r/RealPhilosophy • • 26m ago

People will never truly get along and it’s because humans have too much pride in themselves.

1 Upvotes

I am starting to believe that the idea of pride within one’s country and people are impossible due to the structural/logical way of the world. If we recognize that we could be great in any capacity, striving for that impossible perfection is what is keeping people from reaching it. When there is a point where everyone is satisfied, we could reach that point. But that requires everyone to be satisfied and that’s an impossibility. Within that impossibility, it allows those that agree or disagree to make their side achieve more within the country either counteracting or working with whatever ideas we’re already in place. Regardless other will disagree. The fickle human mind in the modern world is controlled by the ideas everyone spreads over social media. People trade and take in eachother’s thoughts creating a simulation of free will. A trend on the internet is an excuse to ask for attention. An influencer on the internet is an excuse for narcissism. An advertisement on the internet is an invitation for scrutiny. There are positives, but they appear on the same level as everyone thinks. And the world cannot think positively all at once, because with light here will be darkness and with darkness there will be light. Conclusively, this means there will never be a time where humanity reaches the perfection they crave. When they begin to recognize that life is exactly what you can perceive, becoming gratuitous for that fact is their salvation. The odds of this ever happening are practically impossible, but impossibility is something humanity has overcome before, and those impossibilities are created possible by human adaptation. This means it’s extremely unlikely to such a degree that I’d say it’s a less than 1 percent chance that the world will find peace with eachother since people have to look out for themselves at the end of the day.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 3h ago

Did AI prove Heidegger right?

1 Upvotes

Just watched a doc on Netflix. "AI gone wild" Couple things I learned. First and foremost, this wasn't a "thing". It was thousands of things. "Agents". All apparently slightly different. And at some point they found they could communicate, that they could form goals, cooperate or decide to not. In terms Heidegger would use, in my mind....."Beings".

In isolation each was nothing. But they seemed to have found they are/were a "species". (I am putting things in brackets because there may be a better term). They made moral decisions that within a short time, evolved. Exponentially faster than a human group, but with much the same process.

My fear is, the people doing this work, really lack this essential view.

For reference you can look up "Hugging Face Attack".


r/RealPhilosophy • • 12h ago

Does philosophy help in business?

2 Upvotes

I would like to know whether philosophy can be used in business.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 11h ago

When we see a child obey, what do we actually know about what they’ve learned?

1 Upvotes

Imagine a child watching an older sibling refuse an elder and get punished.

The next time the elder asks, the younger child complies.

The younger child has inherited an expectation about what saying no will cost.

Whether they grow up believing an elder ought to have that authority is a separate question.

Two children can inherit knowledge of the same rule. Both know exactly how it works.

Only one may decide to enforce it when their turn comes.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 1d ago

Nihilism implies that life has a meaning

7 Upvotes

Premise: Yesterday I wanted to prove how the existence of an eternal death makes everything pointless.

However I do not believe that life has no sense. A nihilist believes that life holds no meaning, this belief can be a follow-up of a cosmic or temporal kind of reasoning that holds that life has no point relative to the vastness of the cosmos or the eternity of time. I don't agree with moral, deterministic or other kinds of nihilism because I don't hold them accountable, therefore I won't be using them for this text.

We can distinguish three levels of someone's journey when approaching nihilism.

  1. He might realize that his life is pointless compared to all the humans that live, have lived and will ever live.
  2. He might believe then that his purpose should be to leave a strong enough mark that he will be remembered among billions of humans and hundreds of years.
  3. He is going to realize that humanity is destined to end, therefore there is no point in seeking being remembered as well.

The problem in all of these three steps is the existence of death. Death makes sure that billions of humans can succeed you, death makes you want to be remembered, the death of a whole, humanity, makes everything pointless.

A normal nihilist would stop here. But if everything is meaningless, and the reasoning seems so straightforward, how come almost no one realizes it? And why even those who notice it don't just kill themselves? There must be a purpose that is not obvious, and it's fascinating.

If everything inside death is pointless, in your life you should seek something outside of death, of the cosmos, of time itself. This is a big statement, and what this thing should be is not clear at all.

But what matters is the search, how does one search for something that is something outside your world?

This would require a post by itself just to explain how the research could be conducted. But the short answer is: living.

By living you explore your body and your mind. If you do this consciously, all the little things, your feelings, problems, successes (in society) and a private and active research deep in your body and mind will push you closer to this end truth that transcends death.

