r/PubTips • • 20d ago

Series [series] Check-in: November 2026

63 Upvotes

Happy extra hour of sleep for everyone who celebrates! Tell us what you accomplished last month and what you are up to this month. Do people still do not-NaNoWriMo these days? Or have we found a different way to torture ourselves as the days grow darker and the chilling kiss of mother nature reminds us that death comes for us all?

Ha ha! Watch out for flu season.


r/PubTips • • 25d ago

Discussion [Discussion] Where Would You Stop Reading? #9

69 Upvotes

It's time for round nine! I think. Don't quote me on that. It's been a while since we did this.

This thread is specifically for query feedback on where (if at all) an agency reader might stop reading a query, hit the reject button, and send a submission to the great wastepaper basket in the sky.

Despite the premise, this post is open to everyone. Agent, agency reader/intern, published author, agented author, regular poster, lurker, or person who visited this sub for the first time five minutes ago.

This thread exists outside of rule 9; if you’ve posted in the last 7 days, or plan to post within the next 7 days, you’re still permitted to share here.


If you'd like to participate, post your query below, including your age category, genre, and word count. Commenters are asked to call out what line would make them stop reading, if any. Explanations are welcome, but not required. While providing some feedback is fine, please reserve in-depth critique for individual QCrit post.

One query per poster per thread, please. Should you choose to share your work, you must respond to at least one other query.

If you see any rule-breaking, please use report function rather than engaging.

Have fun!


r/PubTips • • 5m ago

[QCrit] THE HOLLOW KEEPS ITS OWN (adult speculative cryptid horror, 83k words, 2nd attempt)

2 Upvotes

I only got one comment on my first attempt, but I made some adjustments based on that. Here's another version.

Dear agent,

Hettamiah Topher is infatuated with her best friend and she’s willing to give up her own life to have her.

I’m excited to send you THE HOLLOW KEEPS ITS OWN, a speculative, sapphic folk horror complete at 80,000 words. This work combines the dark, Appalachian atmosphere in Andrew Joseph White’s You Weren’t Meant To Be Human with a complicated and raw female lead like that of CJ Leede’s Maeve Fly.

Hettie, an awkward and forgettable young woman, has fallen in love with her best friend, Genie. The only problem is that Genie already has a partner, Judson. When Judson invites her into their relationship as a third, Hettie feels like she’s living her best life. Hettie ignores all of her own red flags and is willing to do whatever it takes to get what she wants. When locals begin to express their disapproval for this unconventional relationship, Hettie responds by isolating herself. She finds an abandoned mine and crawls deep inside of it, eager to make it her own sanctuary. As their relationship begins to fray, Hettie decides to take matters into her own hands, and give Genie everything she’s ever wanted — a baby, a husband, and the white picket fence.

While Hettie has the delusion that she is making decisions for Genie, she begins to confuse real life with the life she has made up in her own mind. She would do anything to make Genie happy. When questions about Hettie’s intentions get to be too much for her to bear, she knows exactly where to hide. Deep in the mine, despite what creatures she may find down there, she finds comfort under the ancient, Appalachian mountains.

Hettie, consumed by her love for Genie, isn’t sure if she wants her or wants to be her. She must act fast before anybody else realizes just how far she will go to get what she wants.

Short bio,

Thanks!


r/PubTips • • 2h ago

[Qcrit] Overdue (adult bookclub / uplit, 87,000) First attempt

3 Upvotes

Please save me from the bland meh my brain churns out the minute I try to write a query letter. I'm querying UK literary agents.

Thank you in advance.

Dear Agent,

[personalisation] Overdue (87,000 words), an uplifting novel centred on a close-knit community, with two intertwined mysteries, will appeal to readers of Fredrik Backman’s Anxious People and The People on Platform 5 by Clare Pooley.

Sometimes you have to lose the plot to find your story.

After a lifetime of being told she can do nothing right, Hazel Ogley dared to be bold just once and ended up destroying a car, being arrested, and sentenced to community payback in her local mobile library... wearing a hi-vis vest.

Ashamed, and desperate to get through her court-mandated hours as unobtrusively as possible, Hazel is surprised by the warmth of the library volunteers and begins to wonder if she might actually be capable of making friends. But when she spots Luna, her childhood imaginary friend, in a promotional video for the library, she’s shaken. Luna disappeared when Hazel was seven and 'seeing' her again raises troubling possibilities. Desperate for answers, she turns to the only person who might be able to explain what happened all those years ago. But her mother won’t talk.

Denied the truth, Hazel pours her energy into resolving a funding threat to the library: a Bitcoin scam that has her reaching for Cryptocurrency for Dummies. Determined to protect the first place she’s felt accepted in years, she realises the library community contains all the expertise she needs to avert disaster: Clarissa, a retired detective missing the thrill of the chase; Albert, a practical Gromit to his husband Sonam’s whimsical Wallace; and Dorothy, an erotic novelist of advanced years and dab hand at pickpocketing.

But despite her success in securing the library’s future, the mystery of Luna refuses to go away. And the truth, when she finally uncovers it, changes everything she thought she knew about her childhood. For someone who has spent a lifetime expecting rejection, trusting other people is a terrifying prospect. Hazel must decide whether to retreat into the safe, lonely world she’s always known or risk opening herself up to the possibility of belonging.

Bio: [a bit about my previously published novels] Overdue is the first book I’ve written in which no-one gets murdered.


r/PubTips • • 1h ago

[QCRIT] Adult - Literary, women's - IMMATURE MATURITY (65k, 3rd attempt)

1 Upvotes

hey guys! this is my third attempt where i redid everything. i'm only including the blurb because its the main obstacle im facing. for context: I've queried around 65 agents so far with a blurb I haven't posted on reddit. Something about agent Lauren Khan's form rejection (after only an hour of having sent the query over) made me rethink my query again. I've made changes now that I believe are genuinely beneficial. this was the blurb most similiar to the one i ended up using for querying.
thank you in advance!!

Cecilia Worthing is sixteen, half-Kuwaiti, and afraid of the widowed father who calls her a whore for wearing a dress. William Fitzpatrick is nineteen, a drug dealer, and the first person to notice her seagaze and ask what she thinks of the view. The night her father drags her across her bedroom by the hair, William is at her window with a proposal: elope with him to London—a move he was already planning—and leave her troubles behind. She agrees, confident that her father won't bring himself out of his drunken stupor to give chase. They leave the following day.

