r/ancientgreece • • 15h ago

From citizen to taxpayer: how the 643 years from Pericles to Caracalla hollowed out citizenship

Post image
3 Upvotes

We usually tell the fall of the Roman Republic as a story of great men — Gracchus, Marius, Sulla, Caesar, Augustus. The institutional reading is less romantic and more instructive: the republic died when the material basis of citizenship was dismantled, twice.

Greece first. Athenian citizenship rested on the citizen-soldier: a smallholder who could afford a bronze panoply (worth roughly three harvests) and therefore had land, family, and votes to defend. The Peloponnesian War (431–404 BCE) broke that class. Spartan invasions destroyed the farms; the plague of 430 killed a third of the city; returning veterans found their land priced by creditors. Plato's diagnosis (Republic): every city is in fact two cities — the city of the poor and the city of the rich — and the two never negotiate. A polis whose soldiers are landless is a polis that has already died; the corpse just keeps standing.

Rome repeats it. Expansion wars (Spain, the East) took smallholders abroad for years; latifundia swallowed their farms. Tiberius Gracchus (133 BCE) tried to redistribute public land — he was beaten to death by senators and thrown into the Tiber. In 107 BCE, Marius abolished the property qualification for military service: the landless enlisted, the state armed and paid them. The logic of the citizen-soldier — my land, my family, my votes, so I fight for Rome — inverted into its opposite: no land, no family stake, so my pay and my promised farm depend on the general. Loyalty moved from state to patron. The slave bodyguard, the march on Rome, the Rubicon — each civil war was the interest on privatized armies coming due.

The hollowing. Augustus (27 BCE) kept every republican word — senate, consuls, assemblies — while concentrating the substance in one pair of hands. By the third century the army auctioned the throne (Year of the Four Emperors, 69; roughly fifty claimants in fifty years). Diocletian's tetrarchy was not a solution but a diagnosis: the empire had outgrown single-point governance. And in 212, Caracalla granted citizenship to every free inhabitant — which reads as universalism only until you ask what the certificate still conferred: not the vote, not office, not the assembly. Only the tax liability. Public life contracted to the household; the forum became scenery. The rise of the redemption community in the same centuries was not a coincidence: when the political community can no longer provide belonging, something else will.

Discussion: The essay's closing claim: an empire is not a scaled-up polis but a different political species — participation versus administration. Where do you see the citizen-to-taxpayer conversion operating in modern states? And is exit (the essay's word) really the only rational response to a system that excludes you from participation?


r/ancientgreece • • 1d ago

Smithsonian Magazine: Have Archaeologists Finally Pieced Together the 'Parthenon Puzzle,' One of Ancient Greece's Greatest Mysteries?

Thumbnail
smithsonianmag.com
16 Upvotes

r/ancientgreece • • 16h ago

Homerology: Are there patterns of Historical Conflation, Distortion and Mythologisation in Oral and Literary Traditions?

1 Upvotes

To what extent are there parallels ot Homeric tradition in other cultures and periods of human history, where genuine historical events, people and places survive as kernels of truth within oral or literary traditions but become conflated, distorted, or mythologised over successive generations, and are there identifiable patterns in how this process happens in humanns?. I.e. Affects personal names, place names, historical figures, and the merging of individuals across generations or genders, etc. etc.?

I'm looking for recurring mechanisms and patterns of historical distortion in sort of an Archaeology of Cultural Memory approach:

For example is there data on the following:

- Are historical individuals more likely to be conflated than geographical locations?

- Are rulers, warriors and male ancestors more likely to absorb the identities of predecessors or descendants?

- Are women more likely to disappear from historical memory, or to be merged into archetypal female figures?

- Do genealogies become compressed, with several generations represented by one legendary ancestor? More often in males or females?

- Do place names preserve historical information more reliably than personal names? Or the opposite?

- Are there recurring patterns in the transformation, conflation, corruption etc. of historical events into epic narratives?

Taking Homer as an example:

The time span of the writing is ~750 years (~1450BC-700BC). That is a long time for things to get muddled up in oral tradition.

