I’m a DM struggling to wrap my head around the advice to “prep situations, not plots.” I’ve read Don’t Prep Plots by the Alexandrian several times, along with plenty of similar advice online, and while I feel like I understand the principle, I’m having a hard time putting it into practice.
I spend a lot of time prepping for sessions, only for my players to blow through what I’ve prepared. I think part of my problem is that I tend to prepare activities for my players to engage in rather than situations for them to interact with.
For example, if I’m preparing a river crossing, I might start thinking about how the players could cross it and end up designing the encounter around a particular approach. Obviously, I’m perfectly happy to adapt if they come up with something else, and I’m not trying to force them down a predetermined path. But I still feel like I’m fundamentally preparing something for the players to do, rather than something for them to interact with.
What I’m struggling with is how to change that mindset, and particularly what the actual process of going from an idea to a playable situation looks like.
A lot of the advice I’ve encountered revolves around preparing NPCs and factions with goals, motivations, and resources, and then letting them react naturally to the players. I can see how that works, but my campaign is focused on exploring a vast, largely uninhabited jungle in search of ancient ruins to loot. There are occasional NPCs and factions, but most of the gameplay revolves around wilderness exploration, environmental challenges, monsters, and dungeon crawling.
So I’m having trouble translating that advice into something useful for my campaign.
For example, let’s say I have an idea for a velociraptor stalking the party through the jungle.
What does that idea actually need in order to become a viable situation? Is “a velociraptor stalking the party” already a situation, or am I starting off on the wrong foot by deciding what the creature is doing? Should I instead be prepping the velociraptor, its territory, and its behavior, and letting the stalking emerge naturally during play?
And once I have those things, how do I know when I’m done? I find it difficult to look at an idea and say, “Okay, this is now a situation I can run,” without feeling the need to flesh it out into some kind of encounter or activity.
I don’t really struggle with allowing unexpected solutions or improvising when the players do something I hadn’t anticipated. What I struggle with is preparing material that doesn’t presuppose a particular way for the players to interact with it in the first place.
So what does the process behind “prep situations, not plots” actually look like structurally, especially when there aren’t NPCs or factions driving the action?
How do you take a simple idea and develop it into a situation that’s ready to run, without accidentally designing an activity around it? And how do you recognize when you’ve prepped enough?
I’d really appreciate concrete examples of what this looks like in actual prep notes, particularly for wilderness exploration or dungeon crawling.