In London, they play at housewife and husband. For a few weeks it's exciting: she learns to cook, he learns tenderness. But as his wealth grows, so too does her sense of unease: the dresses he expects her to wear, the hair he demands she cut, the jealous looks he gives her when she smiles at other men, all become harder to ignore. Cecilia adapts, the way she always has to the men in her life—until William’s desire for control escalates to her own sexuality.

Cecilia must then decide whether the girl who accepted his proposal can survive being his.


r/PubTips • • 2h ago

Attempt #2 [QCrit] Adult Horror - IN CURSED COMPANY (85k/#1)

1 Upvotes

Unleash your magic with FancyWitch™, the premier Witchery starter kit available now at Target™! Complete with cauldron, guidebook, and real witches standing by to grant your gifts!

Except Ptolemy is the only “real witch standing by.” A shadowy curse watches him always, and violently rips out his wish-granting magic for (often dangerous) customer requests. He’s perpetually on-call in a tiny, gray, windowless office located somewhere in downtown LA, unable to leave. Unable to stop his magic from killing people like the ten year old girl who requested the power to shoot fireworks from her hands. Ptolemy knows his death would fix many FancyWitch horrors and end his pain.

Unfortunately, the curse holding him captive made him immortal.

On year nine of withering away behind a desk, Ptolemy is shot by Mike, a hotheaded witch-hunter who managed to infiltrate FancyWitch with the goal of ending the witch behind the magic. When Ptolemy comes to, unharmed, Mike tempers his rage and agrees to help Ptolemy to die for good. Using their combined connections and knowledge, the pair test methods to temporarily end Ptolemy’s immortality and permanently end his life.

But as weeks pass and the two get closer to the solution and each other, a slowly-burning desire grows between them both, endangering more than their mission. Because Ptolemy’s curse is powered by the famed multimillionaire CEO of FancyWitch—Ptolemy’s husband.

IN CURSED COMPANY is a queer adult horror with a dark romance buried somewhere nearby. Complete at 85,000 words, the story would find a home with readers who were moved by You Weren’t Meant to be Human by Andrew Joseph White and She’s a Doll by Barbara Truelove. FancyWitch is a product not unlike those found in The Substance, Obsession, and even Supernatural, which also serve as excellent examples of the type of customer calls Ptolemy fields in his sad, liminal, 90s-inspired cube.

[About me paragraph]

#

Hi PubTips. Thank you in advance for any and all guidance on this query letter! How do we feel about the term "horrormance"? I think this story falls into that category, but I'm skeptical about whether it's a real category right now...

Thanks again!


r/PubTips • • 23h ago

Discussion [Discussion] If you had 1k/5k/10k to spend on your book, how would you spend it?

36 Upvotes

I recently came into some money and am wondering how one would hypothetically allocate a budget for promoting a trad pubbed debut outside of whatever your publisher does for you. Character art? Book tour? Book fairs and conferences? Fellowship applications? Writing retreats? This is not “quit your day job” money but could maybe afford me a few unpaid weeks off to focus on writing the next book (I already have plans for my meager American PTO).

I also asked this question in a self-publishing subreddit but obviously the trad pub answer will be very different! For context, I am going on sub in the new year but am prepared to self-publish if it dies (with my agent’s blessing), so I want to be prepared for either scenario. I know it is early to consider this but a good chunk of money is about to hit my account and having a vague plan for how to spend it will give me peace of mind and the will not to touch it until I know what I truly want to spend it on!


r/PubTips • • 12h ago

[Qcrit] ACORN DATABASE, YA Sci-Fi, 85k words, #9

4 Upvotes

Hello. Struggling here. My sixth version was fairly tight I think? But a huge part of the story is the tribes/cults, which I didn't really include. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dear Agent,

I would like to offer THE ACORN DATABASE for your consideration, a young adult sci-fi novel of 85,000 words. It pairs the character dynamics and storytelling of Snowglobe by Soyoung Park, with the worldbuilding and conspiracy of The Maze Cutter by James Dashner.

Sola and her dad are perpetually hounded by enforcement drones. Their crime is trespassing—something impossible to avoid in a fully-privatized future. Using homemade tech to survive the depleted landscape, they search for somewhere safe to live in peace. After a drone kills her dad however, Sola realizes that this was never going to happen.

Her father’s final act is to send Sola to an old family friend for help, a strange lighthouse-dwelling scientist. He and her parents were once students together back in the city, before they lost their homes in the Collapse and were forced to live on the run. Very quickly Sola realizes why her father never went to his friend for help before. Instead of keeping Sola out of harms way like her father wanted, he talks about an underground mission to stop the drone attacks for good and sends her into a nearby city to deliver his secret research. 

Wanting retribution for her father, and to see where her parents once lived, Sola agrees. In the city she faces many new horrors and challenges, although some of the most dangerous encounters are with seemingly normal communities completely insulated from the outside world. 

When Sola finally locates the people she’s supposed to deliver the research to, she realizes that they, like her parents, belong to one of the feared psychedelic tribes that sprang up during the Collapse. She’s about to flee, but after her hostile encounter with “normal” people, she wonders if the tribes might not actually be so crazy. They are the only ones fighting to stop the drones' relentless persecution after all. 

With everything turned on its head, Sola must decide whether to proceed with their deadly mission, even if it might alter the very basis of modern civilization.

Bio+Tag

Thank you!


r/PubTips • • 8h ago

[QCrit] THE UNFREE KILLER (adult literary crime, 75k, attempt #5)

0 Upvotes

Hopefully the final attempt here. There's a couple of ways I could frame this novel, so I've gone for a simpler version this time. Here's version 4.

One thing I wondered is whether people think writing 'pharisaic' creates a negative impression. I've considered putting 'entertaining' or 'amusing' instead.

I've also changed the title, as suggested, and think it actually works better. Thank you again for your comments.

Dear agent,

THE UNFREE KILLER (75,000 words) is a darkly satirical literary crime standalone dripping with horror. Imagine the delusional male entitlement in Danya Kukafka’s Notes on an Execution set in the messy, pharisaic world of Eliza Clark’s Boy Parts.

John is an outspoken, vegan anti-Zionist, but he keeps quiet about his psychopathy. Studying ethics has curbed his murderous desires, though recently he’s become a free will sceptic. As a polyglot, he’s obviously far smarter than most vulgs, so why all the rejections of his PhD proposal on the philosophy of unfree will? They say, ‘Publish or perish,’ but it seems he’s not fated to publish. Perhaps others are destined to perish – at his hand?

