Trawling through PubTips for all people's different submission stories has been what kept me going for the last weeks, so now that a miracle has happened and WE HAVE A DEAL it feels like I owe it to the sub to share my story, too. I have to be a little annoyingly vague because although the deal is agreed, we haven't officially signed yet. So apologies for that, but I hope this is still encouraging, motivating, useful... whatever the lonely hearted writers of PubTips need it to be.
Stats!
Editors queried:
First wave: 13
Second wave: 10
Weeks on sub:
9.5.
Books sold:
2
Since I signed with my current agent, I've sold two upmarket women's fiction novels to a Big Five publisher. But this year I had a little moment of creative madness and instead of working on fellowship/grant applications for my other job during the summer like I should have been doing, I went off and wrote a passion book: a really wild romantasy novel.
My agent does not represent any adult fantasy or romantasy, but she unexpectedly loved it. We revised a little bit, and came up with a sub list together, and then went out. The first wave of editors didn't give us much. A few polite acknowledgements, some quick, bland rejections (so at least the pitch was working well enough to get them reading) and then a couple of really detailed, flattering, so-close-but-its-just-not-the-right-fit rejections that definitely stung.
At week four my agent nudged and got a couple of requests for more time, and that was it. By way of a hint, I sent my agent a list of fresh romantasy-friendly imprints, some of which were so new that they had literally opened since the first wave of submissions. She was into it, so we tweaked the pitch a little bit (I wanted to mention the specific historical period/place that inspired the setting) and went out again.
Straight away, this wave was different. Every single editor acknowledged and most of them expressed a lot of excitement, saying that A, B or C aspect of the pitch was just what they'd been looking for. Week four for this second wave - so eight and a half weeks on sub in total - my agent was going to nudge again, but before she could an editor (who we've actually both worked with before on a different imprint at the publisher) contacted us. Her email was what my agent described as 'cagey', but it said she was impressed. This editor at Imprint A said she was taking the book to her team and asked for two weeks to get back to us.
My agent immediately notified the other editors and gave them two weeks to express their interest. Within a day, Imprint B got back to my agent to say they were taking the book to acquisitions the following week and hoped to offer(!). Early the following week, Imprint C also got in touch apologising for the delay but saying they, too, were 'taking the book to their team'.
All these emails were really short and business-like. Two lines at most. I didn't know if that was a bad sign or not. I had also been expecting that someone might want to Zoom or do a call to 'vibe-check' (based on past experience) but nope.
A week and a day after Imprint A had first expressed interest, in the late-ish afternoon, Imprint B sent an offer for both books of my proposed fantasy duology and a letter personally addressed to me from the commissioning editor praising the book and telling me what they hoped to do for it (none of which is binding, I know, but it gives you a warm fuzzy feeling). The catch was that the offer was a pre-empt and the deadline was 10am THE NEXT MORNING. While I was doing deep breathing exercises my agent rushed away to inform everyone who had the ms and see if she could shake anything else loose.
Imprint A immediately stepped aside. Imprint C said they couldn't get a counter-offer together this week and maybe not even next week, but they still loved the book (I think hoping we would turn the pre-empt down). A few more people replied to say vaguely interested things but nothing solid. And honestly, Imprint B had been my secret favourite all along because of various factors (including me stalking the very same editor on Insta) so I said I wanted to accept.
My agent wanted to negotiate some aspects of the deal. She told me to stand by. About an hour later she rang me back to tell me the updated offer, and proposed that I sleep on it and email her the next morning to tell her my decision. So I did, and emailed her at 8:30 say: "Go ahead!"
The imprint is at what I believe is referred to as a 'mini-major' publisher rather than a Big Five, and they are very well known for successfully publishing this kind of fiction. I won't give more specifics about the money (not even PW vague specifics) but will say that the amount offered for each book was more than twice what I was paid for my last women's fiction.
So there you have it. It felt like forever, but it wasn't really. My agent said she'd never had a pre-empt come in after nearly 10 weeks out, but on the other hand it was only just a month for the editors in the second wave, and they were the ones who were interested. There are no rules!