I was at a show & the CGC had reps there doing the signature witnessing. I had them witness 7 comics and 1 magazine. I bought 4 comics and 1 magazine from the artists at the show. So they were brand new. I never touched them. They went from the artist / signer to CGC rep. The CGC rep sent in the 7 comics and 1 magazine (separate order).
About 45 days go by and I get the magazine back. 9.8!
About 80 days goes by and no status beyond received. I get nervous and call in a ticket. Support confirms they have them, but there's a problem. The graders need more info. CGC closes the ticket.
I call in another ticket, and finally they tell me the comics were damaged in shipping. They give me 3 options:
- grade / slab as is
- press then grade / slab
- send them back without doing anything
I was like 'you guys shipped it, not me'. They don't care. Now it's 90 days in. I tell them to press, then grade / slab.
I called the CGC reps that shipped it. They said it was bombproof shipping. they tell me that the CGC is always damaging comics. I believe them because the magazine was fine and how CGC stonewalled me. They tell me the CGC is always damaging comics and blaming someone else.
The CGC gives me a $40 credit.
Then the status goes to graded and into shipping. I call in another ticket (customer rep goes "oh that order") and they said they made a mistake. They would pull them out of shipping , crack the cases, press, regrade, re-slab.
Another 2 weeks go by and the status goes to SHIPPED with the same grade/serial # and notes. Pretty sure they never pressed them.
This whole experience makes me wanting to never send in another comic. The CGC has complete control and you have no recourse. Specifically with witnessed signatures. How do you replace them? You can't!!
Sorry for the long winded post.