r/Askpolitics • • Apr 06 '26 Wholesome Seal

MOD POST Respect the Flair: Zero Tolerance for Personal Attacks and Political Projection

52 Upvotes

Following the recent announcement of our new “Advice for Life” flair, it has become necessary to address the behavior we are seeing in the comment sections.

The purpose of this subreddit is to foster the exchange of political ideas and information. The addition of the "Advice for Life" flair was intended to provide a space for practical, real-world applications to navigate a politically charged environment. However, some users have taken this as an invitation to engage in hostile behavior that violates the core principles of this community.

Let this post serve as a final warning regarding the following behaviors:

  1. No Personal Attacks

We have observed an uptick in users attacking the character of others rather than engaging with their arguments. Disagreement is expected; disrespect is not. If you cannot make your point without resorting to insults, name-calling, or condescension, do not comment at all.

2. Stop the Political Projection

A recurring issue in the recent posts as of late involves users "diagnosing" or projecting motives onto others based on their perceived political leanings.

To be crystal clear: Assuming someone’s moral character based on their flair or party affiliation is a violation of civil discourse. Assigning malicious intent to a question or a piece of advice simply because it doesn't align with your worldview is unacceptable.

3. Focus on the Content, Not the Poster

The "Advice for Life" flair is for seeking and giving guidance on navigating a politically charged world. It is not a battleground for you to vent your frustrations about the "other side." When a user asks for advice, respond to the query. Do not use it as a springboard to generalize about entire groups of people or to harass the OP.

Moving Forward:

Effective immediately, the moderation team will be taking a stricter approach to these violations:

  1. Temporary bans will be issued for first-time offenders of the "No Personal Attacks" rule.
  2. Permanent bans will be issued for repeat offenders or those who engage in targeted harassment.
  3. Comments that rely on "projection" or bad-faith generalizations will be removed.

We want this to be a place where people of all political stripes can seek understanding and practical help.and most importantly participate in the discourse. We will not allow a toxic minority to ruin that for the rest of the community.

Respectfully,

r/askpolitics Mods


r/Askpolitics • • Feb 19 '26

MOD POST Partner Community

15 Upvotes

Hey folks!

The mods had the folks at r/PoliticalDebate reach out to us and ask about partnering up with us. As a team, we mods discussed it, and decided that it would be beneficial for our community to partner with this community. Below is their introductory post. If you want to, feel free to go there and participate in their community. We look forward to seeing some amazing conversations in the coming weeks!!

Thank you so much for being an amazing community!

Fleet

First and foremost we would like to thank the mods at r/AskPolitics for agreeing to partner with us, this is probably one of our biggest partnerships in terms of politics so we're pretty grateful! We'd also like to thank you guys for checking us out!

You'd think that a subreddit with a name as obvious as ours would be huge already but about 2 years ago we inherited it dead in the water with 1.6k members. Since then we've expanded rapidly and have built a community that is on a trajectory to becoming one of the top political debate subs on reddit!

Our subs are similar but different in key ways. r/AskPolitics is primarily US politics and exclusive to questions, our sub is an educational subreddit as well but not US exclusive and a lot of our current community is ideology based. We have everything from Marxist-Leninists to Anarcho-Capitalists who have come together to have civilized intellectual debate, but don't think that all we are, we also have tons of in between ideologies and US based content. We believe that by bringing together diverse perspectives, we can deepen our collective knowledge and contribute to a more informed and engaged society.

We allow US politics, political theory, philosophy, history, questions, legislation, and fundamental politics like forms of government.

We're an educational sub first and a debate sub second. Most everyone has something to say that we can all learn from and be better equipped come election season.

We are pretty strict though, as we have to be to keep the sub standards high. We have rules on being civilized, keeping quality discussion, against political discrimination, and against debate fallacies like "whataboutisms" or "strawman" arguments. We require users to set a user flair to participate otherwise automod will remove your contributions. We also have a screening process for posts which mods will have to approve before they're listed.

If you guys are interested, check us out! Here's a link to our wiki and here's our guideline for discussion- The Socratic Method.


r/Askpolitics • • 20h ago

Question How do swing-district legislators handle voters who want opposite things?

