r/evolution • • May 05 '26

meta New Rule 11: Images

33 Upvotes

Hi there, group. Recently, the moderator team has discussed another rule change.

Long before I started posting in r/evolution, in the ancient days of 2017, there was an unwritten rule in place which banned image posts. Evidently, it had to do with people using the subreddit as a dumping ground for memes, image macros, and other types of low effort drive-by shitposts. While we understand why this might have been implemented, we've gotten at least a small handful of requests in that time to be able to post educational images rather than having to link to a third-party image host. In short, we believe that the original ban may have been too restrictive.

After talking it over on and off for about the last month, we've decided to lift the ban on image posts. However, we still think that the Old Guard moderators who implemented the original ban had valid concerns. So for now, we've created a new rule 11:

Image posts are permitted under the following conditions.

  • Images must have educational value, must be relevant to evolutionary biology, and context must be clear. If an image has been taken so far out of context that the meaning is incoherent, we may choose to remove the post.
  • Please do not post AI-generated images, macros, memes, joke images, or comics.
  • No plagiarism: do not claim credit for work made by another artist. We encourage you to source where the image came from.

Sourcing an image won't be mandatory but is highly encouraged, especially if there might be missing context without it. We would also encourage you to include your own thoughts about the image in order to foster discussion.

If you have any comments, questions, concerns, hopes, dreams, fears, and goals, please let us know. Also if you have any ideas on things you'd like to see from us, we'd love to hear about that too. If you feel more comfortable voicing these things in private, that's cool, too.


r/evolution • • 9h ago

question Why have beaks evolved so many times?

12 Upvotes

Archosauromorphs have developed beaks at least six times--rhynchosaurs, turtles, pterosaurs, theropods, ornithischians, and the poposaur genus effigia. Sauropods might have had beaks but I don't know how accepted that theory is. Synapsids, meanwhile, have developed beaks twice. The first time was in the permian with dicynodonts while second time was in the cenozoic with monotremes. It's unusual for a specific trait like this to evolve so many times among so many different lineage groups, especially when the members of said groups eat different things.

Rhynchosaurs and dicynodonts fed on low-to-the-ground plants along with roots. Effigia ate soft plants. Ornithiscians all either browsed or grazed for plants. Monotremes eat very small prey. Eorhynchochelys were either carnivores or omnivores. Pterosaurs mostly ate fish. And early beaked theropods seem to have been either carnivores or omnivores.

Does anyone know of any theories explaining why beaks evolved so many times for so many different groups? Before anyone says it, no, it was not because beaks are lighter than teeth. Most beak-having groups had beaks and teeth for millions of years before going toothless. This 2013 paper argues theropods may have evolved beaks as a kind of shock absorber, but it's only making this argument for only one beak-having group.


r/evolution • • 10h ago

question Can an homoplasy also be an autapomorphy?

Post image
3 Upvotes

In the case of the image, we can see an homoplasy (convergence or paralelism). But since it appears in only two terminals, wouldn’t it be also a case of autapomorphy?

Sorry for my bad English.


r/evolution • • 17h ago

question Despite the fact that Denisovans were native to East Asia, why is it that modern East Asians contain the most Neanderthal DNA and not Denisovan DNA?

8 Upvotes

Shouldn’t it be that populations in the area contain far more Denisovan genetic material?


r/evolution • • 20h ago

question When did poison dart frogs evolve poison?

2 Upvotes

I understand that finding direct fossil evidence of poisons would be difficult, but do we know when the common ancestor of poison dart frogs lived, using molecular clock evidence? Google scholar isn't helping.


r/evolution • • 1d ago

question Why do some insects have a larval and pupal stage before becoming an adult while others have a nymphal stage?

24 Upvotes

The majority of insects like flies mosquitos wasps, fleas ants bees beetles and butterflies have an egg then a larval stage which is very active and eats a lot but doesn’t look like an adult then a pupal stage where they don’t feed but are essentially immobile and helpless and then finally the adult stage while other insects like cockroaches, praying mantises, grasshoppers, dragonflies, and lice have eggs that hatch into nymphs which look like smaller wingless less mature versions of adults and they molt a few times until reaching adulthood and having wings.


r/evolution • • 2d ago

question What's some issues with the biological species concept?

