r/moviecritic • • 18h ago Bravo Popcorn

Rewatched Constantine, it’s unreal how phenomenal the supporting cast is

Post image
2.8k Upvotes

Rewatched Constantine for Halloween. Still holds up, but it has to be said:

The supporting cast is on their A- game here!

Swinton as Gabriel is just spot on casting, love the androgynous look. Hounsou was so badass and cool as Papa Midnite.

And there’s nothing more to say about Stormare: he’s brilliant and unsettling. The back and forth between him snd John at the end is my favorite part. Steals the movie with just five minutes of screentime.

Even Rossdale was fantastic! Just loved how charming yet sinister he was.

Great cast all around, but these four really elevate the film.


r/moviecritic • • 13h ago

Amy Adams is one of the best female character actors of our generation and her acting range is absolutely fantastic and amazing to behold on the big screen. She completely immerses herself into her role and brings a genuine sense of vulnerability and passion by her performance onscreen.

Post image
836 Upvotes

It's really surprising to me how she has never won an Oscar yet, despite having one of the most varied and expansive filmography that touches both blockbuster movies like Arrival and The Fighter as well as niche, indie projects Doubt and Nocturnal Animals, with the same level of grit, charm and tenacity shown so beautifully onscreen.

Even in movies like Man of Steel and Catch Me If Yiu Can, I have feel that she brings a level of sincerity and earnestness through her performance where she demonstrates her skills at having her own voice and character flair in the movie which gives us some very momrable and iconic interactions with her co-stars. One of her first movies that I myself saw was Enchanted on DVD, and I can say without a doubt that, personally, I can not see anyone else playing that role except her. I love how she brings a layer of zaniness in the film rather than playing the character as a typical cookie-cutter, polished princess that we so often see with these projects. With all of her movies, you can see that she reflects her hard work needed on embedding herself flawlessly!


r/moviecritic • • 14h ago

What's a movie you saw when you were too damn young?

Post image
354 Upvotes

My dad took me to see Gallipoli when I was nine. I'm 54 now and probably still traumatized.


r/moviecritic • • 2h ago Bravo

What is a movie that is supposed to be a war movie, but which you don’t even consider a war movie and didn’t like it, either?

Post image
33 Upvotes

I’m not talking about minor historical inaccuracies (after all, it’s not a documentary) but rather about significant, major historical alterations + the dramatic plot they added completely overshadowed the movie, to the point where it no longer feels like a war movie at all.

For me, "Pearl Harbor" (2001) fits this description. I didn’t like the movie, nor the ridiculous love triangle, nor the major historical changes made to such a significant, pivotal event as the attack on Pearl Harbor and (especially) the Doolittle Raid.

What about you? What’s your pick?


r/moviecritic • • 1h ago

Which Live-Action Movies Are Cartoonishly Over the Top in All the Right Ways?

Post image
27 Upvotes

Usually, when someone calls a live-action movie “cartoonish”, it’s meant to be a critique of the film (see Madden as the most recent example). Sometimes, as is the case with 1984’s Little Shop of Horrors, the cartoonish vibe is fitting for the material and the production succeeds simply because everything is dialled up to 11 in the best possible way. A darker, more sadistic version of this film just wouldn’t work.

I’m thinking of films like The Mask, Dick Tracy and Beetlejuice that kind of operate on a different set of rules and that is part of their appeal?


r/moviecritic • • 36m ago

Happy birthdays to Mads Mikkelsen, Scarlett Johansson, and Mark Ruffalo. What are your favorite characters they played?

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

For Scarlett, Olivia in the Prestige and Natasha Romanoff in the Avengers.

For Mads, Le Chiffre in Casino Royale.

For Mark, Dr. Bruce banner


r/moviecritic • • 3h ago

Here are some of Tom Hanks' favorite movies, one of the greatest actors of all time unsurprisingly has great taste.

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

"Some people say Casablanca or Citizen Kane. I say Jason and the Argonauts is the greatest film ever made".

– Tom Hanks, 1992.


r/moviecritic • • 3h ago

Which movie franchise do you think actually gets better with its sequels instead of worse?

5 Upvotes

Usually, the first movie in a franchise is the best and the sequels slowly lose their magic. However, there are a few rare exceptions where the story, atmosphere, or tension actually improves later on.

