Okay y’all, this is a weird one with a lot of context, so bear with me. TLDR: has anyone ever used nesting pastures to protect from predators, or seen research on this?
Here’s the situation: I live in the woods in a rocky area, with lots of red tape around development, no heavy equipment and limited ability to access it, and a pack of eastern coyotes (coywolves) very comfortable getting quite close to my house. I also have foxes and the odd black bear. My goal is to have sheep, dairy cattle, goats, and poultry. I already have horses.
Obviously the animals I want are tasty, and my predators are big. Not great. There are a lot of commonly recommended ways to handle this, but I’m not stoked about any of them. Why?
- Many recommendations for fencing that some people swear by and others said led to stock loss on their farms. Sorry for the bird lovers but this is something I would be more willing to experiment with for poultry, but I know myself and how I see my larger and more personable animals and I know I would take preventable losses hard. They will happen, this is farming, but I don’t want to go into this with a “let’s see if this fence works” approach.
- Stable livestock at night. Cool, sure, right now that’s the #1 idea in the running, but have yall seen building and material prices right now? Definitely a more cost and time prohibitive approach, especially considering rocky uneven ground that can’t be dug much and limited road access within property
- Livestock guardian dogs. These are amazing animals and have been a staple of agriculture the world over for much of human history for a reason. They are also difficult to manage safely (and insurance-wise) in an agrotourism-forward operation, and if I may be frank, they are drastically overrecommended to inexperienced people who are not good dog trainers, resulting in a very sad epidemic of these dogs in shelters because they were not given what they needed to succeed and ended up killing livestock. I am doing agrotourism, and I am inexperienced and not a good dog trainer, so this (and the assistance of an experienced trainer it would require) is a last resort for me.
- Livestock guardian not-dogs. These animals have very mixed results with things like packs of coywolves, and sometimes also kill lambs etc
- Shoot the coyotes. Not very permaculture, or very sustainable, but also I’m a bastion of woods amidst housing developments. There will always be more coyotes.
Anyway, this has been my mental puzzle for a good while now, and I finally thought: what if my pastures were nested within each other, with my largest and least tasty livestock on the outside, and the most vulnerable inside? I’ve noticed the coyotes steer clear of my horses. What if there was an outer loop of pasture with them inside, then a fence inside that with cows, a fence inside that with pigs, and then paddocks in the innermost ring with sheep, goats, and ducks? The large things could do multispecies succession grazing amid the outer rings and the small species could do pivot-style rotational succession grazing in the center. Anything that wanted to eat a small and tasty animal would have to cross multiple types of fences, so if any one type of fence wasn’t that effective against my specific predators it wouldn’t be the only line of defense.
This would have the added benefit of only needing to cut a road to one area instead of a series of separate fields, and similarly only need to get water to one general location.
Am I missing something that explains why I’ve never seen this? Would love thoughts!