I don't understand the huge outrage surrounding piracy, or why some designers feel the need to publicly shame people for it. I'm thinking specifically about the knitting and crochet community here.
Yes, you're potentially losing a sale because someone didn't pay for your pattern. But not every pattern on the market offers the same level of value, and customers are increasingly expected to pay premium prices for designs that sometimes lack even basic considerations in drafting, grading and sizing.
Someone didn't pay for your overpriced pattern with zero to minimal effort put into drafting it well (barely any short rows, no options for mods, not even ideas, and zero regard for people with larger sizes). I saw a pattern advertised as 2XL for a bust size of 90 cm (!!!), which is most likely inspired by a 90s knitting book. Not every pattern justifies its price!
And let's be real, nobody is reinventing the wheel here. Knitting and crochet have been around for thousands of years. There are only so many ways to construct a sweater, shape a neckline or work a particular stitch. Not every vaguely similar design is plagiarism, and not every pattern is some groundbreaking piece of intellectual property. I think people need to accept that instead of treating designers like misunderstood artists whose work is above criticism. And please, stop babying grown adults just because you've developed a parasocial relationship with someone who sells knitting patterns on the internet. They're designers, not your friends, and you're allowed to question the quality and value of what they're selling.
I understand, everyone wants to monetize their hobbies nowadays, and people deserve to be compensated for their work. But why would you blast someone who read your pattern, bought the required yarn, knitted it up and posted it on social media? At the end of the day, it's still advertisement, and it will bring new people in.
If I read a pattern and see that a designer has put in effort, there are waaay more chances of me going out and buying it. Heck, there are plenty of people I know who first pirate patterns or games and then, if they like the content, buy them with their own money. And I am one of them. I want to buy a well-thought-out set of instructions, not the dream of being a skinny hot girl on Instagram.
Some of the most successful contemporary knitwear designers seem to understand that building a loyal community and consistently putting out good designs is a much better long-term strategy than policing every instance of piracy. Maybe that's a better business strategy than publicly berating potential customers.
There's also the accessibility aspect that I think gets overlooked. People in some countries don't even have access to Ravelry or to the websites where these designers sell and advertise their patterns. Not everyone has the same access to payment methods, international platforms, or even the same purchasing power. Making patterns more accessible means more people get to discover your work, try your designs, share their finished projects, and potentially become paying customers down the line.
A person who pirates your pattern isn't necessarily a lost customer. They might be a future customer, someone who introduces ten other people to your work, or simply someone who would never have been able to purchase your pattern in the first place.
The more people who have access to your work, the larger your potential audience becomes. And a larger audience means more opportunities for legitimate sales, not fewer.