Fiddling with water tests, massaging figures and pressure not to tell the public: Investigative journalist’s book sets out scale of the scandal
Investigative journalist Tommy Greene’s book raises serious questions about water testing
Opinion: Sam McBride 21 Nov 2026
As Lough Neagh has died, NI Water has insisted that drinking water drawn from the polluted lough remains safe — but a new book raises disturbing questions about whether we can trust what we’re being told.
Three years ago, the lough’s pollution became unmistakable when massive ‘blue-green algae’ blooms — cyanobacteria — turned the water luminescent green.
The foul-smelling bacteria, producing toxins capable of killing animals as big as horses, have triggered a collapse in the lough’s ecosystem, and ended the historic eel fishing on the vast inland sea which inspired Seamus Heaney.
Some 40pc of Northern Ireland’s drinking water comes from Lough Neagh, yet we also pour raw sewage into the lough — along with supposedly treated sewage.
Troubled Waters, a disturbing new book by investigative journalist Tommy Greene, exposes how Stormont is at the heart of this scandal and how it is getting worse.
The book’s most serious allegation is that NI Water has rigged the testing system for what it calls ‘treated’ sewage discharges.
Various sources alleged to Greene that “a culture of obscuring and misleading presentation of statistics was introduced at NI Water more than 15 years ago”.
NI Water has boasted that it has “achieved the best ever drinking water quality and wastewater compliance” and “near record levels of wastewater compliance”.
The book says that “variations on these claims were trotted out by senior figures…however, there was a problem with this narrative: it was largely ‘built on a lie’, as one well-placed source underlined.”
A blue-green algae bloom at Battery Harbour, Lough Neagh, near Cookstown last August
He says that as the crisis grew, insiders say the Department for Infrastructure (DfI) kept telling NI Water: “Sure, we wouldn’t want to see a situation like the one going on in England currently” — a reference to publicity over British sewage spills and wastewater pollution, implying that Northern Ireland’s position was better.
This, he said, was “absurd and fundamentally dishonest to those with any awareness of NI Water’s data collection practices”.
He quotes a source saying that DfI, which oversees NI Water, was “living in a bubble”, where it was “massaging the figures and neutering any internal opposition”, with NI Water split between those willing to “toe this line” and those who believed they’d a duty as public servants to “level with the public”.
Sources told Greene that NI Water adopted a ‘compliance is king’ culture, but this involved a stance which “is less a culture of actually achieving greater compliance in wastewater treatment than one of providing the impression that this is the case… fiddling with wastewater statistics and testing is allegedly rife within the agency”.
He quotes one well-placed source saying: “It’s a kind of corruption that goes right to the top of government” and sets out how “one of the most obvious and glaring ways in which the official statistics for the quality of water released into our rivers have been distorted is through the way samples are tested”.
Author Tommy Greene with his book, Troubled Waters
Britain has long had unannounced tests on wastewater plant discharges. Stormont refuses to do this and instead largely gives warning to NI Water when inspectors are coming.
That, as senior NI Water and NI Environment Agency (NIEA) officials once euphemistically said, allows them to “get their house in order”.
As a result, insiders have told Greene that samples currently “pass on the days they’re tested but fail on the rest”, with the prevailing attitude allegedly being that “whatever happens, it shall pass on testing day.”
Greene notes that during the late 2000s, NI Water’s reported compliance levels rose dramatically.
What insiders allege to him is at least partially substantiated by limited public data on the small number of unannounced tests.
Between 2021 and 2024, when NI Water had warning of tests, they showed high compliance. Greene notes that the reported figures “were almost identical year on year – 93.75pc in 2021 and 2022, 93.72pc for 2023 and 2024 — which crucially brought them just above its performance target of 93pc.
However, those years’ limited unannounced tests were closer to 80pc compliance — 86.25pc for 2021, 82.5pc in 2022, 86.61pc in 2023 and 83.68pc in 2024 — meaning around a fifth of unannounced wastewater samples didn’t meet NI Water’s legal requirements.
Five-year-old Ailbhe Urquart holds up a bottle filled with green liquid labelled Lough Neagh Smoothie
The author says he has been told that if other polluting discharges were taken into account, as is due to happen by 2028, more than half of NI Water’s biggest treatment works, serving populations of 250 or higher, would fail to achieve basic compliance standards, suggesting that some plants can only process around half of their current sewage.
This raises the most troubling question: If we can’t trust NI Water in this area of testing, can we trust them when they’ve repeatedly insisted the water is safe to drink, even as reports of discoloured and malodourous tap water grow?
When the Lough Neagh scandal erupted in 2023, a press release from Stormont’s Department for Agriculture, the Environment, and Rural Affairs (DAERA) cited drinking water test results with a 99.9pc compliance rate.
While sewage is the second-greatest source of pollution entering the lough, the biggest problem is from agriculture.
Stormont’s 2013 ‘Going for Growth’ strategy turbocharged pollution by using public money to incentivise factory farming.
Greene reveals ministerial correspondence which refers to the ‘Moy Park Strategic Planning Project’ to help the enormous poultry processor’s expansion. It included a ‘dedicated project team’ within government to, in the words of one document, “process an anticipated influx of planning applications for poultry houses by Moy Park”.
Yet when Greene asked DAERA about this, it said it held no records about the unit’s creation, while DfI said any documents it held would likely have been destroyed.
Moy Park supplies a third of UK supermarket chicken, with Tesco and Sainsbury’s among its customers.
The company was far from the only beneficiary of ‘Going for Growth’ but Greene charts how in the decade following that strategy there was a 55pc increase in levels of phosphorus, a key agent for cyanobacteria growth, in waterways.
