r/patientgamers • • 2d ago

Bi-Weekly Thread for general gaming discussion. Backlog, advice, recommendations, rants and more! New? Start here!

39 Upvotes

Welcome to the Bi-Weekly Thread!

Here you can share anything that might not warrant a post of its own or might otherwise be against posting rules. Tell us what you're playing this week. Feel free to ask for recommendations, talk about your backlog, commiserate about your lost passion for games. Vent about bad games, gush about good games. You can even mention newer games if you like!

The no advertising rule is still in effect here.

A reminder to please be kind to others. It's okay to disagree with people or have even have a bad hot take. It's not okay to be mean about it.


r/patientgamers • • 1h ago

Patient Review Yakuza 0 - Liked almost everything - except the combat, and there's a lot of it

15 Upvotes

Just finished Y0 and feel pretty conflicted about the whole thing. My play started off with a mix of main story and substories, but then I went hard focus on the main story because I didn't want to put in 100 hours - or at least wanted the main story out of the way. It took me 30-something hours to finish the main story. Technically my game froze in the last hour. I couldn't be bothered to restart from the previous save 1-2 hours prior and YT'ed the rest.

I thought the delivery of the story was exceptional and much stronger than the actual plot. Every single second of the story is played out in detail. This makes the game a slow burn (perhaps often too slow - I don't think I needed a 10 minute exposition every time a new piece of information is revealed), but it's a satisfying one because the micro emotions and animations are fantastic. The plot isn't bad - it's a bit tropey and ridiculous at times - but it's second fiddle to how it's told. The characters were just okay. I felt like there was a missed opportunity for more depth. There is a lot of melodramatic white knight stuff (the yakuza with a heart of gold - what is this, Hallmark?) going on that didn't click for me, but I'll give it a pass because it was still engaging overall. Three points in Majima's storyline were the highlights for me. I did not like Kiryu's character (invincible golden boy?). They both were badass and total whimps (storywise, e.g. yakuza dropouts) at the same time which I found... odd. Side characters were mostly good - there's at least variety even if they were one-dimensional (although Kuze and Kazama in particular felt like memes by the end). The yakuza bosses are the most interesting characters; despite my beefs, the writing feels intentional in the way it reserves character complexity for them. 8/10 for Majima's story, 5/10 for Kiryu's, 10/10 for general vibes, cutscenes, etc.

I'll quickly note that I did play with English dubs at first. Don't do this. The English emotional delivery is so off. Japanese with subtitles is the way to go to get the correct tone. In addition, the story is so dense that you don't need to catch every single detail (it's probably even a detractor to do so).

The other bit of story is the side content which deserves a huge nod. There is so much and it all seems to be really well written. I appreciate the light-hearted tone and variety. I especially liked having to be a stand-in on a movie set and having to guess what terms meant when quizzed. I will likely go back and finish most of the side stories.

Speaking of side content, the mini-games felt very impressive to me. If I could summarize Y0 in one word, it would be "much". Why is there a full fledged karaoke, darts, billiards, business sim, claw machine, bowling, etc? Well, why not? I'd struggle to call all of these particularly engaging, but they were all quite detailed considering they didn't need to be there in the first place. I liked the darts and bowling games best I think.

That brings me to the combat which I simply think is kind of trash? Y0 is a 3D beat'em up game vaguely reminiscent of a Streets of Rage. You have a basic move set, and enemies are damage sponges that you mash down. Boss fights are more interesting with reasonable things to dodge and work around, but the majority of the game is one of several cookie cutter fights: three random dudes ambush you on the street (which seems to happen every 30 seconds as you are running around the city - why is this even a thing), five random dudes as part of a "well, you just had a conversation with someone, so obviously the next part is fighting random yakuza goons", or the dreaded dungeon session which is room-after-room of goons in a but-wait-that's-not-all fashion of constantly revealing yet another room of guys behind yet another wall. Dude who hits you with a chair repeated over and over, gun-wielding groups who stagger-lock you, etc. I can deal with this in short, broken up chunks, but holy cow does it get repetitive and exhausting quickly. Combat seems like it probably took only 10% of dev time but makes up 50% of play time. I wound up dropping the difficulty to easy in hopes I could reduce the grind, but I don't think it made a difference. TL;DR - if combat was treated more like the mini-games, this game would've been a 10/10

The only other thing I felt compelled to mention was the game's hilarious obsession with back tattoos. Any time someone takes of their shirt (which obviously means that they aren't screwing around any more), the game gives you a close-up slow-mo of their back tattoo. Sometimes this happens multiple times during a back and forth conversation. Just more meme'ing.

I will be playing Kiwami 1 & 2 because I've already bought them. My understanding is they are at least a lot shorter. I'm honestly not looking forward to spending more time with Kiryu, but I do want to follow Majima more. I also have Judgment in the queue which I'm hoping at least improves on the combat and maybe the pacing. I would have appreciated if the Y0 dev time spent on the mini-games was spent on the combat instead, but at least the story delivery was very good.


r/patientgamers • • 22h ago

Patient Review Another Crab’s Treasure

123 Upvotes

Hello everyone! Today I want to talk about a game I just finished.

When it came out, the game became something of a small hit as a Soulslike that combined a colourful, cartoony world with fairly challenging (though not quite FromSoftware-level) Soulslike gameplay, including most of the elements you'd expect from the genre.

And at least for me, the mix really works. The game is charming, and one thing I particularly appreciated, even though I didn't use it myself, is that it offers quite a few accessibility options to adjust the difficulty to something you're comfortable with.

While I struggled a bit at the beginning (partly because I relied too much on dodge rolling, whereas the shell parry mechanic is much more important and effective here), once you get used to it, combat becomes much easier and more enjoyable. And don't worry if you hate parrying: you're not forced to perfect parry everything. You can also simply hide inside your shell, which will reduce most incoming attacks to minor damage.

Although you only have one weapon, the game still offers a surprisingly wide arsenal of tools in the form of different shells, spells, upgrades and abilities, allowing you to develop your own playstyle.

And while the story and world might initially seem a bit silly, there's actually a nice story with a moral behind it (nothing groundbreaking, probably, but still told in a heartfelt way, at least in my opinion). The cast of characters accompanying you on your journey is also colourful, and I really enjoyed spending time with them.

All in all, it took me around 20 hours to finish the game, although I also spent quite a bit of time exploring, grinding a little and getting used to the combat.

If you're looking for a Soulslike that feels a bit different from the others while still offering a decent challenge, or if you're new to the genre and want something that isn't quite as punishing, with the possibility of adjusting the difficulty, this might be a good choice.

And honestly, I think accessibility options are always a good thing. Despite what the git gud crowd might say (and I say this as someone who has finished Sekiro, Dark Souls I and III, and Bloodborne), they don't break the spirit of a game. Lies of P, another excellent Soulslike with different difficulty options, is also a good example of that.

Or, of course, if you just like crabs (or trash), this game could offer you a few very fun and entertaining hours!


r/patientgamers • • 1d ago

Patient Review Persona 3 Reload: What happens when you fix a game so hard that it breaks all over again

102 Upvotes

TL;DR: P3R sadly occupies an unfortunate middle ground where it simultaneously changes so much that it loses most of the charm and vibe of the original, while not fixing enough to deal with the underlying issues the game has always had. As a result, I now consider it one of the worst ways to experience P3 unless you simply MUST have modern graphics.

Stay tuned for a comment below with my quick recap of the various versions and their pros/cons.


I have now played Persona 3 three times. I have given more than 300 hours of my life to this game in its various forms. Nearly two actual weeks, god help me.

And I enjoyed P3R least of them all.

Despite strong first impressions and some seeming upgrades, by the end I found it to be such a SLOG that I had to force myself to push through the last couple months to the ending. And I think it boils down to the upgrades and fixes being implemented in an unfocused way that detracts from the core ideas of the game, while creating new problems of their own.

A Quick Recap for Newcomers

Just in case you've never played a modern Persona game, they're a hybrid of dungeon-crawling RPG and life sim as you navigate the life of a high schooler who's also fighting monsters on the side. Progression proceeds on a day-by-day basis across most of a year, with you splitting your time between standard teenager activities by day - taking classes, going on dates, hanging out at the mall, etc - and crawling around dungeons killing monsters by night.

Atlus's standard turn-based combat system, established decades ago in the Megami Tensei series, is easily the most interesting and complicated of all the major RPG franchises. It puts a heavy emphasis on exploiting elemental vulnerabilities while protecting your own weaknesses, with buff/debuff spells being outright required for success in many cases. This is what keeps players hooked despite how similar combat is across their games.

These are also very very LONG games with even the shortest (P4) still taking 80+ hours. They want to become your second life for a month or more.

Welcome to Iwatodai

P3R begins with our nearly-mute hero (canonically named Yuki) arriving in the fictional portside town of Iwatodai, Japan, where he quickly discovers things are very broken. Somehow, a magical force has caused a new hour to appear at midnight, the Dark Hour, which turns all people in the streets into immobile caskets and causes a massive tower full of monsters to spawn where the high school should be. And time is ticking down towards an apocalypse.

In short order, he's roped into the group SEES - a secret organization primarily comprised of high schoolers, based out of his school dorm, with the ability to summon their inner demons to fight the monsters. So now he must live a double life fighting to save the world, while also slowly forming bonds with his teammates as they live and work together.

Within the game, dungeon-crawling occurs in the tower Tartarus, which the group explores floor-by-floor in hopes of uncovering secrets that can prevent the coming disaster.

And that's where Persona 3's problems begin in all forms, but especially in P3R.

Dungeon Crawl Purgatory

Tartarus has over 250 floors which are randomly generated, and you will have to crawl through ALL of them over the course of the year. While the theming of the levels occasionally changes as you climb, they are fundamentally quite samey throughout. Worse, Tartarus's integration into the story is hazy at best. For about 90% of the game you have no clear plot reason for exploring it, just the hope your efforts will eventually pay off. This often makes it feel like tedious busywork whose only real purpose is letting you grind up for monthly must-win boss battles.

This has always been an issue with P3, but P3R's attempts to make Tartarus more interesting only made it worse. Levels in the original version were tight and compact, typically only taking a couple minutes to explore. Sometimes you'd even spawn right next to the stairs, allowing you to go straight up if you wanted.

P3R's levels are much larger and more sprawling, and also sometimes include optional side-dungeons used for farming high-level materials. The result of this is that exploring each level takes significantly longer than before, and it runs out of gimmicks LONG before the game is over.

Frankly, I found the dungeon crawling absolutely intolerable by the end, well past the burnout I felt from previous versions of P3.

Which leads into the next major problem with P3R.

Sometimes a Game NEEDS To Be Hard

To be clear, I am not one of those 'git gud scrub' types who want every game to be a gruelling challenge... but sometimes that's what a game calls for. Persona 3 tells a very dark story with heavy themes of challenging fate, accepting inevitabilities, and dealing with the unavoidable reality of death. Throughout the story, the crew of students are called on to meet nigh-impossible challenges that they know, deep down, they aren't really prepared to meet.

And this is completely wrecked when the default difficulty level (hell, even the "Hard" difficulty) has been nerfed to the point that a reasonably experienced RPGer can outright steamroll the game with little or no friction.

In earlier versions of P3, exploring Tartarus had major risk/reward elements. It felt scary and oppressive. You'd go into boss battles basically expecting to die at least once learning what the boss was like. You could, and would, lose an hour's progress or more if you died mid-dungeon, which was a 100% deliberate design choice. This was the big thing that kept Tartarus interesting: you could NOT let your guard down.

Making it so easy just adds to how gonad-grindingly tedious dungeon exploration is, on top of compromising its core themes.

So Little To Do, and So Much Time

Another issue that always plagued P3 is that there just weren't enough locations and activities to support a full playthrough - but again, due to the high difficulty, you're also expected to spend a LOT of time dungeon-crawling and grinding.

P3R tries to address this by adding a few new things to do, especially in the evening... but by nerfing the difficulty, it also means you're likely to wrap up your monthly required dungeoneering within just a few days. So they ended up recreating the original problem by altering the gameplay flow balance, and thus it still feels like you don't have enough activities to keep you occupied for a month.

The remake desperately needed a few more locations, such as how Persona 5 Royale got entire new city chunks to explore compared to vanilla P5, but instead it manages to feel even more limited than earlier versions.

At Least It Looks Nice

The one significant upgrade to P3R is purely audio-visual. The upgraded graphics are a big improvement over the PS2 original (nevermind the VN-style PSP port) and it gets a flashier UI more in line with Persona 5. It has more animated cutscenes than ever before, as well as significantly expanded voice acting that now covers everything except the most mundane of NPC chatter.

Also, Tartarus gets more superficial variety. The original versions used the exact same map asset set for every level, only reskinning the walls between major segments. This has different map assets and room types for every block, which does spice things up a bit. (And I did love the one section that looked like a blacklight room in a head shop.) However, the core gameplay doesn't change much, so these improvements are surface deep.

You also get the best version of the always excellent OST, with more remixes and variations, and the highest-quality audio yet.

Somehow Too Much and Too Little At Once

In the end, I just can't recommend P3R over its previous versions, especially considering its high price tag. (Which gets even higher if you want the DLC campaign, "The Answer.") The upgrades are largely offset by new problems they bring to the game, and I simply cannot stress enough how much the brain-dead difficulty HURTS the game overall.

And given this version can easily take 120 hours to finish, it's just painful by the end.

If you've never played a Persona, honestly, this probably isn't the best place to start with the franchise. But either way, I'd recommend one of the older versions. See below.


r/patientgamers • • 20h ago

Patient Review My Journey with Racing Games - TOCA World Touring Cars

12 Upvotes

TOCA World Touring Cars made by one of the greatest racing game studios Codemasters. The third game in the TOCA franchise before the rebranding to “TOCA Race Driver” in the fourth game of the series.

I personally didn’t even know this game existed, as it is a PS1 exclusive unlike the first two games which were available on PC. I tried the first two games but didn’t go too deep with them as they don’t really have a career mode unlike this one.

Emulation Performance & Graphics

I used DuckStation for this game and it started without any issues and further tinkering. The game runs between 20-30 FPS with some dips depending on the number of cars and the time & weather of the race.

Overall, the performance could be better but it didn’t really bother me.

The graphics are pretty good for its age but it’s nothing compared to the upcoming generations of consoles. One issue I had with the graphics is the draw distance. The draw distance of the track itself is fine, but the cars would disappear in front of you even if they are a couple of seconds ahead, which makes you feel like you’re chasing ghosts when you’re behind.

Tracks & Cars

The game has 23 licensed race tracks from all around the world, which includes some easily recognizable legendary tracks like Monza, Silversone, and Nurburgring; also, some relatively new (at the time) tracks like Adelaide Circuit and Surfers Paradise. Overall, the track selection is varied and it doesn’t get repetitive during the career as it matches the length of it.

As for the cars, the game uses a variety of Touring cars during the career mode, which you will get to use most of them without repeating cars between championships. It also has a range of street cars which can only be used during the quick race mode. The cars represent companies from all around the world and some of them don’t appear in many video games, like the Chrysler 300 and The Toyota Camry from that time period. Overall, the cars selection is pretty good.

Handling & Physics

Despite the look and atmosphere of the game, this isn’t a simulation. The handling while grounded compared to full on arcade games; will have a lot of oversteer and some corners can be taken without braking like you would normally do in a simulation game.

I think the handling is pretty decent and strikes a good balance between Simulation and Arcade aside from some cars that feel a bit too light.

As for the physics I think it is pretty good especially when it comes to collisions, cars will react the way you’d expected them to react when they collide. Also, the game has a full cosmetic & mechanical damage that occur according to the type of collision. The damage model is pretty good and for sure one of the best when compared to games of the same age.

Immersion & Career Mode

Before discussing the career mode; I would like to mention the steps the game takes towards immersion. The overall presentation of the game feels very professional and immerses you into the world of racing.

