r/doctorwho • • 1d ago

Discussion [Megathread] The Next Season of Doctor Who: Fancasts, Speculation, and Where We Go Next

8 Upvotes

Let's have a fresh megathread to discuss and speculate about the future of Doctor Who. Place your ideas, fancasts, wish lists, and other hot takes in here:

  • Fancasts: Who is your top pick for the Doctor and their companions and their foes? Do you want unknown actors or established names? Old returning villains and monsters or new ones, and who would play them?
  • Production and crew: Have you noticed someone working on another show that would make a good addition to the team? New directors, writers, cinematographers? New showrunner? Old showrunner? No showrunner? What production/media company would you like distributing it? Any thoughts on rumours about BBC Studios, ITV Studios, STV Studios, and Hat Trick Mercuio?
  • Plot suggestions: What do you want to see happen after Billie Piper's appearance? Longer theories should probably go into their own separate text posts.

Also, please avoid any leaks discussions. If you're bringing up leaked set photos or anything else, please remember to use spoiler tags.

Standalone posts about fancasts will be removed and redirected here. A fresh megathread will be posted every weekend.


r/doctorwho • • 10h ago

Discussion Does anyone else think unit in RTD2 was really strange?

175 Upvotes

For most of doctor who they’re this massive, secret, deep state military organisation who deal with extraterrestial threats. Then suddenly RTD comes along and they’re about 20 guys, (2 of which arent even adults) Live in avengers tower, have a robot and are so weak that some random ass guy named Conrad with a camera can break in.


r/doctorwho • • 6h ago

Discussion Why the Doctor becomes so obsessed with Clara

88 Upvotes

Season 9 ends with the Doctor realizing he cares for Clara too much, to the point of becoming an unhealthy obsession that causes him to take unnecessary risks with other people’s lives and the universe in general. I used to always think this was lazy writing, because there’s no real reason for him to be that much more obsessed with Clara than with any other companion, other than her being the “Pretty Face™” companion whom they want us to obsess over the same way the Doctor does.

But I just realized something. The Doctor has spent more time with Clara as his main companion than with anyone else, by a longshot. Both of the times that Steven Moffat shoehorned an absurd number of years into the Doctor’s lifespan, Clara was his companion.

He spent 900 years on Trenzalore, watching the citizens of Christmas age and die around him, after sending away Clara with his Tardis, just for her to make it back at the end to help him save the day.

Then he spent 4.5 billion years in the confession dial, with a painting of her over the mantle. It’s a little vague if or how he maintains a continuous memory of his entire time there. When he talks about it after the fact in other episodes, he seems like he doesn’t really remember it all, but in Heaven Sent, he says “I can remember it all” and when he does, he’s talking to Clara.

So he spent 4.5000009 billion years tormented about different things that caused him to lose Clara, compared to 200-300 years with the Ponds, and like 2 or 3 years at most with everyone else (ignoring a few bits where he spent undisclosed amounts of time alone in between episodes).

So that kinda makes the end of season 9 make a bit more sense.


r/doctorwho • • 11h ago

Discussion Doctor Who is surprisingly good at making things that are trying to help you absolutely terrifying

95 Upvotes

I was rewatching The Empty Child / The Doctor Dances and something occurred to me that I'd never really thought about before.

The nanogenes aren't evil.

They're medical technology trying to repair an injured child. They just don't understand human biology properly, so they use the first patient they encounter as a template.

And suddenly we've got one of the creepiest monsters in the show's history.

Then I started thinking about how often Doctor Who does this.

The Girl Who Waited has medical robots that are genuinely trying to administer treatment. The problem is that the treatment is lethal to humans. They're not hunting Amy because they hate her. They're following their programming in a facility that was never meant for her species.

In Smile, the Vardy are supposed to look after the colonists and keep them happy. Except they interpret grief as a problem that needs eliminating, which is a pretty unfortunate misunderstanding when people start dying.

And then there's The Girl in the Fireplace, where the clockwork robots are maintaining their ship. They just happen to consider human body parts perfectly acceptable replacement components.

I think there's something uniquely unsettling about this type of threat.

A Dalek wants to kill you. A Cyberman wants to convert you. You understand what they're trying to do, even if you can't stop them.

But imagine being chased by something that sincerely believes it's helping you.

