look around and see other women getting married, having children and building families while you are still writing your thesis, applying for fellowships, working towards tenure or trying to establish yourself professionally.
There may even be people who make you feel that you are prioritising the wrong things. That your career will eventually become irrelevant. That you are postponing the most important part of life. That you will never feel ready so you just need to do it when you say “I am not ready just yet”, or that you should reconsider your ambitions because family should always come first.

Please don’t let those voices make you feel inadequate.

There is nothing wrong with wanting to become an established academic before becoming a mother. There is nothing wrong with wanting financial independence, professional recognition, intellectual fulfilment and the opportunity to see the world before starting a family.

Your ambitions are not a distraction from your womanhood. They are part of who you are.
And please remember that other women’s timelines are not instructions for your life. Some women have children during their PhDs. Others establish their careers first. Some take career breaks, some return to academia later, and some choose not to have children at all. None of these paths makes a woman more or less worthy.

What I hope we can stop doing, as women, is making other women feel that their choices are somehow misguided simply because they are different from our own.

If someone tells you that career doesn’t matter once you have children, remember that you are allowed to love your work and your family. If someone tells you that you will never feel ready for motherhood, remember that readiness is deeply personal. You are allowed to feel emotionally, financially and personally ready, even if someone else’s experience was different.

I decided to enter motherhood in later age, having completed my PhD, established myself in academia, achieved professional security, travelled, experienced the world and developed a strong sense of who I am as a person and an academic prior to being a mother. And I am so deeply grateful I didn’t do it earlier just because of the guilt others made me feel. For me, it’s very likely I would have resented my kid or my husband for “making me to lose me”.

I don’t feel that I missed out on life by focusing on my career first. I feel that I lived it. And now I am genuinely excited about this next chapter.
I don’t believe motherhood requires me to abandon the woman I spent years becoming. I hope to bring that woman into motherhood with me.

So, if you are a younger woman reading this while working towards your PhD, building your career or pursuing something that matters deeply to you, please don’t feel guilty for investing in yourself.
You are allowed to have ambitions. You are allowed to take your time. You are allowed to enjoy your life before having children. You are allowed to want both a fulfilling career and a family, or choose one that makes you feel you.

And above all, you do not have to apologise for the life you are choosing.
There is no single correct order in which a woman must accomplish the things that make her life meaningful.

Build your career. Write your thesis. Travel. Fall in love. Make mistakes. Discover yourself. Have children when and if you want them.
Don’t let someone else’s timeline or expectation make you question your own.

With encouragement,
Someone who needed to hear this 5 years ago


r/academia • • 1d ago

Invitation to review phishing attempt?

0 Upvotes

I received an invitation to review from Advanced Healthcare Materials but I am only a PhD student. The email has accept and decline link buttons and I'm wondering if this is a phishing attempt?


r/academia • • 1d ago

Publishing Priority claim and unresponsive journal

0 Upvotes

I submitted a manuscript in April in a reputable STEM journal. About two months ago, I became concerned about the results I achieved, since I never posted a preprint. I contacted the journal to ask if I could post the preprint now, since I didn't know what the rules are, since my submission itself was anonymous. Two months passed, and I never got a response. Recently I discovered that another group has reached the same result in a very similar fashion and posted a preprint. It's the same thing just achieved six months after me. This is quite bad, so I immediately contacted the journal editors and the authors of the said preprint to establish the timeline. Only, it's been a week and the journal hasn't responded to my email, and neither did the authors of the paper. What exactly should I do?


r/academia • • 1d ago

“if there’s anything at all I can help with, please let me know”

1 Upvotes

tl;dr - how and whether to appropriately follow up on what seems to be a sincere offer of career assistance from a very busy and important person?

I met a very accomplished and well-respected academic leader last week. We had a great conversation (detailed discussion about issues in our field, not just surface-level niceties) and he said that he would give me his contact information the next day. I approached him the next day and he immediately procured his card with a direct email, told me that the work I’m doing is important, and said that if there is anything at all he can help me with in my career, to let him know.