The five years prior to that period had involved a continuing downward trend in both nitrate and phosphorus levels in freshwaters, showing that there was no inevitability to what happened.
One farmer told him that many farmers are now frustrated that the finger is being pointed at them when they just did what government and industry bosses urged.
Moy Park said that there were “a number of drivers behind the algae blooms on Lough Neagh” and “it is a complex issue not specifically linked to any one sector”. The company — which is owned by vast US multinational Pilgrim’s, which in turn is owned by behemoth Brazilian meatpacker JBS — added that “the poultry industry is highly regulated with strict limits set for wastewater quality at all NI facilities” and it was working to “further improve” discharges from its abattoirs.
Local man Tommy McDonald is seen inspecting the Blue-green algae bloom at Battery Harbour last August
As well as animal excrement being spread on land which runs into waterways — or being deliberately poured into watercourses — Greene reveals that human excrement has been spread in the lough’s catchment.
This ‘land-spreading’ sees farmers paid to spread processed human sewage – or ‘sew¬age sludge’ — on their land as a cheap fertiliser. More than 53,000 tonnes of it have been spread in Northern Ireland since 2015 as part of a Public Private Partnership between NI Water and Glen Water Ltd.
Greene sets out a chasm between politicians’ rhetoric and behaviour. Despite Lough Neagh supposedly being one of this Executive’s top priorities, only one minister would speak to him — and DAERA minister Andrew Muir would only give him a 15-minute video interview.
He said Muir’s press officers told him several areas were off-limits — even as they were contacting YouTubers and social media influencers over Lough Neagh.
Inspectors are hopelessly ill-equipped to catch law-breaking — and when polluters are caught, fines are derisory.
DAERA says two staff are required to lead a farm inspection for “health and safety reasons”. There had been 10 staff available to lead inspections in 2014, the year after Going for Growth began. A decade on, there were just six lead inspectors and four in training.
By June 2024, there were more than 26,000 farms in Northern Ireland, meaning there was one inspection team for every 4,333 farms.
While Greene’s book exposes this to the public, he makes clear that Stormont has known this for years, but consciously failed to act.
Weeks before the 2024 general election, one of NI Water’s key figures, Gary Curran, gave an interview to the BBC in which he set out how bad the health of Belfast Lough was becoming.
Greene says Curran was then allegedly “slapped down” by senior DfI figures, acting under instructions from the then minister, John O’Dowd. He quotes a source who said Curran’s interview had run contrary to the ‘nothing to see here’ message being enforced from O’Dowd’s office.
Sinn Féin has run DfI for longer than any other party since the establishment of NI Water in 2007.
A planned £1.4 billion investment in NI Water’s waste-processing facilities between 2021 and 2033 was “gutted” during the last Stormont collapse, falling to less than £350m even as inflation meant costs soared.
O’Dowd rubber-stamped this cut in 2024, despite NI Water boss Sara Venning publicly warning MLAs that “by 2030 large parts of Northern Ireland will be unable to connect new customer demand for wastewater services for homes, public buildings and businesses.”
Greene says that a 2024 presentation informed O’Dowd that his Upper Bann constituency already had “bad/poor” water quality and another slide contained red text from the NIEA which starkly warned: “This infrastructure is presenting a very real risk to both public health and the environment and continued failure to improve this infrastructure will result in continued deterioration of the water quality and will be in breach of regulatory requirements.”
By March 2025, an investigation team from the Office of Environmental Protection — a UK-wide watchdog — told top NI Water figures that wastewater standards and pressures were worse in Northern Ireland than anywhere in Britain.
When the allegations of fiddling with testing were put to NI Water by this newspaper, it did not dispute them.
Instead, it said that independent reports “consistently highlighted the impact of sustained underinvestment in wastewater infrastructure on environmental performance, capacity, new connections, and economic development”.
It said the NIEA sets the regulatory framework, adding: “We welcome greater transparency and scrutiny so there is a fuller picture of the performance of our wastewater system and where improvements and investment are required.”
DfI said it “does not recognise or accept the scenarios presented, or the basis of the assertions made by the author, in the extract provided”.
It said a forensic audit is under way in NI Water, that it gives the utility about half a billion pounds a year, and that in previous years NI Water was “fully funded”.
DfI said Minister Liz Kimmins is introducing ‘developer contributions, changing the law on sustainable drainage, and arguing for more money.’
When decisions were made as to where the inadequate funding for upgrades should be allocated, Greene found that the biggest upgrade happened to help Moy Park.
He says a key reason for the prioritisation of the £44m Dungannon works over greater problems at far bigger wastewater plants was spelt out in an internal NI Water document: “Major impact on expansion plans of Moy Park.”
The company told him that this was a matter for NI Water and it had no direct role in determining what happened.
Greene says he has written confirmation from NI Water officials that regular meetings have taken place between their organisation and leading Moy Park figures — but with no records taken of these discussions.
Looking to the future, Greene paints a gloomy picture. Comparable cyanobacteria pollution in other parts of the world has led authorities to warn hundreds of thousands of people not to drink their tap water for part of the year.
While arguing that the situation can be drastically improved, Greene warns bleakly: “It is also important to be clear that some things have been irretrievably lost. A number of scientists have under¬lined that it will be nearly impossible for the lough to return to the state it was in during the late 1980s or early 1990s. Some species are unlikely ever to return, while a considerable number stand on the brink of outright disap¬pearance or extinction.”
• Troubled Waters is published by Merrion Press
https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/northern-ireland/is-lough-neagh-drinking-water-safe-new-book-exposes-ni-water-sewage-scandal-fiddled-tests-and-how-stormont-prioritised-moy-park/a/164841922.html