r/legaladvice • • Apr 08 '26

Subreddit Rules

75 Upvotes

We've learned that some people just flat out can't see our subreddit rules, so I'm posting them here in a pinned post so we can link them when necessary and so they're super easy to find.

Rules for r/legaladvice Rules that visitors must follow to participate. May be used as reasons to report or ban.

All responses must offer an answer to the legal question posed by the OP. We enforce this with bans.

Anecdotes are not permitted. Neither is advice that encourages someone to break the law. Nor is "get a lawyer" a sufficient response.

There's a pinned post at the top of the subreddit specifically addressing this rule. We will absolutely ban you for commenting without answering the legal question

2. Personally Identifying Information

Posts or submissions that ask for or contain information that could be used to identify either party are subject to immediate removal.

3. Advertising or Recommending a Lawyer or Business

We do not allow referrals to particular lawyers, law firms, or other businesses.

4. Do not request or send a PM

All discussions must stay on the subreddit for everyone's protection.

5. Include your location

You must include your location in the following format: location: yourlocationhere . It must be that exact format, and it must be in the body of your post.

6. Read our full list of rules

Read our full list of rules here: https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/wiki/index#wiki_general_rules

7. This subreddit is for simple legal questions.

This subreddit is for simple legal questions. We can't help with preparing a defense, legal research, etc. We cannot review contracts, plan your defense, or give you specific advice on exactly how to present your case with the court. You need a local attorney for that. Additionally, we do not accept medical malpractice questions.

8. NO LLMS

No LLMs. No ChatGPT. Don't recommend it, don't use it to answer questions, and don't use it to compose your modmail when you get banned for using it. Using it to compose questions is generally ok.

We will permanently and irrevocably ban you for this.

9. Mods can remove things we deem inappropriate or disruptive

Any post and any comment can be removed by the mods at any time if the mods decide the post/comment is or has the potential to be disruptive or is otherwise inappropriate.

10. Posts must be about a real scenario that you or someone you know is facing.

To expand on this, we additionally do not allow anyone but the immediately involved parties to ask custody related questions. Not friends, not significant others, not grandparents. Reddit is free.

11. Post must contain a legal question

A legal question is one that can be answered with the law, be it a law or ordinance, or caselaw.

12. US and Canada only

Laws are different everywhere. We can only help with legal problems in the US or Canada because we have no regular, reliable commenters from other countries. For other countries, please search for an appropriate subreddit.


r/legaladvice • • Mar 15 '25

Mod Post Read before commenting: Off-topic and anecdotal comments are not allowed and subject you to a permanent ban

171 Upvotes

Greetings from the mods!

We've had a flood of off-topic comments recently. We're posting this to remind everyone that off-topic and anecdotal comments are not allowed. An off-topic comment may subject you to a permanent ban.

The Rule:

Commenting Rule 1: Comments should contain a legal answer or a strongly related non-legal answer. If it is not legal advice, do not post. Period. You will be banned.

What is "off-topic?"

Any response that doesn't answer the question by reference to legal information or principles. A joke, a wisecrack, a comment about OP's formatting (use the report button instead) are all off-topic. Off-topic also includes expressions of sympathy, opinions on the law, and comments that berate the OP or anyone else.

Incidentally, simply adding "get a lawyer" to an off-topic comment does not make it on-topic. And "get a lawyer" on its own, without further information or help, is considered unhelpful and may be removed on that basis.

If you want to discuss a post, then wait until it hits /r/bestoflegaladvice or ask a question about the subject of the post in /r/legaladviceofftopic. The main subreddit and a comment thread are never a place to have a philosophical discussion about the law or the post. It is a place to answer the questions asked.

What is an "anecdote?"

For our purposes, anecdotes are stories about something that happened to you (or someone you know or heard about) who may have had something that might be similar that happen to them.

These comments are not helpful. They do not include current legal information that is relevant to the OP, and therefore, they are off-topic. If you know the answer to the question (based on current law and relevant jurisdiction) then just answer the question without the story.

Another type of anecdote is "I don't know the law in the jurisdiction you actually asked about, but in some other state, the law is..." That is just not helpful. Laws are different in different places. These types of answers are off-topic.

Referring an OP to a thread on a different subreddit, or to somewhere else on the Internet because it might include a similar situation, is anecdotal advice and not allowed.

These are not the only types of anecdotes, but they are probably the most common ones. Again, if you are not referencing legal information or principles, your comment is probably not allowed.

Violations subject the user to an immediate and permanent ban

Not that we need to justify enforcing our rules, but this is a busy subreddit and the mods have a lot to do. If a user shows up here, doesn't read the rules, and posts a single off-topic comment, the user may be immediately and permanently banned.