Based on our interaction, I believe this “offer” was sincere. He is aware that I am currently looking for employment and would like to be involved in organizations he is affiliated with. I’m emailing him to thank him and send an article I had mentioned to him in our conversation. I’m not sure how (or whether?) to essentially take him up on his offer, especially since it wasn’t specific. My general ask would be, if he is aware of any opportunities in our field or with his organizations, to let me know… but he is in a leadership position at a large leading institution and frankly this ask feels quite beneath him. Maybe it would be more appropriate to keep an eye on opportunities in his circle and then reach out if relevant. Another thing I would like is to hear his thoughts on my completed thesis, because I’d like to publish it in some capacity but I don’t know how to go about doing that or whether it’s worth pursuing (no one in my field has confirmed that the contents are of any value). Again, it’s a long paper and his time is valuable so I think it would be crazy to even ask him to look at it. But I want to take him up on his “offer”, not to capitalize on this connection at this point in my career would be insane! I don’t want to give the impression that I see connection as purely transactional though - which makes me want to be noble (?) and not mention his “offer” at all. I also do very much need a job or some opportunity to move forward in my career, though. For context on the stakes of this interaction, there are other academics I could ask for help too, but he is the only person I know who is situated squarely in my field of research rather than just being in academia in general.

Any advice for how I should proceed? I am very new to the world of academia (and to the professional world in general) and don’t want to miss out on a potential opportunity for growth, but also don’t want to come across as unprofessional or overly green in my response. What is the normal or accepted thing to do here??

option a: send email with thanks and the article we discussed, with no call to action

option b: send email with thanks, article we discussed, and a general reminder that if he becomes aware of any opportunities for further involvement in our field or with his affiliate orgs i would be grateful if he would keep me in mind (??)

option c: send email with thanks, the article we discussed, and a specific ask (need advice on what the ask should be - connection to a specific organization, connection with someone he knows who might be interested in helping me to publish my thesis, etc?)

option d: open to any ideas you may have

thank you for reading, wishing you all the best in your current pursuits!!!


r/academia • • 1d ago

Research issues Let's talk for a second about Foucault

0 Upvotes

If you proceed to make the simplest Google search, and go searching "The dangers of child sexuality", having the presumption you go in a critical way to find things about this interview, you might be surprised.

Michel Foucault, the Father of Critical Though as some might actually call him, made a public intervention on that interview about the laws of consent.

Can we approach this in a critical manner, or is it something that's long forgotten and doesn't have relevance for CT? I repeat, the interview is right there, the first result on Google (most probably) , so can we dissect this strange event and find out how Foucault's thinking actually works? It is, generally speaking, a type of thinking that it is working for the good, because he managed to open new fields of knowledge in Academia, as the biggest philosopher from last century that he is,and yet he made that type of argumentation. What is the REAL source for that argumentation, then?


r/academia • • 2d ago

Venting & griping Desk rejection after 8 months - WTF???

38 Upvotes

I submitted a paper of mine (my first one, as a matter of fact) 8 months ago to a relatively decent journal (in math) that is well-renowned for fast initial decisions. Within 2 days, it moved from "Submission With Editor" to "Under Review".

A few hours ago, after hearing nothing from them and the status not changing the entire time, I got an email saying that the paper was not "on par with the journal’s standards for novelty & significance in its results and/or methods" and that it had been rejected. No reviewer comments at all, and the email was from a template that was incredibly terse, uncaring and impersonal. It even said that the paper was "recently submitted"... what a punch to the gut.

Why in the world did it take EIGHT MONTHS to come to just a desk rejection??? I couldn't really care less that it was rejected, but in this time I could have submitted elsewhere where they would actually care about it or at least have decent editorial standards.

Am I being silly or is this absolutely ridiculous...


r/academia • • 2d ago

Looking to hear TT faculty who got their PhDs later, what was your experience getting back into the academic game like?