3 Upvotes

My state senate district covers a college town, three dying factory towns, and a bunch of farmland. Our rep just voted for a bill that pissed off pretty much everyone I know, some wanted it stronger, others wanted it dead. Got me wondering how reps in seats like this actually make these calls. Do they prioritize whoever shows up to town halls? Whose calls they return? Or does it come down to which county party has more volunteers? Curious what actually drives the tradeoffs, not the campaign rhetoric about 'listening to all sides.'


r/Askpolitics • • 1d ago

Question How do campaigns decide which precincts get door-knocked versus phone/mail only?

7 Upvotes

Living in a place that gets frequent campaign traffic, I've noticed the pattern seems more sophisticated than just swing district vs. safe seat. Some precincts see repeated door knocks, canvassers with tablets, candidate motorcades. Others in the same district get only mailers and robocalls.

I assume this involves voter file data: turnout history, modeled partisanship, maybe consumer data. But I'm curious about the actual decision architecture. Do campaigns optimize for persuadable voters who show up sporadically? Base voters who need mobilization? Or is it simpler: chase the cheapest marginal contact until budget runs out?

Also wondering if the balance has shifted. With digital contact getting cheaper and address data getting better, does the physical visit still carry premium value? Or has its relative importance declined compared to even a decade ago?


r/Askpolitics • • 1d ago

Question How do pollsters account for people who only vote in presidential years when modeling midterm turnout?

3 Upvotes

Looking at the 2022 and 2024 results, there seems to be a pretty significant gap between registered voter models and likely voter screens, and I keep wondering how much of that comes down to intermittent voters who show up inconsistently.

Do polling firms have reliable ways to identify which presidential-only voters might be activated by specific issues or candidates in a midterm? Or is this just a known blind spot that gets discussed as margin of error? I've seen some analysts treat 2022's youth turnout as a surprise, but it makes me wonder if the models are missing something systematic about motivation rather than just habit.


r/Askpolitics • • 1d ago

Fact Check This Please It it true that non-citizens can easily vote in US elections?

0 Upvotes

Hi, so I am discussing the SAVE Act in the US and my uncle keeps saying that Democrats don't want it because they are cheating in elections. I am not from the US and have never lived there so can anyone tell me if what he is saying is true or not true at all?


r/Askpolitics • • 3d ago

Advice for Life What should I do with my family?

15 Upvotes

I 17f dont know if this is the right place to post this but no harm right?

I honestly dont known what to anymore with my family, I like to stay in the middle as a centralist instead of being right or left, but my family is all mixed

My dad and my mom are right

And my brother is far left

Every meal or conversation always leads to politics and screaming and then my brother either calling everyone racist or homophobic, which i dont believe to be true, I think my parents are definitely from an older generation so the things they say are wring but not necessarily meant badly, my parents will then call him named back, woke ect...

I just not sure anymore what to do, it seems like my family is being ripped apart by this and I seem to get the worst of it by being yelled at by both sides

Any advice?

Thanks


r/Askpolitics • • 3d ago

Question Why do some Dems want to abolish the filibuster?

27 Upvotes

I think this is a horrible idea. Imagine if the SAVE Act would have been passed without the filibuster. Democrats may never have had the chance to get back into office again. Why couldn’t a trifecta come in and pass really restrictive voting laws so that the other party never can come back to power? I find the argument from Dems to abolish the filibuster very very short sided. The filibuster saved the worst of the worst legislation from this administration to pass and forced the president to use executive orders which can be easily repealed.

https://theweek.com/politics/are-democrats-ready-to-kill-the-filibuster

Can someone explain to me the rationale bc I’m sure smart ppl that are pro abolishment have considered the above scenario?


r/Askpolitics • • 3d ago

Question What advantage comes to the Alaska democrats with running a second Dan Sullivan?

16 Upvotes

I am not here to argue whether or not the democrats had any involvement with the second Dan Sullivan on the ballots of Alaska, but to ask, under the assumption that they did, what benefit would that give them?

Alaska is a state with ranked choice voting, so even people who were “tricked” by the ballot could’ve (and should’ve) easily just ended up at

  1. Dan (not incumbent) Sullivan
  2. Dan (incumbent) Sullivan
  3. Whoever else

And ended up voting the exact same as all the people who listed the incumbent first.

Republicans are very quick to blame this election on the “cheating” that came from adding a second Dan Sullivan, but does having him there even provide any advantage at all in a ranked choice system?


r/Askpolitics • • 3d ago

Question Why is American politics so dominated by just two parties?