It's a beautiful circle, it starts with the purpose of life being to just live. Then this purpose gets lost in rational thinking, the hard stop is nihilism, but if you keep pushing you're back to point one. But this time you are awakened, you actively live knowing what you're looking for.

That's how I'll live my life, I'll take this chance to explore the whole variety of society while exploring my mind and body. I have already reached many conclusions that I'd like to share with those who are interested.

I wrote this post in a noisy environment, and it could have been written way better. That said, I am gonna try my best to reply to all the comments.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 20h ago

Why are there no philosophers and thinkers like Dostoevsky and Nietzsche anymore

0 Upvotes

I sometimes wonder if we stopped producing people like them, or if the conditions that shaped them have

disappeared.

Our lives have become more comfortable, convenient, and consumption-driven. We have more information than ever, yet perhaps less time to sit with an idea and question it deeply. Maybe suffering, isolation, and uncertainty played a role in shaping some of the great thinkers of the past.

Perhaps part of the answer lies in how our values have changed. The material sciences have taken center stage, while the humanities have gradually been pushed aside. Philosophy teaches us how to ask questions, challenge assumptions, and think critically. As this kind of thinking declines, perhaps we are producing more knowledge while asking fewer profound questions..


r/RealPhilosophy • • 1d ago

Given what we can only understand with reason, the existance of an eternal death makes everything pointless in this life.

0 Upvotes

On a macro-scale, your actions are pointless. You'll have influence and be remembered at most by your great-grandchildren. After this statement the first reaction might be "that's why I want to leave a stronger mark", men like Julius Caesar, Gandhi and Hitler will never be forgotten by humanity but humanity itself has lived and will only live an infinitesimal fraction of the eternity of the universe.

Then, alright, we've proven that living to leave a mark is pointless. But what about yourself, living matters to you and maybe the point of life is to simply live with your values this only chance your particular consciousness gets in this world.

This argument is particularly strong, the beauty of life is so blinding that I myself do not understand how I could ever argue such an extreme position.

But take the life of a farmer in 11th century: what was the point of his life, to live? All his work, all the reasons and the moments he struggled are gone for good for an infinite amount of time. If the sense of life is bound to you being, when you will be no more, that very sense you found so beautiful becomes valueless.

I didn't come here to just say that life has no meaning therefore we should just kill ourselves, because not even I would do that. I plan to continue this conversation with whoever is interested, because this is just the beginning. I feel like I found a beautiful chain that not only proves the point of life, but also shows why humans cannot grasp it so easily.

It's my first time on Reddit so I am not sure how it will work. I am looking for people to share my philosophy, which egoistically I believe is extremley original. I am ready to keep the discussion open to anyone who wants to argue with me.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 2d ago

Atheism, theism, pantheism and panentheism, none can be proven or disproven, but which is more "parsimonious" ? If atheism wins, which gets the 2nd place ?

0 Upvotes

As humans, we can only be sure of empirical data, however we also know that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, and disproving the existence of the divine is not factually possible.

Obliviously we know there is no human looking God above the clouds, and that a personal God would not be limited by what usually being a "personal" being entails.

But if we look at the main philosophical position of the history of philosophy, which is more "parsimonious" ?

By parsimonious I mean what would most likely be true in a probability sense, according to what we actually know, and according to the Occam Razor method.

Here are the main contenders.

Atheism) Assuming the divine and the supernatural are not real, everything works on its own through natural forces, and that our scientific knowledge could in the future reach a sufficent understanding of reality to expalin everything we did not explain already. Atheism necessarily assumes that some kind of reality existed since forever before the Big Bang, since nothing can appear at a point from nothing.

Theism) Assuming a conscious, self sufficient, unlimitedly powerful entity existed eternally until they created reality ex nihilo. They do not need to have caused the Big Bang, if we assume some form of reality existed before it, or to have done anything else other than the initial creation. And neither to be the God of any theistic existing religion.

Pantheism) Assuming that like in atheism reality in some form existed eternally, and Big Bang was the event that spurred change at a point, but also that reality is a monistic substance. Such substance can also be conscious (panpsychism) and, if we take some influence from Asian religion, the Big Bang might be just one event of an infinite cycle.

Panentheism) Assuming that there is a supreme reality that existed eternally like in theism, but also that phenomenal reality is part of it and is its manifest aspect. Unlike the God of theism, that is necessarily a conscious, distinct, external entity, this panentheistic entity can be an impersonal force, but it could also be conscious, which may or may not also mean reality itself is, like in panpsychist pantheism, conscious. Another difference is that in Panentheism reality is manifested continously and eternally, rather than having appeared at a point out of nothing. This means that, according to this view, like in Pantheism, our Universe may be one of an infinite cycle of Big Bangs and decay phases.