That must be it. And if its romantisierte portrayal on Netflix has taught John anything, it’s that serial murder possesses a macabre charm.

John’s subsequent killing spree causes immeasurable suffering, but it isn’t his choice. Netflix directors are right scrotgrunchers for lying to him, though: social media posts by the victims’ families garner more attention than his crimes, and there’s no glamour in the perennial fear of arrest or drowning suicidal thoughts in sabach.

Miserable yet hooked on serienmord, John prepares to emulate the vicious tricks of serial killers glorified on TV, hoping to emerge from this ill-fated venture with their cult-like status. But killing more people will be risky with a detective on his trail and the victims’ families bent on revenge. Who knows? They might even catch John first.

I’m an academic editor with stories published in horror and satire magazines. With the likes of Yuval Noah Harari and Robert Sapolsky saying free will is an illusion, I’ve fused my knowledge and interests into a debut novel that lampoons ‘unfree’ society.


r/PubTips • • 16h ago

Attempt #3 [Qcrit] WHERE TRUTH IS BENT, Speculative Thriller, YA, second attempt

3 Upvotes

Hey guys, here goes another!

Eighteen-year-old Arthur sees emotion as color—the pale pink of care, or the yellow of joy—a synesthetic trait he’s always attributed to his autism. Exhausted from masking through his family’s suffocating high-society dinners in coastal France, Arthur craves the freedom of the open sea, the one place he doesn't have to perform. Instead, during a heated argument, he accidentally injures his father and is sent away by a tearful farewell from both his parents. 

He wakes up in an isolated estate with fractured memory, no contact with the outside world, and only his caretaker, Viviane, her eerily obedient maids, and a childhood song buzzing endlessly in his head.

Arthur is given two rules: he’s only allowed outside during the day, and his bedroom door must be locked every night. Yet the hours he's allowed outdoors and interactions with the staff feel like a scene that’s already been written—and every few days a crack splits in the sky and the atmosphere loops. 

Suspecting the haunting melody holds the key to his captivity, Arthur uses his color-coded mind to spot slips in Viviane’s persona. He must uncover why his parents had him taken and break free from this scripted world—before he's trapped forever, or loses his chance to ever own his mind.

WHERE TRUTH IS BENT is a 74,000-word Upmarket YA Speculative Thriller set in 2005 France loosely inspired by the legend of King Arthur. It combines a synesthetic protagonist and parental control like NOT YOUR PRODIGY by Emily Perl Copley with the high-tech simulation stakes of TRAUMALAND by Josh Silver.

(Bio)

(Sign off)


r/PubTips • • 22h ago

[PubQ] How does forwarding work in QueryTracker?

7 Upvotes

When a query gets forwarded in QueryTracker, what does that look like for the receiving agent? I've had a couple queries forwarded. One was pretty straightforward, as it was just the query letter and opening pages at that point. But another agent (let's call them Agent A) requested my first 100 pages, then forwarded to a colleague (Agent B), who they thought was a better fit.

From what I can see in QT, Agent A usually requests a partial, then might request a full. Agent B appears to not request partials, and goes straight to requesting a full. I'm wondering if Agent B knows they've been forwarded my partial and not a full? Do agents communicate about this in their day-to-day? Can Agent B see my message history with Agent A, where they requested my first 100? Or did the query and attached document just get dropped into their queue without any context? And then when they get to it, they'll open it and see that it's a partial?

Any insight would be much appreciated!


r/PubTips • • 16h ago

[QCrit] ADULT Epic Fantasy - FOUNDATIONS OF SEEKERS (91K/Attempt 3)

2 Upvotes

After another round of revisions, I think my query letter is closer to being in a good spot. Thank you to everyone who has given feedback so far, and thanks in advance to anyone willing to share feedback on this one! In this query, I tried adding a bit more of the MC's personality instead of it just being a chain of events.

Dear [Agent],

I am seeking representation for FOUNDATIONS OF SEEKERS, a 91,000-word standalone adult epic fantasy with series potential. It will appeal to readers who loved the academy world of James Islington’s THE WILL OF THE MANY and the slow unraveling of an institution’s founding lie in M. L. Wang’s BLOOD OVER BRIGHT HAVEN.

Gareth is an untrusting, self-interested street urchin who remembers nothing before the night he woke in an alley two years ago. The only thing he cares about is remembering who he was. To survive, he steals what he can and runs odd jobs for a shady merchant. That is, until one night, when scouting out a place to rob, a monstrous creature nearly kills him, and he’s saved by Darren, a man who knows who Gareth is.

Darren is reluctant to tell Gareth about his past, and offers a trade. If Gareth joins his secret order, the Seekers, he’ll help him remember. Suspicious, he declines until Darren forces him to by leaving him no other alternatives.

From day one, Gareth feels unwelcome and has to do laborious jobs while others his age train to become Seekers, searchers of history and peacekeepers of the kingdom. Through brutal training and humiliation, Gareth earns his place among the Seekers, and fragments of his memories begin to resurface. As he digs into his past, he uncovers missing recruits, horrifying experiments, and proof that the Seekers built their foundation on a lie.

Confronting Darren, Gareth learns the truth: Darren has been suppressing his memories all along, manipulating him into joining the Seekers to end his enemies once and for all. With nowhere left to turn, Gareth must turn to the only people who might stand against Darren — the very enemies he was trained to hate — before he becomes the key that hands Darren everything.

[Bio]

Thank you for your time and consideration.


r/PubTips • • 20h ago

Discussion [Discussion] Agent wants me to re-submit

4 Upvotes

I recently got a rejection( #1065) from an agency I really stumbled upon. With the rejection, the agent gave me a date of when she wanted me to re-submit my work. Is this common in the industry?

This is a newer agency and to me, it looks like they are really just beginning to develop there catalogue which makes me more excited to re-submit.


r/PubTips • • 17h ago

[QCrit] Adult Thriller UNTITLED (98k/First Attempt)

2 Upvotes

Hi all. This is my first query for my debut. I've sent it to two agents so far and I'm holding the rest of my list for feedback. I'd especially like to know how the plot, stakes and characters come through, and whether the premise feels plausible.

Dear [Agent],

Every hero Rafe Calder investigates is real. That's the problem.

A woman nearly killed saving a child on the Brooklyn Bridge. A petty thief shot tackling a gunman in Italy. A teacher killed shoving children clear of a falling stage. Rafe, an ex-FBI agent turned insurance investigator, haunted by three young women he couldn't save in Greece, follows the money surrounding their rescues to Mirë Ionia, a luxury resort among Cold War bunkers on the Albanian Riviera.

Lira Kosta built Mirë Ionia with dirty money and a genuine ambition to create jobs and opportunity in the country she fled. She doesn't fake heroes. She finds them. Her hidden network, the Club, identifies people likely to risk their lives for strangers, shapes the circumstances around them, and cashes in, down to stock bets placed before the danger hits.

In Madrid, an engineered rescue kills two. Rafe defies orders, saves a child on camera, and gets fired. He returns to Albania, sleeps with Lira knowing it could cost him, and discovers her financier traffics women, reopening his oldest wound.

Lira tries to cut ties, but her brother Valon has conspired with the financier, who seizes her resort. When Rafe gets her out, Valon comes for him with a steel bar and they nearly kill each other in her bunker spa, forcing Lira to choose between the man exposing her and the brother who did her dirty work.

Every act of courage the Club touched becomes suspect. Rafe must take down those who engineer the danger without destroying the heroes who chose to help.

[TITLE] is an international thriller, complete at 98,000 words, for readers of Chris Pavone's TWO NIGHTS IN LISBON (2022) and Joseph Finder's THE OLIGARCH'S DAUGHTER (2025).

I'm an entrepreneur and executive. I've run sales and operations for a $200-million company, founded and sold a coding school, and led tech-training programs for working adults. Years of watching how money and incentives shape what people do drove this book. I live in New Mexico, where I spend most weekends hiking above 10,000 feet. This is my debut.

Thank you for your time and consideration.


r/PubTips • • 20h ago

[QCrit] Query letter advice, NEXT TIME FOR SURE, contemporary romance/romcom, 88,000 words, PubTips attempt 1

3 Upvotes

First time poster - thank you for taking the time to read and any advice you may have.

NEXT TIME FOR SURE is a second-chance romance complete at 88,000 words. It will appeal to readers who love the witty banter of Book Lovers by Emily Henry (do I need to pick a lesser known comp?) and the emotional complexities of navigating chronic illness in The Friends Zone by Abby Jimenez, with the atmospheric Jersey Shore charm of HAVE A GREAT SUMMER by Francesca Cocchi.

Eliza has spent her entire career proving that success isn't about luck, it's discipline. As a high-powered marketing vice president, she's built her life around meticulous plans and ten-point checklists, ambition without sacrificing kindness, and one unwavering rule: never let a little something as unpredictable as life get in the way of her next move. 

So when the promotion she's spent years chasing is finally within reach, the last thing she needs is to be forced into a high-stakes project with the one man she swore she'd never see again — Matt Russo. 

Their history is complicated, their chemistry undeniable, and with her office rival determined to beat her to the finish line, Eliza refuses to let old feelings become another distraction. As emotions resurface, so do a series of increasingly alarming medical symptoms Eliza stubbornly dismisses, convinced she can push through just one more meeting, one more presentation, one more impossible week. But with Matt comes all the reminders of their endless days of summer at the Jersey Shore, a stark contrast to her current life, and a reminder that she can't outrun everything forever.

I’m a writer by any spare minute I can get as a mom. I hold a BA in English with a Certificate in Creative Writing from Rutgers University. I navigate life with stage-four endometriosis and also have PMOS.

Thank you very much for your time and consideration.


r/PubTips • • 1d ago

[PubQ] Agent doesn’t want to send out my new book.

70 Upvotes

Might be a bad idea to post this, but I’m driving myself crazy and would love some perspective.

After not even six months on sub, agent has declared the book is dead. No suggestion of doing another round. The passes have all been effusive on the writing, but universally wished the plot leaned more upmarket/lit and less thriller-y.

Agent disagrees. We did an R&R before signing to make it MORE thriller-y.

In October I wrote a new book. I leaned into everything the editors were saying.

My agent hated it. Really. And proceeded to reject every other idea I pitched that was in the vein of what editors said they wanted to see from me, until I pitched another thriller.

So here we are now with one dead thriller. I really want to take the October book out in Q1. Agent wants me to do a revision of the dead thriller and take that back out, or write the new thriller.

Is there any way I can just say “Yo, I’m insistent we bring the October book to market.”? Or does it not work like that? I’m also hesitant to put the effort into writing a new thriller and putting that in front of editors who’ve already told us they want me to go more literary.

Has anyone experienced anything like this? What did you do? How did it work out?


r/PubTips • • 20h ago

[QCrit] BEHEMOTH OF THE INVERTED SUN, Crossover Fantasy/LGBTQ, 92,000 Words, Third Attempt

2 Upvotes

Hello! Third time's the charm, as they say. Below, you'll find my query letter. I've been working hard to try and understand how to write these, and I think I've stumbled on something workable, but I'm curious to see how everyone else feels about it. Also, I've included the novel's opening prologue for reference.

Hello,

I am seeking representation for BEHEMOTH OF THE INVERTED SUN, a complete 92,000-word crossover fantasy with a slow-burn M/M romance.

In 11 days, three color-eating creatures known as titans will turn the island community of Eastisle into a pale, shapeless mass, and 19-year-old Oliver Greensmith will be blamed.

Stuck in a cycle of poverty and anxiety, Oliver takes an uncharacteristic gamble when he rescues Raine, a young man who falls out of the sky alongside a stolen titan egg. Despite Raine's initial hostility, Oliver's surprising psychic bond with the unhatched titan forces Raine to make a bargain. If Oliver helps the new titan reach maturity, Raine will give him a new life far away from Eastisle.

Desperate for the endless possibilities Raine represents, Oliver accepts. But with titans being illegal for civilians to own, hunters like the fundamentalist cult member Hamish will kill Oliver if his secret is discovered. Worse, his titan’s voracious appetite doesn't just force Oliver to hide his new companion; it threatens to turn Eastisle into a colorless husk.

Yet as hunters close in, Oliver is drawn ever closer to Raine, forcing him to confront desires Eastisle has spent years making him repress. Then, just as Oliver is ready to accept his feelings, a confrontation with Hamish exposes the truth: Raine was never going to help Oliver find a life off of Eastisle. In truth, Raine wanted to use Oliver and his titan to exact revenge against cult members like Hamish who had cost him everything.

