r/Albertapolitics • u/Low-Banana-3207 • 9h ago
Article The week in Oversight: November 16 to 22
Bill 43, the “Safe and Sensible Roads Act”
Coverage has focused on bike lanes. Three questions show what the bill actually does.
Who decides? The minister. New bike lanes that take road space need his written consent. Cities must submit plans covering existing and proposed rail lines. Proposed lines need his approval, and under section 0.5 he can direct changes to planning, design, delivery, asset management or safety infrastructure on any line, existing or proposed, at any time.
Who pays? As tabled, the cities. Under the Traffic Safety Act changes, section 17.1(5) makes municipalities “responsible for the costs” of removing bike lanes, and under the new Urban Rail Transit Act, section 20 does the same for transit directions. Calgary’s mayor says the premier’s office told him the bike lane clause was “a mistake” and the province will pay.
On her radio show Saturday, the premier said, “We’ve got some amendments to propose,” but didn’t say what they will change. She also said, “There’s no intention to take out bike lanes that are well used.” The bill has no usage test. Under section 17.1, any lane that took road space can be ordered removed, and it comes out automatically when the road is resurfaced unless the minister agrees to keep it. A law binds whoever holds the office next; a radio answer doesn’t. If well-used lanes are meant to stay, the amendments are the place to write that down.
Who can challenge it? On transit, the bill sharply limits that. Section 22 of the Urban Rail Transit Act bars lawsuits against the province, cabinet ministers, staff and advisers, whether in “contract, restitution, tort, misfeasance, bad faith” or otherwise, and any case already under way is “deemed to have been dismissed, without costs.” Section 23 rules out compensation for cancelled contracts.
At first reading, the minister described the transit changes as improving “collaboration with municipalities.”
The evidence cited for the bike lane changes is 14,000 responses to a complaint portal that offered no option for supporters. The province says it will now ask the cities for traffic data, after the power to remove lanes is granted.
The same bill sets safety standards for private e-scooters. Emergency and urgent care visits for these injuries rose 33% in a year, and municipalities asked for the rules. That part answers a documented problem.
What the coverage missed. At Thursday’s briefing, officials told reporters the bill didn’t say who pays. The bill says municipalities do. None of five outlets mentioned the limits on lawsuits and compensation.
In brief
Bill 42, data centres. The announcement promised no large data centres within 600 metres of a home. Neither the 600 metres nor the 10-megawatt threshold is in the bill; both are left to regulation, as are the exemptions for the Industrial Heartland. The bill restricts data centres on high-quality farmland, but lets cabinet approve one there by order. Projects already under way, including Meta’s $13 billion campus, are exempt.
Well cleanup. Companies drilling new wells after April 1, 2027 must pay up front for their eventual cleanup. The 7,328 wells already waiting for decommissioning are not covered.
Two energy decisions, one week. On Nov. 18, Bill 42 proposed repealing the Oil Sands Emissions Limit Act, which was never put into effect. On Nov. 19, the province extended its carbon capture incentive to 2035 to support Pathways and its goal of doubling oil production. The release gives no total cost.
Graduation requirements. A ministry decision, with no bill and no vote. The minister says a “mountain of scientific evidence” supports the changes; none has been published. Teachers, parents’ councils, school boards and education deans say they weren’t consulted. The changes take effect from fall 2028, after the next election.
Changed course: after school boards put the cost of new flagpoles at about $6.5 million in Calgary alone, the minister said he’ll change the regulation so schools won’t bear it.
Auditor General: the premier’s and ministers’ expense tracking was found “effective and compliant,” with no recommendations. A separate report found ministry annual reports show money spent but not always whether programs worked: “the receipt back to us about where that money is being spent.”
Emergency rooms: about four hours for the typical Alberta patient, and 6 hours 25 minutes in the Edmonton zone (Montreal Economic Institute).
Passed: Bill 34, including clearer disclosure of the total resale price for event tickets; Bill 38, advanced education, 44 to 16; Bill 36, children and family services.
Question period, Nov. 16 to 19: 49 topics. 27 substantive (55%), 8 on expenses and travel (16%), 14 friendly (29%). About 14 answers on Nov. 18 and 19 turned to the Opposition Leader instead of the question asked.
Next week: Bill 43 second reading, the Q2 fiscal update, and the UCP AGM, Nov. 27 to 29.
This week’s question: when the people who decide aren’t the people who pay, who answers for the result?
Sources: Bills 40 to 43 as introduced; Alberta Hansard, Nov. 16 to 19; Government of Alberta releases, Nov. 13, 18 and 19; Your Province, Your Premier (QR Calgary, 880 CHED), Nov. 21; Auditor General of Alberta via CBC (Zhao), Nov. 20; Edmonton Journal (Tran), CTV News (Ekelund, Franklin), CBC News (Cummings; Farrell, Canadian Press), Canadian Press (Johnson, Krugel, Patterson), Western Standard (Vasseur), Culture Alberta, Calgary Herald (Tran), Montreal Economic Institute, Nov. 2026. Corrections welcome.