This policy is not intended to be punitive, although we know it may seem to be. There are a lot of you and not many of us, and banning users that do not follow the rules, even once, is in the best interests of the subreddit. Violating the rules almost always means the user didn't bother to read them, and we simply don't have time to deal with such users.

Tl;dr: Unless you have a legal answer, do not reply to any post in this subreddit. You may be permanently banned, even for a first offense.


r/legaladvice • • 54m ago

Terminated for bereavement/false report

95 Upvotes

Location: Minnesota

My brother passed away on 11/10. I took my two days off bereavement and was offered the opportunity to take more off as PTO days. I communicated to my supervisor and copart that I would be using these days. On 11/18 I was called by regional HR manager and informed about a report that I threw a trash can at my copart (which never happened, nothing was ever thrown and that’s easily provable by camera) and was accused of “walking off” for using bereavement. I have the texts between my manager communicating about bereavement and I have texts with my comanager on the day of the alleged trash can throwing and after where we were communicating just fine. I find it weird the garbage can incident took place in October and I only heard about it after I was reported by the same manager for walking off the job.

I know Minnesota is at will, but I’m trying to find my best course of action. The job was really good money and I loved all of my employees


r/legaladvice • • 2h ago

Employment Law Contacted my former employer’s HR with concerns about my termination and received legal threats.

77 Upvotes

Location: North Carolina. I was terminated from my job of 12 years for performance reasons which were all fabricated against me. I sent a letter to HR stating I had concerns about my termination including repeated encouragement to join a specific political or ideological organization (I have evidence of) which caused a noticeable difference in treatment. I did not mention anyone or anything specifically in my letter and HR said they will respond where appropriate. I heard nothing until I received my first demand letter from my former supervisor threatening legal action if I do not tell HR my letter was false. I just ignored the letter and received a second which I ignored and it has been silent since.

Do I have anything to worry about considering I never named specific people or groups yet I received legal action from the specific person.


r/legaladvice • • 9h ago

A “friend” I had made my freshman year is accusing me of drugging and raping him.

141 Upvotes

About 2 days ago a person who I thought was a friend of mine contacted me with lengthy paragraphs accusing me of drugging and raping him. For context, I am a 21yr old straight male, I come from a christian background and I’m not a homosexual; I also haven’t talked to him in over 2 years. I had never really hung out with this guy outside of like playing video games and such with him when other friends were present and these accusations were really out of the blue. I haven’t responded to him and I’ve just screenshotted everything he’s messaged me. However, he has also began messaging friends of mine as well as my family members calling me a rapist and such. I talked to a police officer about all of this today and nothing really happened but currently I’m just sitting here wondering what I should do. This whole situation is insane and he keeps claiming he has proof and stuff but I mean I know that’s a lie but I’m really just wondering what I should do. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Location: Mississippi


r/legaladvice • • 2h ago

Roommate stole debit card to make unauthorized purchases

30 Upvotes

Location: Maine

(For context, I’m a student at UMF)

On Friday, I noticed a purchase from a local hair salon that I did not make. I don’t share my account/card info with anyone, and my card was in my wallet in my room(where I usually keep it). Later on Friday, another purchase was made on campus; this is when I became really concerned, and a friend recommended that I contact the salon owner.

At this time, I had no suspicions about my roommate; however, after contacting the salon to ask about the charge, the owner revealed that my roommate had charged my card. The owner confirmed that my roommate was the person who charged my card. After thinking about it, he was the only one who could’ve had access to my card, and the transaction the owner received matched my banking app’s record and the last 4 digits of my card. And altogether, the total amount he spent was $28

It's important to note that tho we don't have a problem with each other, we aren't besties either. And on Friday, before I found out, he was packing to leave “Thanksgiving”. And being unusually chatty and looking back, almost seemed trying to kiss up

I contacted my RA and Campus police yesterday, and Campo gave me these options.

A. Ask for the money back and have Campo speak with him

B. Just “let the whole thing go,” and Campo will still speak with him and keep an eye on him

C. Press charges

I asked for clarification and whether he would receive any punishment if I don’t press charges, and the officer basically said nothing, and since he is gone, whatever action I take wouldn't happen until after Thanksgiving break. The officer is giving me until Monday to decide what I want to do.

I have been asking around and told my parents and friends, but I also want more second opinions


r/legaladvice • • 1d ago

Clients told me in writing not to finish their photo gallery, then sued me for not delivering it. Just got served. How bad is this?

2.5k Upvotes

Location: Colorado
I am a wedding photographer in Colorado. Signed contract for a multi-day shoot in the backcountry this summer, about $13k, fully paid. Contract says it's the entire agreement, services can't be deducted, final payment is for "photography hours and post production editing," permits are the client's responsibility (two separate clauses), and the prevailing party in any legal action gets attorney fees. Delivery term is sneak peeks next day, full gallery 10 weeks later.