You can't appeal to its conscience because it doesn't have one. You can't explain that you're innocent because it doesn't think you're guilty. It just has a job to do, and unfortunately you're part of the job.

What I especially like about The Empty Child is that the solution isn't destroying the nanogenes. It's giving them the correct information.

The thing causing the horror becomes the thing that fixes it.

And honestly, I find that much more interesting than watching the Doctor defeat another army of murderous robots.

I wonder if this is one of the show's most underrated strengths: making the consequences of a perfectly reasonable instruction feel more frightening than deliberate evil.

Are there other episodes that fit this pattern? I'm particularly interested in ones where the Doctor has to understand what a supposed monster is trying to accomplish rather than simply figure out how to stop it.


r/doctorwho • • 8h ago

Discussion Is this a real company?

Post image
45 Upvotes

Rewatching The Star Beat on a quiet Sunday morning, at right towards the end, as Fourteen returns to the TARDIS, I finally noticed something in the background and I've no idea what to make of it. Is it a real company? Did the production team choose this location so they could have this in the background? Did K-9 go nuts and take over a Cyberman army?


r/doctorwho • • 17h ago

Discussion Would the other Doctors also have left all those spiders locked up in a room to starve to death or eat each other in "Arachnids in the UK" or was that a decision unique to the 13th Doctor? How would the other incarnations have handled the spiders?

Post image
226 Upvotes

r/doctorwho • • 2h ago

Discussion Do you think New Who Collection Boxsets will ever happen?

7 Upvotes

I've really enjoyed the special features on the collection box sets and would love something similar for New Who. But with the new who Doctors working so much they probably won't do a behind the sofa until they're 70 or 80. Also, I think there would be less transparency about what it was like to work on the show so I kinda lean towards it not happening and if it does it will be in 20 years time, probably on 12k in a box with a download code.


r/doctorwho • • 10h ago

Arts/Crafts 6 out of 15 minifigures built now.

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

UPDATE Hey guys and gals here are my now six custom Lego builds for the second doctor, Jamie, Susan, Sara, Barbara, and Ben.

Yes I know Jamie still needs a kilt. I will get that once everything is done eventually.


r/doctorwho • • 11h ago

Discussion Thoughts on the first doctor after watching s1-3 for the first time.

25 Upvotes

The first doctor is very, very different from the others. Usually the doctor's character arcs focus on character flaws and specific aspects of growth, whereas The 1st Doctor's character arc is him going from a pretty selfish and slightly cowardly old man, to the doctor as we know him. I really loved it for that, after years of shit with rtd2 and Chibnall (in my opinion) and even before that the Moffat era was full of The doctors 'badass lonely god' Wankery, it's extremely refreshing for him to be so different. Like, For most of Hartnell's run he doesn't seek out danger, isn't really trying to help anyone and isn't a master of all topics.


r/doctorwho • • 11h ago

Misc Anyone use to collect Battles in Time?

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

I use to collect these and sub to the magazine when I was a kid - even had a binder as well, but over time I lost the binder (I know, heart attack 🤣) but literally hundreds of my old cards remained hidden in a box under my bed for over a decade and I recently decided to buy a binder from Ebay (as well as two more because I realised I had a lot of cards).

But, I didn't have all the cards, so I am determined to find and collect as many as possible. It's such a fun little nostalgic hobby to do.

I also have a collection (albeit, considerably smaller) of Alien Armies, Monster Invasion, and Alien Attax, and will potentially go into collecting them too.

I'm also aware they have actually rebooted Battles in Time, which is cool.


r/doctorwho • • 20h ago

Comic Book Ep. 27: Of Gods and Men (4) Fan comic.

Thumbnail
gallery
94 Upvotes

r/doctorwho • • 1d ago

Misc RTD explains how James Bond’s death should be resolved …

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
815 Upvotes

… and funnily enough, give or take, it’s exactly how the incoming Doctor Who production team should resolve the Billie Piper issue.

RTD: ‘I’d never presume to give the great Steven Knight any advice. But if I had to, I’d say: you can’t resolve this as a continuity issue, it’s gone way beyond that. I’d just recast all the others – M, Moneypenny, Q, everyone – and simply have Robert Pattinson walk in for his next day’s work. They’ve never commented on a new Bond, don’t start now!’


r/doctorwho • • 1d ago

Discussion What if the cybermen said yes? Would the Doctor keep his promise?