For example, with horror franchises like Insidious or Evil Dead, some of the follow-ups genuinely scared me way more than the originals and really expanded the lore.

Which movie series do you think pulled this off best, whether it's horror or any other genre?


r/moviecritic • • 16h ago

Denis Villeneuve and Robert Pattinsons bond will be serious

50 Upvotes

New director and Bond signal darker tone

Now we have a director and a Bond. I think we're getting a serious psychological take on Bond with an atmospheric tone. Bond will probably be more psychologically damaged.

I think doing 3 films for Pattinson is great. It gives Denis Villeneuve and future directors and producers the opportunity to plan an arc which i love Craig's era but the lack of planning definitely hurt the overall narrative and bogged it down with unnecessary world building and interconnected storytelling. With 3 films it gives them a clear idea to work on.

One of the things I'm excited about with a new company owning Bond is the opportunity to adapt other Bond novels that Fleming didn't write that apparently the broccolis were against adapting anything that wasn't Ian Fleming.

I think we're in for a real treat.

Also quick side note. I still want more European or how would you say non-american actresses for the bond girls. Also Mexican bond girls would be great too. We haven't had a latina actress as a main bond girl.


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

What's a favorite movie from your childhood that you doubt anyone remembers?

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

For me it's absolutely The Man from Snowy River (1982). It was a perfect movie for an adolescent boy, because it teaches the difference between being a man and being macho. Jim's quiet dignity wins out over everything.


r/moviecritic • • 2h ago

In Nosferatu, which sailong route did they take?

1 Upvotes

It looks like they went on the high sea, but there clearly isn't any short sea route between Romania and Germany...

Or did they sail the Danube upstream?


r/moviecritic • • 3h ago

Movies about chinese culture, but done by American companies?

0 Upvotes

What are some great movies by American companies, that is about Chinese culture like kung fu for example , or at least has Chinese actors on it , preferably a main character in the movie, can be a martial art movie or anything related to any Chinese element


r/moviecritic • • 9h ago

Today Is The Anniversary Of Friday After Next That Was Released On November 22nd 2002

Post image
3 Upvotes

What’s Your Opinion On This Movie


r/moviecritic • • 17h ago

Thoughts on POSSIBLE LOVE

Post image
13 Upvotes

Talented South Korean filmmakers are way ahead of us nailing untrustworthy Gilded Age tech and merger bros pink slipping the workers. First, came the black comedic double whammy of Bong Joon Ho’s Best Picture winning, PARASITE and Park Chan-Wook’s sharp, acrid NO OTHER CHOICE, whose protagonist was killing off job interview rivals. Now here comes director/co-writer’s Lee Chang-dong’s equally wrenching class war drama POSSIBLE LOVE (Netflix).

More slow burn, though no less sharply observed, than the satiric titles above, it elegantly builds to a devastating conclusion thanks to superb performances from a quartet of actors with deep credits from the South Korean film industry.

Choi Ho-seok, a once proud welder (Sul Kyung-gu) is reduced to a sad-eyed stupor after his lay off at SP Heavy Industries and witnessing a violent government crackdown of an ensuing workers’ strike. The laid off workers are acerbically nicknamed “the dead” and the film opens with his reluctance to leave his car for the funeral of a laid off co-worker who took his life. At the memorial, Choi Ho’s earthy, sensibly grounded wife Ahn Mi-ok, (Jeon Do-yeon) meets Ye-ji (Cho Yeo-jeong who also appeared in PARASITE), an ambitious documentary filmmaker who smells a human-interest angle in the couple’s plight; she’s bankrolled by her wealthy, sexy husband Han Sang-woo (Zo In-sung).

Chang-dong subtly conveys the class distinctions between the couples. Ahn Mi-ok secretly Googles the price tag of the posh director’s purse while telling her to dress more casual to fit in among her downtrodden interviewees. Filmmaker Ye-ji embraces the chummy Ah Mi-ok in hopes of cracking her husband’s turtle shell in a probing interview he’s avoiding.