Shoot went awesome and I had a blast and we all were talking about how we need to hang more. I added two extra days for weather and safety at no charge and put them up at my house. Sent sneak peeks the next day.

A week later they texted that they didn't like the photos because of the bride's dress, and asked for a free reshoot. I declined and offered a paid session. Client texted back "no need to process the remaining photos, we'll go with someone else." I replied in writing within the hour that I would deliver the full gallery as contracted within the 10 week window. The bride then replied "no need to spend even more time editing the rest of them," said the lighting and scenery were beautiful, and ended with "you don't want to, so okay. Now we know."

Then nothing for three months. I did not deliver the gallery, because they told me twice not to.
In October I got an email from the client, cc'ing a lawyer, demanding a full refund for breach of contract, claiming I delivered 10% of the photos, shot without permits, and used their photo on my website. I called the lawyer. He told me he was not retained and had not read the contract or the texts. I removed the photo from my site and sent a detailed written response with the contract and full text thread attached, offered again to deliver the full gallery, and (I regret this) added a paragraph that was angry and personal about the dress.

Last week they filed in county court. Full contract price plus interest and about $1,100 in attorney fees. Jury demand. Return date is a month out. I'm hiring a lawyer this week.

Questions:
- Do they actually have a case?
- Does "no need to spend more time editing the rest" after I offered delivery actually work as a waiver in Colorado?
- Should I deliver the full gallery now, before the answer is filed?
- Is a counterclaim for attorney fees under the contract worth it, or does it just make things uglier?
Not looking for "get a lawyer," already doing that. Looking for how Colorado practitioners see this.


r/legaladvice • • 16h ago

Consumer Law Salon posted my before photos with a fake after photo that was not me

218 Upvotes

Location: Massachusetts, USA

I went to a new salon after feeling unhappy with my last one. My appointment was somewhat extensive as I have hair loss from a medical consition. I had a mesh integration system done.

The owner/stylist took before photos. She said nothing about posting them, just that she wanted photos to document how my hair looks. She did not get my face in them. About halfway through the appointment she realized I was unhappy with the way it was turning out. She continued to ask how she could fix it and I told her I wasnt sure what it was that I wanted changed and maybe I just had to get used to it. She continued to act upset but finished my hair. At the end she sent me to the front to pay. I asked if I could tip her on their POS machine. She said something along the lines of "why would you tip if you dont like it? I dont want you to tip" and walked away. We did NOT take after photos of the finished hair. On their social media is a video with a "before" photo of my hair, a photo of my hair in the middle of the process, then a clip at the end of the "after" that is NOT me. I am unsure if it is AI or literally another person that she had wear similar clothing as me to take photos of.

Is there anything I can do about this? I was already thinking of going there to ask for a removal since my head is in an immense amount of pain (not normal for this hair system since extra tension can cause even more hairloss) but now I'd really like to see what I can do about using my photos and posting fake results? I did not sign any agreement or contract for anything regarding the appointment and again, I was not asked and did not verbally consent to photos being posted.


r/legaladvice • • 1d ago Bravo

BMW employee totaled my car

1.0k Upvotes

Location: Houston, TX

I took my car in to a BMW service center on October 24th to get my routine maintenance done. When I came back to pick up my car I was told that while one of their technicians was driving the car he got into an accident. I was told that the other driver ran a stop sign causing the accident. A few moments later they pulled my car into the service center and the front bumper had all the damage. They said they would take car of the repairs and put me in a loaner car.

A few days later I called my service advisor and he said that the other driver's insurance found that driver at fault but they were only willing to pay for 75% of the repair. He said they were trying to get that figured out first and didn't have an ETA on when I should get my repairs done, because insurance can sometimes take weeks, but I'm able to keep my loaner in the meantime.

Fast forward to November 19th I still haven't reached any update or communication on my car. I decided to send an email to corporate, the parent company as well as the VP of BMW detailing the situation. An hour later I received a call from the service center's general manager and asked me for details on what happened. I let him know and he said he would call the body shop in the morning and get back to me.

The next morning I then get a call from the sales manager saying the insurance company has said my car is a total loss and someone will come out early next week to do a walkthrough and get evaluation of my car. I do not have gao insurance all I have is car replacement assistance coverage. When I told him this he said we will wait until they say how much they will value the car and we will look at options from there. I told him in that moment that I did not feel like I should have to pay for anything out of pocket as my car was under BMW's possession at the time of the accident.

Later that night I get a call from the service advisor. He also tells me that my car has been totaled. He then says that since insurance has found the other driver at fault that BMW is not financially responsible for anything.

