r/pokemonconspiracies • u/The_Omnidexx • 4h ago
Gen 1 A New Kanto War/Surge Theory
I have a theory on Lt. Surge's war that I haven't heard anyone mention before and wanted some thoughts on it.
From what we know, Lt. Surge is a US soldier who fought in a war now living in Kanto, which means somehow Kanto and the US/a US region were involved in said war. Now we know it can't be WW2 as Surge is around 30, meaning he's far too young for it to have been WW2, and if it's not WW2 then Kanto and the US were likely allies in this conflict, not enemies.
Some people suggest it was a war between Johto and Kanto, given they share a league, but if that's the case why would the US/US region get involved? Also, while this may be considered retconned now, in the Sinnoh games professor Oak says "Ah, <player>! This is it! This is Pal Park! Pokémon from around the country can be brought here. In other words, Pokémon from places like Kanto and Hoenn. This place also happens to be where you compete to see how quickly you can catch those Pokémon!" Now this suggests both Kanto and Johto are already apart of some bigger country that is likely just all of Japan. Assuming this is still canon, it wouldn't make sense for Johto to be fighting off Kanto, as that would mean it has to fight all of the Japanese regions too.
With the notion of Japan being a country, and each province simply being a region, I came up with a new idea - what if the war was apart of the cold war - but without nuclear weapons existing the cold war ended up getting hot. A war broke out between the east and the west, and Japan got dragged in. Together the US and Japan launched an invasion into Russia through the east but could break through Siberia, and there is one line of dialogue that strongly involves Russia in a war.
In the gen 1 games and their remakes, if you go to the Silph Co. Building there is a trainer named Scientist Taylor who states that they have a branch in Tiksi (Russia) and it's located "in Russian no-man's-land."
No man's land is an unowned, uninhabited, or disputed area of land that belongs to no single authority or side. It is perhaps most well known as the middle ground between two sides during the first world war, which really leads me to speculate...why would they choose this wording? Was there a conflict with Russia/a Russian region? Russia and Japan do have a history of competing over territory, especially the Sakhalin island, an island right above Hokaido/Sinnoh.
Another, smaller and less interesting theory I had was this "war" was never a real war, but a figurative war for Kanto's war on crime against team rocket. The only issue I have with this theory is that it doesn't make sense with why a US soldier wearing fatigues would be fighting, unless they needed professional trainers or something.
Either way, what are some thoughts on this theory?