Hittite: Piyam-aradu (Greek: Piamarados) could over centuries be eventually confused with Hittite: Pariyamuwa (Greek: Priāmos).

The name was a confirmed real warlord in Troy (Tablet:CTH 181 / KUB 14.3) 1250BC

Hittite: Akagamuna (Greek: Akagomōn) could eventually be confused with Agamemnun (Agamemnon). Over 30 generations of campfires and royal courts, an archaic ruler's name like (W)akagomōn could certainly have been reimagined by bards into the majestic-sounding Agamemnon ("very steadfast").

The name was an actual king of the Achaeans who ruled over “many islands”. (Tablet:KUB 26.91) 1430BC

Hittite: Alaksandu (Greek: Alexandros) is taken directly and was a historical King of Troy. (Tablet:CTH 76) 1280BC

Hittite: Attarsiya (possibly Greek: Atreus) was a historical king of Achaea. (TabletCTH 147) 1390BC

Greek: Akhilleus (Hittite rectn: Aḫḫilawaš ?) was an actual historical Achaean high status warrior (Tablet:KN Vc 106) 1425BC

It’s obvious that the Epic Cycle has a strong foundational kernel of truth with all these names (if we allow for some drift/corruption) being the same or similar characters in archeology as they are in literature. 

The specifics are incorrect as the story has elements dating from a 750 year time span (atleast 1450-700BC).

So whether Agamemnon was Atreus’ son or the other way around, or whether Priam was a King of Troy or a conqueror of Troy, or whether Agamemnon lived at the same time as Priamos, or whether a character was actually the composite of 3 generations of the same family, etc. These are all obviously conflated in the 700 years of oral retelling. The Hittite and Mycenaean tablets give a surprisingly clear view of who lived when and what happened.

Do we have "patterns" as to how human culture distorts actual history like this?


r/ancientgreece • • 12h ago

Why charging 300 Spartans was a death trap — the real story of Thermopylae

0 Upvotes

In 480 BC, Xerxes brought around 200,000 men to Greece. 7,000 Greeks held a mountain pass for three days — the pass was only 50 feet wide, and the phalanx turned the Persians' numbers into a disadvantage. It only ended when Ephialtes showed them a path around it. I made an 8-minute explainer on the full story — and why a battle the Greeks lost still won them the war. I'm not an expert but i think I got the story right.

Feel free to check on it and point out any mistake or areas of improvements in storytelling. thank you

Tell me your honest thought after watching it . would help a lot. Im trying to improve.

https://youtu.be/kwn7whFu8IQ


r/ancientgreece • • 1d ago

Changing Perceptions of Sparta

3 Upvotes

ANCIENT SPARTA: a militaristic and totalitarian state, holding down an enslaved population, the helots, by terror and violence, educating its young by a system incorporating all the worst features of the traditional English public school, and deliberately turning its back on the intellectual and artistic life of the rest of Greece. Such, at least, is the picture, if any, which mention of the name consciously or unconsciously conjures up in the minds of most people in this country today. The liberal democratic tradition that dominates modern English thought has very naturally tended to idealize Sparta's great rival, democratic Athens; and its consequent distrust of Sparta was reinforced by reaction against a very different set of political ideas, particularly prominent in Germany, where admiration for Sparta reached a fantastic conclusion under the Nazis; to some writers, at that time, Sparta was the most purely Nordic state in Greece, and an exemplar of National~~ Socialist virtues. Two hundred years ago, however, an ordinary educated Englishman would most probably have viewed the Spartan constitution as a prototype of the British limited monarchy in all its perfection; his French contemporary might have been one of those who revered her, with Rousseau and others, primarily as an egalitarian, often more or less communistic, republic. Two hundred years before that she appeared in still other guises; as the ideal aristocratic republic, for example, practically indistinguishable from Venice. And so we might go on.
For over two and a half millennia politicians and philosophers, in the light of their own needs and convictions, have regarded now one aspect and now another of Sparta as significant. From almost the dawn of Greek history enormous prestige surrounded her, and this was exploited to recommend the most disparate virtues and institutions; the occasional reactions are correspondingly obsessive. Only Rome, sometimes as republic and sometimes as empire, has exerted greater attraction; influence cannot be measured, and is a word to avoid.