With Hamish and his titan Angus threatening to liquefy Eastisle to capture Raine, Oliver faces one final choice: risk his life fighting a battle he can't win to rescue the boy who betrayed him, or save himself and watch Eastisle crumble around them as Raine is dragged back into Hamish's twisted cult.

Combining the literary, character-driven fantasy of Kelly Link's The Book of Love with the creature-bonding fantasy of Moniquill Blackgoose's To Shape a Dragon's Breath, BEHEMOTH OF THE INVERTED SUN is a crossover fantasy about identity, sexuality, and how people rebuild in the wake of losing everything.

Best wishes,

Evan

PROLOGUE

Even thirty years later, the first thing I remember about the Eastisle Incident is the pale glob of matter dripping from a crack in the sky like blood from an open cut.

The dissolving rules of reality were the least of Eastisle’s problems that night. Houses, schools, and restaurants I’d known since birth had been reduced to rubble beneath the heel of behemoths. Hollow people sifted through the debris of their lives, looking for some surviving piece of themselves, of their friends, of their families. Searching for anything that had lived through the paling.

I still remember the strangling guilt as I watched my last friend turn faded and shapeless. Even now, knowing what I know, the echo of We caused this sends me spiraling back into that dark place I thought my titan and I had left so many years ago.

The second thing I remember is the reason I wrote this book. A grainy old photo of me at 19 on the Daily Tribune’s front cover, the headline above reading, “Grocery Clerk Still Wanted After Terrorist Plot Left Tourist Hotspot in Shambles”. Most of that headline could be construed as true if you squinted your eyes and folded your brain in half. I have tried to put it away. To chuck it into the murky tides of memory so that it would only resurface in fits and starts among the waves of other things that kept me awake at night. But no. There were those words, “Tourist Hotspot,” and they became a wound that never healed quite right.

The third thing that surfaces about the Eastisle Tri-Behemoth Incident is the dark circles under my eyes and the hunger in my gut eleven days before my homeland’s destruction.


r/PubTips • • 1d ago

[QCrit] A Mark of Magic, adult alternative history fantasy, 78k, Attempt #3

4 Upvotes

New title and significant revisions since my last attempt. I dropped comps altogether after noticing that many of the agents I am interested in targeting don't really care about them. I have also really shortened the blurb. I was trying to cram too much plot into the previous blurb and it seemed to just confuse people. Hopefully this is just enough to pique a reader's interest. Thanks in advance for any feedback!

Dear Agent,

I am seeking representation for my novel, A MARK OF MAGIC, a multi-POV alternative history fantasy with series potential complete at 78,000 words. Set in a version of Earth where most writing has been destroyed or consumed by demons sometime in the early middle ages, the novel explores a world where caravans traveling the Spice Road are valued as much for the information they carry as for their tangible goods.

When Elif carves a rune in the mud and unwittingly attracts a monster, she discovers she has a talent for a rare and dangerous magic that requires a forbidden art: writing. Eager to leave her controlling guardian, Batu, she joins a visiting caravan and starts learning about long forgotten alphabets and scripts. Elif does not know that Batu has bound something old and dark to her and has been waiting twelve years for it to show itself. When she abandons him to travel the Spice Road into the heart of Cappadocia, Batu is convinced Elif has unlocked what he needs to save his lost love from a hellish fate and sets off in pursuit. For Batu, the ends justify any means. Realizing that Batu has blood on his hands, Elif must decide to what lengths she is willing to go to stop him knowing that her magic endangers her newfound family.

[short bio] This is my debut novel.

Thank you for your consideration. I hope to hear from you soon.

Sincerely,

xxx

First 300:

Batu sat and watched with annoyance as the karg slaughtered and devoured his horse. The hyena-men were making impressively quick work of it. They cackled and yipped at each other as they gorged, pausing now and then to stare malevolently and snap at Batu. He could not help but flinch as the largest karg crunched one of the horse’s forelegs in its jaws as if it were a twig. He had tried to keep the stupid beast calm inside the circle of protection he had drawn on the ground before sunset, but its fear of the demons had driven it mad.

Keeping his eyes fixed on the monsters, he slowly leaned onto his side and released a low moan. There were five of them now, which was odd. Unlike the natural animals from which they drew many of their characteristics, karg were not known to associate in packs. Bah! He almost spat, but thought better of it. Everything he knew of karg was based on folktales he had heard decades ago, not research. And folktales were worth about as much as the remains of his horse. More likely they were so rare they never had the opportunity to form a pack, he thought. At one time Batu would have wagered that he knew more about demons and devils and their spawn than any man living. And behold the glories that knowledge has brought me! One of the monsters paused its dining to noisily relieve itself just outside his protective circle.

He observed that one of the hyena-men had several wounds on its chest and back and moved with a noticeable limp on a twisted leg. That must be the one that killed the caravan guard and chased Elif’s friend, the goat milker. Too bad it didn’t catch her. That might have discouraged Elif from leaving with the caravan.


r/PubTips • • 23h ago

[QCrit] ASTERIA, thriller, 88K words, second attempt

2 Upvotes

Hello all! Hoping the tweaks in the below version make the stakes more clear and compelling. Query is 417 words without personalization (on the longer side), so every word must earn its place. Please advise on anything unclear or trim-able. Looking forward to your thoughts!

A young reporter must risk her life to stop a deadly infestation that emerges from the sea in ASTERIA, a thriller complete at 88K words that combines the scrappy female protagonist of David Koepp’s Aurora with the hubris of Douglas Preston’s Extinction. Think Bradley Jackson of “The Morning Show” thrust into the global stakes of James Rollins’ Kingdom of Bones 

Doing whatever it takes to “get the story” is what made Anna van Lutten a rising star at the NBS network, but now she’s just gotten two of her sources killed. Fresh off a work suspension, riddled with guilt and self-doubt, she takes it as a career setback when she’s sent to do a fluff piece on a glut of starfish in Narragansett Bay. 

That changes during her live report on the beach, when a starfish starts feeding on the flesh of her palm. The video goes viral…but the bigger horror is revealed when Anna learns a little girl who collapsed on the beach that day was found to have tiny starfish, a mutated species dubbed Rex, feeding inside her digestive system. Worse, a government Task Force is covering up the fact that a mere lick of seawater could contain enough Rex larvae to kill you. 