19 Upvotes

I have always wondered why American politics is basically just Democrats vs. Republicans. I know other parties exist, but why don’t they ever seem to get anywhere? Is it just the way elections work, or is there more to it?


r/Askpolitics • • 3d ago

Question What makes state party platforms worth reading if national politics dominates coverage?

5 Upvotes

Every cycle I see intense focus on presidential candidates and congressional races, but the actual policies that affect daily life, zoning, licensing, education standards, seem to get hashed out in state party platforms that barely anyone discusses. I sat down with a few from different states and the variation is striking: same national party, completely different priorities on housing, transit, and even foreign policy tangents. Is there any research on whether voters know their state party's platform, or if candidates downballot even stick to it? Or is this just a document that conventions produce and everyone ignores?


r/Askpolitics • • 3d ago

Discussion Should the 2021 $1.2T Bipartisan Infastructure Bill have been more selective In its $25B allocation to the FAA?

5 Upvotes

The 2021 Bipartisan Infastructure Bill allocated $25 billion to the FAA to improve the buildings and equipment throughout FY 2022 - FY 2026. $5 Billion of that $25 Billion went towards air traffic control facilities and equipment at a rate of $1 Billion a year. By the time Trump took office, 3/5 of that money would have been disbursed at that point. At least they should have been, since allocation schedule and actual disbursement is different. (1, 2, 3, 4)

And then we have the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024. To my knowledge, it was to renew the broader aviation system's programs and rules through 2028, after the FAA's previous long term authorization expired in 2023. As well as addressing controller hiring and training, aviation safety, passenger protections, and modernization of the national airspace system. $105.5 Billion planned throughout a five year lifespan. (5, 6, 7)

In retrospect, more funds should have been directed towards air traffic control throughout the five years the 2021 bill promised to fund, especially when reports have been out there since at least 2017. Maybe before. (8, 9)

  1. https://www.faa.gov/iija
  2. https://www.faa.gov/media/83706
  3. https://www.faa.gov/iija/airport-terminals
  4. https://www.faa.gov/iija/iija-airport-infrastructure-grant-funding-amounts
  5. https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/IF12791
  6. https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/3935
  7. https://www.congress.gov/event/119th-congress/house-event/LC74852/text
  8. https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/FY18-22_CIP_Complete_Nov_2017.pdf
  9. https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/FY13-17_CIP_Complete_March_2012.pdf

r/Askpolitics • • 3d ago

Question How do small states keep their influence in presidential primaries once the calendar reshuffles?

5 Upvotes

Reading about how Iowa and New Hampshire have historically dominated the early primary calendar, and how both parties are now pushing for changes that would move other states earlier. It seems like the current system gives outsized attention to a very narrow slice of the electorate. What mechanisms do smaller or earlier states actually use to protect their position? Is it purely party rules negotiations, or do state governments have leverage too? And when the calendar does shift, what determines which new states get picked?


r/Askpolitics • • 3d ago

Question Isn't the Greenland deal a win for Trump?

0 Upvotes

Danish parliament unanimously approves historic Trump deal with Greenland reshaping Arctic security

Trump's style of negotiating ruffles a lot of people feathers, but it seems to work out at times.

He talked about making Greenland the 51st state, which many criticized, but in the end this deal was made and which is a huge benefit to the security of the USA.

https://justthenews.com/government/security/danish-parliament-unanimously-approves-trump-deal-greenland


r/Askpolitics • • 3d ago

Question What explains the gap between expert political consensus and how actual legislation gets written?

4 Upvotes

Reading policy analysis from think tanks and academic political scientists, there's often a pretty clear consensus on what would work for a given problem, whether it's tax policy, healthcare, or immigration. Yet the bills that emerge from Congress frequently diverge substantially from those recommendations, even when the party in power aligns ideologically with the experts.

I'm trying to understand where the friction enters the system. Is it primarily electoral pressure from constituencies who reject the expert view, the influence of organized interests with different priorities, the institutional constraints of the legislative process, or something else entirely? Are there specific policy areas where the translation from expert recommendation to enacted law works more smoothly, and what distinguishes those cases?

I'd particularly like to hear from people who have worked in or adjacent to legislative staff roles, but any perspective on the mechanics of this disconnect would be welcome.


r/Askpolitics • • 4d ago

Question What is the difference between independence, being a commonwealth, self determination, and Internal self determination?