At this point I'm not sure what to do. I am looking into getting an attorney but is he right that BMW isn't responsible? I was also advised by a friend to not go and get any of my belongings out of the car yet because that could be agreeing to my car being totaled and releasing my car. Is that true as well? I need a few things out of my car but I know Texas laws are different than what I'm used to

EDIT: I forgot to mention since I had no communication from the service center I never received any information such as a police report, the employee who was driving the car, the other driver, their insurance, or an insurance claim number. When it first happened I called my insurance and they told me that since BMW is handling everything that I don't need to do anything additional. Because of this I still don't have any info and when I requested it in an email the sales manager told me they were working on it and the advisor that called later said he will have to ask a manager because there may be legalities where they can't share certain information.


r/legaladvice • • 18h ago

My mom abandoned my 15 year old brother

206 Upvotes

Okay long story. Location: Charleston, Wv

In 2024 my dad passed away. My mom and younger brother were still living together when this happened and still lived in the family home. I was already supposed to move in to help out when he got sick but his cancer progressed very quickly and he died before I could even do anything. My mom does not drive, and has never had a job. I moved in after he passed to help her with necessities like grocery shopping etc. Everything was fine at first, she got a 100k life insurance policy and was also getting survivors benefits for her and my brother. She is very impulsive and ended up spending all of the money in less than a year. When her money was almost gone at the end of the year she met a guy and essentially stayed gone until she was technically just living with him. She left all responsibility to me. Left all her animals and my brother. Also around this time my other adult brother broke up with his girlfriend and moved in with me. The time I lived there she sent me grocery money for my brother from her survivors benefits and that was it. I had to pay all utilities and whatever extra, make sure my brother went to school pretty much take over all her responsibilities. My adult brother brought a ton of cats in and essentially ruined the house, wouldn’t help clean, didn’t have a job etc. I stayed there all of 2024 with my mom, everything went to shit 2025 and now here in 2026 I’ve moved out and taken my little brother with me. My mom was fine with this arrangement and she started sending my brothers half of the survivors benefits to me for my childcare of him. The insane part is when I left I tried to get her to take her child and she would not. She said he’s old enough to take care of himself and was essentially trying to leave him with my mentally unwell brother in a cesspit. I got the paperwork together to get custody of him and she’s willing so far to sign off on it and do everything cordially. The issue is this: now that my little brother is about to turn 16 her benefits will be cut off and she is trying to say I don’t deserve the money and she’s the real survivor. She also has never done probate on my dad’s estate so all of his stuff is at risk of being taken because he had debts left behind that she never took care of. I don’t want my brother to end up in foster care, which is why I haven’t gone the cps route. What can I do????


r/legaladvice • • 15h ago

Consumer Law Business Threatening to Sue Wrong Person

121 Upvotes

Location: Parkville, MO

My husband and I hired a local roofing company to replace our roof. On Friday, 11/20, they came and replaced our roof. Then first thing this morning, 11/21, they called us, saying they were going to sue us for a 1 star Google Review. We did not leave a Google Review. When we looked on Google Reviews, we saw that a review was just posted by someone whose username indicates they have the same first name as me. We explained to the company that it was not me. We even sent them proof that it was not me, including pictures of myself vs pictures from the profile of the person who left the review, and screen shots of my own Google account and every Google Review I have left to show this is a separate person.

Regardless of what we said, they did not believe me. The owner and his son were so incredibly rude and accusatory. The owner even made some statement of, "I've been running a 5 star business for 30 years!" If you ask me, they have only kept that 5 star rating by harassing anyone who dares to leave a bad review, only this time they got the wrong person. It all boiled down to them saying that the lawyers will handle it all on Monday.

I have absolutely no idea what to do. Should I get in contact with a lawyer? I did file a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission, The Missouri Attorney General Consumer Protection thing, and BBB. But now I'm expecting court documents to show up to my door about them suing me over a review I did not leave. We also still owe this business thousands of dollars, and I feel so gross about that too now in the wake of everything.


r/legaladvice • • 1d ago

Landlord Tenant Housing Landlord changed doors and locks to whole building locking out 60+ tenants

537 Upvotes

Location: Chicago I’m a renter. My new landlords purchased the building I live in a couple months ago. Yesterday they changed the door to the main building, and today the changed the side door. They informed us after work had already begun, and said this would not be disruptive, however last night when I got home my keys did not work. I was still able to get into the building from the side door, but as of today that door has also been removed and the locks changed.

I have contacted them multiple times via text and email, and reported it to 311. What else can I do? Can I use this as grounds to terminate my lease? They have also previously barred me from paying rent online, and refused to accept my checks (which I think is also illegal).


r/legaladvice • • 15h ago

Employment Law Is my employer allowed to deny me water if I don't have a container to store it?

98 Upvotes

Location: Pennsylvania

I work at Chic-Fil-A, and they have a rule with free water to employees, that being you can have water for free if you bring a container for it. Though it would be easy to bring a water container, sometimes me and my co-workers forget, to which they tell us we're basically shit out of luck, even though they have cups. Water is also free to customers with the cup, but for some reason not for us.

Is this legal? I know refusing water outright is illegal, but is it legal to have this caveat with their water distribution?

EDIT: I need to make this really clear because people are not grasping what I am saying. The ground rule is if you do not own or have a container for water, you are not allowed to have access to the water that is there, period. So, if you show up to work with no water bottle, then you just can't have water, doesn't matter if you own one or not.

Also, everyone STOP downvote bombing comments that don't agree with you. I don't mean me specifically, I don't care about that, but this is just turning into a massive argument with everyone, and people just ganging up on eachother. I don't want to have to make another post. Be respectful.


r/legaladvice • • 21h ago

Traffic and Parking Is it legal to cover my car in sequins?

188 Upvotes

Location: Missouri

I recently bought an old beater van online. It's ugly as sin, but it will get me from point A to point B reliably. However, I would really like to change the ugly as sin part of it.

I am very, VERY into anything bright, colorful, and shiny. I can't really afford to have this thing professionally painted, but I do have access to millions of multicolored sequins.

My question is, if I were to attach the sequins to the outside of the van, is that legal? They'll be properly glued on, so they're not going to come off and hit other cars or anything. But I know that they are particularly sparkly in the sun, and I wasn't sure if that would make them illegal.


r/legaladvice • • 7h ago

Can I get my dad arrested for leaking gas in the house and creating fire hazards?

11 Upvotes

Location: Portland, Oregon

I don’t use Reddit, but I figured I should probably try to see if this is even worth perusing before hiring a lawyer or calling the police.

For the past week my dad has been leaking propane into the house. He’s not doing it to intentionally hurt anyone, but it’s still happening. He said that he’s transferring propane from the tank to something else, but the smell is so strong. He has bipolar 1 and is manic almost constantly. He won’t elaborate and he won’t see an issue and he will never view himself as in the wrong. Yesterday the smell was so strong we had to spend the night at a friend/neighbors house. We had to beg him to leave the house with us and he started yelling and accused my mom of being dramatic. He did eventually leave though, just not with us. My concern is that it’s propane and I know propane can be very dangerous. It’s November, but we’re keeping all the windows open because of the propane and even then I’ve had a headache for the past few days. We also are in a very fire hazard riddled house!! So it being propane is scaring me a lot and that’s why I wanna know if I can call the police. I know we’ve had other gas leaks in the house, but I don’t know what because my dad refused to tell us what it was.

For some background my dad is a hoarder. He mostly hoards machinery, both large and small, and tools too. He has filled our house with broken microwaves, ovens, laundry machines, literally any appliance you can think of, and they’re always broken or barely work. He leaves his tools lying around, both dangerous and not. Power saws, hand held grinders, welding tools, torches, etc idk I’m not a tools guy. When my sister was 14 she stepped on a razor blade he had left out and she had to go to the hospital. Her foot was almost split open and she still feels some pain when she walks for too long (she’s 18 now). Once he caused a fire in the garage because he was welding next to his pile of clothes.

My sister and I are both adults (18 and 20), but we do both have autism and struggle a lot with independence. When I turned 18 I was given the option to continue our parents being our legal guardians, but I opted out because I wanted to prove that I could be a functional adult. My sister did the same so I don’t think we meet the criteria for disabled adult endangerment because we are our own legal guardians. This has been going on for my whole life though and we were taken away by CPS when we were 11 and 13. My dad swore in court that he would change to regain custody of us. He did not change.

We have 2 dogs in the house. I’ve tried to re-home them, but my mom gets upset at the idea of letting the dogs go, so I’m focusing more on keeping their areas clean and making sure they’re taken care on inside the home.

I’m planning to move out in a month and take my sister and the dogs with me, but the gas is happening right now and it’s scaring me. I’m not sure if I should call the police about the gas right now, or just get out of the house and talk to a lawyer later, or if none of this is viable legally and all I can do is move out and never look back.


r/legaladvice • • 2h ago

Publisher committed a breach of contract with one of my books that likely shut me out of the recent Anthropic settlement and others to come. How to proceed?

4 Upvotes

LOCATION: CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS

Last year, around the time when the landmark Bartz v. Anthropic suit led to a settlement for authors and publishers who had their works pirated, I discovered that my publisher had committed a serious breach of contract with one of my books that appeared in the online mirror libraries that Anthropic downloaded the books from.