Anna prevails in getting the word out, but the worst is yet to come: Rex mutates to invade drinking water and is virtually unstoppable: purification systems fail, death lurks in a sippy cup, violence erupts in water rationing lines, and self-proclaimed “Star Slayers” go from clubbing starfish to attacking the people they believe are responsible. Determined to find what caused the mutation and driven by her own moral baggage to “fix things”, Anna must overcome government stonewalling, conspiracy theories and the revenue-driven agenda of her own network. After she barely survives an attempt on her life, marine biologist Del DiCotta breaks ranks with the Task Force and joins her and a handful of unlikely allies in a desperate bid to save the world from the brink of collapse.

[Bio info] ASTERIA, my first work of fiction, incorporates as a key plot thread the common but little-known illness that took my father’s life. The story is also a love letter to the ocean…and the power of human perseverance in the face of monumental odds.

I’d be happy to send you the full manuscript. Thanks very much for your time.


r/PubTips • • 1d ago

Discussion [Discussion] We Got a Deal!: A Submission Story

131 Upvotes

Trawling through PubTips for all people's different submission stories has been what kept me going for the last weeks, so now that a miracle has happened and WE HAVE A DEAL it feels like I owe it to the sub to share my story, too. I have to be a little annoyingly vague because although the deal is agreed, we haven't officially signed yet. So apologies for that, but I hope this is still encouraging, motivating, useful... whatever the lonely hearted writers of PubTips need it to be.

Stats!

Editors queried:

First wave: 13

Second wave: 10

Weeks on sub:

9.5.

Books sold:

2

Since I signed with my current agent, I've sold two upmarket women's fiction novels to a Big Five publisher. But this year I had a little moment of creative madness and instead of working on fellowship/grant applications for my other job during the summer like I should have been doing, I went off and wrote a passion book: a really wild romantasy novel.

My agent does not represent any adult fantasy or romantasy, but she unexpectedly loved it. We revised a little bit, and came up with a sub list together, and then went out. The first wave of editors didn't give us much. A few polite acknowledgements, some quick, bland rejections (so at least the pitch was working well enough to get them reading) and then a couple of really detailed, flattering, so-close-but-its-just-not-the-right-fit rejections that definitely stung.

At week four my agent nudged and got a couple of requests for more time, and that was it. By way of a hint, I sent my agent a list of fresh romantasy-friendly imprints, some of which were so new that they had literally opened since the first wave of submissions. She was into it, so we tweaked the pitch a little bit (I wanted to mention the specific historical period/place that inspired the setting) and went out again.

Straight away, this wave was different. Every single editor acknowledged and most of them expressed a lot of excitement, saying that A, B or C aspect of the pitch was just what they'd been looking for. Week four for this second wave - so eight and a half weeks on sub in total - my agent was going to nudge again, but before she could an editor (who we've actually both worked with before on a different imprint at the publisher) contacted us. Her email was what my agent described as 'cagey', but it said she was impressed. This editor at Imprint A said she was taking the book to her team and asked for two weeks to get back to us.

My agent immediately notified the other editors and gave them two weeks to express their interest. Within a day, Imprint B got back to my agent to say they were taking the book to acquisitions the following week and hoped to offer(!). Early the following week, Imprint C also got in touch apologising for the delay but saying they, too, were 'taking the book to their team'.

All these emails were really short and business-like. Two lines at most. I didn't know if that was a bad sign or not. I had also been expecting that someone might want to Zoom or do a call to 'vibe-check' (based on past experience) but nope.

A week and a day after Imprint A had first expressed interest, in the late-ish afternoon, Imprint B sent an offer for both books of my proposed fantasy duology and a letter personally addressed to me from the commissioning editor praising the book and telling me what they hoped to do for it (none of which is binding, I know, but it gives you a warm fuzzy feeling). The catch was that the offer was a pre-empt and the deadline was 10am THE NEXT MORNING. While I was doing deep breathing exercises my agent rushed away to inform everyone who had the ms and see if she could shake anything else loose.

Imprint A immediately stepped aside. Imprint C said they couldn't get a counter-offer together this week and maybe not even next week, but they still loved the book (I think hoping we would turn the pre-empt down). A few more people replied to say vaguely interested things but nothing solid. And honestly, Imprint B had been my secret favourite all along because of various factors (including me stalking the very same editor on Insta) so I said I wanted to accept.

My agent wanted to negotiate some aspects of the deal. She told me to stand by. About an hour later she rang me back to tell me the updated offer, and proposed that I sleep on it and email her the next morning to tell her my decision. So I did, and emailed her at 8:30 say: "Go ahead!"

The imprint is at what I believe is referred to as a 'mini-major' publisher rather than a Big Five, and they are very well known for successfully publishing this kind of fiction. I won't give more specifics about the money (not even PW vague specifics) but will say that the amount offered for each book was more than twice what I was paid for my last women's fiction.

So there you have it. It felt like forever, but it wasn't really. My agent said she'd never had a pre-empt come in after nearly 10 weeks out, but on the other hand it was only just a month for the editors in the second wave, and they were the ones who were interested. There are no rules!


r/PubTips • • 1d ago

[QCrit] THE SPIDER QUEEN, Adult Political Fantasy, 102k, First Attempt

0 Upvotes

Hi! This is my first attempt. I’d especially love feedback on whether the premise/stakes are clear, whether Ari’s character arc comes through, and whether the query feels too dense. Thanks everyone in advance! <3

Dear [Agent],

[Personalised entry]

Ari isn’t the prophesied princess destined to save Arachna. She’s the maid the Spider Queen is willing to sacrifice instead.

When Arachna loses its war with Ophidia, King Lorian demands Princess Thalia’s hand in marriage. But the Spider Queen refuses to surrender her daughter. Instead, she blackmails Ari into assuming Princess Thalia’s identity, buying Thalia time for her magic to manifest. Ari is to marry the enemy king and spy on his court; in return, the Spider Queen will free Ari's imprisoned family and restore their name. But Lorian is ruthless, unpredictable, and armed with ancient magic. Magic that can detect lies.

Meanwhile, Thalia vanishes without a trace. Ari owes her life to the princess, but gratitude is harder to hold on to while Ari bleeds for a kingdom that was never hers to save.

But Lorian turns the marriage into proof of his right to rule Arachna and annexes the kingdom. Spying is no longer enough. Yet the role meant to make Ari a pawn has given her something she never had as a maid—power of her own. And she grows to enjoy wielding it.