You have radio chatter throughout the race, where you will be informed about events unfolding and the other racers are mentioned by name. You will get commentary at the beginning of the race and at the end, and the damage model with other realistic features like cockpit view and pit stops.

However, the game also takes some steps back compared to the previous game in the series, like there aren’t any penalties for reckless driving even though it existed in TOCA 2. Also, you can’t qualify for races, the game just drops in a seemingly random position at the beginning of the race.

Overall, it is clear the game is trying to immerse you into the race but it falls short by removing the core simulation elements like qualification and penalties.

Now for the career mode, the game has 11 championships split into three tiers. The national championships, International Championships, and the World Touring Championship for the final one. To unlock each tier you will have to accumulate a minimum amount of points from the previous tier, which can be done by performing well in races.

The career isn’t economy based, you won’t get to buy, sell, and upgrade cars. At the beginning of each championship you will receive offers from a number of teams, each team will have a different car, compete in a different championship, and will have a different goal to achieve. For example, a team with a mediocre care will require you to finish with a certain amount of points, but a team with a fast car will require you to win a number of races. You pick a team which might or might not require you to beat a lap time to be accepted. After picking the team you finish a championship, which will unlock rewards for the quick race mode and get you points to progress through your career, and after finishing you will repeat the process of picking a team and racing until you reach the WTC and finish the career.

I think the career mode was pretty unique for its time. I know contract based career modes became more popular in the early 00s, especially with F1 games, but I can't really recall a game doing that in the late 90s other than this one.

I enjoyed the structure of the career mode. Yes it can be improved upon but also this is Codemasters creating something new which will affect their racing games in the future.

One negative I can think of is that the offers you receive don’t necessarily respond to your performance; for example, I have beaten two championships but I was still receiving offers from mediocre teams rather than teams driving the fastest cars, which makes it difficult to progress. I had to replay one championship when I received an offer with a better car for it just to progress to the final tier.

AI & Difficulty

The AI is a mixed bag for me it seems like the AI behavior shifts from trying to avoid you and weaving left and right to make a pass to ramming you without remorse especially during corners, which can really ruin your race. Trying to be cheeky with the AI and blocking them when attempting to make a pass, could result in them spinning you out.

The AI will also compete with each other during the race and might even spin out on their own without player interference. One of the main points and complaints you will read about this game when looking it up is the difficulty, which in my opinion depends on four things:

No Penalties: The lack of penalties in the game will result in the AI constantly ruin your race for no reason at all, which can be very frustrating.

The Track: You might think that I mean that some tracks are harder than others to drive on, which is true for any racing game. But what I am referring to here is that the AI’s behavior changes based on the track. You see the AI doesn’t brake or ease off the throttle during light corners, they will just go through such corner at full speed while you eventually slow down to take it like a normal person.

This means that tracks full of such corners will become a constant battle of trying to catch up. On the other hand, tracks with sharp & hairpin corners will force the AI to brake which usually results in them spinning out for some reason, which makes such tracks much easier to race.

No Qualification: Not being able to qualify isn’t usually that much of an issue in simcade or arcade racing games, as you can usually speed past your opponents from the beginning, but couple the lack of qualification with the cheating AI, some races are lost right from the beginning when you are placed 10th and can’t beat the AI in the first couple of corners. The race will just turn into you trying to hold onto whatever position you end up with after those corners.

The Car: Obviously the car you are being offered will affect your ability to beat the AI.

As the career went on I was getting more and more frustrated with the annoying AI and difficulty, so I tried to use the lack of penalties to my advantage and became a menace on the track where I cut every where I can to gain an advantage.

Verdict & Recommendation

While I think the career mode is brilliant and unique for its time, the AI behavior and the difficulty stemming from design decisions really soured me on the career in the final third of the game.

I will only recommend this game if you really want to play a game dedicated to touring cars with a career mode

Other than that, I can’t recommend this game due to the frustrations with the AI & difficulty.

Previous game


r/patientgamers • • 1d ago

Patient Review Bioshock: Infinite. Setting new heights...or maybe not. Spoiler

52 Upvotes

I recently replayed Bioshock: Infinite and felt compelled to write a retrospective, if for no other reason that to justify the time spent on the game. Infinite is by no means a bad game, in fact it was lauded by critics on its release, but for long time fans of the first 2 games it fell short in a couple of places and I wanted to talk about that.

Now a lot has been said about Infinite in the years since its release and Ill try not to tread the same old tracks that others have in the past, but I think some of that is unavoidable when talking about this game.

Before we kick things off, I wanna set the scene somewhat. Bioshock (the first one) came out in 2007 and was a spiritual successor to the Systemshock games of old. On its release it was considered a great game, but there were complaints about a lack of replay value, no multiplayer, and PC players criticised the simplified mechanics. Personally, i really enjoyed it and thought it was a lot of fun, shortcomings notwithstanding.

Then in 2010 we got a sequel in the form of Bioshock 2. Unlike its predecessor, Bioshock 2 didn't receive as warm a welcome, with many questioning if the first game needed or warranted a sequel. Much hay was made about the fact that you play as a Big Daddy for the whole game, something that had briefly come up in the first game and was panned by critics and fans alike. However in the years since its release opinions on the game have looked kindly on it and now its considered a classic and even the best in the series by some (myself included).

After a couple of years of wondering and waiting to see what would come of the series, fans started to get glimpses of what would become Bioshock:Infinite. Initially, reception was lukewarm; they ditched Rapture, the underwater city setting of the previous entries. They also seemed to do away with the plasmid mechanic and replaced it with powers that were basically plasmids by another name. I remember being wary of the trailer and the release material, such a huge divergence from what had made the previous games memorable seemed like a big risk to take. That being said, I patiently waited to see what the final product would be like and, when Infinite finally came out, I was satisfied at first. After a while though, the cracks in the veneer started to show and became distracting from the experience. After a couple of playthroughs i left it to languish in my Steam library until now, 13 years later. So does it hold up? Or does it fall behind its predecessors?

Before I get into the meat of the review here, I wanted to briefly mention my PC specs, just in case anyone was wondering (although a game this old could probably run on a microwave oven):

Ryzen R9 7900X3D

64GB DDR5 RAM (dont tell Altman)

Radeon RX7900Xt

With all that out of the way, what do I actually think of the game?
Well it still looks good, so thats nice I suppose. The textures look great and the lighting is as cool as ever, though one can see how far games have come since Infinite's release in terms of graphical fidelity. Still, for a game that came out in 2013 it looks pretty fantastic, though i think first time players might not be as impressed as we were when it first released.

Graphics are only one quality to consider, what about gameplay and story?

The gameplay is okay. Controls are smooth and responsive, and you can tell the developers put some thought into how the player moves around the city in the skies. There are floating platforms, skyhook rails, and lots of moments in the game where they make a big deal about being in a city in the sky. Theres a moment in the game where you fall off an airship and land on an artificial beach and that scene of you falling is very cool indeed. The combat leaves a lot to be desired though; You are limited to only 2 weapons at any one time, which is a strange choice considering you could carry a battalions worth of weapons in the previous entries. This limits combat somewhat. Mobs of enemies leaving you groping for a machine gun, but trickier enemies demand the use of snipers or rocket launchers. When the going gets tough, and you've only brought a pistol and a rifle to the fight, one can be left feeling like you've been shot in the foot before you even get a chance to get to blows with the bad guys.

The totally-not-plasmids feel weak and kinda unnecessary. In theory there are some neat combos you can make with them and by using certain combinations you make them more powerful, but in truth I found very little use for them as guns can solve any problem you come across.

Okay so the combat and the gameplay might be hit-and-miss, but what about the story?

Infinite introduces timeywimey mechanics which seem like a neat concept, however there are moments in the game where I was left wondering what the hell was actually happening and you end up getting lost in it a bit. You change the course of history and have to deal with the consequences, which im not against but it comes across as contrived. Halfway through the game you become a hero of the Vox Populi, a rebel faction against the government and thats a nice payoff, however it turns out your character, Booker, had died and was a martyr. Being you are very much alive, this causes your erstwhile comrades to turn on you. The explanation? The "real" Booker died, and therefore you must be some kind of imposter? Im not really sure, but it seemed like a weak way for the developers to prolong the game.

It was at this point in the game where I felt myself wishing I playing one of the other games, but I decided to stick it out to see the ending. Oh.

Okay, so, the ending isnt terrible, but Im not a fan of it. Basically story behind the events of the game had been hinted at throughout the game, but is finally laid at your feet at the ending. It turns out in a previous life Booker had sold his daughter, Anna, to pay off his debts. In one timeline, Booker wishes to ease his guilt and gets baptised. In the timeline of the game Booker refused to be baptised and was sent to Columbia (the sky city) to find his missing daughter. The main antagonist in the game's timeline is Father Comstock. At the end of the game Comstock is revealed to be the Booker that accepted the baptising. How this is all explained is by way of 2 scientists who had discovered a "tear" in the fabric of reality and manged to merge the timelines in certain places.

Got a headache? Me too! Im no stranger to relatively complicated Sci-Fi (reading the 3 Body Problem for the first time was a trial all of its own) but this left me unsatisfied really. Everyone and their dog knows that introducing time-travel mechanics to a franchise a huge risk and comes across as jumping the shark as it were. The end experience for me was one of disappointment, but then things got worse.

Most Bishock fans consider the ending of Infinite to be not cannon. Basically the ending makes it out that the previous games are a multiverse of the Infinite universe; each game starts with a lighthouse (although this isnt true as the second game starts in the underwater city and not with a lighthouse, unlike the first game), and each game is connected by timeywimey stuff that hurts to think about.

So, where does that leave Bioshock: Infinite today? Well its not a bad game and there's fun to be had, but really the gunplay leaves a lot to be desired and the ending is a bit like Marmite: some will love it, others will hate it.

Is the game worth your time? Maybe? Its hard to recommend. If you've played the first 2 games you'll probably find Infinite weaker by comparison, but if Infinite is your first foray into the series you'll probably enjoy it more until you get to the ending where I imagine you'll find it even more confusing.

Tl;Dr: its okay, i guess. If you can pick it up for a couple of quid then I can think of worse ways to spend your money, but if you've played the first 2 games and are expecting a similar experience then I would warn you that you're in for something altogether different.


r/patientgamers • • 1d ago

Patient Review Covert Front (2007): Gone in a Flash.

12 Upvotes

You are officially an old person if you remember the words "Macromedia Shockwave" on the internet before reading this sentence. A long, long time ago there used to be these things called "flash-games" you could play online in a browser. I'd say it wasn't worth the effort playing one without broadband because yes, at one point you'd have to manually access the internet at the cost of blocking your landline phone. If you were born in the last century you may remember the sound of a modem ripping its ass.

Flash-games could be all sorts. There were Horror games like Exmortis, RPGs like Sinjid, Strategy games like Pandemic 2, and Bullshit games like The Impossible Quiz. The flash-game scene of old is effectively dead, though many fledgling developers got their feet wet and continue to make excellent games to this day. One creator I hold in high regard is Mateusz Skutnik, an independent comic-book artist and game-developer from Poland. His best known work is the Submachine series, which has you explore beautiful though desolate environments that are entirely hand-drawn. It starts out as a simple point-and-click adventure in a couple of rooms that slowly morphs into a maddening voyage through an endless complex of buildings subject to the whims of a distorted spacetime. I would not compare the Submachine to the Backrooms because it predates the place by over a decade. That'd be like complimenting David Bowie for playing a Nirvana song and seeing him choke back a reply. Thankfully you can find the entire Submachine series remade in one package on Steam right now. Go do that.

Elsewhere Skutnik did the artwork for two detective games called The Scene of the Crime. Here you collect clues littered about a murder-scene and piece them together on a pin-board. With every deduction made you slowly fill up a bar that denotes completion. The actual mysteries themselves aren't terribly exciting, but the artwork is stellar and the detective-genre wouldn't see anything like it for another decade until Return of the Obra Dinn. Which brings me at last to Covert Front.

Unlike Submachine, Covert Front hasn't been remastered or expanded upon. I doubt it will only ever be a footnote in gaming history. In a way that's appropriate since you play a spy called Kara who naturally is on a mission to avoid all notice. It's 1904 and in a very different Europe a premature war has broken out. You as Agent Kara are assigned to find a missing scientist named Karl von Toten. First she searches his abandoned mansion, then she explores the facility underneath. The trail leads to Zurich and soon ends at a most unexpected place. Gameplay wise Covert Front is a standard point-and-click affair where you pick up and combine items across different rooms. Sometimes it's straightforward but often you'll get stuck as in the adventure-games of old. The whole experience is only an hour long, but it's elevated by the hand-drawn presentation and pre-war setting. Across its four chapters the game gets a little more daring; like including voice-acting, more cutscenes, actual characters to speak to, and several locales to visit. I loved the short time spent in this fragile era and can only dream of a bigger game set at the turn of the century with a touch of sci-fi.

I'm likely one of the three people who remember this flash-game series that wrapped up decades ago on a platform cruelly destroyed, but the important thing is that I do remember it. Not every work will see massive success or a critical evaluation, yet it's a good thing to give every artist their flowers no matter the years gone by. Covert Front can be played here.


r/patientgamers • • 2d ago

Patient Review Pathfinder Kingmaker: "Tristian's Inspiring Recovery failed to overcome Nok-Nok's spell resistance!"

98 Upvotes

Pathfinder: Kingmaker is the first game released by Owlcat Games in 2018. It adapts a Level 1-20(? 15?) Campaign for the Pathfinder ttrpg released in 2010 into a cRPG. Despite having the plot and structure and mechanical overview given by the ttrpg campaign and Pathfinder rules, Kingmaker remains an enormously ambitious game, easily extending over 100 hours. I clocked in at a baffling 133 hours having visited most locations (except the ones in Thousand Voices), finished all companion quests successfully, but playing mostly on realtime with pause. Its controller support is almost perfect, which is a HUGE plus.

I have found Kingmaker to be difficult to write about without devolving into manic rants. You spend so much time with it that its many friction points have weeks to scrape across your skin. You're practically stewing in your thoughts about how you would make it again, fix it, tweak it. I'll endeavor to keep snark about the jank to a minimum, but here's a sample: "In Pathfinder: Kingmaker, your phoenix downs can miss!".

tl;dr

Pathfinder Kingmaker is an extremely ambitious game that shines brightest in its first two thirds. Only one in five people who complete the 5-10 hour act 1 will roll credits. One in three people who complete the penultimate act will not finish the dungeon that follows. This is for a reason. I'd recommend stopping after completing the high-point of the game: the dungeon at the end of the 'Varnhold Vanishing' questline, Vordakai's Tomb, which gets about as mean as possible without spilling over into just being ridiculous. And hey, if the first half of a 133 hour game was good, that's a lot of good game that I got to play!