3 Upvotes

I'm applying this cycle for ecology and evolutionary biology and genetics PhDs. I'm 33 and will be 34 by the time I start (if I get in). I've always wanted to be a college professor and already have a Masters and plenty of experience, but I know that there's some ageism in academia (as well as everywhere), so what's your experience been like?


r/academia • • 3d ago

Academic politics Was told by head of search committee my application suffered because my recommenders are not prominent in the field. How do I fix this?

23 Upvotes

Throwaway for privacy reasons.

Hello all,

I am a senior postdoc applying to TT faculty positions. I have gotten a couple of zoom interviews but have not been invited for any in person interviews. Recently, I had contacted the head of the search committee for some feedback after the position closed and a different person was hired, and was told that my letters of recommendation, while they spoke highly of me, came from people that are not prominent in the field that I am applying into, and that was hurting my application. He said they liked my proposed program and track record, but had to go with other candidates that came from more prominent labs with all else being equal.

I am a little flabbergasted to be honest. I knew that this mattered but for it to be used as a disqualifying thing for a candidate feels honestly wrong?

How would I even go about fixing this? These are the people that are the most familiar with my work, work ethic, and my ability to succeed in such positions. How do I even go about finding more prominent references that can speak to my abilities without really knowing me as well as my current references do?

I can obviously control the rigor of my research program, work ethics, and research fit to improve upon my application. I would even understand if the letters just didn't speak highly of me or something. But for this to be based on the pre-eminence and how well known a particular recommender is just seems to bias hiring toward people coming from elite labs, regardless of whether they would be better at the job or not.

Any advice is appreciated.


r/academia • • 2d ago

Choosing between two PhDs

1 Upvotes

Hi, I’m posting because I’m hoping to gain some insight before I make my decision between doctoral programmes.

I’m someone who returned to school later in life, and who eventually decided to aim for a PhD. After several tries, I was finally accepted into two different doctoral programmes this year: one in Philosophy focused on the study of religion and another in Sociology focused on communication and media.

Both positions are in the same university and funding isn’t an issue at this time. Similarly, both of my projects look into digital media, and the ways we interact with it to engage with each other. They also have a similar quail-quantitative approach and use large language models, so the frameworks and possible results could be applicable outside the specific contexts that I would be studying.

To be honest, if I were to choose the programme solely on the basis of my supervisors, I would choose Philosophy because their guidance works so well with my work style and I already know that I get along with both supervisors while I don’t know the other supervisors as well. Additionally, while I would prefer to stay in academia, I know that it’s quite competitive. However, my professional experience also gives me a good chance to work at NGOs, civil society organisations, or think tanks post-PhD. So, given all this information, which of the doctoral programmes would be more useful for a career in and out of academia?

Thanks in advance for any and all input, and I hope my post makes sense since it’s quite late where I live. I will answer any questions ASAP, but that’ll probably be until tomorrow since I should be heading to bed soon.


r/academia • • 2d ago

PhD in Biology Is it possible to move to Germany and find a job?

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I have a PhD in Biology from Tunisia. I graduated three years ago and have been unemployed since then.

I'm wondering whether there are realistic ways to move to Germany and find a job without pursuing a postdoctoral position

I'm willing to start learning German and work towards a B2 level before moving, if I can find a realistic pathway to employment and relocation.

Has anyone been in a similar situation and successfully moved to Germany? I'd really appreciate hearing about your experiences, advice, or any possible routes I should consider.

Thank you in advance!


r/academia • • 3d ago

Honorary Aurhorship and Inventionship

17 Upvotes

I used to work at Amazon as an Applied Scientist in Robotics. As such, I would frequently publish many research works.

Higher management would take advantage of all scientists by tacking in their names in all of our publications and patents.

I once protested, but it fell on deaf ears.

Fastforward to now and we had a patent rejected because of that (company's lawyers got to know and cancelled the submission).

I understand that honorary authorship is just an ethical misconduct, but when it comes to patents it really is fraud.

Has anyone else been through a similar situation?