To qualify for the settlement, pirated works had to be registered with the US copyright office at the time of the pirating. My publisher had failed to register this particular book of mine for US copyright within 90 days of publication, which the book contract explicitly required them to do. A lot of other authors discovered similar breaches of contract from their publishers, via the same event.

This breach may have led to my book being excluded from the Bartz v. Anthropic settlement, and it could also mean being shut out of future settlements from AI piracy suits that are currently in play; if the copyright quaifier is used for eligibility in those suits too. So, the potential damages here are big.

But what makes this tricky is the "potential" part. Me and my publisher have no way of knowing if the book that wasn't registered with the US copyright office was part of the dataset that Anthropic illegally downloaded, because we don't have access to that master list of books. This publisher is one of the so-called Big Five. Notably, when authors learned of these copyright breaches, one of the other publishers from the Big Five (Macmillan) decided to take accountability for the lapses on their end, assuming that harm had been done to the affected authors and promising to pay them the money that the Anthropic settlement would have yielded if their books had been registered for copyright. This was a big deal, and those of us with books from the other Big Five publishers have been waiting to see if they would follow Macmillan's lead.

Unfortunately, one year later, my publisher has not taken any steps to compensate authors in my position. They did belatedly register my book with the US copyright office, but on the matter of damages, I have been in touch with their legal team to inquire about their position over the last several months. In September, I basically learned that my publisher is basically doing the opposite of Macmillan; taking advantage of the ambiguity with this situation and assuming that no harm was done to authors via their breaches of contract (essentially saying, "We have no way of knowing if your book was in the dataset, so we're not doing anything.") I sent them a followup message about this, with additional questions, and they never responded to it.

In late October, per the advisement of the Authors Guild, I sent the publisher's legal team a demand letter for the money that the Bartz v. Anthropic settlement would have yielded for the affected book. Unsurprisingly, they did not respond to the letter. So now, I am trying to figure out how to proceed and whether there is a legal path forward from here. I have no qualms about burning a bridge with this publisher. They've already lit the match and set the fire.

The question is whether taking them to court for a breach of contract suit would be worth it, given that I have no way of proving damages in the Bartz v. Anthropic case?

If there's a precedent for such lawsuits hinging on probable damages (current and anticipated), then taking my publisher to small claims court is something I would strongly consider. But if making this kind of legal argument would require the skills of an IP lawyer, then I might be out of luck; as the cost of retaining a lawyer would probably be more than what I could win in a suit like this.

Alternatively, instead of seeking monetary compensation for damages, I have thought about going to court with the goal of securing a rights reversion: This would put the publisher in a very tough spot because they are publishing a new edition of the impacted book next year, which contains much of the original manuscript. If the rights for the affected book reverted to me, they might have to scuttle that book. This could make them amenable to a settlement.

It's a weird situation and I'm prepared for the possibility that a resolution might depend entirely on the decency of the publisher. Worst case scenario, I cut ties with my publisher and go public about my experience with them in channels frequented by authors, agents, and editors. But I'm only taking that path if exploring legal options yields no alternative options. And that’s the question here: Is considering a breach of contract suit worth it in this case?


r/legaladvice • • 9h ago

Drug addicts are inhabiting my deceased father's house. What recourse do I have?

15 Upvotes

Location: North Carolina

Dad died 2 weeks ago, no will, renting the property. I am the only living hier and next of kin. I am stuck in the UK right now because my visa hasn't been fully processed and can't get back to the USA until that happens or I won't be able to return to the UK.

Funnily enough, I deal with intestate estates in the UK but I'm at a loss for the USA. To keep things simple, dad had allowed a meth head to stay with him because he was old, lonely, and I suspect that he had dementia. The methhead has now taken over the property and has gotten the landlord on his side. They have a verbal agreement that they will live there and will be signing paperwork on Monday.

All property inside the house was my dad's or mine. I know they've already been stealing things as early as the day after he passed where they moved in fully and have been lying that they live there. Hell, one of the vehicles is already missing and they tried to replace my dad's debit card the day he went to hospital.

I'm tempted to just get what I can, mostly sentimental things, and just let it go. Unfortunately, dad also left some debt that I'll need to clear.

So where things get tricky... I was being civil with them but yesterday, a third party got the law involved as the person who was romance scamming my dad called for a welfare check as she was no longer receiving money. I stupidly asked the law to get them out of the property but they showed the police text messages with the landlord and said my dad had been letting them live there. So now they know and I'm afraid of retaliation.

What recourse do I have here?