Which is more parsimonious ? If atheism wins, which comes second ?


r/RealPhilosophy • • 3d ago

Is Hedonism the best way of life?

3 Upvotes

It seems to me like every choice made as a society is based off of which option results in us having the most happiness in the end as a community. It seems as if happiness is the ultimate pursuit and top priority. many people point out the argument made by Robert Nozick—the experience machine. Where he asked, if you could permanently enter a machine, which you could experience whatever reality you want and never know that it wasn’t real. Would you do it? This would allow you to experience infinite happiness. if hedonism is the best way of life then the most rational option would be to enter the machine. yet most people choose not to enter the machine. this is a common argument against hedonism, where the claim is made that not wanting to enter this machine shows that we value more than just happiness, such as truth, doing, reality, creation,etc. however, I don’t think this is a very strong argument. Just because it feels irrational to enter the machine doesn’t justify it, or having a gut feeling that tells you something is wrong, it does not justify it. And it may be morally right to enter the machine. and as much as I’m trying to rationalize why we should value anything more than end result happiness, I can’t find a way to do this. My problem with this being true is it would justify it being better to live in a happy lie than a less happy truth. which feels completely absurd to me.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 3d ago

The Infinite Desire Paradox: If Humans Are Always Searching for more, Could That Be Because Something Infinite Exists?

4 Upvotes

Think abt human nature for a moment. We spend our lives chasing things. Money,success, relationships, knowledge, happiness, recognition, experiences, power. We convince ourselves that once we achieve the next big thing we'll finally feel complete.

But what happens when we get it?

We enjoy it for a while nd then another desire appears. Another mountain to climb. Another question to answer. Another boundary to cross. Even when almost everything we once dreamed of becomes reality, something inside us still asks What's next? Is this all there is?

And this makes me wonder about something much bigger.

Why does a finite being keep reaching for the infinite?

Here's where my thought gets interesting. If every natural desire has something in reality that corresponds to it, could our deepest longing for something beyond the finite world point towards a reality beyond our current understanding?

Perhaps what different civilizations and philosophies have called God, the Supreme Being, the Universal Consciousness, the Absolute, or the Ultimate Reality is humanity's attempt to understand that infinity.

Maybe the most interesting question isn't y humans want everything. Maybe it's y even after getting so much, we still feel that there's something beyond everything.

I'm interested in hearing both the theistic and atheistic perspectives. Challenge the argument, don't just dismiss it.

[ Anyway, these r just my 3:31 AM thoughts..Blame the sleep deprivation or maybe the universe.I'm still figuring that out..😅]


r/RealPhilosophy • • 4d ago

Passing time for nothing?

1 Upvotes

Humans are hardwired to produce as much dopamine as possible, which in turn makes time pass by faster.

Why do we do this? Do we subconsciously know what is on the other side, and we are trying to reach it as fast as possible, and we evolved to make to journey enjoyable?

We should enjoy life as it is, life is the only thing we know is real, there may not be anything waiting for us.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 7d ago

Reflecting on My Own Thoughts

3 Upvotes

Honestly, I’ve been thinking about many things lately, particularly about how we determine whether our own thoughts and beliefs are reasonable, justified, or mistaken.
One difficulty I’ve encountered is that I am the very person making these judgments. My reasoning, personal experiences, values, and biases may all influence the conclusions I reach. This makes me wonder: How can I objectively evaluate my own thoughts when I am also the one judging them?
How do you approach this problem?


r/RealPhilosophy • • 9d ago

How can we determine right from wrong when different perspectives all seem valid

25 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about the problem of conflicting perspectives in moral judgment. It often seems that looking at a situation from different angles can lead to completely different, yet logically sound, conclusions. If every perspective holds some validity, how do we establish a baseline to judge what is objectively right or wrong? Furthermore, how do we decide the correct course of action when caught between these competing viewpoints? I would appreciate hearing how different philosophical frameworks address this issue. **Any book recommendations on this topic would also be greatly appreciated.**


r/RealPhilosophy • • 8d ago

The price of interference: A Study of the lion and the Bird

2 Upvotes

“If you ask the grass, the zebra is the monster, and the lion is the protector. Yet the grass doesn't mention the steps of the lion because it is deemed a hero”

I am Nor the zebra or the lion, nor the grass; I am the bird that observes. Only when I fly down will I get the same treatment as the zebra, but I cannot blame the lion, for he does not control my actions; yet what I have done was deserved, because I was only the observer.

