r/kumocrew • u/82nd_REBEL • 3d ago
Cycle 107: Evil Begets Evil
Ahoy Crew!
Lady Zi’s Fire Lotus Coalition continued to dominate much of the media (FDEV forum, subs on Reddit and many Discord servers) coverage throughout Cycle 107... largely thanks to her popularity among players—ranging from the most ardent fans of this "new revolutionary criminal syndicate" to those who remained skeptical, or others who were entirely indifferent to the whole narrative. A Discord server dedicated to the Fire Lotus Coalition has also been set up as well as a Reddit sub; it hosts a community of supporters (and perhaps a few detractors, too), as well as various squadrons with names and emblems that appear in the game. But perhaps, in the end, the appeals (or reminders) to pay attention and participate in the two [dual: attack/defense] CGs in Sorbago and Exphiay have had some effect... during the second—and final—week, the number of contributors increased, albeit not dramatically:
- Support Fire Lotus Coalition (Sorbago): >3.1k contributors, Tier 2/5
- Defend Mastopolos Mining Inc. (Sorbago): >6.9k contributors, Tier 2/5
- Support Fire Lotus Coalition (Exphiay): >2.5k contributors, Tier 2/5
- Defend Gallant Investment Brokers (Exphiay): >3.7k contributors, Tier 2/5
Based on the CGs results, despite winning for combat bonds in Exphiay (68m Cr. vs. 55m Cr.), it would seem that the "anti-corporation and anti-superpower" cause championed by the Fire Lotus Coalition has not gained much traction [but all CGs closing poorly at Tier 2/5 says even more…]. Moreover, in the Elite: Dangerous universe, "criminals" are almost always generically depicted as pirates—or, at the very least, as individuals with a notorious reputation (i.e. murderers, smugglers, robbers, conspirators and so on). Players almost never hear of crimes committed by "white-collars" or those dressed in expensive, ostentatious attire adorned with flashy jewelry. All the more so following the latest post on GalNet, "Hacking Concerns Grow in Major Systems," which reports on hacking incidents at stations in the Facece (Arissa Lavigny-Duval's stronghold), Nanomam (Jerome Archer's HQ), and Lave (Edmund Mahon's fortified) systems—carried out by a coder named Yaz Murano (some nobody who escaped during the prison break at Redonesses). The sort of thing that happens when a new bunch of outlaws tries to elbow their way up the Galaxy’s popularity ladder.
For the moment, there isn't much else to know... the two Lady Zi megaships (Whisper of the Wake and Coldwood) have set sail toward a permit-locked system... who knows if there will be anything new before the release of Law & Disorder [still scheduled for December, for now]. Or perhaps other CGs will see the light after the update’s release, to see whether the "outlaw side" of Elite finally gains more traction with the release of this game update.
The Powerplay Numbers
Where did Powerplay go in Cycle 107? The question behind this part of the weekly report is one that we find increasingly "intriguing"—though, at times, it also presents the greatest "complexities." In fact, rather than being complex, we should perhaps speak of "nuanced layers"—because, a couple of years after the arrival of Powerplay 2.0, it is clear for all to see that every Power, despite having one or more "centralized" communities to coordinate pledges, must ultimately find a way to coexist (or cooperate) with other communities, groups, or even individual CMDRs who are pursuing different plans, strategies, or simply other interests. And this occurs without causing any significant disruption to the Power as a whole—a point we have, in fact, discussed several times in these reports regarding the "decentralization" of Powerplay. Anyway, as always, let’s take things in order... starting with the +80 (net) acquisitions, which would have returned to triple digits if there were not so many systems being lost this week. Edmund Mahon posted an excellent result, leading the expansion standings, while Li Yong-Rui’s run suffered a major setback—one of the rare times we’ve seen a cycle end with a negative. Yuri Grom and Jerome Archer also hit a few bumps along the way, finishing with a flat balance, while Zemina Torval also posted a solid result,
- Mahon +21 (2426)
- Antal +17 (1720)
- Kaine +12 (1947)
- A.L. Duval +10 (2146)
- Torval +8 (850)
- Winters +7 (1318)
- Delaine +6 (974)
- A. Duval +5 (3270)
- Patreus +1 (747)
- Grom 0 (1697)
- Archer 0 (1375)
- Yong-Rui -7 (2316)
Surprisingly, Vanya Driscoll—a correspondent for the Alliance Tribune known for her stance against the risk of external interference in Alliance affairs—has published a statement in support of Edmund Mahon, which reads: “…we trust that someone intended to send a very clear message to Sirius. The old issues concerning Reorte and Alioth must not be forgotten, nor should the risk of causing reputational damage to the independence of our leaders—both prime minister Mahon and councilor Kaine—be underestimated.” She then added, “This has been an outstanding term for the Alliance, a well deserved success for the prime minister that we’d like to celebrate in Gateway, even though there are still a few minor disagreements with Tionisla to iron out.”
The Powers’ leaderboard therefore remains unchanged, as do the gaps between the most competitive Powers—though it is worth noting the successful Pranav Antal’s attempt to pull further ahead of Yuri Grom, having overtaken him a couple of cycles ago. Given that both Powers have fairly substantial active player bases, it is logical that it will take some time to establish a more significant and stable lead. Although the total volume of reinforcements (approximately >69m RF CPs, of which >6.3m were "wasted") was in line with Cycle 106 (with much less CPs “wasted”), what we have observed is, without a doubt, a greater dispersion among the Powers. It is no coincidence that there is a very significant gap between the top-ranked Power (Aisling Duval, >12.9m RF CPs) and the lowest-ranked one (Denton Patreus, >1.2m RF CPs). Of course, it should be noted that the "war chest" for Cubeo contains over 2.6m "wasted" RF CPs, and there are more than >600k RF CPs at the Exphiay stronghold (CG).
On the other hand, it is also true that for many Powers, reinforcements [in certain systems] are directly affected by the "drag effect" from the undermining side—especially in systems in a "boom" state with ring/surface mining resources—though the correlation is not always one-to-one. This is the case, for example, with a bunch of no-name-whatever XYZ Sector colonies and well-known systems such as HIP 104026 (Aisling Duval) and HIP 100259 (Pranav Antal). In other situations, the opportunity for a quick upgrade—immediately following acquisition—encourages the acquiring Power to continue their push for as long as the economic state allows; in Cycle 107, there were five such "upgrade sweeps," pushing systems from [new] exploited to fortified across different Powers. Among the contributors to the RF bottom line there are, of course, other systems—specifically those that experienced "hostilities" during the cycle and where reinforcers did their best to counter UM. Among them we might include Fuelum (Yuri Grom), Andel, Iverdi, Honoto and Wulpurna (Felicia Winters), ICZ MS-T b3-1 (Li Yong-Rui), and 64 G. Capricorni (Archon Delaine, see below).
Where undermining has not been countered, the result has been losses or risk of being downgraded (e.g., Yuri Grom’s LHS 480 and Luyten 205-128, Aisling Duval’s HIP 50070, and Jerome Archer’s EP Eridani). There are certainly other similar situations and, as we anticipated, there have been many systems lost among the ones left with little or none reinforcements above the minimum threshold—the details of which we leave to the reports of the respective Powers—but regarding overall undermining (>13.1m UM CPs / >24.7m UM CPs including decay), there has been a degree of dispersion, with four Powers each one accounting for around 10% or more of the total (>1.3m UM CPs), a few more around 1m UM CPs and a significant gap between the most heavily undermined (Li Yong-Rui, >1.9m UM CPs) and the least undermined (Denton Patreus, just above >200k UM CPs). The zero and negative numbers we’re seeing in the expansions table are very likely a consequence of focused UM activities.
Having observed these undermining numbers for several cycles now, following the introduction of Rhino and surface mining, it seems to us that a new equilibrium has been reached. At least a greater balance—as we’ve already mentioned—between players’ UM and decay, with the former averaging above 50% of the latter. We must also consider the marginal contribution from Operations; however, it’s easy to expect that, unless something changes, the undermining numbers will increase (and not by a small measure) once the Rhino becomes available to all players. All the more reason, then, for us to continue to argue that Powerplay’s other activities will also need to be rebalanced even more—starting with trading and combat. That said, further changes to the PP2 framework could come with Law & Disorder.
The Pirates
Let’s start right away with the good news, which mainly concerns acquisitions (+6 in Cycle 107), since several that had been in the backlog for some time have been completed, and the Crew also succeeded in the contested 18 Aquarii. Among the first to be mentioned are Crathajapus (an industrial colony controlled by Channel Zero and within range of Delaine’s stronghold in Biko) and HIP 110106 (an extraction system controlled by allies of the Tethys Independent Crew [TICR] and within range of our stronghold in 34 Pegasi). As for the contested one (18 Aquarii), it was really little more than a skirmish among alley cats, at least at the beginning when the bearded dictator Grom tried to even the CPs score. Then the scallywags pulled ahead a bit, until the few agents sent by Clayakarma packed their bags and disappeared. It’s certainly not a system of value that joins Harma with this success, but from what we’ve observed over the past few months, it’s best to keep the bears at a safe distance.