Post image
634 Upvotes

Just for some context:

This scene is a deleted scene in the series 2 finale titled "Doomsday". The doctor offers the cybermen to hop away and head to the tardis, I really wonder what would've happened had the cybermen said yes, or had 10 have a brief cybermen companion.


r/doctorwho • • 18h ago

Discussion Unexplored Stories and Concepts

10 Upvotes

Hi first of all to all Whovians. As a fan of Red Dwarf, I was rewatching a couple of episodes such as Back to Reality. Considering the context of the episode, I have wondered why Doctor Who never explored it as an idea. Any ideas you'd want Doctor Who to explore?


r/doctorwho • • 1d ago

Discussion A growing whoniverse.

Post image
130 Upvotes

I've been developing my collection over the last couple months since I saw the re-release or recollection of the new who doctors. I think I'm making some real progress. I'm watching Collin Baker's run before I start Capaldi.

I hope we get Tom Baker's last one or two seasons in the collection set in the next few years.


r/doctorwho • • 7h ago

Discussion My Idea for The Next Era

0 Upvotes

New Actor/ Actress to play the Doctor. Ideally hasn't starred in Doctor Who at all before. Age is late 30s, early 40s.

They're the 17th Doctor. Billie Piper remains the 16th Doctor.

Big Finish is welcome to do anything they want to with 16th Doctor stories, but it must move the lore along from how it was at the end of the 15th Doctor's era to how it is at the beginning of the 17th Doctor's era.

The Daleks are back, The Cyber Men are more of a concept of runaway transhumanism that occurs in multiple societies across time and space as opposed to a unified force of interstellar combatants, The Time Lords are back, and The Master will make some form of appearance.

That won't all be made known in Season 1, but will all be relevant hopefully around Season 5.

Story Structure: 2-part episodes, 45 minutes in length each part, 10 total parts (5 stories) per season.

There will be a fun, campy episode each season, an episode that toes the line between thriller and horror, and a tense and climactic finale

Seasons will not have major, season-long, storylines. It complicates things way too much.

Additionally there will be a Holiday special each year, with Part 1 Airing on Christmas Day, and Part 2 Airing on New Year's Day.


r/doctorwho • • 7h ago

Speculation/Theory Hybrid theory/ speculation

1 Upvotes

Even though hybrid was intended to be clara and the doctor maybe ashildr I just realized that the spy master fits the bill as well. He stood in the ruins of gallifrey killed unknown amounts of time lords plus other species's almost unravels the web of time daily, and he destroyed gallifrey cause he wanted revenge aka healing his own?! Plus he's gallifreyen plus whatever the doc is. I kind of like the idea that it's the master


r/doctorwho • • 1d ago

Discussion Are these two related?

Thumbnail
gallery
207 Upvotes

They look similar and sound similar.


r/doctorwho • • 1d ago

Discussion Deeply considering checking out Doctor Who. But I have no idea where to start. The old classic stuff, the new stuff?

25 Upvotes

Obviously, it’s been going on for decades. I know most people love the David Tennant era, but I don’t know how each season is for continuity.


r/doctorwho • • 1d ago

Spoilers Throwback to a little over a year ago… Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
164 Upvotes

I can’t believe the insane amount of leaks RTD2 had especially for series 2/15


r/doctorwho • • 1d ago

Arts/Crafts I pretended I was re-designing the Daleks for a reboot

Post image
24 Upvotes

I spent the last couple of evenings doodling a redesign for the Daleks, thought I'd share the results!


r/doctorwho • • 10h ago

Discussion The Midnight Episode Rewatch

0 Upvotes

I rewatched Midnight and I was thinking. I think the Doctor telling people to stop copying him as a character trait. That would been a great way that the Doctor being affected by the events of Midnight.


r/doctorwho • • 16h ago

Discussion Christmas Special: The Next Doctor

2 Upvotes

What if the child, Fredrick or his children, find The Doctor and have their own adventures


r/doctorwho • • 2d ago

Discussion Just got off watching Tooth and Claw, I think I noticed something

516 Upvotes

While the werewolf was getting attacked by the moonlight​, a piece of sfx sounded like the regeneration sfx. I think it's the same sfx with minor tweeks. Video included so that you can check it yourselves.

edit : now that people are mentioning it's a stock sound, I remember hearing an audio that was sued in Halo CE too. I don't remember which one, it was some sort of error sound. Like health low sound I think.