Use this post to discuss anything and everything about the US Midterm elections tomorrow, even if it isn't law adjacent. Also feel free to make a dedicated post to something elections/elections-law if you think it's big enough as well.
It goes without saying, but if you are American and eligible, please vote tomorrow if you haven't already. You can use vote411 and provide your address to see what's on your ballot this year.
I think most fellow OA listeners know what I'm about to summarize, but I kinda want to record this for posterity:
Election Context: Going into early 2026, the conventional wisdom was that Dems were quite favored in the house (as is typical for the opposition) but that the Senate was an uphill battle: Dems have a couple of pickup opportunities in swing states (Maine/North Carolina) but the next tier pickups were in Trump carried by double digits (Alaska, Ohio, Texas, Kansas, Nebraska, Iowa). Dems need 4 pickups total to win the Senate.
And then come the summer and fall, and the Trump coalition has really had a collapse, especially in those Senate odds. From a combination of poor economic performance, breaking his promise on no-middle-east-wars, ICE acting as secret police, and gestures wildly, pretty much every one of that next tier of pickups states has come online as a tossup or even lightly favoring Dems in the polls. It's not implausible that Dems could pick up 8 Senate seats tomorrow and win 240 house seats. It's been kind of incredible to watch.
On polls: they've performed well in the Trump era in midterms so there isn't much reason to be skeptical ab initio. And yet I do find it hard to internalize Dems being able to pickup Senate seats in that many red states.
- If they're accurate like 2018 and 2022: Dems win the Senate somewhat narrowly but without much fuss and take ~235 house seats.
- If they underestimate the GOP by a "normal" (3-4%) amount, then the Senate is a tossup but the Dems still take the house with ~225 house seats.
- If they underestimate Dems by that amount (3-4%), then Dems take those 8 senate flips and win ~240 house seats.
Races to follow early on election night (from states that close early/count fast):
- Not Florida. In 2018 Florida actually swung rightward relative to 2016, and gave an early/false indication that there wouldn't be a wave. I would look elsewhere for early signs in 2026 as Florida has been a strange state in the past decade.
- KT-06 (Lexington). Polls close at 6PM eastern and is a very Trump district with very tied polls. In a wave, Dems will keep this close or win.
- IN-1 (Gary) and IN-4 (north Indianapolis suburbs). Polls close at 7PM and 6PM eastern respectively. In a wave, Dems win IN-1 easily and keep IN-5 close (and the latter takes a while to call for the GOP).
- VA-1 (North Richman suburbs, Williamsburg), VA-2 (Virginia Beach), VA-5 (rural Southside Virginia). Polls close at 7PM eastern. In a wave, Dems should easily win VA-2, win VA-1, and be close in VA-5.
- North Carolina Senate and Ohio Senate. Polls close at 7:30PM eastern. In a wave, Dems will easily take NC and win (with some buffer) in OH.
- Texas Senate, Michigan Senate, Maine Senate, ME-02 (west/north Maine). Polls close at 8PM eastern but counting will probably take several hours. Still, look for Dems to match or overperform their polls if they want to win the Senate. Winning ME-02 is a good sign of a large wave in the house.
After 9PM there's probably plenty of indicators as to which way the night is going.
Election Watching Resources: