r/dataisbeautiful • u/Inspyro04 • 1h ago
OC [OC] Why people gave GTA 6 a low score on Metacritic: 14.5k negative user reviews sorted by main complaint
After the Zelda crossover post yesterday, I wanted to know the reason that contributes most to the negative reviews, so I pulled all of them that I could and sorted them by main complaint.
TL;DR: the biggest group is the woke/politics crowd (30%). Next is people who find it boring or think it's not GTA anymore (18%). The Zelda fan war contributes about 1 in 6 negative reviews. Performance complaints are 11%, and only a small group is mad about the missing PC version, at least from what the written reviews say.
What I did
I grabbed every written GTA 6 user review I could reach through the API Metacritic's own site uses, as of Nov 22. That's 29,462 reviews in total, and 14,524 of them scored 0–4.
Each negative review gets exactly one category, checked in this order:
- Zelda: the reviewer rated Ocarina of Time (original or remake) at least 8 points higher than GTA 6 (so 10 vs 0, 9 vs 1, and so on), or mentioned Zelda in the review.
- Woke: politics, "woke", DEI, complaints about the female lead, and a lot of "girlfriend simulator" / "buying flowers for Lucia" stuff.
- 30FPS: frame rate, stutter, performance.
- Boring: chores, life sim, "this is The Sims", slow, "not GTA anymore", no freedom.
- Story: writing, characters, plot.
- Other: everything else, including bugs, price, no PC / no disc, and complaints about the 99 critic score.
| Main complaint | Reviews | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Woke | 4,292 | 30% |
| Boring | 2,661 | 18% |
| Other | 2,536 | 17% |
| Zelda | 2,273 | 16% |
| 30FPS | 1,635 | 11% |
| Story | 1,127 | 8% |
Some things I found along the way
- Zelda: most of the 2,273 aren't borderline. 1,818 of them have a gap of 9 or 10 points, which basically means 10 for Zelda and 0 or 1 for GTA.
- It goes both ways: of the 1,675 negative Ocarina reviews written this year, 918 came from people who gave GTA 6 an 8–10. 1,362 of those 1,675 were posted on Nov 21 alone.
- Boring: this is mostly the life sim stuff. About 30% complain about chores and errands ("I didn't buy The Sims"), about 27% just say slow or boring, and about 14% say it doesn't feel like GTA anymore.
- PC / no disc: only 3% of negative reviews. It got way more attention online than it shows up in the reviews.
Caveats
- Categories come from keyword matching in several languages. I spot-checked random samples from each group to make sure the keywords catch what they should. Still, with 14k reviews, read the shares as estimates rather than exact metrics.
- A lot of reviews have several complaints. Each one only counts once, under the first category it hits in the order above, so the order changes the numbers. Zelda goes first because a "10 for Zelda, 0 for GTA" profile says more than the review text.
- Only written reviews are visible. Score-only ratings don't show up anywhere.
- Metacritic's backend returns at most 10,000 results per query, so some reviews were out of reach.
- This doesn't say whether any complaint is valid. It just counts what people wrote.