Companions

There are around 10 companions. They will chat with one another during camping which is extraordinarily welcome, and it's great to see them interacting with each other, not just with you. Each of them have their own quest, but I found the quests pretty wan. I was never brought to the heights of emotion that I was from other cRPGs--none of the wistful heartbreak of Rogue Trader's Yrliet, nor the searing emotions of Pillars of Eternity 2: Deadfire's Maia, nor the love for Disco Elysium's Kim Kitsuragi. I guess these ones are better than specifically Annah from Planescape: Torment? A standout to me was Jaethal's quest, which despite sharing the anemia of the other questlines can end with her renouncing her Goddess and exploding into meat, dying forever. I normally get crazy FOMO, so I'd avoid an outcome like this one like the plague, but for Jaethal it felt fitting. I even wrote in my notes as I was playing how surprised I was at how much I liked this outcome. It tied together this short questline in a satisfying way and overcame the fear of permanently losing a companion. It really was a triumph of the writers to be able to clear this hurdle and make the player satisfied despite losing a companion and advisor. Now imagine my disappointment when she gets revived in the penultimate dungeon hours later. It completely upends a satisfying ending that you've had hours to reflect on. It sucks! Despite the questlines having a bunch of traps in them (in Nok-Nok's there's a bunch of choices you can make which kill him two seconds later), I generally liked them. They add a lot to the game, but still feel to anemic given how they are dwarfed by the game's runtime. There are many non-local traps where your choices can doom them to die dozens of hours later. But if you play neutral good, the objectively correct alignment, that won't happen. This benevolent autocracy sim endorses my values

Only after beating it, did I learn there was companion romance in this game. I wasn't interested in joining or breaking up Octavia and Reg's open relationship, but would have gladly gotten to know dearest Tristian or Valerie better. Thinking back on it, I'm not really sure what I could have done differently besides telling Valerie "I'm glad your scar is gone", which is an absolutely nuts thing to say given what you know about her life. That her scar disappears really rubbed me the wrong way. I felt that it completely undermined the lessons she learned about how we all construct each others places in society. So I sure as hell wasn't saying that to her. For beloved Tristian, I have no idea what I would have had to do to set his heart aflame. Ah well. I guess because he was blind, he couldn't see my beautiful fencing form from his proper place in the backline. But it's okay. It should be illegal for a monarch to fall in love, anyway, given the power imbalance there.

Mechanics

The combat system has imported as much Pathfinder as it can. This has the fantastic advantage of it being clear what stacks with what. You'll be faced with "bonuses", "morale bonuses", "insight bonuses", "sacred bonuses", and the system makes it very clear that morale bonuses don't stack with one another, but do stack with other bonuses (non-adjective "bonuses" stack with everything). This clears Owlcat's Rogue Trader easily because there it was completely inscrutable what stacks with what. Pathfinder imports its own fiddly nonsense, but knowing for sure that Burst of Glory stacks with Good Hope despite them both being yellow is a great place to start and lets the player feel confident in their choices. Other pathfinder mechanics feel like even Owlcat were chafing against them. At one point during Amiri's questline you find like four hundred diamond dust (a resource consumed by certain spells) hidden in some logs. It's as if the game is saying "ok scarcity was fun for a while, but you should ignore that mechanic now. Cast stoneskin every morning."

The biggest flaw is directly importing Pathfinder's bonkers weapon variety and weapon proficiency system. You can take specialization feats that give you +1 or +2 to attack rolls when wielding a specific type of weapon. Attack roll bonuses that stack with every buff spell you cast are hard to come by, so you're strongly incentivized to take these (the game even puts a big green thumbs-up next to them on the feat list). Unfortunately, Pathfinder has two billion obscure types of weapons that you will find constantly (dwarven urgosh, starknife, kama, elven curve blade, dueling sword, falcata, sickles AND scythes, tongi, nunchucks, gnome hooked hammers, something called a 'sling spear'). Because of the specialization feats the game begs you to take, you will feel disincentivized to use them even if you can wield them. So you constantly see cool weapons you don't feel you can use. I really wish they had stolen (or predicted? not sure which came out first) the Pillars of Eternity 2: Deadfire system where weapon proficiency in a type of weapon gives you a unique buff when using it (e.g., toggle on to attack slower, but when you hit with a club, drop the enemy's will score by X). This would make it actually feel like a "specialization" that you could build around. As it stands, the weapons feel mostly fungible, but you're artificially locked in to just one through the specialization feats. It doesn't help that some weapons are intrinsically superior to others (the fauchard). Want to roleplay Shohei Ohtani with clubs? Too bad, there is exactly One (1) unique club in the game compared to 8 unique rapiers. Guess you're using greatclubs, dummy

Combat and Balance

It is difficult to find a discussion about this game online that doesn't complain that Owlcat went ham pumping up the stats and resistances of every beastie in the game. The reason they draw so much ire about this is because they absolutely did tune the hell out of the beasties. I am not an experienced minmaxer or buildcrafter or Pathfinder player, but I'm familiar with the basics. I'd never done any high-level campaigns, so I was excited to play around with 6th-9th level spells. Imagine my shock when, as a rule, my experience casting high-level offensive magic in Pathfinder: Kingmaker is that it does nothing at all. Enemies have such high resistances that spells often do literally nothing, and the strong enemies you'd really want to debuff will definitely shrug off anything you throw at them. I don't think I hit Chains of Light a single time. Basically, Grease is completely busted at early levels, stinking cloud is often good, and by the time you get them, every other spell is completely useless. I only got to cast Polar Midnight and Sunburst--9th level spells--once each, during the final boss (their aoe was too big to use elsewhere and most enemies are chaff who die quick anyway). I think beautiful Tristian did maybe 50 damage total from those. I'm sure that it's possible to break through with itemization, consistently picking the correct feats from early levels (i.e., having a plan for level 19 when you're level 3), and deep multiclassing. But unless you know beforehand what to do, the game constantly gives you the impression that magic is just for buffing physical DPS builds. Heck, even fireball stops doing anything because everyone and their mother gets improved uncanny dodge. Resplendant Tristian, leave the damage to the women and Nok-Nok. You're here to cast death ward six times every time we wake up.

Combat in general is extremely swingy. You will be cruising along until one companion will get randomly gibbed out of nowhere. You'll reload and try the fight again, only to find it trivially easy. This extends all the way to the final boss, and can happen whether you're in real-time with pause or turn-based. So many of your spell slots are dedicated to playing rock-rock-rock with your opponent's debuffs. They use poison, I bring delay poison; now we're back to where we started. They bring negative levels and fingers of death, I bring death ward; now we're back to where we started. They bring fear, I bring remove fear; now we're back to where we started. They bring slow, I bring haste (well, I'm always bringing haste); now we're back to where we started. The consequences for not bringing the one exact counter to what the enemy is doing are dire, so it winds up just being a spell slot tax rather than a cool choice. But as long as adorable Tristian is around, you'll likely have an answer to prebuff against whatever your opponent is doing. I think the game would be really improved if both players and enemies did half as much damage. That would prevent the final boss from transitioning to phase 3, casting slay living on elegant Tristian and two archers filling him with 8 arrows before you get a turn, and would stop you from just running over most of the game buffed to the nines.

Overall, it's fun and at its best for the first two thirds of the game. But after Vordakai's tomb, everything really falls off a cliff. At one point, my entire frontline was killed from stat death on round 2 by Four Mandragora Swarms in the "hateit" dungeon. That was when I realized that we had jumped the shark. The fights in Vordakai's tomb are really fun, and it's legitimately stressful hunting for camping supplies and dodging exhaust traps, but the back third of the game is so egregiously underbaked (at one point you spend two hours pointlessly upgrading kingdom stats waiting for the next calendar year. This turns out only to matter if you're going for the secret ending) that it might be best to drop the game after Vordakai's Tomb--50% of players who beat it don't roll credits.

"I HATEIT"

Speaking of the "hateit" dungeon, the final dungeon, House At The Edge Of Time is so universally reviled by the playerbase that they can't keep themselves from talking about how much they "HATEOT", caps-posting, misspelling the word "it," and dropping the space out of pure rage. Jokes aside, there's a reason that according to steam achievements, a third of people who unlock this dungeon will not complete it. It's like a go at Dishonored 2's Crack in the Slab level or Titanfall 2's Effect and Cause level where you swap back and forth between two versions of a building. But here, both versions look identical and you regularly swap between them so can easily lose track of which version you're in. To beat the dungeon, you have to realize that That Room Which Teleports You Randomly isn't random and instead there are six magic clouds between the room's two versions, and you have to find the singular one that sends you to the goal ('front' version of the house, the version with the witch, the cloud straight ahead from the hall). It's super easy to spend an hour plus wandering the halls after you've killed everything with no clue how to get that third key. It doesn't help that the enemies here are the toughest in the game. It was in this dungeon, after finding the room with four (4) Mandragora Swarms that cemented the transition from "oh boy! more content!" to "dear Lord, more content?" that had been brewing for the past dozen hours. Anyway, here's a foolproof way to get rid of the swarms in that room: delicious cheese.

Conclusion

The part of the game that most people play--the first half--is fantastic and a real romp. Owlcat commits hard to making your choices matter. If you misclick in the first 20 minutes and tell Valerie to leave that servant to die in the fire, you'll get bullied about it for the rest of the game. People are constantly bringing up stuff you did 40 hours ago, which is neat. But it cuts both ways. If you don't solve certain quests just so, you can get some really nasty consequences down the line. The back third is quite a drag. I'm guessing that things turn out better in Owlcat's next game, Wrath of the Righteous, seeing that 80-90% of the posts in /r/pathfinder_kingmaker are about Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous. I'm looking forward to trying that one out.


r/patientgamers • • 2d ago

Patient Review Dragon Quest 1 Remake (1986/2025): "But thou must get ambushed by two rock golems who pummel thee into a fine, pink paste."

42 Upvotes

Dragon Quest 1 is in an awkward spot in that while it was an influential game, it was quickly superseded by its sequels and the subsequent RPG subgenre it inspired. The first game was a 1986 Console-RPG that took inspiration from the incredibly complex Ultima and Wizardry series, then distilled down to a small cartridge meant for newcomers on a gamepad.

In effect you are a knight who has to save a princess from a dragon and defeat a dark lord. That's the plot. You play one static character who has turn-based fights with one enemy at a time. There are ten spells, five towns, five dungeons, fifteen monster sprites, and twenty-one pieces of equipment. Being such an early game there are no party-members, no real side-quests, no vehicles, and no progression-system to tinker with. While Dragon Quest 1 is considered an early "JRPG", it's notable for lacking any barriers that gate off areas until you advance the plot. You can technically walk anywhere from the get-go, but will be stymied by tough monsters since you need to battle for gold and experience to survive. I believe if you took out the grinding this game could be finished in under an hour.

The remake of Dragon Quest 1 I'm here to review is in a different but still awkward spot since it's been rewritten to act as the middle chapter of a trilogy. Originally the first game was followed by a direct sequel, while the third game acted as a stand-alone adventure that reveals itself to be a distant prequel in the surprising last act. In the remade trilogy forty years on the intended order is 3-1-2. While it ultimately functions on a story level, the remake of 1 sticks out like a sore thumb. The remakes of 2 and 3 both work for me because they're traditional RPGs with four-character parties and vast non-linear quests.

Dragon Quest 1 Remake adheres to its modest roots by being about a single player-character on a relatively linear journey. Like the other two remakes it comes with gorgeous graphics and orchestrated score, alongside a bevy of quality-of-life features you can freely toggle. Do you want your objective spelled out or would rather take in-game notes? Do you want to highlight treasure-chests and secret spots on the map? Do you want to dial down to Easy mode because you're stuck? Every little convenience has been thought of. I must give credit to an Easter egg that alters the entire second half of the story.

Where the original game lacked any real structure, the remake has a more ordered plot with several smaller arcs running in tandem. From the start you can access two-thirds of the map, and as is Dragon Quest tradition you can acquire three keys that let you find new loot in previously visited areas. The issue with the story is that we're supposed to care about the side-characters we meet along the way, like the Princess's Guard or the Cantlin Priest. But for some reason most of these characters are never named despite being voiced. Imagine trying to care about some guy in a movie who has both arms ripped off by a lathe machine and gets a parking ticket in his three minutes of screen-time, but he's only ever referred to as "Errant Poolboy". On the whole the story won't surprise anyone since it can't subvert or deepen its premise despite the added cutscenes. I'm reminded of that producer who acquired the legal right to make his own Bond movies on the condition he only remake the shittiest one, Thunderball. You just can't add any meat to the first Dragon Quest's skeleton. I do, however, recommend playing Live a Live right after this game for reasons that are best left unexplained.

Now a word about game balance. In my opinion balance isn't about every option being equal, but instead every option being viable or interesting. The other day I posted a review of Skyrim and made a note about just how pathetic mages were in that game were compared to rogues and warriors. Then somebody in the comments posted a screed about I could make a mage work almost half as good as the other two classes if I put in the effort to find these select pieces of gear fifty hours in. Nope, nope, nope. Balance is a malleable thing where you have different options and aren't pigeonholed into the one role to proceed. Final Fantasy VI is a very easy game because there a dozen ways to break it over your knee, but that's a better alternative than every character and spell being nigh useless bar for one that's mandatory to finish the damn thing. Would anyone like a Diablo game where classes like the Warrior and Necromancer soon fall to the wayside, and only the Tax Executive class has a hope of completing the campaign?

I'm not going to be hyperbolic, but this remake was play-tested by the devil. It's not hard, it's annoying. The combat feels balanced around a party, but you're doing it as a solo-character run. You as the knight can act once per turn. The enemies number up to five and can often act twice per turn. Even though you're winning it's not a great feeling when the action-economy is so weighed against you. The UI makes it obvious the framework is meant for parties, as one of the auto-battle option is a healer. As a single character you can be critically hit by a boss twice in a row, silenced, paralysed, confused, drained, or even killed by an instant death-spell. Finding a mimic chest is a game-over if you don't out-level it. You have four times the abilities that you had in the original, but will likely lean on the Cop Out skill available at Level 1. This gives you a 90% chance of reflecting a physical attack back at the enemy. I killed two major bosses this way, one of them being the major optional-boss who was meant to fought twenty levels later. You find so much loot meant for a party that's obsolete by hours. I had to drop down to Easy mode for the final boss on this replay because victory was a crap-shoot despite being at the effective power cap. You win less because of a tight strategy and more because Rosencratz kept calling heads on his coin-flips. I'm sure there's a game out there that does 1v5 turn-based combat well, but this remake isn't it.

Dragon Quest 1 Remake is an awkward title that should have been better given the literal forty years of game-development that have passed since the original. If anything it reminds me of Yakuza Kiwami, being a remake that plays like a middling expansion with a bullshit difficulty-curve. I should note that this 10-hour obligation comes packaged with its sequel the Dragon Quest 2 Remake, which I found to be outstanding and my favourite instalment in the series. It's a much larger game too and evidently where all the work and innovation went. If you can overlook this lacklustre prologue you'll find the actual game afterwards a surprising classic.

Dragon Quest Series Ranking

DQ XI: 7/10

DQ III Remake: 8/10

DQ I Remake: 5/10

DQ II Remake: 9/10


r/patientgamers • • 2d ago

Patient Review Almost 20 years late but I got there | Phantom Hourglass (2007), Nintendo DS

75 Upvotes

Took me a while to finally beat it, but I've completed Phantom Hourglass for the NDS. All in all I think it's the weakest Zelda game I've played so far, probably a 5.5/10.

For a tl;dr: The game's on-shore movement is huge PITA, ship movement is boring, and Temple of the Ocean King actually made me dread completing dungeons. I've heard you can mod in traditional analog movement and I would recommend that completely, it'd probably alleviate some of the problems I have. I don't really have any intention of ever coming back to this one. This should have been a zelda-themed puzzle spin-off like Puzzle Agent/Layton in my opinion, because the game is genuinely funny.

I got a New 3DS recently and decided I'd go back and check out the DS games I missed when I was a kid. I think WW is an amazing 3D zelda, so why not try out the direct sequel I never got as a kid.

For a more in-depth review, I wanted to talk about the few things I think were actually good in this game. The final stretch of the game is pretty good, with the bosses all being a lot more entertaining compared to the earlier ones. The game also utilizes (for better or worse) every aspect of the DS. Everything. I don't want to spoil every aspect but it is very creative about them. Finally, the game is pretty funny, sometimes at the player's expense (which is not a negative, it does a good job jabbing you in the ribs). My personal favorite is probably the cursed tablet, and I wont say more because it made me laugh pretty hard. Linebeck is also great, probably the second best partner character after Midna.

That's it for the positive stuff, everything else is mixed or negative. It's totally possibly I just didn't click with the game but I was struggling to keep playing by the end. I kept putting off the second-to-last island in the game because I was tired of opening my DS just to get frustrated with the act of actually playing the game. Then the battery died and it sent me to the beginning of the island before a save. Totally my fault but I've played games where a failure/crash was just annoying, not a dreadful experience, because at least the gameplay would entertain me while I got back to where I was.

Characters in general are mixed. I've already stated I enjoyed Linebeck, and Ciela did grow on me by the end of the game, but almost every other character was a dud to me. Special mention goes to the main antagonist of the game though, Bellum. I don't think there's any explanation about it in any way. That can work in other games but I don't think it's even got a brain. No dialogue from it or indication it's anything more than feral. I think this burns me a bit because Ganondorf in WW was probably the most interesting incarnation. Tetra is absolutely wasted in this though, and it's pretty egregious that she gets tossed aside at the beginning of the game as another Zelda in distress.

Utlization of all of the DS's features is good, but some are better than others. I don't want to spoil a puzzle (even if it's pretty well known), but they really use everything about the DS. I got pretty tired of using the mic, but it thankfully didn't come up that often. One event requires the player to get loud, so I'm sure this game spooked some parents. The most used is the touchscreen, which is used for movement and drawing. Drawing is fun, but it could've used an undo button for maps instead of just the eraser. If I missed the undo button please bully me for being dumb, but man I was really annoyed whenever I had to erase something. Dragged it down a bit by the end.

Bosses are also a mixed bag. I think this is a Zelda game that gets better by the end. At Gleeok the bosses take a noticeable turn towards the better and it maintains that momentum pretty well. Most bosses try and play with the top screen in mind, but I usually just found this to be an annoyance. It's cool the first 2 times, then it just bothers me. The game is also noticeably laggy during boss fights, with noticeable dips on any boss really pushing the 2 screen gimmick. End gauntlet is cool though. They all use the dungeon items pretty well I think, and the dungeon items are also pretty okay. Most unique thing is a shovel, which is meh.

I don't know where else to put this, but you can customize your boat as well. I did not really bother. If you did, awesome.

To start with the negative: Everything is controlled via the stylus. Running, attacking, reading things, aiming, everything. There was no need to link all of these mechanices to the stylus. The D-Pad would have sufficed. If KH:Coded can handle the d-pad for a platforming game, I'm sure this one could've made it work for an adventure one. It could've at least been an option. It's just the root cause of so many of my issues in this game. Rolling is a pain and I never really got the hang of it, I would try and read items and instead my sword would cut down the sign, and I would fall off of cliffs semi-frequently. You have to physcially carry boss keys and at some point I accidentally threw it in a pit and had to run back to the beginning of a long puzzle.

There's also one point late-game where the stylus was actively getting in the way of seeing things attacking me. It never really happened outside of that battle, but it was very late game and should be mentioned since it dragged down what was a decent fight. I almost never play games with mods for the first attempt (unless it's required for stability or similar), but I really wish I had used the d-pad control mod.

Environmentally I preferred the Great Sea to the Ocean King's domain. Islands themselves are okay, at least. I find myself more entertained just sailing in WW and I always make an effort to complete my sea chart there. Here, I found myself wishing I could clock out more often than not. You get fast travel at a pretty reasonable pace, but the teleports require drawing on the touch screen. Not a big deal, but kind of annoying marking everything with the symbols. Boating itself was pretty annoying after a while, you draw the route to take then jump or shoot the cannon. Scavenging is also done in the boat and is frankly horrible. You drag the chain down through obstacles, hook onto a chest, then painstakingly drag it back through the same obstacles, and if it's damaged you have to pay a fee back at the starting island to get it repaired. I stopped scavenging pretty quick.

I saved the worst for last, and I've learned there's a reason anyone who talks about this game complains about the Temple of the Ocean King. I was expecting it to be an exaggeration, but you really do come back here after every dungeon. It's cool that every new item you get lets you continue through levels faster, but that doesn't make up for having to go through the same floors over and over and over again, all on a somewhat strict time limit. Enemies in this area will reduce that time limit every time you get hit, and running that limit down starts damaging you. Hope you don't have any issues avoiding monsters with the stylus. Though every item opens up new shortcuts, you still need to use those shortcuts on later trips back to the dungeon, so you'll be repeating the same action multiple times. The final trip back is better, except for a gauntlet at the end. It just made me actively dread beating a dungeon, cause I knew I was gonna have to go back there.

I didn't like it. It is better than plenty of other DS games I've played/ but there is so much friction all over the place, and when movement is the biggest cause of that it makes it hard to even enjoy playing. I don't think the game is actively bad, it's put together well and it does use the console it's on to full efect, but man I don't think I can ever come back to this. I was just actively getting depressed or annoyed thinking about some of the things I knew I'd have to do moving forward. I'm sure my expectations were a bit high, hoping for a more WW like experience on a DS cartridge, but I remember finishing KH: Days just a while ago and it was a pretty complete pseudo-KH2 experience, even if I didn't like parts of it. If you want to play it you can I guess, but frankly I don't think it's worth it compared to other mobile Zelda games.


r/patientgamers • • 3d ago Diamonds are Forever

Game Design Talk I finished Tunic and I remember video games. *SPOILER-FREE (and maybe logic-free) rant.

293 Upvotes

I have a buddy. My buddy has custom-made Majora's Masks on his mantle. Zelda is one of the most important franchises in his life. I have never played a Zelda game, a fact that he and many others have lamented. I went from SNES to Playstation pretty hard around 98 and Nintendo has been mostly vicariously enjoyed through Arlo videos.

After I finished Tunic, a game that is lauded to hold the DNA of Zelda games at its core, I asked my buddy if this was the experience I had been missing.

"Yeah, pretty close."

In Tunic, you are an isometric fox in an isometric world. You have nothing but a few pages from an incomplete game manual written in a fictional language. Your objective is to satisfy your curiousity. I cannot directly say anything else about the game without feeling that I've compromised something for you.

This game reminded me of one of those feelings you had as a kid that you were too inexperienced to have words for. Paradoxically, as an adult you've collected a wide variety of words, thoughts and ideas but have forgotten those ephemeral feelings that tied them to you.

Remember when video games conversed with you?

Not spoke to you, not narrated, nor pointed, nor nudged. When they would have an honest-to-earth conversation with you. When it wasn't just your fingers that interacted through a controller, but your thoughts, your feelings, your MIND was part of the game experience.

Actually, I don't know if I do. I don't know if I'm taking the experience of Tunic and overlaying memories with the amazing sense of discovery and EFFORT that I felt playing and finishing this game. I talked to myself while playing this game.

Tunic encouraged me to feel like a human being on a journey. I was taking notes, I was concocting theories. I was wrong many, many times and it felt like that was a part of the game. I grew frustrated at points and left the game. I came back. I questioned if I should look something up, about what that said about me. It was a relationship, a conversation. All this started with an isometric fox with a stick.

Lately I've been trying to remove HUDs as much as possible when playing AAA games. Many games don't allow it; one that does is Spiderman 2. Navigating the city by landmarks, trying to find where to Press X by environmental clues...it's mostly possible. It gives me a similar feeling of conversation that Tunic did.

Tunic ultimately allowed the adult in me to have a conversation with the child in me. Feelings found words and now I have a new lense with which to view my gaming experiences. What games were conversations for you? Is this way of thinking about games possible outside of exploration or management-heavy titles?

EDIT:
Some of the games mentioned by the community, in no particular order

Dark Souls
Shadow of the Colossus
Chants of Senaar
Ico
Outer Wilds
Breath of the Wild
The Last Guardian
Kyrandia
Elden Ring
Monkey Island
Spyro the Dragon
Duke 3D
Ash Lake
Quake 

Monomoon


r/patientgamers • • 3d ago

Patient Review Lunacid will be a blast for people whose idea of exploration in games is defined by wandering.

102 Upvotes

So you know Dark Souls, right? And that it's made by From Software?

Well, before Dark Souls, and even before Demon Souls, From Software had a game series from the mid-90s to the early 2000s called King's Field, which is fair to think of as proto-Souls. It's first person instead third person. It's slower, more methodical, and not as difficult (or, difficult in a different way). Combat is defined by spacing and timing instead of dodging and parrying. And there's a strong focus on mood and atmosphere than set pieces.

Fast forward a couple of decades and now we have this very niche microgenre called fieldlikes. If you're familiar with soulslikes, you can probably figure out what that genre is all about. And Lunacid is one of the big games of this microgenre.

So I gave Lunacid a shot, bounced off it pretty quick intially, got convinced to give it another shot, and then picked it up again. Eventually I played it for a long time, but I ended up realizing that the reason it wouldn't really grab me is because Lunacid's idea of good exploration isn't quite the same as mine, and this genre is defined by its exploration.

I love exploration that's driven by a sense of adventure and curiosity, constantly stimulated by the environment at every turn: What's that thing in the distance? How do I get to this place? What's behind that locked door? How do I open it? What will I discover if I follow this trail? That's a conspicuous looking ledge, am I supposed to try getting there with the tools that I've gotten?

Lunacid, by contrast, is dominated by long corridors, hallways, passageways and pretty bare spaces. That's not to say it doesn't have what I mentioned above, but the amount of those things is far less dense than the amount that usually tickles my adventuring sensibilities. The game is also visually homogenous a lot of times. There isn't a lot of environmental legibility or memorable landmarks, and not that much in terms of enemy variety, so areas tend to blend together often.

So instead of the earlier questions, I usually end up asking: Where am I supposed to go? Have I already been here? Am I missing something important? Is there even anything worth finding in this direction? Should I be elsewhere? Is that all?

So my general feeling when playing this game is that I'm wandering more than exploring.

Take Breath of the Wild or Elden Ring for example. You see an unusual structure in the distance, a mysterious landmark, some curious markings on walls or doors that remind you of something you came across earlier, or a seemingly inaccessible area right now. That compels me to investigate and motivates me to play more to see what's what.

Lunacid certainly has secrets and interesting discoveries, but I find that its environments don't consistently generate that same curiosity and oftentimes I just stumble on to things rather than those things being the product of purposeful poking around.

I'm not saying wandering is inherently bad. If you enjoy that sense of disorientation, aimlessness and uncertainty, that's perfectly valid. I'm just saying why Lunacid's particular approach to exploration doesn't engage me as much. In fact, the mood and atmosphere of the game lends itself a lot to that kind of exploration with its eerie, dreamlike, almost unknowable mystical quality.


r/patientgamers • • 3d ago

Multi-Game Review My Top 40 Games That Are Best Played On PS3: Ranked

131 Upvotes

Sorry for my brief absence. This one is special to me. I "grew up" on PS2, but PS3 was the first time I was able to spend my own money on games and followed gaming news. It was fun to revisit some of this, as well as getting to some titles I have had on my shelf for 20 years. Not everything aged well, but it was a fun era.

  1. This is NOT a retrospective. This is a list of games that are exclusive to this console, or the console is the best way to play it NOW. Only the best version of a game can make the list. If you think I missed a classic game, there's probably an explanation in a comment I made on the post as to why, and what platform I recommend.
  2. All games on a list are worth playing despite any criticisms I may have for them.
  3. Ranking is not necessarily by which is the best, but in terms of what I most recommend playing. Perhaps my theoretical opinion is that the worst Mario is better than the best Street Fighter. But the best Street Fighter would still rank higher, because it's a unique experience, and the best version of that experience.
  4. Only consoles & PC (Windows/DOS) are considered. No arcade/Neo-Geo, mobile, or other home computers. MAME is difficult to work with & high maintenance. Mobile changes architecture too often for all-time lists, and often don't support controllers. Other home computers rarely meet rule 1 & rarely have controller support.
  5. I default to PC when available. If it's better on console, I'll put it on the console's list. Usually, it's better or the same on PC, and more accessible.
  6. Games with the same name will be clarified by year or console within (). Games not released in North America will have the region abbreviation within []. Alternate names will be included within {}.
  7. My lists are in increments of 10 to make it easier to track & for quality control. If there are 61 good games, I make a cut to make it an even 60.

#40: Resistance 2

Resistance 2 improves significantly with graphics & somewhat with aiming, but unfortunately conforms to the then-popular standard of only 2 weapons at a time. Having a toolbox of options was pretty much the main thing saving Resistance 1. For such a unique setting, the plot of 2 is surprisingly generic military shooter, which unfortunately doubles down on the things that DIDN'T work about R1. The devs seemed to realize this wasn't going anywhere, and decided to switch protagonists, tone, controls, and even subgenre for the third game. This sounds negative, but 2 is not without its moments. It's a fun ride, just a bit ho-hum in the greater context of an all-time list. I had fun playing through it & I enjoy the alien designs. I think some fellow PS3 fans will be shocked that this is so low. But I also think some PC/Xbox fans who tried it later will wonder why it made the list at all.

#39: ModNation Racers

MNR is a truly genius concept for competing with Mario Kart: going hog wild on customization. Tuner cars were already a fan-favorite feature in racing games for the upgrades & ricing you can do, so this was a no-brainer. The ModNation devs double the customization choices from even the most in depth Need For Speed game, and then allow a crazy amount of options for track creation as well. Customizing stuff is intuitive & very fun in this game. The physics are even good, which is rare to see for hyper casual arcade racers. Unfortunately, the rubber banding is WILDLY unfair, making the whole thing feel pointless. MNR is also badly optimized. There are truly absurd load times, occasional bugs, and frequent frame drops. Somehow the dev team managed to do even worse with the spiritual sequel LittleBigPlanet Karting, which is still badly optimized with bad rubber banding, then further chooses to pare down the customization significantly which is...the entire point of the game.

#38: Eternal Sonata

A JRPG about Polish classical music composer Frederic Chopin, in an adventure he dreams up as he is dying of tuberculosis. The summary says it all really. If you're willing to accept this bonkers concept and see where they go with it, I doubt you will be disappointed. If you're not interested, I am not going to try to convince you. That said, in a vacuum, it is a pretty good game. The battle system is inventive for a turn based RPG. The music, of course, is a highlight. It is 100% linear, but I don't mind that much these days. The story is heartfelt & has interesting things to say about life, though I will note that it isn't exactly life changing. It feels a bit like a young person trying to write from an old person perspective if that makes sense, which makes it more surface level than it is shooting for.

#37: Resistance - Fall of Man

Aliens invade in the 1950s, and unfortunately for us, they are able to make more aliens by infecting humans & incubating inside of us. After discovering you are the only known human to Resist™️ infection/transformation, you decide to put together a Resistance™️ force to destroy alien nests. Resistance tried to bridge the gap between Halo & WW2 FPS games, as well as add the fun of carrying an unrealistic amount of guns from boomer shooters. And it...sorta works! It's an early PS3 game. The aiming is not quite there (but not enough to be infuriating), no ADS, texture-wise it is an upscaled PS2 game, and the art direction is very washed out with the infamous 7th gen brown filter. Guns are good though, the alien guns in particular are creative. The level design isn't stellar, but decent & straightforward. Unfortunately they do absolutely nothing to capitalize on the fun of 1950s Americana, nor is it particularly fun with the SciFi. It's fun to play through, but not as memorable as it probably should have been.

#36: God of War Origins Collection {Chains of Olympus + Ghost of Sparta}

Chains of Olympus takes place before GoW1, and Ghost of Sparta takes place immediately after GoW1. Both should be played after 1 & before 2, since they explore Kratos' origins more than they break new ground. Both games are both relatively important to the lore while still remaining nonessential; a good combo for a spinoff. They are remarkably well done for PSP games, but we ARE comparing them to big boy console games though, so Origins can't go too high. They're starting to scrape the bottom of the barrel for Greek mythology characters too, though not as badly as GoW Ascension, and they do more interesting thing with Kratos than Ascension does. If you're not feeling Chains of Olympus, try out Ghost of Sparta before giving up, since it is significantly better.

