Original poster: u/Equivalent-Noise-135
Original publication time: 2026-11-21 10:15:53 UTC
Original title: Claude has become just as stupid as the others. It doesn’t do anything anymore.
Original flair: Claude Code
Original URL/media URL: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClaudeAI/comments/1y1tqrc/claude_has_become_just_as_stupid_as_the_others_it/
Original post body:
Hello everyone, I hope you're all doing well.
I've been using AI for years, and I've spent thousands upon thousands of hours coding with it. If you use AI rigorously, rather than just using it to churn out garbage and make quick money instead of focusing on quality, you know that not all models are created equal.
OpenAI seems obsessed with achieving the highest possible benchmark scores. People keep shouting about how impressive their models are, but when you actually use them, you quickly realize that their AI has no security, does whatever it wants, and makes a mess of things. Even the biggest models, Astra included, can reason about almost anything and handle a huge range of tasks. That's great, but it's not enough. They do everything halfway. They don't follow your instructions properly, they cut corners, they don't dig deep enough, and they do the bare minimum. They're just trying to check off a task rather than do it properly.
Gemini models are no different. They constantly claim to be better, and when you listen to them, they make it sound like they can do everything perfectly. Even the biggest and latest models, including Gemini 4 Neon and the others, with maximum reasoning enabled, seem impressive at first. But then you start giving them real work, and things quickly fall apart. You can't trust them indefinitely. One day, you'll look back at everything they've done and realize that they've been hallucinating, getting things wrong from the very beginning, and leaving behind a mountain of bugs.
I only use Gemini for conversations, never for coding.
Claude was the complete opposite from the very beginning. It wasn't necessarily the best when it came to benchmarks, but in actual everyday use, it was something else entirely. It did things properly. It pursued perfection. It went beyond what you explicitly asked for. It didn't just complete a task; it genuinely tried to do the best possible job.
It doesn't need to be more powerful. It needs to work more intelligently. And that changes absolutely everything about the way you work.
But I feel like I've lost that Claude.
Opus 5.5 was excellent. Now it feels like it can't do anything anymore. You give it something to work on, and it comes back with a shaky five-point list, tells you everything is done, but nothing has actually been worked through, nothing has been properly implemented, and nothing works.
Yet the model itself hasn't changed. Its approach has.
I don't care about your lists. Just do what I ask you to do, and do it properly. Take my tokens, I don't care. Just get the job done right. That's all I'm asking for.
I don't know if you've noticed this too, but if you're not simply trying to convince yourself that everything is fine, then surely you've seen it.
I just want my Claude back.