9 Upvotes

I've seen a lot of discussion regarding word games in science, particularly in discussions of species. My issue with this is that while there are exceptions to this definition, I feel that it's a generally good working definition. Is there something I'm missing, that really drives the nail in the coffin?


r/evolution • • 3d ago

article Baboon Skulls Suggest Eagles May Have Hunted Early Humans

Thumbnail
gizmodo.com
145 Upvotes

r/evolution • • 2d ago

discussion Have Humans Lost Genetic Potential Through Evolution?

0 Upvotes

What if early humans experienced generations of inbreeding, cannibalism, interbreeding with other human species, and even eating them? These things must have affected our genes in some way. We know that we still carry small amounts of Neanderthal and Denisovan DNA.

Could scientists find out what genes we gained, lost or still carry from our ancestors? Is it possible that humans once had certain abilities or stronger genetic traits that disappeared over time?

I know there must be research and papers on these topics, but I’d rather explore these ideas through discussions, ask questions and gain knowledge through conversation.


r/evolution • • 3d ago

discussion Overview of the Out-of-Africa evolution narratives

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/evolution • • 4d ago

The roots of Culture.

2 Upvotes

Do you think culture do you think comes from evolutionary, psychological, and biological roots or pure human invention?


r/evolution • • 5d ago

question Why didn’t houseflies evolve to be silent?

41 Upvotes

I just killed a buzzing housefly. I might have left it if it were silent. Given houseflies have adapted to live in proximity to humans, why aren’t they quieter?


r/evolution • • 5d ago

article McCullough et al. find rare support that stochastic processes (drift) can accelerate phenotypic divergence

Post image
142 Upvotes

Caption

Fig 3 | Lineages with lower heterozygosity have higher plumage color evolutionary rates

Summary

Background

The tempo of phenotypic evolution can influence how quickly lineages diversify.1,2,3 Evolutionary theory predicts that rapid evolution of signaling traits, such as feather coloration, can promote speciation4,5 because of their vital role in establishing prezygotic reproductive barriers,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16 but empirical support is inconsistent.17,18 Phenotypic divergence of such traits is expected during speciation,5 but these microevolutionary dynamics are rarely examined at macroevolutionary scales or linked to underlying population demography.

Methods

Here, we leverage complete taxon sampling across an iconic insular bird radiation of kingfishers (Aves: Alcedinidae) that helped shape early theories of allopatric speciation. We integrate whole-genome data with a comprehensive, fine-scale dataset of whole-body plumage coloration to directly test whether signaling trait evolution covaries with lineage diversification and to disentangle the roles of selection and drift.

Results and discussion

We find that lineages with faster rates of color evolution diversify more rapidly. Strikingly, rates of color evolution accelerate as genomic diversity declines, providing direct evidence that genetic drift—rather than strong sexual or ecological selection—can drive rapid phenotypic change in small, isolated insular populations. Together, these results provide compelling evidence that neutral demographic processes can accelerate the evolution of sexual signals and play a central role in generating phenotypic diversity during island radiations.

 


Published today;
Not open-access, but the preprint is here: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.64898/2026.06.09.731170v1.abstract


r/evolution • • 5d ago

question What do humans have in common with other primates?

65 Upvotes

For a long time I believed that humans were related to apes but it’s more accurate to say that humans themselves are apes. There are a lot of other species of primates on earth like chimps gorillas orangutans baboons and smaller primates like lemurs and tarsiers. Are there certain traits that all primates including humans have in common?


r/evolution • • 4d ago

question Etmli5 if lizards can regrow their tail… why haven’t they evolved to the extent they don’t have a tail?

0 Upvotes

Etmli5 if lizards can regrow their tail… why haven’t they evolved to the extent they don’t have a tail?


r/evolution • • 6d ago

question Can someone explain multi-mutation evolution/natural selection to me?

11 Upvotes

To preface this I know absolutely nothing about the subject of evolution so I need someone to explain this to me.