Hot to break down boundaries, the filmmaker invites the couple to her and her go-go-husband’s high end vacation home. The visitors bring their ten-year-old son who sees the cracks between the couples before an inevitable show down. POSSIBLE LOVE quietly indicts both the slumming director and the status-seeking Ahn Mi-ok but its heart is with the traumatized Choi- Ho who reveals the true source of his suppressed anger in a supple twist.

South Korea’s submission for Best International Feature Oscar, POSSIBLE LOVE already scored three awards at the Venice Film Festival and deserved a longer theatrical window but its on tap now for emotive, pungent home viewing.


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

Name a movie that people often forget about.

Post image
282 Upvotes

Angus (1995)


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

Favorite performance(s) in a box office bomb

24 Upvotes

I always loved Richard E. Grant and Sandra Bernhard in Hudson Hawk. The movie is such a weird blast and they’re absolutely batshit in it. What are yours?


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

First time watching Whiplash(2014), and crowned it my number 1 spot immediately.

62 Upvotes

First post on this subreddit, but let’s just get straight to the point. I’ve watched a good amount of movies before, but this one immediately snagged my number one spot of my favorite movies. Finished sweating, out of breath, and had to let the credits roll til the end. I did watch this turned all the way up on my big screen, I thought it was very tense, loud, and just overall perfectly executed. Not the one to analyze stuff, but this was just so good that I had to. Off the top of my head, there was a whole lot of harsh teaching, and from this I puzzled together that pressure and passion gets you to places. But anyway this is my new favorite movie, obviously my first time watching, if I had to rate it, easily 10/10. Jeez that was good.


r/moviecritic • • 4h ago

Racialized Gender Stereotying in Hollywood

0 Upvotes

Now after watching new new hunger games film i can’t get this out of my mind so I wanted to talk about two things.

First of all Asian male representation in Hollywood media:

Regarding the hunger games franchise, this is only an example. I haven’t read the books, so when I found out Ben Wang was casted in this film I was pretty hyped. Going into this film I hoped that maybe his character was more of a leader, confident and stronger in a way, that type of characteristics. But once again the only Asian male in the entire film is a weaker, self conscious guy who’s exceptionally good at numbers/ math and used for comedic relief. We really need to stop this trope guys.

I could say the same thing about Asian females representation but this is different. Asian men are often deromanticized/desexualised. Asian women are being hyper sexualised or fetishized and often chase white boys.
That’s the same for many poc women in film, most couples are white male + poc/mixed female.
For example, in regard to the hunger games films in both the last films it was that paring. But it’s found in most films nowadays.

We almost never see the opposite, in comparison it’s just crazy and I’m wondering how not more people are seeing these two things. It’s 2026 and we’re still doing this.

Everyone deserves complex, well rounded representation in characters, that goes beyond cliches and stereotypes. Diversity in romance shouldn't just mean pairing women of color or mixed race women with white male leads while men of color are left out of romantic storylines altogether.


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is as dark as I hoped it would be

Post image
9 Upvotes

This is Haymitch’s story and we know that he ends up beaten down and drunk so I wanted to see him go through hell to get to that point. This movie definitely delivers in that and the story isn’t just him getting chosen and surviving the games. He’s trying to end the games for good and that was an interesting storyline.

I did have a lot of issues with it though. I didn’t care about some of the characters/relationships that I’m supposed to, some things just didn’t make sense, and the games didn’t feel dangerous enough.

Overall it was a solid movie and nice to see a lot of characters we know. What did you think?


r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

Who did Odysseus better?

Thumbnail
gallery
423 Upvotes

Damon or Fiennes?


r/moviecritic • • 19h ago

Ebenezer 2026 - Bah, Humbug. Pass the Tissues 90/100 [No Spoilers]

2 Upvotes

Here is my review. It is written by me. Sorry for any grammar or spelling mistakes. I write in bullet points. I know this is not for everyone, but it is just my style. Be warned.