I'm tempted to press charges for elderly abuse as this is a clear case of cuckooing (UK law) as well as theft for the car and attempted debit card. I just want to know in case I decide to do anything. Like I said, I just want this all to stop.


r/legaladvice • • 2h ago

Upcoming Meeting with State and Federal Prosecutors

3 Upvotes

I need to keep this as vague as possible as to the actual job description, as well as Agency names, as this is a major Federal case that will be going to litigation soon.

Location: Virginia, and that is as much as I will divulge.

First, a little background-

I am a former employee of a State Agency. We were "subcontracted" by a Federal Agency, 100% funded by that agency, trained and given the titles and the authority of members of that agency.

We inspected civilian "processing" plants. In the course of my inspections, I discovered "paperwork issues" and incongruities. I brought this to the attention of colleagues, as well as my supervisor, and was told not to worry about it, just keep monitoring things. A few days later, the Federal Agency we worked for informed us they were coming to investigate a few deaths that occurred, directly associated with what I had found.

My supervisor informed me of this, then told me to essentially speak as little as possible to the Investigators. I did not comply with her order, and FULLY complied with the Investigators. This led to the closing of the plant. A week or so later, I was fired- for made up reasons that I had evidence I was unable to have done, as I was in a documented meeting at the time. As I was only 7 months on the job, and my State has a 1 year Probationary Status, I had no legal recourse (at the time).

Now, to the present.

I was visited by two Special Agents from two Federal Agencies. They wanted to talk to me about the closed plant. I am MORE than willing to cooperate. In the midst of our discussion, I evidently had given them information that they had not heard before. Nor did they know that I had been terminated from the State Agency. As I gave the basic information listed above (and more, that I CANNOT disclose here), they were very interested in talking more, so we scheduled a meeting for just over a week from now, with these two Special Agents, two State Attorneys, and three Federal Prosecutors.

Question 1- what should I expect to deal with at the meeting? I ask, as I have never been a part of anything like this, and want to know what to be prepared for.

Question 2- I had heard in the past that a Criminal Negligence investigation had been opened into the State Agency I had worked for. Now, after some of what I informed the Special Agents of, that could be upgraded to Obstruction of Justice. IF it is proven that the Agency that fired me is guilty of this, and I was wrongfully terminated for whistle blowing, do I have a case to sue the State Agency for said wrongful termination?

Not that I am looking for a "payday". My first concern is to get justice for the people that died due to this issue. My second is to hold Public Servants accountable for their wrongful actions, and I want to get my life back. I have been trying to get back into that field, but believe that the State Agency is actively black balling me from doing so.

It is a very "niche" field. Large, but two Federal Agencies cover this field, and other than State agencies that are "subcontracted" as we were, every State had their own Agency that is affiliated with this field. So, openings are VERY limited.

As said, I just want my life back. Any help or guidance would be greatly appreciated.


r/legaladvice • • 1h ago

Crazy ex trying to steal dogs

2 Upvotes

Location: Missouri
My (32F) boyfriend (36M) and his ex wife have been sharing the dogs since their divorce about 3 years ago. No kids, but the dogs are like family to both of them. He kept the dogs for the first few months after the divorce while she got a place. Then she asked to have them more regularly, as she felt safer with them. He agreed and all has been fine. We get them once every 6 weeks or so.
A few months ago, one of the dogs (we will call him K) had an emergency. We took him in and paid for all of it. I work in the veterinary field, so I also took him to my work for his recheck, bloodwork, etc. K recovered well. They (my bf and his ex) made a deal that she would take them for their annual exams (only due a couple months later) to call it even. All was well.
Now there’s another medical concern on K. She never took them to their annuals (now 4 months overdue) so we were trying to schedule a time to get both dogs to take them to my work. We would do their annuals and have the concern checked out. We were struggling to find the time that fit everyone’s schedules but finally settled. The discussion was difficult but in no way disrespectful imo. All of a sudden, she’s upset with how he communicated, and she said that she’s keeping the dogs full time.
In the divorce agreement, one of the dogs (call her C) is his, and K was hers. They didn’t want to split up the dogs so they have been doing this arrangement. And since we have paid for everything for K for the past year, I don’t know what legal proceedings we could do. Do we have a case to fight for full custody of both?
Edit to add: we had to struggle to get her to give the free heartworm prevention that I got for them from my work. Also I would get discounts which I explained, since she offered financial concerns. She also wouldn’t give the joint supplements and has fought me every step of the way on their care.


r/legaladvice • • 11m ago

Other Civil Matters My brother who has stolen from me is coming home in an hour to "look through his stuff." Follow him around and record him while he's here without his consent but with his knowledge? (CA, USA)

1 Upvotes

edit: I'm panicking and bit and had a typo in title. I meant to ask, Can I follow him around and record him while he's here without his consent but with his knowledge?