#35: Tokyo Jungle

A pretty weird survival game about animals roaming around abandoned cities in a human-less post apocalyptic future. There is a noticeable pattern to the gameplay loop, generally hunting, avoiding predators, and marking new territory. But the mechanics are varied & can get hyper specific, which is pretty funny sometimes. Even one of the core mechanics is making sure you fuck frequently enough (good luck gamers) to have enough offspring to make sure your lineage survives as long as possible, which adds some roguelite qualities. There is a surprisingly robust roster of animals to choose from, and gameplay can vary significantly depending on what type of animal you are. So, this is nobody's favorite game, but I think half the fun of console gaming is being there for the "you had to be there" experiences. Cracking open a magazine (or browsing reddit/a gaming forum) and being like "Ok Sony, what have you got this month to tide me over? Animal Sex In The City? Alrighty then, let's go." Nintendo is the last company left who still does this, which kinda sucks.

#34: Twisted Metal [2012]

It feels like this "should" be the best Twisted Metal, but it is missing something. The story is still dark & edgy, but maybe more...cinematic? There is a certain magic to Black that this doesn't have. Even Head On, as radically different as it is from Black, feels just as authentic with its own brand of chaos. 2012 succeeds at having the best gameplay & graphics, but then again Black's physics feel better. Content wise, it is comparable to older titles, but the roster is very limited, the story is short, and the online lobbies didn't work that well. Maybe I just expected more by this stage of the series. 2012 is MILES better than literally anything besides those top 2 games though. Yes, even TM2.

#33: The Darkness

An FPS that combines dark superpowers in a similar way to Bioshock, which came out the same year. After losing someone close to him, a young man with ties to the Italian mafia gets bonded to the titular "Darkness", a creature somewhere between a demon and the Venom symbiote. As you might expect from this premise and being released in 2007, the story is very dark, and takes you many places, including the afterlife. Despite being a bit edgy, the story is the best part of the game; the pacing is great, and I find it engaging, even heartfelt at times. The frame rate is REALLY bad on hardware, but if you have a decent PC, emulation can fix that. It can't fix how awkward the aiming can be. On hardware, I was never suffering through the gameplay exactly, but you are playing this for the premise/story.

#32: 3D Dot Game Heroes

An adventure game inspired by Zelda, from the gameplay down to the pixel art of the NES original. It is charming, but does feel slightly manufactured. While I understand & even have historically asked for console competitors to fill blank niches in their roster, on the other hand, asking where Sony's Zelda is would be like asking where Nintendo's Halo or God of War is. There isn't one & there doesn't need to be one. Now, 3DDGH is not the full-on nostalgia bait slop that is so common nowadays, but it IS very smart about what buttons to push to make you remember fond memories of other, more original games. What it captures best is the sense of playfulness. It knows it is a game, and that is cool. And in some ways, this does set it apart slightly from Zelda, which tends to have a different tone. The minigames shake up the standard gameplay, and sometimes reference other old games, so that's fun.

#31: Army of Two

AoT is nearly a classic third person shooter. But not quite. The aggro mechanic is interesting even in single player, and even better in split screen. Being built completely around split screen gives it a lot of free points, since there are so few games like that these days and so few good 3rd person shooters before 7th gen. I think the sequel makes the wise choice to dispense with any kind of historical accuracy; at this point in my life, it is a little weird to see this completely unserious power fantasy set during the War On Terror. AoT is firmly tongue in cheek, which is appreciated, but neither is it satire. It doesn't have anything insightful to say about the war, PMCs, or really anything. And sure, the level design, plot, gun choice, enemy variety, and graphics are bog standard. But when you're blasting away with a buddy on the couch next to you, chugging a beer & riffing off each other's terrible jokes, an interesting plot would just be a distraction anyway. It's not that kind of game.

#30: Folklore

Sometimes rare games achieve "classic" status just for the aura that they have from being rare or unique. Folklore is...kind of one of these, but not egregiously so, like Rule of Rose for example. Folklore is legitimately good, but I'm not quite comfortable calling it a classic. The graphics & overall vibe/aesthetic is the reason to play the game. It doesn't even look very dated in today's terms, and even if it did, the art direction more than makes up for it. The murder mystery is engaging, and I like the combat mechanics, which involve using Folks in a strategic way. Unfortunately, the level design is linear & repetitive, made even worse because you essentially have to play each level twice. Rarely do I feel as though I learn or gain anything radically different than the first time around, so this feels like pure padding. It's also designed for 30 FPS, which is common for the console, and not too bad for this type of game. Unfortunately, some of the physics (particularly cloth) are tied to the frame rate; you can somewhat reliably bump it up to 50 FPS, but not 60.

#29: Killzone 3

I struggle to know where to rank this. 3 is good in the way that matters most for an FPS: the gameplay. In fact, the shooting is best on this list, and even competes with other best in class competitive shooters at the time such as Halo & COD. 3 has better graphics, I remember the particle effects being particularly impressive. 3's level design is solid for an FPS; therefore, moment to moment, the game is good. I just don't remember much of it. I have no idea what the plot of Killzone is, but I'm pretty sure we play as the bad guys. And not in a fun subversive way, more of a "rah rah jingoistic imperialism that they hoped we wouldn't think about too hard" kind of way. 2's campaign is not immune to this issue, but has better characters & level design. As a result, the highlight of 3 is the online; which of course doesn't exist anymore. 2 works online with RPCS3, but not 3 yet. Also, 2's online experience felt more exciting & memorable, despite 3 being more balanced & giving more reasons to play less popular classes. Even the shooting, which is objectively more precise with less input lag in 3, could be reasonably preferred in 2 due to being heavier, meatier, and with more forgiving reaction time. If you were to rank KZ3 in the top 10 though, I wouldn't argue much, it's more the criteria of the list.

#28: Heavenly Sword

God of War lite. I mean that in a good way AND in a bad way. It is innovative, in some ways. The motion capture is very well done, and particularly at the time it was a showcase of what later games such as L.A. Noire could accomplish on the same hardware. I love Anna Torv, and she is excellent in this. Andy Serkis is also a delight, particularly when motion capture is involved. The graphics are great in general, it is probably the best looking early PS3 title. The motion controls for archery (and optionally, panning the camera) were also ahead of their time. And yet, it really is just GoW's hack & slash base and...not much else. Not that there's much time to evolve, the game is about 7 hours, roughly half GoW's runtime. They even went with similar themes, and a similar vibe as GoW. The main character has a destiny to ascend with the power of the gods, but it also tells you in the opening cut scene that they are supposed to die at the end. The main character wields a curved magic blade given to them by the gods, that looks like it was designed by the same blacksmith. I like GoW a lot, and I liked this too...I just don't know why Sony would follow that formula so closely when they own both IPs. Also, it is an inconsistent 30 FPS on hardware. Still, there isn't really a bad moment to speak of, emulation fixes the performance issues, and the short runtime is not a detriment now that you don't have to worry about it being a good value at full price.

#27: Army of Two - The 40th Day

This is just more AoT, but tightened up. Bigger set pieces, better graphics, slightly refined controls. The main difference being that the humor, bromance, and amount of talking in general has been toned WAY down. Whether this makes 40th Day better or worse depends on how funny VS obnoxious you found the previous game. I think it's a step closer to being a classic than the first, but also since it's less memorable (for better or worse) & much more linear with less ways to approach a situation, it's another half step back. The well thought out couch co-op continues to carry the series. You could get enjoyment playing solo, but you're missing the point.

#26: Tales of Xilia 2

X2 does a lot of interesting things & takes chances, and I respect it for that. Like much Japanese media, the Xilia duology represents the contrast between old Japan & the rapidly developed modern Japan. The world of Xilia used to be a magical place where anything could happen, and now it is full of corporations where you are immediately saddled with unpayable medical debt after a train accident early game. You can react to this & yell at people who constantly harass you to pay up, but ultimately the young employee on the other end of the line is just a wage slave with no responsibility for the debt you incurred, and has been nice to you & upbeat the whole game. After being hired by corpos to "delete" offshoot dimensions that "shouldn't exist" and "will destroy our world if left alone", suddenly you're forced to ask yourself big moral questions when you're forced to decide whether to kill an alternate universe version of an old friend from Xilia 1.

Direct JRPG sequels don't often turn out that well because they tend to either be too similar with not enough plot scraped together that wasn't already done in the first game, or too different which alienates the fans. But X2 takes that inherent weakness, and chooses to emphasize & capitalize on it. You reunite with characters from the first game, but it's bittersweet; a metaphor for "you can't go home". I might actually write a pretty in-depth review on this, but to sum up: X1 is probably a better game for most people, and despite X2 reusing some characters & most of the map, X2 is a very different game, and the themes have stuck with me more. I can understand someone thinking it's a little too real though, and not what they look for in a video game.

#25: Soul Calibur IV

I have played SC4 a truly ridiculous amount, easily the most of any Soul Calibur, because it was the first with online & the character creator is a big step up from 3. However, it's only 5th best in the series, maybe 4th if you like it better than 1's simplicity. 4 doesn't do a single thing best compared to other SC games. The amount of single player content & the roster was a colossal step down from 3. The stage design is better than 5 & 6, but a step down from 2 & 3. Graphics & character creation are better in 5 & 6. Character designs are fine, but more fantastical (and unapologetically slutty). I prefer the near-grounded nature of 1 & 2, though I do have a soft spot for stomach-less Nightmare as a moment in time. The star power (pun intended) of Darth Vader was great for a guest character, but doesn't suit the setting, like at all. I still recommend playing it (unlike 5): the performance is great, it looks great, and the lore is a satisfying wrap up to the series, if short. But you don't need to play it as much as I did.

#24: Ratchet & Clank Future - Tools of Destruction

Next gen R&C was a strong step forward. I like it quite a bit, and I am very pleased that they kept the excellent 60 FPS optimization despite the impressive graphical jump. It does rank a hair below the original trilogy for me though. The series was getting samey by this point. The future gimmick is a good idea to set it apart, but it is not quite enough.

#23: Gran Turismo 5

The devs had a hell of a time trying to get this running at all on PS3 hardware, so it suffered delay after delay for 4 years. As a result, they didn't go as hard on the single player experience as GT4 did, and that's most people's main gripe with it. That, and Xbox got 2 of the best Forzas before it even came out, and 2 even better Forzas before 6. But this is a retro game now (good Lord) so that doesn't matter. It's still a very good game, ranking 4th best from a modern perspective in my opinion, though 6/5/3 is arguable (4>7>6>5>3>Sport>2>1>PSP). And the devs succeeded in getting it running smoothly, somehow, which is impressive for how pretty it is. It only ranks as low as it does because I slightly prefer 6, and 6 has sufficient content. If 6 didn't exist, 5 would occupy its ranking.

#22: Armored Core - For Answer

This may be my favorite Armored Core besides 6, and I don't even like mech games that much. The main reason is that it is just so fast paced & fun to play, and the customization is very in-depth. It's not perfect though, nor is it for everyone. The camera is inconsistent, the auto target is hyper sensitive, the menus are basic with black backgrounds, and the environments are peak desaturated brown 7th gen smear with little interactivity. It really min-maxed the shoestring budget by placing all effort into the gameplay, but for that alone, you should at least try it out. I'll take that over a boring but pretty AAA game.

#21: Sly Cooper Collection {1-3}

The least appreciated of the PS2 mascot trilogies. And I understand why: Sly is certainly the most linear & traditional mascot platformer of the bunch. But even Sly 1 is certainly no PS1 game, there is far more polish. You play as an international thief, and you must incorporate platforming, stealth, and basic combat in order to steal back your family's heirloom book of thieving techniques.

2 feels a bit more modern in a way that's hard to describe. Still linear, but more in-depth. It also added minigames, which can be fun but often far too hard, particularly the races.

3 ia more of the same as 2, which makes it less impressive. But it has plenty of ideas for level design & mixups to gameplay, and the story is a satisfying ending to the series. Do yourself a favor, and do not play 4, which has a cliffhanger ending. It ends here as far as I'm concerned, and 3 is not one to miss.

20: Puppeteer

At the time, one might have expected a 2D mascot platformer in the Year of Our Lord 2013 to be old hat, which is why it didn't sell well, but time has proven that assumption wrong. There is more than meets the eye. It's whimsical, but darker than it appears, like old school fairy tales dark. You quite literally lose your head at the beginning, and have to collect severed heads to attached to yourself that give you different powers. The presentation & art direction is perhaps the biggest selling point, with pretty graphics, a stage play format, and a narrator. The gameplay is pretty good too, using scissors to interact with the environment in a variety of ways.

#19: Battlefield - Bad Company

There is no debate whatsoever that Bad Company 1 & 2 have the best campaigns of any Battlefield, and as such, they are the best Battlefields for retro gaming. BC1 was the debut of the Frostbite engine, which allowed for impressive destruction effects for 90% of objects in the game. The story is about B Company, nicknamed Bad Company due to being comprised of fuck-ups. You're there essentially to be cannon fodder in a war against Russia, and your Sergeant is one day away from retirement. Of course, everything goes upside down, you're forced to go AWOL, and end up aiming to steal a stockpile of gold from a dangerous mercenary group. It has good humor without overdoing it as the 00s tended to; the characters are memorable & tongue in cheek while feeling completely real. The main downside is the enemy Ai, who can magically see you immediately even crouched behind a 6 ft wall. 2 is better in just about every way: the pacing, the dynamic levels, the variety, the graphics, the controls, the performance, the color palette, the "existing on PC". Still, even if we include the multiplayer experience, BC1 makes my top 5 Battlefield games, easily. It's just...fun.

#18: Jak & Daxter Collection {1-3}

I love all 3 games here, but admittedly they're a bit of a mixed bag.

1 is a classic 3D platformer. It doesn't reinvent the wheel in terms of gameplay or tone, but knocks it out of the park in the execution of every single aspect of the game. Definitely top 10 non-Mario 3D platformers.

2 takes a hard left into being a third person shooter open world game. Basically GTA, but rated T & easier to trick your parents into getting. The dark powers add a new dimension to the gameplay. The difficulty balance is a bit wack, but it's a good game, if dated.

3 ends the story in a satisfying way, evens out 2's rougher edges, and mixes up the semi open world gameplay with a Mad Max esque desert sandbox with vehicle combat. The light powers weren't as revolutionary as the dark powers in 2, but at least you have both here.

#17: Midnight Club - Los Angeles: Complete Edition

MC3 was technically an open world, but LA really defines the open world racing genre, with a city that is bigger than all 3 cities in 3 combined. This adds to the immersion, and so does the day/night cycle, weather, and better physics. 3 had some fun story beats, but LA's has perhaps the best storytelling in a racing game. Better graphics of course. LA shares a lot of the same flaws as 3 though; there is some chugging, and the extreme difficulty & unfair rubber banding may be even WORSE in LA. It has less content than 3, and less customization. But at the end of the day, it is a different enough experience, and an excellent cap to the series that Rockstar could be proud of.

#16: LittleBigPlanet

There was no "one game" that could be said to have brought back 2D platformers. But if there was, it was LBP. It is one of the first AAA 2.5D games, and it still looks beautiful today. The gameplay is good, but extremely approachable. More of an excuse to explore the theme park that is the level design. The vibe is very cute & fun, and pays tribute to many cultures around the world that the levels are based on. And when you finish the game? No you didn't! There is an incredibly well-made level creator, and tons of hyper specific unlockable content to make each level truly feel like it's yours. Same with the costumes & skins; customization is really the name of the game here. It took Nintendo 7 years to even attempt to copy it, and while Mario Maker may have a more interesting competitive scene, LBP still does a better job with the sheer level of creative customization options. It even had split screen multiplayer a year before New Super Mario Bros Wii. Truly, the only thing holding this game back is that 2 is better in every way, and 1's unlockable content can be imported into 2. Which is just a positive from a user perspective. LBP1 is still a classic, and you should definitely play it before moving all your stuff to 2. If only for the dev-made levels, which are a full length game by themselves.