The Spartan Tradition in European Thought

I love this book and this intro because it puts into words my experience as a person who loves to read history and a person who talks on the Internet. As someone with a strong interest in early modern philosophy, specifically political philosophy, Sparta comes up a lot. (thanks, Rousseau) Their understanding of Sparta couldn't be more different than what I'd say is the "popular" reaction to Sparta today.

I love history and I love talking about it with others but it never fails to tire me out how many people are less interested in history than they are in grinding a political ax. Because Sparta's legacy has been hijacked by some garbage people, they give you a side-eye if you like Sparta. They see fit to tell you Spartans weren't the best warriors, they didn't live in some egalitarian republic, and in fact they were actually just Ancient Nazis.

It feels like any historical topic worth discussing or remembering engenders this kind of reaction. Because the Spartan legend is wrong, that must mean we take the total opposite view of the legend. YouTube recommended me this video of a guy screaming about how Robert E. Lee is the worst general ever and it's plain he's just reacting to a similar myth, that of the Lost Cause.

I just don't know why it's so hard to say "wow, they were cool and interesting" instead of falling into one extreme or the other.


r/ancientgreece • • 1d ago

The Antikythera Mechanism: Greece’s Amazing First Computer

Thumbnail
learninggreek.net
11 Upvotes

Did you know the ancient Greeks created a machine that could predict solar and lunar eclipses over 2,000 years ago?

The Antikythera Mechanism is often called the world's first analogue computer!

Discover the fascinating story behind this incredible invention.


r/ancientgreece • • 2d ago

Homerology: Are there patterns of Historical Conflation, Distortion and Mythologisation in Oral and Literary Traditions?

3 Upvotes

To what extent are there parallels to Homeric tradition in other cultures and periods of human history, where genuine historical events, people and places survive as kernels of truth within oral or literary traditions but become conflated, distorted, or mythologised over successive generations, and are there identifiable patterns in how this process happens in humans?. I.e. Affects personal names, place names, historical figures, and the merging of individuals across generations or genders, etc. etc.?

I'm looking for recurring mechanisms and patterns of historical distortion in sort of an Archaeology of Cultural Memory approach:

For example is there data on the following:

- Are historical individuals more likely to be conflated than geographical locations?

- Are rulers, warriors and male ancestors more likely to absorb the identities of predecessors or descendants?

- Are women more likely to disappear from historical memory, or to be merged into archetypal female figures?

- Do genealogies become compressed, with several generations represented by one legendary ancestor? More often in males or females?

- Do place names preserve historical information more reliably than personal names? Or the opposite?

- Are there recurring patterns in the transformation, conflation, corruption etc. of historical events into epic narratives?

Taking Homer as an example:

The time span of the writing is ~750 years (~1450BC-700BC). That is a long time for things to get muddled up in oral tradition.

Hittite: Piyam-aradu (Greek: Piamarados) could over centuries be eventually confused with Hittite: Pariyamuwa (Greek: Priāmos).

The name was a confirmed real warlord in Troy (Tablet:CTH 181 / KUB 14.3) 1250BC

Hittite: Akagamuna (Greek: Akagomōn) could eventually be confused with Agamemnun (Agamemnon). Over 30 generations of campfires and royal courts, an archaic ruler's name like (W)akagomōn could certainly have been reimagined by bards into the majestic-sounding Agamemnon ("very steadfast").

The name was an actual king of the Achaeans who ruled over “many islands”. (Tablet:KUB 26.91) 1430BC

Hittite: Alaksandu (Greek: Alexandros) is taken directly and was a historical King of Troy. (Tablet:CTH 76) 1280BC

Hittite: Attarsiya (possibly Greek: Atreus) was a historical king of Achaea. (TabletCTH 147) 1390BC

Greek: Akhilleus (Hittite rectn: Aḫḫilawaš ?) was an actual historical Achaean high status warrior (Tablet:KN Vc 106) 1425BC

It’s obvious that the Epic Cycle has a strong foundational kernel of truth with all these names (if we allow for some drift/corruption) being the same or similar characters in archeology as they are in literature. 