She swears to destroy Lorian and take his throne.

Her best chance is Kairan, Lorian’s older brother—and the man who made him king. The more Lorian uses his magic, the more volatile he becomes. Convinced that Lorian needs to be removed to save his country, Kairan offers Ari a bargain: she will legitimise his claim to the throne; in return, he will liberate Arachna.

As they conspire against Lorian, their reluctant alliance deepens into an attraction neither can afford. But the futures they envision cannot coexist. While Kairan wants to save Ophidia, Ari wants to make sure it can never threaten Arachna again.

To free her country, Ari will have to betray the man she fell for.

THE SPIDER QUEEN is an adult political fantasy complete at 102,000 words and the first in a planned duology, with a slow-burn romantic arc. It combines the court intrigue and transformation of an underestimated woman into a political threat in Shen Tao’s THE POET EMPRESS with the slow-burn romantic tension, divided loyalties, and political upheaval of Stacey McEwan’s A FORBIDDEN ALCHEMY.

I’m a Ukrainian writer living in Germany, where I work as an information-security engineer. I previously self-published an epic fantasy novel and I create fantasy reader-focused content on Instagram and TikTok under -handle-.

Thank you for your time and consideration,

First 300 words:

The screams were unbearable. The Spider Queen's castle shuddered beneath my feet as I stood on the balcony, staring at the blazing horizon. The city rocked and wailed under the siege. The fires devoured the capital, ash whipping through smoke in the freezing winds of the Norshard Mountains.

Thick smoke encircled the city. Beyond the walls, halos of firelight glowed in the gathering dusk as the enemy army rolled catapults and trebuchets into position. Battering rams drummed against the city gates, soldiers on both sides roaring with effort, fear, and anger.

A violent boom rang out, making me flinch. My nails dug deep into my palms as the thundering echo rolled through the narrow streets of Silkveil. A rain of stones fell upon residences, gardens, markets, and city squares. Each volley brought larger, heavier boulders. One of them tore through the air in a high arc before crashing into the top spire of Nephara's cathedral.

I gasped as masonry broke away in a cloud of dust and plummeted through the timber roof. The spider statues guarding the clerestory burst into pieces. Fragments shot through the stained-glass rose window, splintering its delicate stonework.

Smoke scorched my throat. That cathedral was where I'd been named. Where my parents had sealed their marriage. It was where I went each time I lost hope, whenever I felt powerless.

And now the Cathedral of Nephara, the Spinner of Illusions, was crumbling before my eyes.

"I can't watch it," the princess hissed, clenching her fists on the balcony railing. She trembled, veins bulging beneath her pale skin. Her eyes, swollen with tears, burned with fury. But she refused to look away from her ravaged kingdom.

My gaze dropped to the spider-shaped necklace at her throat—Nephara's Tear—passed down through generations of Spider Queens. A symbol of old power.


r/PubTips • • 1d ago

[QCrit] ANGELS ON MY SHOULDER, YA speculative, 72k words, first attempt

4 Upvotes

Hi guys! This is not my first novel I've written, but the first time I've posted here. I had a couple FR on my first one but it went nowhere, and while I'm waiting on a couple from my second this idea came to me and was so insane I wanted to get it out. My manuscript has been beta read and peer edited, and Ive done a couple renditions before settling on this query letter but I would love some expert advice:

Dear Agent,

What happens when the guardian angels that randomly show up claiming to protect you turn out to be demons hellbent on making you their leader? That is the question Lilith finds herself asking in ANGELS ON MY SHOULDER, a 72,000 word YA speculative contemporary novel with a sassy, defiant tone similar to Dangerous Impulses and an overarching theme of self-acceptance similar to When I was Death. (personalize)

Lilith has spent her whole life believing she was the cause of the accident that took her father’s life and left her terrified of fire. After another near-death experience saving the hot loner girl that she always quietly defends to her self-righteous friends, she herself is rescued by three women claiming to be her guardian angels. Yet over the course of the next week, she finds their influence to be pushing her to do things she has never done before, and finds that she is equally horrified and excited by the new her. 

As she struggles with figuring out what actually happened to her all those years ago, she is aided by the resident school bad boy and afore mentioned loner girl, after being persuaded by the angels to drop her straight-laced boyfriend of almost a decade. Eventually the angels are forced to shed their guise and reveal themselves to be demons, and they inform Lilith that the accident she thought she barely survived was not in fact an accident, but a planned murder—in which she died in a sacrificial ritual at the hands of none other than her own mother. The fire she constantly feels is actually a reminder of hell, where her soul was brought back from, and given a second chance at life because the demons decided they wanted her to be reincarnated as the original folklore Lilith, mother of all demons, rather than Lilith’s mom, who was attempting to retrieve that power for herself. 

Now Lilith and her mom have to duke it out as only one of them can be left alive. If she wants to live it can only be by ending her murderous mother’s existence and fulfilling the ritual, and she isn’t sure she will be able to fight the demonic influence forever. So will she let them overtake her and become the greatest evil this earth has ever seen, or will she find a way to rid herself of them one and for all? And if she can find a balance of the good and evil within her, who will she be able to choose as her romantic partner: the man who sees her flaws and likes her anyway, or the girl who pushes her to be the best version of herself?

(Bio)


r/PubTips • • 1d ago

[QCRIT] Adult Horror - Blood in the Hallowed Rift (62,000 words/Attempt #2)

1 Upvotes

Sorry if the formatting is rough. I’m doing this on mobile. Please lmk how you’re feeling about this attempt, I’m open to all criticism.

On Halloween in 1953, Jordan wants a night to party and find love in New Orleans. Instead, an invitation leads him to a house with a doorway into another world beyond time. There, he finds a school whose students remember fragments of their lives, most clearly the moments before their apparent deaths. They’re around Jordan’s age, but as he pieces together their memories, he realizes they’re enslavers, Confederate soldiers, and perpetrators of human experiments. Even their teachers are former SS officers. Rather than condemn their crimes, the school teaches everyone to celebrate them, so Jordan’s certain he’s been damned to Hell.

The teachers forbid students from leaving the school, but Jordan disobeys and glimpses the realm outside, where an entity holds them prisoner and feeds on their dread. Searching for a way home, nobody is willing to help. They know his past, and the longer he remains, the harder it becomes to escape with his humanity intact. So Jordan must confront his privilege in the racial supremacy that sustains the school, and the guilt he has spent years trying to outrun.

