After some removal from the initial watch and just being reminded of it again, I realize I still have interest for S4, and my thoughts about S3 got to crystalize a little. While the show and the season got a lot of fair criticism, most of which I heard and I a lot of which I agree with, I think the good points are solid enough to carry a lot of it, and maybe don't even get all the love they deserve.
So here is what I loved about S3:
- Aegon - it's not particularly original to point out that Aegon had a great arc and was the highlight of the season, but i think it's often delivered with the tone of "the best part of something really bad" which doesn't give enough credit to how genuinely good his character is. And by that I mean the acting, the whole arc (so I guess even credit to his writing), and even as far as individual scenes go. The rise of Sunfyre as he is giving his speech is just such a phenomenal moment and I don't give a shit about how people feel it may be unrealistic for Sunfyre to still be alive because I think it something that can be perfectly accepted within the universe. But betweent that and his scene with Larys giving him shit, and his moment with Aemond, he isn't just the best of shit characters, he is legitimately a strong character within the whole universe and a total pleasure to watch, just like GOTs best.
- Ormund - I know this isn't even from the books, but I really loved Ormund as a villain and all the intrigue and cruel fun he brought to the show. But what I especially love is that he brought the only actual point of view and cause I can support, as much as he may be villanous as a person. Really, picking a side between two entitled heirs of a psycho usurper foreign family just comes down to who you like more (or common sense, whose choice brings more stability to the realm and that would be going with the established tradition, so Aegon.) But here is someone who actually despises Targaryens and wants to slowly remove their lineage by using the most "civilized" and culturally most Westerosi one of the bunch. It's actually a noble desire for the nation to be free from the foreign ruler and to be governed by its own. And I really found it interesting and liked it. Also really good acting and overall enjoyable arc, I wasn't happy about his ending and relatively short stay, but to be fair considering he isn't even close to this in the books, I would be asking for a fanfiction. I should appreciate the nice surprise of a character the show gave us.
- Sheepstealer - I heard solid arguments from people who mind that there's no Nettles, but for what the show is, I genuinely don't mind it being Rhaena. While her character wasn't very strong through the season, I think it's also obvious that this story will continue so I won't rush to judge. On the other hand the character of Sheepstealer managed to emotionally resonate like no human characters can, and I can't imagine anyone not rooting for him when everyone ganged up on him.
- Daren and Gwayne - not the most interesting or the most exciting characters, but it was nice to just see two good guys trying to make it within the madness they can't get away from.
- Daemon - continued being solid and well-acted, and had a better plot than in S2, though funny how he grew into the voice of reason.
- Larys - also very good, appreciate his thinking and plotting.
While I don't have much nice to say about other characters, it is slightly enjoyable to see Rhaenyra fuck herself up and despair, and I genuinely like the actress who plays Alicent even when the character is lost. Starting with the death of Jace was strong, Helena's death had to happen too so I like to see the high stakes. As someone who shares Ormund's feelings of Targaryens, I actually enjoy seeing them suck and lose (feel bad for the dragons though), though Aemond manages to elevate himself above that with his charming personality and great arc.
So if S4 is more of Rhaenyra's crying as her family grows smaller, I'm in.
Btw - I did read the books, but I just watch the show as it's own thing since clearly it may change some significant elements like it was doing so far. At this point I just accepted it.