There’s no reason to complain about the reinforcements either, given that Cycle 107 still posted quite respectable bottom-line numbers; however, they were spent primarily on “counter [UM]mining” and on some repairs that had been pending from the past few weeks. The addition of a new stronghold brings us closer—albeit only slightly—to the goal of reaching triple digits in the medium term and thereby increasing the resilience of the Pirate King’s territories. The strategic approach Harma is pursuing is based on the need to have a “solid foundation” on which to build any future expansion plans, particularly toward the Pegasi Sector, where there is still abundance of unclaimed territory and where there is also a great historical value for Archon Delaine. Provided, of course, that Lady Zi doesn't come back to cause too much chaos in the Galaxy... Or at least, Archon Delaine hopes that the new “criminal syndicate”, the Fire Lotus Coalition, will focus its attention on the “enemies of corporations and other superpowers” rather than on those who, for so many years, have provided her with room and board, as well as teaching her the ropes of the pirate profession. So far, there have been no official diplomatic contacts... although pirates, in general, have certainly never been known for their “diplomacy,” favouring the classic parlay over such a traditional and formal landlubber practice.
The Crew’s reinforcers also focused, as we mentioned earlier, on containing undermining attacks... including, for example, Bhattra (where few enemy pledges were intercepted and eliminated) and Autamkindia, joined by Bamuti and 64 G. Capricorni. The latter had, in fact, been added to the Imperial tribe’s list of public targets… unfortunately, once again showing a lack of respect toward the Crew. We’ve already pointed this out in the past: listing these targets without the notation “open-play required” only leads to awkward situations where sportsmanship and fun are clearly the main victims. Callan Salamanca, a member of the Kumo Council, declared to the Pegasi Sentinel that “...as we have done in the past, one way or another, those lecherous imperialists and sunken-crowns worshipers will end up facing the consequences of their actions… Perhaps some other innocent one will end up paying for the sins of those who didn't want to risk getting their hands dirty in our turf!” and then concluded “...a behavior typical of these regrettable lineages, who enjoy embellishing themselves with aristocratic titles and then shift the responsibility for their misdeeds onto their people.”
As we pointed out last week, there have been a few events involving Harma’s BGS… events that have led to some changes and have helped shake things up at Gabriel Enterprise as well. Incidentally, to our surprise, we also received help from other players who, despite not supporting Archon Delaine, still wanted to lend a hand, and hardpoints, against a common “threat”. We thank all of them here as well, offering barrels of Silver Sea Rum in exhange… even though this confirms that whoever orchestrated this operation isn’t very well-liked in the Galaxy (for what is worth). For Cycle 108, priority will obviously be given to reinforcements for the new acquisitions, as well as additional repairs (e.g., to Lalande 45292 and a handful of other systems that have fallen behind in recent weeks). As of now (at the time of writing), no other CGs have been announced. But it’s also Black Friday week—which, after all, is the color of the pirate flag—so be sure to check out the deals on the FDEV Store (as well as the black paint jobs). And if you happen to have a little time left, don't miss the VoW (Video of the Week) from the Kumo Crew piglet pirate CMDR HairyHogg: “Piracy! When in Trouble, Stay Cool!” YARRR!!!
Cycle 108: Preliminary Targets
All systems below the 25% CPs “decay threshold” are good/eligible targets to be reinforced (as these systems will not be hit by decay). Prioritize strongholds over fortified and leave exploited as last ones. All acquisitions above 100k CPs (or being contested during the Cycle) are good/eligible targets to be acquired.
Attack/Defend Markers: The markers may change during the Cycle and may not necessarily follow the current plans, so be sure to check the system activity and status on GalMap (when in doubt: ask).
To our enemies: don't be shy—be respectful. If you decide to pay a visit to Archon Delaine’s systems, the [only one] appropriate game mode is “Open Play.”
Seek & Destroy (enemy presence/UM): Harma.
Reinforce ([new]/recent acquisitions): 18 Aquarii, Crathajapus and HIP 110106.
Reinforce (counter [unknown] enemy UM): Bhattra, Bamuti, Lalande 45292, Turd Wu, Autamkindia and LHS 3702.
Acquire (new/backlog): HIP 112069, HIP 110447 and Neitsi.
Re-acquire (previously lost systems): LHS 1026.
Blockade enemy takeovers/contested: N.A.
Undermine: OpSec.
Operations (UM enemy systems): OpSec.
Further updates will be broadcast on Tortuga Radio Frequencies.
Click here for the Elite Dangerous - Powerplay 2.0 Reddit Digest.
FOR THE ARCHON!!!