2 Upvotes

Aloha! I am studying arguments made by the Hawaiian sovereignty movement on arguments they make regarding the injustice they feel is made against Hawai'i because of the overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom. I usually see these terms be brought as options for Hawai'i by the Sovereignty Group. What is the general difference between these things? what would your ideas of an outcome be if Hawai'i went through any of these routes with the United States?


r/Askpolitics • • 5d ago

Question Why do state parties with similar voter registration numbers produce such different legislative outcomes?

7 Upvotes

Looking at states where D and R registration is within single digits, some produce lopsided legislatures while others stay competitive. Michigan and Wisconsin come to mind as nearby contrasts. Is this mostly gerrymandering, turnout patterns in midterms, or something about how each party organizes at the state level? Curious what drives the gap between raw numbers and who actually writes the laws.


r/Askpolitics • • 5d ago

Question Danish student here, genuinely curious: what is it Americans don't like about Nordic style welfare?

80 Upvotes

Hi all,
I'm a political science student from Denmark, and I want to say upfront that I'm not here to lecture anyone or claim our system is better. I'm honestly curious, and I realize I've mostly heard one side of this debate.

Some context from my end: I pay no tuition, and the state gives me a monthly grant while I study (it's called SU, around $1,000 a month before tax). When I'm sick, I see a doctor and never get a bill. In return, we pay a lot in taxes. Most Danes I know think that's a fair deal, so I find it hard to see why someone would say no to it.

But I know a lot of Americans do, and I'd like to understand why, from people who actually hold that view. A few things I'm wondering about:
Is the main objection about taxes and money, or is it more about principle, like the role of government or personal freedom?
If you oppose universal healthcare, what do you think would get worse? Wait times, quality, choice, something else?
Does the size of the US matter? I often hear that this works in a country of 6 million but not in one of 340 million. Is that a big part of it for you?
What does your ideal society look like, and how big a role does the state play in it?
Is there anything about the Nordic model you think we get wrong, or just can't see from the inside?

I'd especially like to hear from conservatives and libertarians, since that's the view I know least about, but everyone is welcome. Please keep it civil. I'm here to learn, not to win an argument.
Thanks in advance!


r/Askpolitics • • 5d ago

Question What exactly is going on with politics in the US?

0 Upvotes

I am a teenager who recently got interested in politics and want to learn more about it

some of the topics im interested in and want to learn about are:

What do the Republican and Democratic party’s stand for?

What will likely happen with this blue wave?

How is the US doing in global affairs(Specifically with NATO, Japan, Russia, China, Israel, Iran, and Palestine)?

What are the biggest issues in capitol hill?

What are some other important things I should know about

Thank youI


r/Askpolitics • • 5d ago

Question How do independent redistricting commissions actually decide which public input to prioritize?

4 Upvotes

Several states now use independent commissions for drawing legislative maps, and they all have some process for public comment. What I cannot find clear documentation on is how commissioners weigh competing community testimonies. If one group shows up with hundreds of coordinated comments supporting a particular district configuration, and another group presents detailed demographic data pushing a different approach, what typically breaks the tie? Is there published research or reporting on how commissioners describe their decision criteria when public inputs conflict? Or does it vary so much by state that no general pattern exists?


r/Askpolitics • • 6d ago

Question How come there aren't any Democratic Senators in the Progressive Caucus?

9 Upvotes

Senator Bernie Sanders belongs to the Progressive Caucus. Why aren't there any Democratic Senators in the Progressive Caucus?


r/Askpolitics • • 5d ago

Question what exactly makes someone a democrat or a republican?

4 Upvotes

for context i’m australian, so our political parties are a bit different compared to americas, if that makes sense.


r/Askpolitics • • 5d ago

Question Should the United States abolish the federal minimum wage and allow wages to be determined entirely through contracts?

0 Upvotes

The federal minimum wage has been a fixture of American economic policy for decades, but I think there's a legitimate question about whether the government should be setting a legal floor on what an employer can pay an employee.

My position is that the federal minimum wage should be abolished, leaving compensation entirely to voluntary negotiations between employers and employees.

I have several arguments for this position.

1. Freedom of contract

If two consenting adults agree to an employment arrangement at a particular hourly rate, why should the federal government prohibit that agreement?

An individual should have the freedom to reject an offer they consider inadequate, but also the freedom to accept an offer that suits their circumstances.

2. Barriers to entry into the workforce

A statutory wage floor can make hiring inexperienced workers more expensive.

Consider someone with no professional experience who wants their first job. Their initial productivity might not justify the legally mandated wage, even if they're willing to accept less in exchange for experience and training.

An employer might consequently decide not to hire them at all.

Wouldn't an opportunity to earn a lower wage and develop marketable skills sometimes be preferable to unemployment?

3. Small business flexibility

Large corporations and small independent businesses don't necessarily have the same capacity to absorb increased labour costs.

Abolishing the federal minimum wage would give smaller businesses greater flexibility to negotiate compensation based on their financial circumstances, productivity requirements and local labour markets.

4. Competition between employers

Without a government-mandated wage floor, employers would still need to compete for workers.

Businesses offering poor compensation could struggle to attract and retain employees, while businesses offering better wages, benefits and working conditions could gain a competitive advantage.

Compensation would be shaped by labour supply, demand, productivity and negotiations.

5. Alternative approaches to poverty

Rather than relying on wage mandates, policymakers could focus on reducing the cost of living, lowering unnecessary regulatory barriers, encouraging business formation, improving competition and reducing taxes.

There are, of course, substantial counterarguments.

Employers can have disproportionate bargaining power, particularly in areas with limited employment opportunities. Removing wage floors could also reduce earnings for some workers, and there is disagreement among economists about the employment effects of minimum-wage legislation.

I'm not suggesting that abolishing the minimum wage would automatically improve everyone's financial circumstances.

However, I think the distinction between protecting workers from coercion and prohibiting voluntary employment agreements deserves considerably more discussion.

My questions:

  1. Would you support completely abolishing the federal minimum wage?
  2. Do you believe the potential employment and economic benefits outweigh the risks of lower wages for some workers?
  3. Should adults have the legal freedom to negotiate employment contracts below the current federal minimum?
  4. If you oppose abolition, what specific economic evidence makes you believe a statutory wage floor is preferable?

I'm interested in hearing arguments from both sides, particularly from people who disagree with the proposal.


r/Askpolitics • • 7d ago

Question What does it mean to “get money out of politics”?

17 Upvotes

I want to interrogate the widespread notion that “getting money out of politics” would be a good thing. It’s a salient proposition in the US now right after the 2026 midterms but it isn’t exclusive to the US. 

I keep wondering what it means precisely. I think it can mean a whole bunch of different things, which sorta makes me a little suspicious. I can’t shake the feeling that it’s potentially deliberately kept vague so that it means both everything and nothing. The image that comes to mind is that of an electoral waterbed that commits to nothing with room already built in for its eventual failure to deliver.

Vagueness itself isn’t my objection. Obama's “Yes We Can” was great as a slogan: it was openly motivational and didn’t pretend to be anything beyond what it was. “Get money out of politics,” however, sounds like a concrete commitment while leaving unclear what would count as fulfilling it.

Other examples of such electoral waterbeds include:

·      “Draining the swamp.” – the Donald Trump presidential campaign of 2016

·      “Making big corporations and the wealthy pay their fair share.” – Biden White House, 2024

·      “Put the country back in the service of working people.” – UK Labour, 2024 manifesto

I can think of several concrete interpretations:

·      Stop politicians from exchanging decisions for payments

·      Stop reserving politicians’ attention for donors

·      Remove the need for politicians to attract wealthy backers to become viable in the first place

·      Stop making it possible for wealth to buy greater reach for political messages

·      Stop making governments accommodate people who control investment and employment 

Those overlap, but they aren’t interchangeable. You could eliminate one, but that elimination alone might make another one more attractive or create an entirely new one. It’s basically the same dynamic that makes capital flight a thing. That’s of course not an argument to not get cracking, it’s an argument for doing it properly once you start.

My concern is that keeping the vague formulation available always leaves room to retreat to it. The risk, at least as I understand it, is that the political message “Get money out of politics!” has every opportunity to become an infinite restriction generator that lacks a clear stopping criterion.

“One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results.”

— Milton Friedman, The Open Mind, 1975

 

The Friedman quote here is only ALMOST relevant: it would be great if the intentions themselves were clear enough to scrutinise.