#15: inFamous

inFamous checks all the boxes of what it's trying to accomplish. It looks great, it has a cool open world, the powers are expansive & varied without feeling like you're constantly in menus. You feel powerful but there is a reasonable challenge. The story is good, with well-done voice acting. The only downside is the performance, which chugs in hardware, and causes occasional glitches. You could nitpick. I suppose at times, you can see the seams of the gameplay loop; some of the side missions get a bit repetitive, but I still completed all of them each time I've beaten the game. Similarly, the morality system is a bit arbitrary & binary. Could be done better, but I'm sure glad it is there, it is a lot of fun for role playing purposes, especially in the superhero/villain genre. I have a lot of good memories of this game.

#14: Ico

To this day, Ico still comes up in conversations about video games as art. It is difficult to describe it here, because it is more than the sum of its parts, most of which are still good, mind you. The impressive visuals that still hold up because of the art direction. The music. The body language & unspoken bond between Ico & Yorda. The logical puzzle design. Being weak but not obtusely frustrating. The gameplay is usually the point of contention for most people, since you have to hold Yorda's hand the whole time, and you can't fight at the same time. From a raw gameplay perspective, this is bad & annoying, but it is simply part of her character & the experience of Ico. You would think that Escort Mission: The Game would suck, but you'd be wrong; as long as you have an open mind. Ico has such a consistent vision that coalesces into something beautiful. That being said, it is a "play once" type of game. Or at least once a decade or so when you forget the impact, or want to show someone the game.

#13: Ratchet & Clank Collection {R&C 2002, Going Commando, Up Your Arsenal}

There's a reason R&C has lasted significantly longer than its fellow PS2 mascots. Part of that is the polish, but there's also more to do. It is primarily a 3rd person shooter, but has strong platforming sections, and mixups like vehicles & controlling Clank to solve puzzles & make repairs.

The original is the most memorable in terms of story. Ratchet is a bit of a jackass at the beginning, but lovable. His Leroy Jenkins-ing through life is frustrating to Clank, the straight man, yet sometimes what is needed. Ratchet grows as a character, and he & Clank end up making a great team.

GC fixes the glaring aiming issue from 1, and the gameplay in general is refined, making it easier to return to. The story is not nearly as memorable, but it does have some fun with the concept of "OK the story is over...now what do we do?"

UYA goes wild with the upgrade system, but is otherwise just a solid entry with a plot that I confuse with GC's most of the time. It has well thought out level design for the platforming sections though. I don't know which I prefer between GC & UYA, but both are contenders for the best R&C game, despite being less memorable.

#12: Killzone 2

I still don't particularly like or understand Killzone's story, but it has the best characters in the series. Radec is the most memorable enemy, and some of your squad mates have good-ish banter. More importantly, the gameplay is excellent, the shooting rivaled only by Killzone 3 on this list. It's beautiful, and the online was legendary. It occupies a solid middle ground between Halo's slow time to kill & COD's madhouse, the same way it balances Halo's sci-fi with (old) COD's realism. The weightiness of the weapons & the way they combine with the crunchy sound design & animations are a particular standout. "Halo killer" it was not: Killzone caused a total of 0 competitive FPS fans to switch to PlayStation. But if your Xbox buddies were dragging you for playing Killzone over Halo, are least you could honestly argue "but have you tried it tho?"

#11: Skate 2

Skate 2 has a better storyline, a more cohesive open world, and is generally more immersive, realistic, and challenging than Skate 3. The thing that annoys me most is how clunky it feels to walk when not on the skateboard. It takes me right out of the experience each time, especially if I'm switching between 2 & 3. 3 also beats it in graphics & content, so I do give it a slight edge. But realistically, 2 feels the most like a memorable "must play" experience. Similar to LBP1 VS LBP 2: play Skate 2 first, enjoy the heck out of the experience, then move on to 3 where you will probably clock many more gameplay hours than 2. Except in Skate's case, you will secretly miss 2.

#10: Resistance 3

That's right: Resistance ranges from worst FPS on the list to the best. I'm just as surprised as you are. To achieve this, R3 had to course correct hard, and I'm pleased to inform you that they do pretty much everything right. It's not a generic war shooter anymore because there is no war. Humanity lost. We are what's left. You get your moment to "win", but it feels earned, instead of the previous protagonist being essentially the chosen one. The gameplay is MASSIVELY improved, with ADS, much smoother aiming, meatier sound design + force feedback, and they brought back unlimited weapons. The graphics are also significantly better, and less washed out and...7th gen-y than 2. There is even a good co-op split screen mode! The only downsides are the noticeably narrow FOV, frame drops on hardware, and the online was...fine, but not impressive at the time.

#9: Tekken 5 - Dark Resurrection

5 is best remembered as a PS2 game, but to me, it is THE PS3 fighting game. Dark Resurrection is a big step up from the original. It adds 5 new characters, several new modes, new stages, new moves for some characters, and much better balancing. Notably, it was the first Tekken to have online, and it did a good job from the start. And...it's still one of the best Tekken games in general. After 5's course correction, they started to get a lot more iterative, so it's a bit of a wash, and I also disliked the reliance on paid DLC. But by 8, the small improvements added up enough to be meaningfully better. 4 is the weird one which is fun to go back to sometimes, and 3 is the classic. Overall, in my opinion: 8>5DR>3>4>7>6>2>1.

#8: Motorstorm - Pacific Rift

MSPR is the anti-Gran Turismo in some ways. GT is a sim (or simcade by today's standards), while MS is strictly an arcade racer, though it does have physics realistic enough to feel "right". GT is legal motorsport track racing, while MS is off-roading with questionable people in between partying it up at a music festival in the desert. GT's graphics are very good, yet toned down & grey-ish, while MS has eye popping tropical colors with graphics that are nearly as good, but lean on even better art direction. GT is refined, while MotorStorm is dramatic. Which is better? Who cares! I love them both all the more for having such a strong identity. MS's track design is S-tier, it keeps your blood pumping with plenty of chaos. The choices in vehicles are nice, though personally I find them wildly unbalanced in certain tracks. PR is the best Motorstorm by a wide margin. I like the others plenty, but I just don't see a reason to go back to them. The first one feels like a proof of concept for Pacific Rift. Arctic Edge is a snowy, scaled down to PS2 version of PR. Apocalypse is the most unique, featuring asphalt driving & vehicle destruction, but overall not quite good enough to hit the list.

#7: Skate 3

It's hard to argue that Skate 3 is not THE definitive skating game experience, particularly for fans of real skating. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 1+2 competes, but it's much more arcadey. Skate 2 is better in some ways, but I think the amount of content triumphs here, which is further extended by a pretty solid level designer. The controls are a lighter/less realistic than 2, but more polished, and still heavier/more realistic than 4. I think it is possible to improve upon Skate 3, which is why it's not even higher, but we sure have not done that yet.

#6: Gran Turismo 6

6 is very similar in quality to 5, for slightly different reasons. 6 has better physics, customization, and more content. 5 has better progression, special events, and includes endurance racing. 6 doesn't have used cars, which can be considered either good or bad depending on your opinion. Personally I preferred not checking the used lot constantly, and just buying what I wanted when I wanted it, and knowing my bank account won't suffer as a result. The graphics are more advanced in 6, but are more stylized than 5. 6 was more of a mess on launch & came out too late, so very few people have stellar memories of it. But judging how the games are now in a vacuum, I'd say it's close to a direct upgrade from 5. Absolutely play both, neither are disappointing. Despite some unevenness, I'll hesitantly say that this is my third favorite GT.

#5: inFamous 2

For whatever reason, inFamous isn't talked about as much as it used to be, but it absolutely sits in the upper echelon of superhero games, next to Spider-Man 2018 & Batman Arkham. Just about everything is improved in 2, including the story. Whichever ending you get, the series definitively ends the plot with no dangling plot threads, which is something you just don't see too much, especially for the second game in a series. New Orleans is a rare setting to see in video games, giving a nice switch up to the overdone New York styled city from the first game. The powers are greatly expanded & noticeably more polished. 2 inherits a bit of the first game's chugging on hardware, but it's perfectly playable. I want more, and yet I don't. I'm glad it got a good ending instead of being done to death.

#4: Ratchet & Clank Future - A Crack In Time

CiT is, in my view, the greatest R&C to date. It isn't without tight competition. Rift Apart has better graphics & polish, but is nearly devoid of grit or charm. ToD is very good, but CiT polishes & improves spectacularly on ToD's foundation, making the Future series feel like almost a separate thing. And it pushes UYA's focus on customization innovations even further. I love everything about it. CiT is one of the greatest 3D platformers(?) of all time. Or is it more of a 3rd person shooter? Or action adventure? Whatever it is, it's one of the best.

#3: LittleBigPlanet 2

I'll keep it short: LBP is in the top 10 greatest 2D platformers of all time. It does everything as good or better than LBP1, and supports moving all content from 1 to 2. The level creator in particular is the most improved aspect, which was far and away the #1 reason to play LBP1 to begin with. The long history of community made levels have been backed up on community servers, and people still create new content to this day. You can play LBP2 forever...and I just might.

#2: God of War Collection {1+2}

For some reason, there is this persistent zeitgeist understanding that GoW was mindless blood & guts with no nuance before GoW 2018. Let me assure you, that is completely, utterly false. From the opening scene of Kratos throwing himself off a cliff, you know you're in for something special. GoW is a classic Greek tragedy. A testament to tenacity, yes, but just as much a warning about how societies make their own monsters & how rage can consume you. This is what originally cost Kratos his family, yet his response is to rage even harder. Kratos may not have learned the lessons he should have until later, but the audience does; the storytelling makes sure of that. The gameplay is also quite good, elevating hack & slash gameplay and keeping the camera pulled way, waaayy back so that you can truly see the scale of what is happening, yet easily see & control Kratos. And boy, is it beautiful, even on PS2.

2 is even better in just about every way, except arguably 1 has higher highs in the story. 2 is THE benchmark for hack and slash games.

#1: Metal Gear Solid - The Legacy Collection {MG 1-2, MGS 2-4, Peace Walker}

I'm not even sure what to say here that would adequately express how much these games mean to me. 2, 3, and possibly 4 could have taken the top spot alone. All together? Nothing else stood a chance. MGS has a lot to say about a lot of things, but is most often a tale about the American military industrial complex, and how we treat veterans. It is told with an honesty & accuracy that is only truly possible from an outsider's perspective. Even glimpses at the future have been shockingly on point, even the parts that are wildly over the top. Yet, MGS is not a satire or fully even a criticism. To the contrary, there is a certain reverence & appreciation for the West. Above all, MGS strives to be a very good GAME, and one that pays close attention to the details. It is quite easily one of the greatest game franchises of all time.

The Rest:

Think I missed a game, or question why I'd choose the PS3 version? Check here and here respectively.


r/patientgamers • • 3d ago

Multi-Game Review A round-up of short games

24 Upvotes

I’m not sure if everyone does this, but my backlog list isn’t just made up of titles. I also include how long it takes to complete (according to hltb.com). And sometimes this is how I choose what to play next. If I just finished a long 50+ hour game, I might want a shorter, more compact experience to hold me over until the next big adventure. 

Ittle Dew

I have some very mixed thoughts about this game. On one side, it is really short and simple. There aren’t that many controls, the map is small, and the story is minimal. These are all traits that I usually like, but I mostly found the game forgettable. Something about the art didn’t really click with me and I cannot tell you much about the music or the characters. The puzzles are cool and give a fair bit of challenge. The cards you get are a funny little detail. 

Mind Over Magnet 

Certainly, part of my enjoyment for this game came from following the development on the GMTK channel. It is a simple puzzle game where you take your magnet buddy from point A to point B. A couple of mechanics are introduced but overall it’s nothing crazy. It took about 2 hours to finish and I thought that was a fair amount of time before it grew stale. Still, from a development aspect it is cool to experience someone’s creation after watching videos of the process. With such a straight foward story and puzzles, I don’t think I will come back to it but I was happy to support an emerging developer. 

Despelote

A game about Ecuador’s road to qualifying for the World Cup 2002. This game is filled with nostalgia and authenticity. A lot of this enhanced by the style of the surroundings and the dialogue. Even though I’m from a different Latin American country, I couldnt help but smile at the conversation among the parents and the way the teacher scolds the students. It really immerses the player into thinking they’re looking through a different point in time. The World Cup is the only sporting event I watch intensely and with all my attention. The anticipation as your team approaches qualification (or elimination) is truly captivated and the way it envelops a whole nation really comes through. At about 2 hours of gameplay, I really can’t recommend this enough to fans of the sport. The ending is something sweet and it really left an impression on me about relationships, dreaming, and the love of the game.  

Thank Goodness You’re Here

This game would fit nicely into an Adult Swim slot. I went in blind and I came out laughing hysterically. I don’t think I can describe this game and do it justice, but I will try. It feels like playing through an adult tv show. Your move set is limited to walking, jumping and … slapping! That’s right, all interactions start by slapping. The main character explores a town and gets into a variety of nonsensical scenarios. Mostly, you help out the townspeople with various tasks. The dialogue is confusing, hilarious, but also sort of charming. At times, you might feel like you have the hang of how the game works, but then an unthinkable scenario unfolds. The game is simple, but if you enjoy story and dialogue driven games with some off-the-wall humor, this might be for you. 

Mail Time

If you need a game to fit the season, then Mail Time is a great game to pick up in autumn. It feels very cozy in every way. The nature, the tiny environment and cute community of animals, and the warm music. The game is simple, you’re a mail carrier on your last assignment to complete your training. The game gives you the task of finding Greg and it becomes clear that you will not find them until the end of the game. So, you must talk to the residents to find out Greg’s whereabouts which leads to side-quests involving delivering one thing or another. It is a laid back experience throughout as you explore the land, find small treasures, and get acquainted with the animals. The controls are mostly fine, but the double jump can take a bit of getting used to. The only major complaint I have is that there is far too much dialogue and it is not interesting enough to really get me to read all of it. At 3 hours, it’s perfect to not get frustrating and short enough to get through in one lazy morning. 

Vividlope 

I’m actually not sure when I started this game because I’ve been slowly going through it. It’s a game that is easy to play but hard to master. The concept is simple: step on the tiles to turn the stage into the desired color. As you play along more rules apply and items are introduced, but that is the gist of it. I was happily cruising through this game until about level 6 when there is quite the jump in difficulty. This is not a complaint, it just made me realize there was more to this game and I needed to change my approach. Doing so made me focus more on the mechanics of the game and I came to appreciate a lot of small details. I’m still not done with this one, but it has some unique art and it is easy to pick up and play a short session. 

Once Upon a Katamari

I love the first two games so much that I did not have high expectations for this one. I have to admit that I had more fun than I thought. This feels more ‘game-y’ than previous entries with the addition of power-ups, collectable crowns, and more focus on high-scores. That isn’t a bad thing at all, but it was a notable change for me. I ended up really appreciating the crowns as they made me spend more time in the level and looking around the environment. There were less eras than I expected but I was glad at how varied they were. As usual, the game is full of humor and some of the challenges are great because of it (especially enjoyed finding the philosophers). I don’t think anything will ever match my excitement for the first 2 entries, but I think this is a neat addition to the series. 


r/patientgamers • • 3d ago

Game Design Talk Dying Light: Holler the horrible bossfight Spoiler

46 Upvotes

I need to talk about Holler. If you want a review of Dying Light: The Following, here is it: it’s good.

I like the world. I like the story. I like the game play. Do yourself a favor and play it if you get a chance as it’s a fun take on the zombie genre and has good parkour mechanics.

With that being said, I need to talk about the scructure of a boss fight in a DLC area. As I was running through the rurual countryside, a boss health bar popped up at the top of the screen. This was curious to me as there did not appear to be any NPCs around me that would carry that level of importance.

To find the boss, labelled Holler, I walked backwards until the health bar disappeared. From that point, I could triangulate where the boss was based on the radius of where the health bar does and does not appear. Using this, I found a little shanty in the middle of nowhere.

In the courtyard of this tiny homestead bumbled a massive Demolisher archetype with extra armor plating. Excited to face a new foe, I lept into the courtyard and was one tapped.

I realized I was not prepared to deal with this monster right now, and instead finished the DLC at my leisure. Once that was finished, I got the best gear in the game including legendary weapons and pristine firearms hidden away in caches.

Returning to Holler, I fired all of my ammo at him, only to barely take a sliver of his health. I then jumped down to engage in melee combat with him, only to once again be instantly killed.

Frustrated, I looked up a walkthrough, only to find Screen Rant's only hope being to cower behind cover while Holler throws a rock at you and then attacking him at range while he is in a stunned animation.

Alright, I thought. Fair enough.

I loaded up again, fired all my bullets, then proceeded to loose my entire quiver into his skull.

I barely scratched him.

Over the course of the next hour, through sweaty palms I crafted arrow after arrow to impale Holler during miniscule windows of oppurtunity. With massive stones flying overhead, I continue to run out of arrows and craft more on the fly. I use all of gadgets and throwables I had collected through the game. I set him on fire, have explosives detonate and put every knife I have into his eye sockets.

Everything I had to my name I used against him, and he still had over half his health left.

Are you kidding me? I have been cowering on a balcony painstakingly listening for the boulder to be thrown, launched every resource at my disposal, and still this guy is standing?

Conceptually, I'm fine with a bossfight just being a regular enemy with more health. But this is ridiculous. This random in the middle of nowhere is stronger than any other enemy in the game by far.

And is this how the fight was playtested to be won? I can't imagine the designed route was to perfectly dodge every attack in melee for 8 hours while you flick Holler's health down point by point.

In the end, Holler died and I uninstalled the game.


r/patientgamers • • 4d ago

Patient Review Fallout 2: Tale of a lowly gutter scum Spoiler

27 Upvotes

This was my first Fallout game in the ancient era of 2015. I really liked how open it was, so I keep returning to it every once in a while. About 3 years ago I did a dummy run, which was almost like a challenge run in a sense. This time I went with an evil dude with as little looking up info as possible

I called myself Poindexter, to reflect on my combat strategy. My special stats were S5 P6 E2 C2 I5 A8 L10, tagged skills small guns, energy weapons, as well as lockpick. My traits were Finesse and Jinxed, for maximum crits in every sense. This high precision setup was specifically to shoot people into eyes and balls for maximum pain per shot.

The temple of trials was relatively easy on experience alone, even though my build was not build for it. I told Hakunin and tribal boy to get lose before leaving the Arroyo. In Klamath, I helped jerkey bros dupe the idiot Torr and used all the money I gathered to free Sulik. Upon arriving to the Den, I sold off Sulik and instigated a gang war, only to betray my first employee at the last second. My next move was to join slaver guild. Objectively it's terrible in the long run, but I had to commit to the bit. Metzger's money let me buy out Vic and take him with me. I knew I could pawn my new minion in the Vault City, but I chose not to. His equip load and repair skills were quite useful. I guess you can rationalize it as my character having a soft spot. I made sure to remove the stealing kids from the streets, since it was a perfect excuse.

My stay in Vault City and Gecko was quite brief. I "fixed" the ghoul's power plant and didn't get the citizenship for some reason. Oh well, I still got directions to go from a nearby trader. Since I destroyed Nixon toy and had no wrench, the only way to get the car part for me was to kill the ghoul mechanic and employ the secret Joestar technique.

Abbey (I played on Restoration Project) was very simple. I went to the basement and slayed the Deathlcaw as a level 5 goon. How? With the power of save scumming and random crits, of course. After a good shot to the eyes, it went blind and switched to permanent flight mode. The Abbey computer did not have useful data, so I formatted it and made a run for it.

On the way back to Den I sparked a war between Modoc and Ghost farm. It was hard to stay alive but I managed to help Modoc citizens "win". That guy's kid died in a crossfire btw. The Den mechanic installed everything for me, and then I spared him by only stealing my thosands of dollars back.

My butt was pretty damn underpowered due to avoiding all the good behavior quests and actions. I decided to make life easier with a simple plan.

Step 1: Make a beeline to New Reno to steal electrnic lockpick.

Step 2: Someone steals your car (???) Get it back somehow

Step 3: Return to Klamath and accept the lost trapper quest.

Step 4: Open the electronic lock in the toxic caves to procure laser pistols and combat armor. Profit! And make sure you don't rescue Mr Smiley.

Redding quest for Wanamingos was still too hard, and I couldn't make progress with New Reno families. In the wasteland, I randomly met a traveller who unlocked Military Base on the map, which also contains location of San Francisco. Might as well get as OP as possible to freely be evil.

The car combined with motion sensor made dodging Enclave Patrols trivial, so I reached Navarro with no issues. I had to do some shooting in the lower levels to get the tanker key (no speech skill), but everyone there had energy weapons. Tesla armor I bought was even better at negating them than even power armor.

After returning to SF, I joined hubologists. I killed Badger for them with reverse pickpocketing, then broke Shi's Claude and had to kill people on streets. ASH-9 told me to piss off, but strangely he helped me fuel the tanker when I got dumber. I guess there was a more elegant solution.

Back to New Reno, I couldn't work with Wrights due to their anti-slaver bigotry, with Bishop I forgot how to start his quests, Sal's quest I was too dumb or perhaps unconvincing. I finished Mordino's quesline but he didn't give me Made Man trophy. At least I still had Berserker from somewhere.

I finally slayed aliens in Redding, and at this point I maxed my 3 tagged skills. Rest went to science for reasons I'll explain later. In Broken Hills I played against a scorpion and helped the anti mutant conspiracy. My grandpa must be proud.

NCR only had a few quests for the slaver, and they weren't very interesting. In Vault 15 I had to get good karma by killing dudes who stood between me and location of vault 13. Damn it, I worked hard on that "Hellspawn" title! The opposite was in vault 13, where racist Deathclaw didn't let me in due to my smell. The last thing he smelled was an pulse blast in his dick!

After getting the GECK, I picked "mysterious stranger" perk for the first time in my life. He was not worth it but that's ok. For some reason, I had 3 special encounters after this point in game than zero before it. Maybe main quest progression triggered something. There were unwashed villagers killing a spammer, giant statue of a head, and crashed whale. At least the Kaga encounter felt appropriate, and I killed him. The only time I actually wanted MS and he didn't come to help.

Tanker was the regular routine with overdosing the president and exploding the reactor. My final fight with Horrigan was super tough. I had very little hp on level 18 even with power armor and drugs. TIL game actually stores more than 99 skill points, so you can hoard more than a hundred at once. I used all my spare skill points on science and speech to get robots and soldiers on my side. Could I have won with less help? Maybe, I was able to solo Frank as moron years ago, but at least he was unable to consistently kill me in one turn back then. So we jumping that mutie.

Ending slides showed how miserable almost everyone was in the end, thanks to me! Only NCR was doing kinda fine, and New Reno since I was almost uninvolved, and there was a forced good ending for Arroyo. Since even Elder said I was worse than Enclave devils, I wish there was an exile ending in this game as well.

This was fun, although I kind of cheated by getting OP super early. In this game, evil does not pay.


r/patientgamers • • 4d ago

Patient Review GoldenEye 007 – A Golden Oldie

62 Upvotes

Growing up in the 90s, the N64 was the console on which I first got into video games. For me that meant classics like Ocarina of Time, oddballs like Space Station Silicon Valley, and endless rounds of multiplayer on GoldenEye. Given the heavy nostalgia, I was a bit wary to pick it up again after so many years, but with the new recompilation out on PC I thought I’d give it a go. The good news is that it’s still really good… like, really good. So good that this review is mostly me gushing about it, but I’ll try to put some weaknesses at the end.

My first impression was how fast and fluid it is. This is not a game that aims for realism or carefully stalking your foe. You are much better off dashing between cover, leaping out to ambush enemies, and taking advantage of the auto-aim to down five guards in the blink of an eye – it’s all very James Bond! The enemies themselves are pretty dumb and inaccurate, but there are lots of them – again, exactly the sort of thing to make you feel like 007. Their animations are undeniably dated (weird bunny hops etc.), but for me this adds to the charm, particularly when they idle by swatting at flies or when their death animation doesn’t play until they finish a sideways roll. As this hints, there is some jank here for sure – enemies can shoot you through each other, but you can’t do the same, meanwhile enemies won’t shoot at you over railings, but can take damage through them – but you get used to it and if anything, having to hide while a death animation plays just encourages you to use cover more strategically. Strafe-running to go at 141% speed is a classic trick too.

Its other great strength is variety. The roughly 20 levels span varied environments and fall into different archetypes (rescue, stealth, corridor shooting, exploring wilderness, driving a tank) and the devs really got creative with the source material. Some levels feel very grounded, while others (Statue, Jungle) have a bizarre, hallucinatory feel to them. There’s great variety of guns too. They all feel and sound different and you quickly learn their strengths and weaknesses (the klobb being utterly without merit). The music is fun, all level-specific variations on the traditional Bond theme. Kinda hammy, and it’s all MIDI, but it works.

The game has great progression too. Agent difficulty is trivial, but by 00 Agent it is seriously tricky, and some levels (first two carriages of Train, Bunker 2 defending Natalya, Aztec’s opening) are truly difficult and demand some practice. The thing I liked the most is that the objectives are given to the player without detailed info (just briefings in the persona of M, Q and Miss Moneypenny) and it’s up to you to figure it out. This means your first run through of a level might take 20 or even 30 minutes, but once you have it down you can blitz through – which is necessary if you want to unlock all the secrets. Completing Facility on 00 Agent in under 2:05 requires absolute optimization of your route through the level.

Occasionally the difficulty can feel a bit punishing. Enemies can stun lock you with burst fire, which on the harder difficulties can cost almost all your health, and some levels are probably too cryptic (floor tile puzzle in Egypt being the most obvious example). But in general, the difficulty feels fair. The reward for this is a whole lot of unlockables; two bonus levels, about 20 “cheats” that change the rules of the game (invincibility, different guns, big heads, turbo, paintball mode etc.) and ultimately 007 mode that lets you configure the difficulty to your taste. It’s kinda amazing how much is packed in here.

Its one big weak spot is the dated controls, but the recomp allows KBM controls that feel entirely modern. This probably does make the game easier, but certainly not enough to trivialize it – it just makes 00 Agent mode and the harder unlocks a bit more manageable.

It’s kinda wild to say this, and maybe it is the nostalgia speaking, but Goldeneye still feels like a really excellent game. Even if it was released today (as a retro, PS1-style, indie shooter), I still think people would find it to be a whole lot of fun. The retro charm, the slightly cheesy character, the variety, the laser-focus on ultra-tight gameplay, it all still shines through 30 years later.


r/patientgamers • • 4d ago

Patient Review I'm Not Sure If I Like Assassin's Creed Valhalla

83 Upvotes

I recently played Odyssey, which you can read more about here. In short, I liked Odyssey a hell of a lot more than I expected to. I played Valhalla shortly after, and I’ve got some very strong mixed feelings I’d like to ramble about. I really like a lot about the game, while a lot of it made me mildly uncomfortable.

Valhalla takes place during the Viking raids on England during the middle ages. You play as Eivor, a viking who is especially good at hurting people. I picked Boy-vor, though I do appreciate the ability to freely swap between genders. You start in Norway, and go to a surprising number of areas around the map during your travels. I continually found myself impressed by the number of new areas and amount of content this game has. For perspective, I’m about 150 hours in, still haven’t finished the story, and haven't even seen the third DLC yet.

The elephant in the room is the “bloat” complaint. Every time this game comes up, I always see people say “there’s just too much stuff”. I think I’m completely immune to that, for perspective, my favorite game of all time is Yakuza 5, which has this same complaint levied at it. I approached both of these games by playing them in “chunks”. I find myself leaving and returning to the game often. Not related, but my inbetween games for Valhalla have been Persona 4, Etrian Odyssey, and For Honor. I can see why one might get burnt out if it’s the main game you’re playing, which is why I think it’s important (especially as a trophy hunter) to take stock of whether or not you’re having fun periodically. The AC RPG games are very excellent games to play for a few hours on the weekend, but not so great to play for hours on end daily for a few months.

Combat, Gameplay, and the “Loop”
The actual combat is quite improved. In Odyssey, I often felt very squishy and wanted to avoid combat at all costs. In Valhalla, you’re sort of expected to be doing head-on combat more often. It’s mostly light attack, heavy attack, parry, but attacks feel weighty, enemies react accordingly, and you don’t feel like your armor is paper. As the monkey paw curls, the stealth is quite a bit worse despite sounding better on paper. You’re able to put your hood up to initiate “social stealth”, like the old games, but often you can’t really do anything besides pick off stragglers from behind. There’s no double assassination (though you chain an axe throw, which only works if your first attack isn’t spotted), and you have no cool abilities like Odyssey to let you deal with groups or take out whole areas. Stealth is fun as a concept, but there’s so many barriers you really need to go out of your way to do it.

Progression is a bit different than Odyssey as well, gone are the oceans of loot to sort through (ironic, considering you’re a viking raider). Instead, you get relatively few weapons that you’re expected to upgrade. A benefit of this is that it’s far more exciting to find gear since it's something completely new to you. However, it leads to the Dark Souls problem of “oh hey a new weapon!” that you suddenly realize you can’t use because you don’t have the crafting materials to make it as strong as the sword you’ve been using for the past 40 hours. I think a problem I had early on is that it took quite a while to get my second armor set, so I didn’t feel like I was very customized, I was just “default viking guy” until like 20 hours in. This feeling disappears later on once you’re swimming in outfits, but it takes a bit to get to that point.

That brings me to the collectibles and exploration. I do generally enjoy hoovering up all the little markers on the map, and this game has a lot of them. Of course there’s the generic collectibles, like “chest full of crafting material that became irrelevant hours ago”. Don’t get me started on circling a building 15 times to find an open window or barred door. They present the collectibles in a clever way so that you don’t know what kind of thing it is, besides a broad color to designate “collectible, activity, or other collectible”. Generally I like the variety, some particular favorite activities include stacking rocks on a cliff, maps with clues that lead to treasure, and the occasional surprise bossfight.

The Uncomfortable Setting and Tone
Norway starts amazing - you’re in this beautiful scenic snowy area, challenging rival viking clans with a deep-seated grudge, and then all of that’s resolved like an hour into the prologue. You kill the guy who killed your father, and, for lack of anywhere for the plot to go, head to England. As a literal map, England is just fine, it’s not a super exciting setting, and I won’t pretend anything is particularly memorable, but it works. For every beautiful sweeping landscape of hills and forests you get two craggy beaches and a swamp. I do like the roman ruins dotted across the map, and the Northern part of the map is a highlight.

Tone-wise, everything takes a bit of an uncomfortable turn after Norway. I’m unsure if you guys are big history buffs or not but the Viking “immigration” to England wasn’t particularly pleasant for the Anglo-Saxons living there. Of course, we’re one of the “good ones”, but the game seems to flip-flop between us being a remorseless Viking raider or a sensitive beacon of light for the downtrodden, a bridge between cultures. Some arcs have us accompanying violent psychopaths who execute praying monks and torturing people begging for their lives before watching an ally do a blood eagle on an enemy who we had just made peace with, while Eivor, at best, scoffs at his contemporaries's violence despite actively enabling it. Other arcs have Eivor act as if his people are unfairly prejudiced against as he stops infighting between Norse and Saxon cultures. It’s a bit jarring, to say the least. They have us act as an unapologetic bad guy but then the narrative treats us like a good guy, and it goes pretty much unaddressed.

I think the most upsetting repeated gameplay section is the monastery raids. I think even just a thin narrative justification, like, “Oh, these monasteries are actually disguised bad guy bases!”, would help me a lot. As it stands we’re just cutting down innocent soldiers defending their place of worship while we torch the nearby homes and loot. I think I just have to emotionally check out during these sections. I tend to empathize with an RPG character I spend 100 hours inhabiting, so it makes me uncomfortable that the game is so gung-ho about something it spends other times being dead serious about.