I heard on a YouTube video that evolution of traits that require multiple gene mutations would take hundreds of millions of years due to how rare these mutations are and how long natural selection takes. The argument was mostly from statistics, and argued that humans couldn’t have evolved from monkeys since it would have taken 200 million years or something, and that dinosaurs were still around 200 million years ago hence debunking common ancestry. (The video didn’t set out to debunk this but rather raised this question)

Can anyone explain to me if this is a solid argument or if this is a big question in evolutionary biology? Is this even true, and does this debunk natural selection if so? Also is natural selection even the main way we believe evolution occurs anymore because this video seems to disprove it if what they were saying is true.


r/evolution • • 6d ago

question What are the most cutting edge / debatable aspects of evolutionary theory today?

15 Upvotes

This might be a rambling, vague question from a layperson so apologies in advance, but I ask in a spirit of genuine enquiry.

What aspects of evolutionary theory are currently under debate in scientific circles? I'm not asking about advances in the application of the theory, or ethical implications of that. I'm more interested in what the current debates are around how evolution actually works - the nuances of it I suppose.

For example, I'm reading 42 Tales from Life by Dawkins at the moment, and it touches on the idea of structuralism (phenotypes being determined by the fundamental constraints of physics and chemistry) Vs functionalism (phenotypes being purely determined by the classic processes of natural selection). Dawkins gives a nuanced account of both sides.

Do we have examples of other similar debates? I ask for the purposes of a novel I'm planning (it's a sequel to an earlier book in which the basics of evolution are explored, now I want to ramp things up).

Thanks, and apologies again for the rambling.


r/evolution • • 7d ago

article Beaven et al. discover a single growth factor to be behind the origin and assembly of a complex, water conservation system in beetles

6 Upvotes

Some earlier background I found from 2023: Researchers get to the “bottom” of how beetles use their butts to stay hydrated – Faculty of Science - University of Copenhagen.

Today's study's abstract piqued my interest; I'll share some excerpts from the paper that answered questions I had:

How unique is that system?

Beetle CNCs are widespread (found in ~190,000 known species) and similar organ systems appear to have evolved independently several times in other insect lineages5. This suggests the CNC is an important evolutionary adaptation, likely underpinning the evolutionary success of species possessing it.

What was the ancestral state?

The CNC is a derived organ system that evolved through a dramatic reorganisation of MpT position - from an ancestral state in which MpTs float freely within the haemocoel to one in which they became tightly bound to the rectum - and through the recruitment of the PNM, a novel tissue unique to CNCs, and a dedicated tracheal supply. Remarkably, we find that regulated deployment of two FGF signalling pathways orchestrate the assembly of all these developing tissues into one integrated organ system.

What could the step-wise sequence have been like?

It may be that the MpT tip cells have evolutionarily acquired responsiveness to FGF signalling de novo, by activation of FGFR expression, or have modified their response to FGF signals, by altering the timing of expression or splicing of FGFR. This could account for the changes in MpT guidance, required for CNC evolution in beetles. Alternatively, evolutionary changes to the location and timing of FGF ligand expression could have driven these changes, if the tip cells were ancestrally responsive to FGF ligand chemoattraction.

Go exaptation / change of function! I'm reminded of evo-devo biologist Enrico Coen's remark that development is unintuitive (his Royal Society lecture): how simple changes lead to remarkable results.

 


(Published today; in press.)

Beaven, R., Fafinska, M., Dai, J. et al. Assembly of a renal countercurrent system in a beetle. Nat Commun (2026). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-026-79593-4


r/evolution • • 7d ago

article Evolutionary conflict among microchimeric cell lineages: today's enemies, tomorrow's friends (Úbeda & Wild 2026)

7 Upvotes

It was amazing to learn about feto-maternal cell trafficking (and the history of discovery), which I first came across in Zimmer's book on genetics (1). The tl;dr of that: the past few decades have shown that fetal cells remain behind after a pregnancy, which can be neutral, good, or bad, in the long term. An example of the (serendipitously) good is a woman whose long-aborted son's cells repaired her liver (2).

 

1: Zimmer, C. (2019). She has her mother's laugh: The powers, perversions, and potential of heredity. Penguin.
2: Bianchi, D. W. (2007). Fetomaternal cell trafficking: a story that begins with prenatal diagnosis and may end with stem cell therapy. Journal of pediatric surgery, 42(1), 12-18.