  • An exceptional Christmas movie that genuinly moved me to tears multiple times. I watch an enormous number of films, and it's increasingly rare for one to affect me this strongly. Ebenezer managed it repeatedly. Whatever criticisms I might have about the screenplay or pacing I simply can't ignore how extraordinarily well it worked on an emotional level. Apparently my heart hasn't completely surrendered to years of mediocre Hollywood productions. Good to know. I was starting to wonder if I had become completly immune to feeling anything when watching movies.
  • Johnny Depp is magnificent and practically born for these types of roles. I genuinly struggle to think of another actor better suited to these eccentric, theatrical and slightly grotesque characters. His performance is expressive, charismatic, convincing and occasionally hilarious. This is precisely the kind of acting that reminds me why Depp became such an enormous movie star. I mean who else can play a miserable Victorian businessman who hates Christmas and make you feel this emotionally invested in him? Depp seems to have a special talent for turning bizarre characters into people you actually care about. Itslike the man was born to play people who look slightly insane.
  • The supporting cast is excellent, including the Ron Weasley guy. He is very good as Bob Cratchit, and I thought the entire ensemble delivered consistantly convincing performances. Nobody felt like a weak link. The supporting characters bring the warmth and humanity needed to contrast Scrooge's spectacular commitment to being miserable.
  • The Gothic cinematography and Victorian atmosphere are beautiful. I appreciated that the filmmakers updated certain elements without turning Dickens' story into some aggressively modern adaptation. The dialogue still feels appropriate to the period, the environments look fantastic and the supernatural scenes have a genuinly impressive atmosphere. Sometimes the best way to modernise a classic is to resist the urge to modernise absolutly everything.
  • The story is simple, familiar and still increadibly effective. This was my first film adaptation of A Christmas Carol, although I already knew the original story. So perhaps people who have watched the 1951 classic and countless other versions won't find much that's new. But originality isn't everything. Dickens' themes of compassion, regret, generosity and redemption have survived for nearly two centuries because they work. And they definately worked on me. A story doesn't have to reinvent itself every 20 years to remain powerful. Although Hollywood seems to have made an entire industry out of trying.
  • The opening is a little slow and Scrooge's transformation might feel too sudden for some viewers. I can understand the argument that such a dramatic change of personality requires more psychological development. But personally I found the emotional journey convincing enough. Could it have been more sophisticated? Sure. Did that stop me from a couple of tears? Apparantely not. I can sit here and analyse the character arc all day but it doesnt change the fact that the movie worked on me.
  • I wouldn't have minded more Christmas magic and more time with Tim. The Gothic atmosphere is excellent, but the film could perhaps have been a little more christmasness For absolute Christmas movie greatness I also want that extraordinary feeling of entering an enchanting world, something films like The Polar Express achieve so well. More development of Tim and his family could also have strengthened the emotional impact. The movie was already moving me, but apparantly I would have appreciated further psychological damage.
  • I also have to acknowledge that I haven't seen the other adaptations. Maybe I'll watch the legendary 1951 version and discover that this one simply recycled an already perfect movie. Who knows. But I can only judge the experience I actually had. And the experience was exceptional. I was entertained, completly drawn into the story and emotionally moved multiple times.
  • 90/100 because emotional impact matters more to me than technical perfection. The acting, cinematography, atmosphere and storytelling are all very good or excellent. But what elevates this into my highest category is how deeply it moved me. I recognise that the film isn't revolutionary in any respect and that the screenplay could have been slightly stronger. But it's unquestionably one of my favourite movies of 2026 and one of the best Christmas films I've personally watched. It's not a perfect movie but its definately an exceptional experience.

r/moviecritic • • 20h ago

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping 2026 - May the Odds Be Ever in Favour of Character Development 77/100 [No Spoilers]

2 Upvotes

Here is my review. It is written by me. Sorry for any grammar or spelling mistakes. I write in bullet points. I know this is not for everyone, but it is just my style. Be warned.