I suppose that brings me to the rest of the tone and setting. I don’t mind a game being a bit serious, but nothing good ever happens to anyone in Valhalla. It’s reminiscent of the miserable swampy Velen in the Witcher 3, or war-torn Tsushima in Ghost of Tsushima (both of which I found exhausting - at least you leave Velen at some point). ⅔ of the time there’s a side quest with a peasant, prepare to watch them meet a gritty end or tell you about someone else who did. The other ⅓ accounts for out of place silliness. The setting is so miserable and the people who bear the brunt of the suffering are the ordinary people who live there. To make matters worse, as viking invaders, oftentimes we’re part of the problem. It makes the game a bit depressing after a while.

It’s not all horrible all the time though. I liked the stuff when we were helping solve problems the natives were having, like succession crises and clearing a city of the obligatory not-yet-Templars. I liked the big raid towards the end with all your allies you’ve made along the way joining you, and updating you on what has happened since you last met. I also really liked the uneasy air whenever a certain character returned after a long absence. I’m fairly close to the end of the story at the moment, and it’s sort of feeling like a high point.

Other relatively minor complaints I haven’t addressed
Most of the arcs, at least 80% of them, are fairly generic. It’s mostly just “solve problems in one region and leave”. Characters mostly come up and introduce themselves as being your allies and then they’re the primary quest giver for the next little bit. There also seems to be fewer decisions than Odyssey, sometimes I’ll finish a quest and google to see what would’ve happened otherwise and it just says “the outcomes are pretty much the same”. There are much fewer traditional sidequests, what’s left are more like collectibles where you solve a problem in under a minute and leave. No longer are there any globe-trotting sidequests like in Odyssey.

One last thing that annoyed me more than it should is that all of the haircut options are forced to have that stupid half-shaved head. Why give us a cosmetic option if they’re 80% the same? I went with a full-shave just to look normal

In short, I think I like the game, but there’s a lot that makes me uneasy. The gameplay is completely serviceable and fun at times, and the plentiful stuff to hoover up around the map feels designed for a player like me. However, my experience was particularly hampered by the severe disconnect between me and Eivor, namely the violence and cruelty that Eivor causes or allows, while the game treats us like a “generic RPG good guy”.


r/patientgamers • • 4d ago

Patient Review Paeon, stile, yagi? "Letter Quest: Grimm's Journey" loves you if you love word games.

10 Upvotes

Letter Quest: Grimm's Journey (LQ) is a game released in 2014, and now available on Steam, Xbox and iPad. The Remaster was released in 2015, to which the Endless mode was added, but nothing much has changed except that from what I hear.

The core gameplay is simple: You'll be handed 15 random tiles with a letter on each, and make a word from them. (pic, see also the example below) LQ is somewhat an RPG, in which you fight monsters constructing words.

XYUAD
NTECU
ROEPV

Probably such an idea is very old. However this game is built well and balances are well adjusted, and I really enjoyed LQ although its QoL is not excellent. This game is easy and relaxing, and won't test you. It took me 11 hours to beat the final boss. I didn't do much in postgame.

I received this game as freebie at Fanatical.com.

Contents:

  • More about core loop
  • About its dictionary
  • More challenges
  • Audiences and final thoughts
  • Appendix: Words I used

More about core loop

This game has tens of stages. Each stage has 1-5 fixed monsters. Combats are turn based, and you always act first.

Each letter has points. (J, Q, Z have three, B, H, W etc have two, the rest are one.) I guess the total points of the word determines your attack value. Used tiles are replaced with random new tiles. Attacks have a random multiplier. Monsters attack you too, which is purely numerical and not related to a word.

# Being turn based means longer words are better in general, like brace → braced → embraced.

Some tiles have a special effect, like attack/defense boost, heal, etc. Monsters can harm your tiles, giving negative effects.

If you beat all monsters in a stage, the next stage(s) will be unlocked. You gain money on various occasions. (Beat a monster, a stage, achieve something and so on.)

You can purchase various upgrades and healing items, adding some RPG flavor.

You can also receive an entire new set of 15 letters consuming your turn.

About its dictionary

You can't attack if it doesn't make a valid word. When it's a valid word the letters glow so that you know it. There's no penalty of making an invalid word. So you can freely try any spelling even if you're unsure.

One- or two-letter words are not accepted. Like many other word games, proper nouns are excluded. Of course. Acronyms are excluded too. (But shouldn't "lan" be accepted today?)

# But the game accepted "iowa" and "maine". There was a middle English legacy variant of "main", but it must mean "Maine". :(

# And for an unknown reason "piss" isn't in its vocabulary. "arse" was accepted.

Some word game players are unforgivingly strict and nitpick Serious competitors in word games love to be precise about the vocabulary, so I mentioned this topic. ;)

More challenges

Each stage has four modes: The basic, time trial, challenging and super-strong, if I dare name them. Some bosses in the basic mode and these challenging modes have some special conditions, like "quintuple damage from words containing Q" or "beat the stage with 10 words at most".

There's also the endless mode, in which you fight infinite monsters until you die. There's shops after fighting monsters so that you can buy items.

Audiences and final thoughts

Some people think LQ is more for kids. If they mean LQ will help to expand vocabulary, I do not necessarily agree. In particular it's rare to construct longer words due to the limitation coming from the tile availability. (I'm an ESL and I learned many words that are almost useless in real life from LQ.) Rather I recommend it to those who like puzzles/games like scrabble or sudoku. You think (or quickly in the time trial mode) and recognize which tiles make a word, and try. However as I already stated, this game should be understood to be easy and relaxing. It might not satisfy serious word game lovers. (The appendix below will show that I stashed random spellings into LQ rather than looking up my mental dictionary.)

Despite its simplicity this game was surprisingly addictive and relaxing for me.

Unfortunately LQ crashes too often at the (Unity) splash screen. However no one seems to complain about this, so this seems specific to me.

Appendix: Words I used

shieling and stile, tass, hexer, quare (queer variant of queer), jole, fay.

technical terms: howe (not Howe), puna, pilea, zoa, fila, plie (= plié! You don't write naïve today!!)

Possibly useful? : fuze, swarf, shim, chuff

paeon: I was about to type peony but there wasn't a "y" tile. Then I thought of this. Probably most Cambridge students knew it in 1970 but an LLM said many native English speakers don't know this word any more.

# At that moment I thought "paeon" is related to "penult" but I was terribly wrong. Penult is paene + ultimus which is originally a pure Latin, and paene is an adverb meaning "almost". Paeon came from Latin, but its origin is in fact Greek, and it was a poetry term from the beginning.

coyer: More coy, of course.

I doubt if they're English: vox, ama

dota: What!? DOTA?? (I instead recommend doat, which is undisputably valid.)

shiva: Not Shiva, a proper noun of Hinduism

hazes: Isn't it uncountable? Then I noticed it's also a verb.

Informal words that ESLs aren't required to know: doss, jeez, fib.

ibid: This game doesn't accept this. Supercalifragilisticexpialidociously nonsensical. ٩( 💢•̀ з•́)و

vaze: Again why isn't this legit? This is the British variant of "vaze"... ¡madre mía! This is a borrowed word from French "vase" and in Britain it's pronounced like French, but the spelling is the same as North American. XD

embrio: Why isn't it valid...my bad it's embryo. I was in hurry. :p

I'm glad I discovered creepier, nitrogens, hopping, aliener and juvenile.

Didn't know but I should: vide, quid, qua, veer, fiver, trop (for "de trop"), fave (I always spell "fav").

I've forgotten for decades: ewe, ewer, cubit


r/patientgamers • • 4d ago

Patient Review Barony - The Good, The Bad, The Questionable

65 Upvotes

Barony is a first person roguelike RPG developed by Turning Wheel LLC. Released in 2015, Barony reminds us that I need to stop making friends with people who only play co-op farming sims.

We play as a hero of the small town of Hamlet on a quest to defeat the vile lich Baron Herx and his minions before they can escape the nearby mine and conquer the land.

Gameplay involves dying on the first floor, then dying on the second floor, then dying on the third floor, then dying on the first floor again, then dying on the fifth floor, then recruiting your friends to play and everyone dies on the first floor.


The Good

As a roguelike meant to punish you, it does the job well. I have never heard my friends swear so much. Barony manages to illicit such a primal frustration rage that is simultaneously maddening but also joy inducing. Every so often I like to play a game that makes me resent it, just to set a baseline as to what in life is worth being mad about.

I appreciate the variety in the ways you can die. If the only thing you ever died to was a mob hitting you it'd get old quick. Fortunately you can also get crushed by a boulder, choke on a cream pie, burn yourself drinking from a fountain, get crushed by a boulder, get teleported into lava, get crushed by a boulder...all kinds of ways to die! Did I mention getting crushed by a fucking boulder?


Favorite Screenshot

https://i.imgur.com/Kv8Sp4L.png

Zap brigade did not fare well against the trolls. Oh well...more food for me.


The Bad

I hope you're on good terms with our Lord and Savior RNGesus. I'm sure there are some sweaty nerds out there who can win every single run. I, a mere mortal, am at the mercy of a system that sees I'm going for a ranged build and offers me nothing but rocks as I slowly bleed out over 4 floors.

I get the idea is you need to be able to adapt but at least work with me here. It doesn't help that there's a durability system as well. RNG -and- items having durability is just a one-two-fuck-you punch.

I don't mind dying because I wasn't paying attention or took unnecessary risks. Dying because RNG thinks it's funny to see how many floors I can go as a wizard without getting a single spell book? Yeah, screw you too buddy.


The Questionable

The late game felt kind of lame compared to the early game. Maybe it's because at some point you switch from "See how far you can go!" to "We might actually win this one..." mode. You start to take things more slowly and it sucks the joy out of the experience. It's less lock in and be serious and more cheese the hell out of single pulls and pathing.

It reminds me of 4x strategy games where the best part is the first hour or so when things are fresh and new and there's lots to discover. Then you reach an apex point where you know you're going to win, it's just do you care enough to keep going or would you rather reset and do the fun bit again?

We beat it once just to say we did it, then went back to screwing around with the race/class combos and doing silly things like seeing how deep we could get without killing.


Final Thoughts

It was a good way to waste a few weekends with friends. I did try playing it solo but dying alone simply isn't as fun. Watching others die hilarious deaths is the true experience here.


Bonus Thought

There's a nude mod. Of course there's a nude mod. Why wouldn't there be?


Thank you for reading! I try to post a new discussion every Tuesday morning for your reading pleasure. I'd love to hear your thoughts as well! What did you think of the game? Do you agree with my take or am I off my rocker again?

My other reviews on patient gaming


r/patientgamers • • 4d ago

Patient Review Call of Juaraz series

47 Upvotes

After years and years I finally restarted the Call of Juarez series via Steam. Notably the last game Gunslinger on my MSI Claw. I loved these games as a teen and I got it on sale for like a few euros, totally worth it.

It really holds up well, the storytelling is quite unique. The protagonist narrates in real time while you playing the game as he tells the story in a saloon. Whenever he exaggerates or gets a detail wrong, the level actually rewinds and changes on the spot.

It just has that vibe you don’t really get anymore in modern games. It reminds me a bit of action movies like Lock Stock and Two Smoking Barrels, RocknRolla, Zombieland. Where the whole plot is based around an unreliable narrator.

You have a basic skill tree, fast paced action that you can jump right in to. Proper blast from the past.

Anyone remember playing this series? I know it wasn’t super popular back so curious about your experiences.


r/patientgamers • • 5d ago

Patient Review Dispatch: This is the Avengers

45 Upvotes

I heard plenty of good things about Dispatch from several guys on Youtube, and the gameplay sold it to me. I'm a fan of This is the Police 1+2, so getting something similar was nice. I actually played this game in December 2025 and wrote this text back then. Sorry for impatience.

At first I tried to play with QTE but then I turned them off before Chapter 1. The game picked up for me in Chapter 2 with the first shift and all the wacky characters. Gameplay wise (comprared to Police) I liked how dispatched units were actual characters and not some abstract chess pieces, but I wish there was on option to ignore stupid calls like standing in line. I cut Sonar in Chapter 3 because his stat swaps were annoying, then replaced him with Phenomenal Man because I was hoping for good stats. His depression was a pain in my neck but at least he was pretty funny. Throughout all this time, I like BB because she was a honest and kind woman, and Visi was just very annoying. I ended up cutting her in Chapter 7 at the team's insistence, then didn't trust her in Chapter 8. She became a villain and I couldn't decide Shroud's fate. At least I let Sonar back now that the shitshow was over.

The second run was mostly just to see the other options. Sonar was still annoying in dispatching but his Strong Back was nice. Makes we wonder why other flying heroes can't also carry people. *Cough* Phenomenal *Cough*. Waterboy was less obnoxious with his gimmick but his low stats meant I could really only make him good in 1 area. I supported Visi and saw that she really needed validation from Robert, but her terrible past made it hard for her to properly convey her feelings. Coop looked way more villainous as a mini boss.

Third run was mostly just for achievements. I noticed how some perks were way better than others. Prism's perfect clone let me beat the final battle with just her and BB, Golem's copies made him a one man army in some cases, and Punch Up's squeeze could come in clutch for 1 unit calls. I think for both Waterboy and Phenomaman the perks that remove their silly quirks are the better ones, especially for Chapter 8 when you need to be in full control of the situation. I wish we had more gameplay with all these hero gimmicks. All in all, I'd still take Coop and Phenomaman because I think they need Robert's help the most.

For now, I will eagerly await the second season. 2-3 years should be enough, right?


r/patientgamers • • 6d ago

Bi-Weekly Thread for general gaming discussion. Backlog, advice, recommendations, rants and more! New? Start here!

56 Upvotes

Welcome to the Bi-Weekly Thread!

Here you can share anything that might not warrant a post of its own or might otherwise be against posting rules. Tell us what you're playing this week. Feel free to ask for recommendations, talk about your backlog, commiserate about your lost passion for games. Vent about bad games, gush about good games. You can even mention newer games if you like!

The no advertising rule is still in effect here.

A reminder to please be kind to others. It's okay to disagree with people or have even have a bad hot take. It's not okay to be mean about it.


r/patientgamers • • 6d ago

Patient Review Anno 117 - great game

131 Upvotes

For some context out of all the genres I would say I am a fan of I think city/colony builders are at the very bottom. While I like them they are one of the few types I play casually on easier difficulties and I just build the entire tech tree once and I am done with that. Not that interested in building the most perfect and most efficient city. And this was my second Anno game with me playing 1800 fairly recently.

I really loved this game and it is currently on sale if you are interested. It is very similar to 1800, but the changes are all positive.

To start with the similar things: what I loved is the casual nature of the game on the normal difficulty. If you are failing at developing something or meeting the demands of your citizens your progress stalls instead of regressing or snowballing into more disasters so you cannot recover. They also added active pause which the previous game did not have.

I really enjoyed their balance between simulation and it more leans toward just being an abstract representation and it feels great how your settlements and empire develops. It feels very natural how you start small, need to expand first on the island, than to other island to other resources and then to other region to keep feeding your growing capital that grows more and more developed and needs help from outside to feed the more advanced products and population.

Game is nice on a technical level. Bug free, nice intuitive ui, looks and runs good.

To start with the changes the biggest one is the setting and Rome is much more interesting in my opinion.

Aqueducts replace electricity and function similarly. A lot of small items and expeditions are entirely removed which is for the best. It was too annoying to micro. A tech tree is added which is always fun. The games at the Colloseum are expanded compared to The World Faire and combined with tourism. And one of the biggest changes is that they actually added positive effects to a lot of production buildings so you are incentivized to place them inside your residential areas instead of always just far away. And they are generally smaller, but various service buildings are much larger and look awesome.