Complete at 62,000 words, BLOOD IN THE HALLOWED RIFT is a standalone adult cosmic horror novel combining the historical and institutional horror of Tananarive Due's THE REFORMATORY with the visceral, reality-bending horror of Jenny Kiefer's THIS WRETCHED VALLEY.


r/PubTips • • 19h ago

[QCrit] Adult Fantasy, 220k words, THE BOUNDLESS WEAVE (1st attempt)

0 Upvotes

Hi all!I know 220k words is a lot for a debut novel, and I'm planning to work on a shorter, revised version, possibly splitting the manuscript into multiple books. But I feel that if I don't start querying and getting feedback, whether positive or negative, I'll be stuck in an endless cycle of revisions.
I'd appreciate any feedback on the query itself. Thanks in advance!

Dear [Agent]

I am seeking representation for The Boundless Weave, a 220,000-word adult fantasy novel centred on exploration, magical discovery and adventure. It is the first book in a planned trilogy.

In the archipelago of the Free Cities, Tandrish is a divination mage who has built a life she loves among the scholars of Tirrel, far from the teachers who insisted that control and emotional restraint were essential to practising magic.

When an unnatural storm cuts off a nearby island, Tandrish is asked to join the Sea Ghost to investigate. Its captain, Benedict Montague, is determined to recruit her as his permanent deck wizard, though he is considerably less forthcoming about why he needs one. During their voyage, they discover that the storm is the work of a legendary creature made of sea and magic, far from the home she left centuries ago. Its power resonates with Tandrish's own and leaves her eager to learn more. Sensing an opportunity, Benedict offers her the chance to pursue her own explorations aboard the Sea Ghost if she helps turn his smuggling vessel into a pirate ship.

Tandrish's investigations soon lead her to a group of mages whose plan to control such beings threatens the independence of the Free Cities. Benedict and his crew, though not usually inclined to deal with problems that don't concern them, decide to fight to protect the archipelago's freedom. Tandrish, meanwhile, must deal with the summoned creature, whose curiosity about human emotions offers her a way to communicate with it.

And emotions are hardly in short supply for Tandrish and Benedict, who have fallen in love despite their different ambitions. But Benedict has an ambition he has yet to reveal: reaching the Last Run, the richest region of the Teramar Sea, whose access is controlled by the newly formed Western Alliance. How much room that leaves for the exploration he promised Tandrish, or for their growing relationship, is another matter.

My novel combines the adventurous spirit and experienced protagonists of S. A. Chakraborty's The Adventures of Amina al-Sirafi with the intricate worldbuilding and character-driven storytelling of Antonia Hodgson's The Raven Scholar.

I hold a PhD in physics and previously worked as a research scientist. I now work as a programmer and narrative designer at a video game development studio.

Thank you for your time and consideration.


r/PubTips • • 1d ago

[QCrit] LET YOUR LOVE DESCEND, adult gothic fantasy, 101k, second attempt

4 Upvotes

Hello all, I posted my query letter a couple of months ago here

I've since done another round of revisions and may be ready to start sending queries out as early as next week! I've also since tweaked my query a little, so I'd appreciate any feedback on any part of the letter or sample. Thanks!

--------------

Dear [Agent],

Kalannar el Satheem is an elf who wants nothing more than to live out his centuries with his wife, Ravaphine. So when she dies at sea, Kalannar refuses to accept her death. Instead, he keeps it a secret and attempts a forbidden resurrection ritual that could send him to the gallows. But when he performs the ritual, standing in the summoning circle is not his wife, but an immortal demon from the plane of fire who looks exactly like her, save for the horns and bright red skin. 

Jynvielle may have Ravaphine’s face, but she’s excitable, uncouth, and nothing like Kalannar’s studious wife. Worse, she can’t get back to where she came from on her own. Now Kalannar needs to find a way to send her back while searching for a new way to resurrect Ravaphine. To maintain the ruse that Ravaphine is alive, he forces Jynvielle to hide her demonic features whenever they step outside. It devastates him to see his wife, alive but not.

Between dodging Jynvielle’s insults and learning to control the magic she gives him, Kalannar learns that the necromancer who penned the resurrection ritual is alive—deep within an ancient forest from which few return. And if the necromancer can’t help him, Kalannar’s only other option is to find another, or go to the underworld himself. Jynvielle has her own reasons to tag along—her obsessive boss has been stalking her since she was summoned, and he is not the type to let a runaway go unpunished. To bring his wife home, Kalannar will need to stop managing every move the demon makes and trust Jynvielle, because she may be the only one who can help him.

Featuring Sumerian-inspired world-building and told in dual timelines, LET YOUR LOVE DESCEND is an adult gothic fantasy novel complete at 101,000 words. It will appeal to fans of Nettle & Bone by T. Kingfisher for its themes of bodily autonomy and The Tainted Cup by Robert Jackson Bennett for its platonic odd-couple banter. 

[Personalization]

[Bio]

Thank you for your time and consideration,

[Name], writing as [pen name]

First 300 words:

The stone scrapes my fingers as I pry it from our cellar floor. She deserves a proper headstone, but commissioning one with no death registered would raise too much suspicion.

Kneeling, I fish in my pocket for her satin shawl. For the first time, I study it in the orange light of the fireplace beside me. The random colorful embroidered lines stir and become clear images that I never noticed, little vignettes of life. An orchid. A fisherman. A foal.

This shawl was a wedding gift to her from our dear friend Jay, and she wears it whenever we go somewhere together. How have I never noticed any of this before? I would likely have seen it every day for another three centuries without ever noticing. I always wind up looking at her instead.

The embroidery becomes blurry, and I bury my face in the shawl as I try to stop my shoulders from shaking. It still smells of that perfume that she bought when we visited my mother in Bershishia, of the salt of the sea. Of her. When I lift my face from it, dark, wet circles have formed where my eyes were.

I lay the shawl out flat on the stone floor and fold it until it fits snugly in my palm. I cannot remove my eyes from it as I rest it in the makeshift grave. The hot ash of the lit fireplace burns my fingers as I grab a fistful, but I scarcely care. I throw the ash over the shawl before reciting a prayer to Afarda that I recall the presiding ashalthi droned at Jay’s burial. There were so many attending his funeral. It should have been the same for her.

Her parents have a family mausoleum in their local church where they would have her interred, though that has been a point of contention for decades.