The specifics are incorrect as the story has elements dating from a 750 year time span (atleast 1450-700BC).

So whether Agamemnon was Atreus’ son or the other way around, or whether Priam was a King of Troy or a conqueror of Troy, or whether Agamemnon lived at the same time as Priamos, or whether a character was actually the composite of 3 generations of the same family, etc. These are all obviously conflated in the 700 years of oral retelling. The Hittite and Mycenaean tablets give a surprisingly clear view of who lived when and what happened.

Do we have "patterns" as to how human culture distorts actual history like this?


r/ancientgreece • • 3d ago

Lysistrata by Aristophanes

Post image
9 Upvotes

Lysistrata of Athens going celibate to unite Sparta and Athens.


r/ancientgreece • • 4d ago

Lysistrata by Aristophanes

Post image
23 Upvotes

Lysistrata of Athens goes celibate to unite the ancient Greek city-states of Sparta and Athens.


r/ancientgreece • • 4d ago

Why were the city states not just their own nations

11 Upvotes

Hi all!

I've recently been reading a lot about the greek poleis and all their intricacies and differences. It got me thinking about how they are genuinely all so culturally different and separate to each other, which makes me wonder why they weren't considered as their own nations. Like why wasn't Athens a mini country, rather than a city state of Greece.

My question relates to the way they considered themselves at the time, and also why scholars haven't relabelled then in modern scholarship too based on our modern interpretation of their set up.

I am aware of the fact that they all considered themselves Hellenic based on their shared aspects and did distinguish all Greeks from "barbarians" but I'm so curious as to why because they also considered themselves radically different from each other too. They essentially did act independently unless they were fighting a common enemy or each other.

I'd love to hear any insight or discussion, and feel free to recommend me reading material too! I love it all, cheers


r/ancientgreece • • 5d ago

(CH.2: The Iliad): "Book 9: The Embassy to Achilles", Illustrated by me

Thumbnail
gallery
73 Upvotes

r/ancientgreece • • 6d ago

My favorite photo from visiting the Athenian Agora today. Temple of Hephaestus in the background

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

r/ancientgreece • • 5d ago

The oldest Arabic book mentioning Alexander The Great & Cleopatra (English Translation inside)

Post image
8 Upvotes

Futuh Misr wa Akhbaruha, often translated as The History of the Conquest of Egypt, is a foundational Arabic historical text written by the Egyptian Arabian historian Abd al-Raḥman ibn Abd al-Hakam (801–871 CE). It is widely regarded as the earliest surviving account from Arab sources of the Muslim conquest of Egypt and the West. Because earlier works on the subject have been lost, later historians have relied heavily on this book, making it a primary source for the political, social, and religious history of early Islamic Egypt.

Ibn Abd Al-Hakam depends on oral narratives, and this was the common methodology of the time.

------------------------------

The Building of Alexandria

The one who built Alexandria and laid its foundations was Dhu al-Qarnayn* (the Two-Horned One), the Roman (P.S. a title given to the Greek-speaking Byzantines), whose name was Al-Iskandar (Sic).

Alexandria was named after him. He was the first to produce ornamental woven fabrics (brocade), and his father was the first of the Caesars.

Abd al-Malik ibn Hisham narrated to us, saying:

"His name was Al-Iskandar."

ibn Musa narrated to us, from Saʿid ibn Bashir, from Qatadah, who said:

"Al-Iskandar is Dhu al-Qarnayn."

It is also said that the one who built the Lighthouse of Alexandria was Queen Qilbtrah (Sic). She was the one who directed her canal until she brought it into Alexandria. Water had not previously reached the city; the canal used to branch off from a village called Kassa, opposite al-Karyun. She dug the canal until she brought it into Alexandria, and she was the one who paved its bottom.

---------------------------

*For centuries, many classical and modern Muslim commentators have linked Dhu al-Qarnayn to Alexander the Great (Iskandar). This connection is heavily influenced by the pre-Islamic Alexander Romance—a popular collection of legends (including Syriac and Ethiopic versions) where Alexander is depicted traveling to the edges of the world, wearing or being depicted with two horns (as seen on coins showing him with the horns of the ram-god Zeus-Ammon), and building a gate against Gog and Magog.


r/ancientgreece • • 7d ago

Lamp shade looks like an Apulo Corinthian Helmet

Thumbnail
gallery
37 Upvotes

My mate sent me this photo with the following text:

“Lying awake at the Wife’s parents house, and can’t help but think the shadow of the light shade looks like an Apulo Corinthian helmet”

Thinking about the real issues in life. Bravo good sir.


r/ancientgreece • • 7d ago

Lack of interest about the Hellenistic period among western audiences.

38 Upvotes

In pop history why most people focus so much in the classical era and the city-states of the south? I see very few people interested in the Hellenistic era. Many actually don't know that the Hellenistic kingdoms even existed, after Alexander the Great's empire splitted. There's a complete lack of knowledge about the existence of the diadochi wars, the unique hellenistic art, etc. Especially among western audiences. I'm Greek and in school we focus equally on Hellenistic period as much as the Classical or Archaic period. We approach them as periods of equal importance. So why in western audiences the Hellenistic era, where ancient Greek culture dominates in the entire middle east, goes fully unnoticed? It's like all the ancient Greek world were just the city-states of the south. Kingdom of Epirus, Thessaly, kingdom of Macedon (pre-Phillip II), the Seleucid Empire, Ptolemaic Egypt seem to be completely irrelevant for the average ancient Greek history enthusiast.

P.S: I'm not talking about this sub. This sub is one of the positive few exceptions in online spaces, where people are actually quite knowledgable.


r/ancientgreece • • 7d ago

Depictions of Poseidon and Athena in Greek Tragedies

9 Upvotes

Hello ancient Greece lovers,

I am directing a performance of The Trojan Women by Euripides and am struggling with deciding on the costumes for the gods, particularly Poseidon and Athena. I would like them to reflect the ancient Greek depictions of them as much as possible. Ideas would be much appreciated!


r/ancientgreece • • 7d ago

Sparta or Athens?

1 Upvotes

Personally for me, Athens because, compared to Sparta is the less worse overall. I'm more towards Athens because Athens is a democracy and Sparta is an oligarchy.

In Athens, they don't care if you're poor, a beggar, middle class, working class, or a nobleman. All free adult male Athenian citizens have an equal right to speak and participate in the Assembly, although women, slaves, and metics were excluded.

Although Sparta also had "some" democratic elements, like how male Spartan citizens also had the right to vote, the democracy in there was mostly limited because you could only vote yes or no, and voting was generally done through shouting. The Gerousia (Council of Elders) could also reject or overturn assembly decisions under certain circumstances, giving the assembly much less power than the Athenian Assembly.

Meanwhile, in Athens, politicians wanting to propose a law to the public still needed to get through the Council (Boule), which consisted of 500 citizens selected by lottery every year, with its presiding officer changing daily. This helped make sure proposals were examined before reaching the Assembly.

And if a citizen thought that a law passed by the Assembly was unconstitutional or dangerous, he could bring a case against the politician who proposed it through a procedure called graphe paranomon, regardless of his wealth. Both sides had to present their arguments and convince the jury.

To make sure the jury wasn't just one or two people being subjective, Athenian juries could consist of hundreds of randomly selected citizens, often 500, who had sworn a juror's oath. The jury would then vote on which side they supported.

And while both Athens and Sparta used slavery, and both were incredibly harsh, Athenian slaves could sometimes gather enough money to buy their freedom or be freed by their owners and become metics. Meanwhile, Spartan helots were treated horribly, had very limited opportunities for freedom, and the Spartan government traditionally declared war on them every year, allowing Spartans to kill them without the usual religious consequences.

And you know one of the true purposes of the Peloponnesian League, don't you? Besides its military and political interests, it helped Sparta maintain its dominance over the Peloponnese and protect itself against threats, including potential helot revolts. It's completely self-serving from Sparta's perspective.

