Hi, I'm 33. My partner and I have been trying since early this year (about 10 months now). I don't smoke, I exercise regularly, and I only drink occasionally. Since late spring I've been on antioxidant / men's fertility supplements (CoQ10, carnitine, zinc, etc.) and I tightened up my lifestyle a bit.
We've had four semen analyses: three at the same lab (reported against WHO 2021) and a later one at a different lab.
**Late spring, same lab, 2 days abstinence**
- Volume 2.5 mL
- Concentration 2.1 M/mL (WHO 2021 ≥ 16)
- Total count 5.2 M (≥ 39)
- Total motility 12% (≥ 42)
- Progressive motility about 2%
- Vitality 18% (≥ 54)
- Typical morphology 4% (≥ 4)
**Late spring, same lab, 3 days abstinence**
- Volume 4.0 mL
- Concentration 2.1 M/mL
- Total count 8.4 M
- Total motility 20%
- Progressive motility about 11%
- Vitality 36%
- Typical morphology 1%
There's a small uncertainty in how the historical columns were aligned on those first two tests, especially for progressive motility.
**Early fall, same lab, 4 days abstinence (the most complete report)**
- Volume 2.8 mL (≥ 1.4), normal
- pH 8.0 (lab: ≥ 7.2, typically 7.2–8.0)
- Concentration 2.1 M/mL (≥ 16), same as both spring tests
- Total count 6.0 M (≥ 39)
- Total motility 11% (≥ 42)
- Progressive motility 0% (0% rapid, 0% slow, 11% non-progressive, 89% immotile)
- Total progressive sperm 0.0 M (≥ 12)
- Vitality 21% (≥ 54)
- Typical morphology 3% (≥ 4)
- Leukocytes > 1.0 M/mL (≤ 1.0)
- MAR test not evaluable because of the low motility
A few days before that third test I had a mild flu-like illness, with no documented high fever. We went ahead with the collection.
**Mid-autumn, different lab, also 4 days abstinence**
- Volume 3.5 mL, pH 8.0
- Concentration 0.6 M/mL (600,000/mL)
- Total count 2.1 M
- Total motility 7%; progressive motility 0% again (7% non-progressive, 93% immotile)
- Eosin test 63% (I'm not sure if that's vitality, or how comparable it is to the 21% from the other lab)
- Normal forms 1%
- Round cells 8 M/mL; leukocytes reported as "some"; bacteria "+"
- MAR / sperm preparation test not evaluable (sample reported as unsuitable)
So at the first lab, concentration was literally the same on three tests. The later lab reported a lower count. I don't want to over-read a single result from a different method, but either way it's a severe picture. Not azoospermia, but very low numbers, and progressive motility was 0% on the last two tests.
**Workup so far**
- Hormones in mid-autumn, all within that lab's reference ranges: FSH 6.07 IU/L, LH 3.01 IU/L, total testosterone 14.22 nmol/L (about 410 ng/dL). Prolactin, estradiol and TSH were also in range. SHBG was requested but isn't on the report I have.
- Scrotal Doppler / ultrasound in early summer: no pathological reflux, no varicocele, testes and epididymes looked normal. Another exam later also found no significant varicocele. At the fertility clinic in mid-autumn they reported a left grade II–III varicocele, but said surgery wasn't indicated given the semen quality. Testicular volume there was about 10 mL on each side.
- Karyotype and Y-chromosome microdeletion testing were requested. I don't have results yet.
- Sperm DNA fragmentation has not been done.
- A standard semen culture in spring was negative.
- Early on, one andrologist thought this might be a transient picture. After the repeat analyses, the fertility clinic's indication was ICSI.
I'm leaving my partner's medical details out of this as much as I can. She's around the same age, and there is also a tubal factor on her side, so the clinic is looking at us as a couple, not only at my numbers.
I'd be grateful for any experiences or thoughts on a few specific points:
- How much weight would you give the drop from 2.1 to 0.6 M/mL when it was a different lab? Would you repeat the semen analysis before starting treatment?
- With 0% progressive motility on two tests, is ICSI clearly the next step, or is there still workup worth doing first (culture / the round cells, DNA fragmentation, another look at the varicocele)?
- Hormones including FSH are in range despite this severe OAT. Is that a common pattern, and does it change how you'd think about next steps?
- If anyone here had a similar picture (low count, almost no motility, normal hormones) and went on to ICSI: did anything actually move the needle on the semen analysis beforehand, and how did treatment go?
Thanks for reading.