Person A lives in Mumbai. Person B lives in Hyderabad. B has never met A and doesn’t even know A exists. A does a task, call it X. Then A calls B and says: “I did task X, so now you’re obligated to do task Y.”
That makes zero sense. B never asked A to do X, never agreed to anything, and has no obligation to A.
Now suppose it’s the very nature of task X that once it’s done, task Y must be done by B. It’s still unfair. The nature of X doesn’t change who chose to do it. A chose X, so the consequences of X are A’s, no matter what X naturally leads to. B had no say in any of it.
Now replace A with the parent and B with the kid. The parent did the task (creating a life), and the outcome was a new person. Parents did the work, the outcome was a new life, and they can’t expect that new life to do anything. The kid owes nothing, and I mean not a single task. Everyone is a distinct individual, and two individuals can owe each other things, but nothing here makes the kid owe the parent.
What the parent imposes on the kid
Nothing about this was the kid’s choice. The imposition isn’t only the big things like going to school or marrying someone. Even if those bring happiness, or sadness, they are still imposed on the kid, because the kid never chose to exist in a world where those things happen.
It goes all the way down:
- Existence itself. The kid’s life was imposed on them, and so was being a life form at all.
- Breathing. The brainstem, mainly the medulla oblongata, generates the rhythm of breathing automatically. The kid never decided to breathe.
- The heartbeat. The heart has its own built-in pacemaker cells that make it beat, and the medulla speeds it up or slows it down. The kid never decided that either.
- Moving the body. Moving arms, even moving the pupils: the brain and nervous system run machinery the kid never asked for and cannot opt out of.
- Everything that comes with it. Every need, risk, and limit exists because the parent acted and the kid never agreed.
And it doesn’t matter who the parent is. Even if a person with 10 trillion dollars has a kid, the kid’s life is still imposed by the parents. Wealth can change what the kid’s life contains, but it can’t remove the imposition.
The parent didn’t just do a task. The parent imposed a whole existence on someone who couldn’t say no. That is why the burden is on the parent and not on the kid.
The first burden: justification, before any oweness
Before the parents owe the kid anything, something comes earlier in time. Right after the parents have sex in order to have a baby, the burden of justification falls on them. Not after the kid is born, and not when the kid grows up and asks. Right at the act.
You may ask: justification to whom? The kid doesn’t even exist yet.
But justification doesn’t need a person to hear it. Justification is not an excuse, and it isn’t about protecting yourself from anyone. It is the natural reasoning behind an act. Every act should have a justification, because a justification is just the reason you did it. So the act of having a kid puts a burden of justification on the parent, and it comes way before in time than any oweness. First the parent justifies the act. Only then does the question of what they owe begin.
My principles
- The burden is on the parent. Duties come from your own acts. The parent did the act, so the duty is theirs, and the kid has none.
- Oweness doesn’t decay with time. The degree of owing is the same now as a month later. A 99-year-old father who created a son still owes him.
- No limits on the duty. If parents can’t fulfil it, the answer isn’t “the duty shrinks,” it’s “don’t have the kid.” If a task is extremely difficult or impossible and you still owe it because you did act X, then simply don’t do X.
- Acting is signing an unread contract. A should only act if he knows the consequences of the act. If he acts anyway, he has already accepted every possible permutation of it, read or not. He signed anyway.
- Kids should help parents, but that isn’t owing. We should help our parents in every possible way, out of love, but nothing is owed.
The conclusion: the kid owes nothing, the parents owe everything, and parents who can’t deliver shouldn’t have had the kid.
Attack it.