  • A very good movie that genuinly exceeded my expectations. I went in expecting another generic young adult franchise movie with some romance, attractive people and a bit of action. But I was pleasantly surprised. It's visually impressive, well acted and most importantly I was entertained throughout.
  • Joseph Zada is Hollywood's latest it boy (an attractive young man with x appeal and an engaging personality), and unfortunatly for my initial assumptions, he can actually act. When he first appeared I wondered whether Hollywood had hired an actor or accidentally recruited a top model. But he does a really good job as young Haymitch, even capturing some of Woody Harrelson's mannerisms. Ralph Fiennes is excellent as President Snow and Jesse Plemons is very good too. The supporting cast is generally strong, although the screenplay doesnt give them enough depth. Apparently character development wasn't included in their contracts.
  • The pacing is both really good and kinda frustrating. I was almost never bored because something is constantly happening. But thats also the problem. The movie moves so fast that major events barely have time to register before the next tragedy arrives. It's over two and a half hours long and somehow still feels rushed. Quite an achievement.
  • The emotional moments don't always feel earned. I could hear people sniffling around me in the cinema, especially younger female viewers, but I just didnt have the same emotional investment. You can't introduce someone, give them two emotional conversations and then expect me to be devestated by what happens next. Well you can, clearly. But it doesn't mean I'm going to cry. The movie sometimes seems to think tragedy automatically equals emotional depth. It doesnt. Probably the target audience (also see bullet 1 is young female audience)
  • I'm not entirely convinced the Hunger Games themselves even make sense. Apparently they're supposed to be punishment, propaganda AND entertainment. That's already quite an ambitious business model. But some of the stuff happening in the arena just seems terrible for television. And if everyone is being monitored why do contestants openly discuss sensitive information? Are there microphones or not? Does the Capitol just turn them off whenever the plot needs it? Maybe the whole concept is something you simply have to accept. I mean we're watching a society that somehow decided televised child murder was a perfectly reasonable annual tradition.
  • The movie misses a huge opportunity by barely showing the people WATCHING the Games. I would have loved to see more reactions from ordinary citizens and families. Are they enjoying this? Are they horrified? Do they realise how rigged the whole thing is? The franchise is about propaganda and political control, yet we spend almost all our time with the contestants. I think seeing the viewers would have made the whole thing alot more interesting. After all without an audience the Hunger Games are just a spectacularly expensive health and safety violation.
  • The plot works as an origin story but its not particulary clever. I enjoyed the connections to the original movies and I think Zada convincingly establishes how Haymitch becomes the character we know. But some plot developments are just too convenient. There are moments where the characters seem to succeed not because they're brilliant, but becuase everyone else suddenly becomes an idiot. Apparently even a dystopian dictatorship has occasional problems recruiting competent staff.
  • The visuals are beautiful but the sound and world building are less impressive. The colours, environments and production design are excellent. I didn't watch it in IMAX but I can imagine it looking fantastic. The soundtrack and sound editing are fine, nothing particularly memorable though. I'm also still a bit confused about how technology works in Panem. They have incredibly advanced surveillance and futuristic equipment but sometimes the security feels like it was organised by the same people responsible for airport Wi-Fi.
  • 77/100 because the movie is very entertaining but definately not excellent. Strong performances, impressive visuals and a good origin story make this an easy recommendation. But the rushed characters, unearned emotional moments, convenient plotting and questionable logic keep it below my 8/10 category. The movie is very good at showing us that terrible things are happening. Its less good at making us care as much as it wants us to.

r/moviecritic • • 1d ago

Happy belated birthday to Jodie Foster! What’s your favorite movie she was in?

Post image
70 Upvotes

Mine are Taxi Drvier and Silence of The Lambs.


r/moviecritic • • 10h ago

Hot take: Bad Lieutenant (1993) by Abel Ferrara isn't really that good. Is not really dark as I usually read, is not even so much a cop movie as a sports gambling movie. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Seriously, not much really happens does it? Dude is getting high..ok.. he doesn't even really gets violent with anyone unless we take psychological violence on the matter of traumatizing two young girls by making her do things and wanking in front of them which is really all the bad he does?

The nun rape case is only engaging cause of the heniousness of it but there's not much to it.

Whole movie feels more like that movie "Kids" just a guy getting high driving around and watching sports while fearing for his life. Then he gets shot at the end and that's it.

Don't get me wrong, is a good movie overall, good cinematography and acting, whatever but screen play/ plot wise? Not sure! I suppose in 1993 it was more groundbreaking like Tarantino movies were showing lots of drugs and violence but that doesn't necessarily mean they're masterpieces per se.

This one's not even violent. And I don't really see themes of guilt or redemption here. Dude is a mess and his mistake was gambling with someone dangerous but other than the behavior with the young girls which is a form of violence, I don't really see him being a criminal elsewhere.

What you think of it? I would say is worth a watch on certain mood but perhaps my expectations were higher. I would have probably enjoyed it more when I was younger I reckon.