Location: CA, USA

As the title says, my brother's coming to my parents house where I live and pay rent. He's blocked all contact with me for over a year. He's attempted to defraud godfather and myself for $4500 and took $1500 from me last year. He demanded money from me in order for him to join in family therapy, once he got it he blocked me and lied to everyone about getting. I took him to small claims court and he paid it back a couple days before the court date because everything had gone down in writing and he obviously took it and ran.

It just got dropped on me that's he's coming by in an hour too look through his stuff that's pretty much been abandoned here. I don't trust him at all. I want to follow him around and record him because I fully expect him to try to take or do something to get revenge. I'm not planning on doing any of it secretly, he'll be very aware I'm following him recording.

California is a all party consent state, he's coming onto private property where I am a resident and he his not.

I want to cover my ass as he tends to come here, start trouble, then leave and tell lies about what happened. He'll be here 11 am pst 11/22/26 so I know this is a really short window to ask for advice.

Thank you


r/legaladvice • • 18m ago

Traffic and Parking Got a speeding ticket as a CDL driver

1 Upvotes

Location: Whicita falls, TX

Not here for technical questions just curious how it all works. Got a lawyer, my negotiation docket is already on the 25th, already told them I have the money set aside if they want a trial. Was a 17 over ticket, which absolutely damn sucks.

Mostly curious what happens after the negotiation docket, how fucked am I and if I should have even told them I have the money set aside. Tbh, this is my first ever moving violation and I have no idea what to expect, or how this all works.

Just looking for some clearance in the smoke because I'm lost to all hell about this.

Edit: Forgot to say, it was a personal vehicle, I know that doesn't matter under law but it is easier on me.


r/legaladvice • • 24m ago

Suing for car accident from a year ago

1 Upvotes

Location: Virginia

Last year in December I was turning on a left green arrow at a stoplight and a car hit mine at full speed going straight ahead. It was on the drivers side and my car was completely totaled, air bags didn’t go off since they hit the drivers side tire & door. I took videos and pictures but no witnesses stopped unfortunately, and police arrive at the scene and the other person claimed they had a green light, so they didn’t set a court date and they just let him go. I tried for weeks to find camera footage from businesses around, going around asking people if they had witnessed it, calling the officers who were at the scene, hoping maybe the stoplight camera captured his car (where the front license plate was also covered in duct tape)… Nothing. I end up going to the hospital and had a bruised rib and concussion from the accident. I didn’t have collision insurance so neither of our insurance covered anything. He had Agency Insurance Co, a small insurance company with a singular website. They were incredibly unprofessional and took over a month after repeated phone calls to give me an answer which was that they wouldn’t cover anything even after initially claiming they would cover at least my towing fees. It was a total loss.
Is this worth hiring a lawyer and bringing to court before the statute of limitation expires in Dec 2027?


r/legaladvice • • 6h ago

Landlord Tenant Housing New apt management not offering discount mentioned in lease

3 Upvotes

I was offered 3 week discount on my lease, supposed to be applied the first month of the lease. The lease was however signed after the payment date of the first month and autopay from my account paid the full rent. By the time I checked and asked the then management to confirm when they’ll apply the discount, the building was sold and moved over to new management firm. Now the new management firm is not giving me the rent credit or refund for the 3 weeks I overpaid for the first month. Nor are they applying the discount to the next month’s rent. They say I need to contact the old management firm because “they promised me the discount”. The lease mentions agreement mentions the 3-weeks discount and I also have rent payment receipts for the months I paid the old management. I also have every conversation about this with the old firm over email (which I forwarded to the new management).

I feel I am owed the discount irrespective of the management company for the building but want to make sure I know about potential loopholes before I go demanding them for this.

Has anyone faced similar issue? What did you end up doing? What helped you to get your money back?

Location: Seattle, Washington.


r/legaladvice • • 1h ago

Computer and Internet What can I/should I do if somebody I know is scamming people?

1 Upvotes

Location: the internet and various locations in the US

Not a friend of mine, and we're hoping we can get some sort of justice against this person.

The common though I've seen on reddit, is that it's most likely a hacked account. But we know for sure this isn't a hacked account.

Basically this person will create a fake social media accounts. Create a sob story and beg for money. We have quite a few examples of these fake accounts being linked to their social media accounts(Facebook, Instagram, snapchat) and their financial apps(PayPal, venmo, cash). this person also has, atleast to us, a few known instances of selling items, but never delivering the item. The value being less than $100 so not worth effort of getting the money back.

This person regularly talks about their moderately extravagant life style, travel and events. And we believe they're doing this to fund their lifestyle.

This person has lived and scammed all across the East Coast, Texas, and is currently located in California.

Is there anything we can do? Or is this just something that the authorities will just blow off?