And while I'm not saying the Delian League was good, at least its original purpose was a joint military alliance to continue fighting against Persia and provide collective defence, although Athens eventually abused it to create the Athenian Empire.


r/ancientgreece • • 9d ago

Eleusinian Kykeon

11 Upvotes

So for one of my university classes I was hoping to make the mysterious beverage Demeter made but im having a difficult time finding a recipe that isnt traditional kykeon. Does anyone know how i could make it or a recipe on how to make it?


r/ancientgreece • • 9d ago

King of kings

Thumbnail
substack.com
7 Upvotes

So much has changed over time that it would take hundreds of books to tell the story. Empires have risen and fallen, languages have vanished, and ethnic groups have disappeared or been assimilated… A period of roughly 2,000 years, from the beginning to the present day. The common thread among all of them, however, is the repeated use of a single title for their rulers: “Βασιλεὺς Βασιλέων (King of Kings).”

The earliest known use of this title comes from the East; the inscription (or a copy of it) in the first image is a monument commemorating a letter by Darius I (the Great) in the region of Caria. Indeed, we know from inscriptions carved into his statues that Ashurbanipal also referred to himself as “šar šarrāni (King of kings)” in Akkadian. This usage continued in the Iranian region in Middle Persian as “šāhān šāh.” Similarly, on the second-to-last relief, we see that Shapur I referred to himself as “βασιλέως βασιλέων Ἀριανῶν” (King of Kings of the Aryans).


r/ancientgreece • • 11d ago

Head of a warrior. Greek, 6th c BC. Bronze. Wadsworth Atheneum collection [4464x7936] [OC]

Post image
83 Upvotes

r/ancientgreece • • 10d ago

Writing a course book on Ancient Athens for my class. Please help!

3 Upvotes

Hi all, I'm a high school teacher and would like to write a book, something in a similar vein to "In Their Own Words" The Romans by Robert Hull. It's only about 60 pages, and is full of primary evidence. An example of the flow of his chapters are Family Life (chapter title), a brief description of the overall life the family, Head of the Family (heading) brief description followed by a Cicero quote. Then Marriages, brief description, quote on a tomb inscription, another description, Cato the Elder quote, then another etc.

I'll be teaching my students about Pericles, the Periclean Building Program, the Delian League, the Parthenon and the Acropolis, and life in Golden Age Athens.

Does anybody here have pages I could nab off you on what Thucydides and Plutarch have said about him? Aristophanes could be quite handy, too. Just anything primary you think would be useful to include :)


r/ancientgreece • • 12d ago

(CH.2: The Iliad): "Book 8: Zeus Tips the Scales", Illustrated by me

Thumbnail
gallery
73 Upvotes

r/ancientgreece • • 12d ago

I want to learn about Alexander the Great

16 Upvotes

I want to choose one book to learn about and understand the life and great conquests of Alexander the Great. Through my research of books written about him, I have narrowed my decision of what book to purchase down to three.

- Philip and Alexander: Kings and Conquerors by Adrian Goldsworthy

- Alexander the Great and His Empire: A Short Introduction by Pierre Briant

- Conquest and Empire: The Reign of Alexander the Great by A.B. Bosworth

Could anyone who has read or has knowledge of these books compare and contrast these three so that I can decide which one is the best option for me to purchase? Thank you all and may the Lord Jesus Christ be with you and your families.


r/ancientgreece • • 13d ago

The "Hunters Frieze" from Philip II's tomb at Aigai.

Post image
75 Upvotes

On the tomb of Philip II is a beautiful painting, The Hunters Frieze. Recently reconstructed by H. Brecoulaki and the “ReVis” team, the scene depicts King Philip killing a lion (and a young man, perhaps his son Alexander, taking aim with a spear).

Are ALL their reconstructions correct? Hopefully, but in any case, it's the best a team of great scholars could do.


r/ancientgreece • • 13d ago

Ancient Greek ritual?

6 Upvotes

A friend of mine from Greece has lived in the United States his whole life, his mother passed away several years ago but he remembers when he was a little boy his mother did some kind of ritual with a sword and several candles. I thought I would ask someone to learned people here, does that sound like any kind of ancient Greek ritual you know of or some religious right that was native to the Greek?

Thanks!