An evolutionary conflict study was published a few months back on that general topic; I was waiting for the manuscript to be edited, but that is taking too long, so here's that study:

Split abstract

Background

Microchimerism - the long-term persistence of genetically distinct cells exchanged between mother and fetus - is a widespread feature of mammalian reproduction whose evolutionary significance remains debated. Recent empirical work shows that newly arriving fetal microchimeric cells actively displace resident microchimeric populations, challenging the view that maternal tissues progressively accumulate cellular memories of past pregnancies. Here, we develop models to investigate how such displacement may have evolved and what it reveals about the function of microchimeric cells.

Results

We show that the maternal microchiome contains two opposing factions: cells originating from the current offspring, which favor increased maternal investment in the ongoing pregnancy, and resident cells from previous offspring or matrilineal relatives, which favor preserving resources for future reproduction. Crucially, cells from the current offspring switch allegiances after the period of maternal care, becoming part of the inhibitory resident population in subsequent pregnancies. This recurrent reset generates selection for incoming fetal cells to displace resident microchimeric cells, because displacement increases the relative influence of the resource-enhancing faction more effectively than simple addition. Conversely, resident microchimeric cells are selected to proliferate without displacement, generating a predicted tug-of-war over microchiome composition.

Discussion

Our results show that pregnancy-induced displacement emerges naturally under the conflict-based Trojan Horse Hypothesis, in which fetal cells manipulate maternal physiology to enhance resource transfer to the current offspring. By contrast, displacement is difficult to reconcile with the Tolerance Hypothesis, which predicts selection for maintaining a diverse and persistent microchiome. Overall, our model suggests that the loss of maternal cellular memory is not paradoxical but instead an expected outcome of evolutionary conflict among microchimeric cell lineages.


From the paper

On the authors' modeling versus what is observed:

Therefore, our results predict that circulating microchimeric cells are predicted to protect mothers from cancer, whereas engrafted microchimeric cells are predicted to contribute to the development of cancer. Interestingly, recent work provides some evidence for this dual role of microchimeric cells in cancer. In general, studies that measure circulating microchimeric cells in peripheral blood tend to associate them with a protective role against cancer, while studies that detect microchimerism in diseased tissue often report a contributory role in cancer (Parmeggiani et al., 2025). While more empirical work is needed to validate this observation we find intriguing the match between our theoretical predictions from a model for displacement and the observation of an apparent dual role for microchimeric cells in cancer.

 



r/evolution • • 9d ago

discussion Green Tigers

Post image
3.8k Upvotes

Really fucking stupid question: Why did they evolve to be orange to deer and wild boars instead of just evolving to be green, which would make them harder for everyone to spot?


r/evolution • • 8d ago

question Could the rear feather patterns of dabbling ducks function as a form of defensive mimicry?

Post image
45 Upvotes

I noticed something interesting while watching a video of ducks dabbling underwater.

When they tip forward to feed, the black-and-white feather patterns on their exposed rear ends look remarkably like the open mouth of a predator. There’s even what appears to be a tongue or jaw-like structure formed by the feathers.

What caught my attention is that this appearance becomes particularly prominent when the duck’s head is submerged, meaning it cannot visually monitor its surroundings.

It made me wonder whether these markings could potentially serve a defensive function by startling or discouraging approaching predators.

Obviously, resemblance alone doesn’t establish an evolutionary adaptation, and this could be entirely coincidental.

Has anyone encountered research investigating this possibility, or is there an established explanation for these particular feather patterns?


r/evolution • • 9d ago

article The Point Reyes mountain beaver is the lone survivor of an ancient rodent family that diverged millions of years ago. Scientists are only beginning to understand how it has survived.

Thumbnail
sfgate.com
111 Upvotes

r/evolution • • 9d ago

article The importance of genes does not predict their mutation rate (Radrizzani & Hurst 2026)

11 Upvotes

Periodically since 1972 some researchers have argued that "selection has acted on between-gene variation in the mutation rate": important genes are protected from mutation; genes where change could aid adaptation mutate more frequently -- to overcome problems inherent in these studies, Radrizzani & Hurst used data from "mutation accumulation" experiments, which are designed to minimize the effects of selection: "three separate tests found no evidence that natural selection had substantially skewed the results".

"While we see known causes of variation in mutation rates, we found no evidence for the effects that have been proposed as a challenge to the conventional model. None predicted which genes would have high or low mutation rates, and there are certainly no grounds for a shift in paradigm," said Hurst.