In nitpicking the contract with organizers, our city councilors squandered something special.
I almost bought the T-shirt.
If the Back Cove Music & Arts Festival was only going to happen once — as I assumed it would in the lead-up to the event two Augusts ago — I remember thinking I might want to have something to commemorate the experience.
I didn’t particularly like the shirt design, though, and already was struggling to accept the $17 price tag on the giant White Claws being sold at the concession stands. Plus, by the time I got a look at the merch, I felt the festival was running smoothly, making its return seem more likely.
As I left Payson Park that Saturday night, after watching headliner Lord Huron play in front of Portland’s moonlit skyline, I was sure the festival would be back and that I would be, too.
With the announcement Tuesday that the festival won’t return, I’m having some Marden’s-style nonbuyer’s remorse about the shirt. Mostly, though, I’m disappointed that I won’t get to go again. And I’m perturbed that such a promising event met its end for seemingly preventable reasons.
RelatedOrganizers cancel Portland’s Back Cove Music Festival — this time for good
To make the event financially viable, the festival’s organizers said its capacity would need to increase from 12,500 to 15,000 people. The city said it wasn’t likely to approve that change; the inaugural festival didn’t even reach the previously agreed-upon limit, with about 12,000 people attending each of the two days, according to organizers.
Advertisement
Based on the lack of lines and low-key nature of the festival, it seemed to me as though the park could handle the extra bodies — something the city might have been able to better evaluate, had the event been held this year.
That’s where the real issue lies.
People were skeptical at first, understandably, and not necessarily willing to risk $137 a day on an unproven concept (especially if they weren’t overly excited about the lineup, which included Jack White, Lucy Dacus and, originally, André 3000, who dropped out and was replaced by The Roots).
With the rave reviews this festival received, though, I have little doubt the following year would have been a sell-out event.
We didn’t have a chance to find out because the council’s Housing and Economic Development Committee spent too much time last fall scrutinizing the festival’s contract. As a result, organizers determined in January — as they had warned previously — that there wasn’t enough time left to pull off the event in 2026.
Mind you, there were no major problems with the three-year contract under consideration. Festival organizers agreed to give the city an increasing cut of ticket sales (up to $2 each) and pay $100,000 annually to the Portland Parks Conservancy. Money from the first event has gone toward traffic-calming measures in Payson Park, including new bike lanes and speed bumps.
Changes made during the extended deliberations included increasing the noise deposit, from $1,000 to $5,000, and requiring council approval to transfer the festival agreement to another entity. There was nothing here worth thwarting what should have been a hallmark annual event for the city.
In the long run, the cancellation of this year’s festival might not have made a difference. The weekend could have been a washout, leaving the park torn up and attendees disappointed. A different lineup of artists could have brought out a more disruptive crowd, enraging the neighborhood. For any number of reasons, the city might never have approved the increased capacity. With all that said, a second festival would have given officials a better idea of what was feasible.
When the council committee ultimately approved the three-year contract, outgoing Councilor Kate Sykes still wasn’t satisfied that the city was getting enough out of the agreement. Now, all we’re left with are memories. And a few new speed bumps.
Leslie Bridgers - Columnist