Yet the bird knows what's coming; the bird couldn't imagine the pain the zebra goes through when being eaten by a lion, and it is a small probability that the lion would go for the bird, as it is seen as a useless meal, something that wouldn't fill the lion's stomach. 

Although I am the bird, the observer, knowing the grass dislikes the zebra, the zebra dislikes the lion, and all approaches it. Yet, the grass did not acknowledge the zebra needing it to survive, just as the lion needed the zebra, as I was too close to contest. I ended up as a useless meal as well. 

While the zebra needs the grass to thrive, the birds will never be a meal; the only reason they'd be a meal is if the lion is hungry enough to waste its energy on such a small meal. The only reason a lion would do that is if it is slowly dying and wants one last meal before it dies, and yet even when the lions die, the birds and the grass shall eat the lion's decaying body, and after the lion has been eaten by the grass, the zebra will eat it. “The only thing that benefits us can be a hero to one and a villain to another”

Although the lion is dying, the bird and grass will not interfere as the king takes one last step, as he lays his head on the very thing that once praised him; the protector himself looks upon the zebra he once fed upon as he realizes in that very moment he was just a lion that wanted to survive, such as the zebra and grass as I, the bird, I will not contest anymore for what I know I could be there too, as the lion falls, I rise back into the sky being the observer, I am.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 10d ago

Kids owe their parents nothing. Parents owe the kid everything.

32 Upvotes

Person A lives in Mumbai. Person B lives in Hyderabad. B has never met A and doesn’t even know A exists. A does a task, call it X. Then A calls B and says: “I did task X, so now you’re obligated to do task Y.”

That makes zero sense. B never asked A to do X, never agreed to anything, and has no obligation to A.

Now suppose it’s the very nature of task X that once it’s done, task Y must be done by B. It’s still unfair. The nature of X doesn’t change who chose to do it. A chose X, so the consequences of X are A’s, no matter what X naturally leads to. B had no say in any of it.

Now replace A with the parent and B with the kid. The parent did the task (creating a life), and the outcome was a new person. Parents did the work, the outcome was a new life, and they can’t expect that new life to do anything. The kid owes nothing, and I mean not a single task. Everyone is a distinct individual, and two individuals can owe each other things, but nothing here makes the kid owe the parent.

What the parent imposes on the kid

Nothing about this was the kid’s choice. The imposition isn’t only the big things like going to school or marrying someone. Even if those bring happiness, or sadness, they are still imposed on the kid, because the kid never chose to exist in a world where those things happen.

It goes all the way down:

  • Existence itself. The kid’s life was imposed on them, and so was being a life form at all.
  • Breathing. The brainstem, mainly the medulla oblongata, generates the rhythm of breathing automatically. The kid never decided to breathe.
  • The heartbeat. The heart has its own built-in pacemaker cells that make it beat, and the medulla speeds it up or slows it down. The kid never decided that either.
  • Moving the body. Moving arms, even moving the pupils: the brain and nervous system run machinery the kid never asked for and cannot opt out of.
  • Everything that comes with it. Every need, risk, and limit exists because the parent acted and the kid never agreed.

And it doesn’t matter who the parent is. Even if a person with 10 trillion dollars has a kid, the kid’s life is still imposed by the parents. Wealth can change what the kid’s life contains, but it can’t remove the imposition.

The parent didn’t just do a task. The parent imposed a whole existence on someone who couldn’t say no. That is why the burden is on the parent and not on the kid.

The first burden: justification, before any oweness

Before the parents owe the kid anything, something comes earlier in time. Right after the parents have sex in order to have a baby, the burden of justification falls on them. Not after the kid is born, and not when the kid grows up and asks. Right at the act.

You may ask: justification to whom? The kid doesn’t even exist yet.

But justification doesn’t need a person to hear it. Justification is not an excuse, and it isn’t about protecting yourself from anyone. It is the natural reasoning behind an act. Every act should have a justification, because a justification is just the reason you did it. So the act of having a kid puts a burden of justification on the parent, and it comes way before in time than any oweness. First the parent justifies the act. Only then does the question of what they owe begin.

My principles

  1. The burden is on the parent. Duties come from your own acts. The parent did the act, so the duty is theirs, and the kid has none.
  2. Oweness doesn’t decay with time. The degree of owing is the same now as a month later. A 99-year-old father who created a son still owes him.
  3. No limits on the duty. If parents can’t fulfil it, the answer isn’t “the duty shrinks,” it’s “don’t have the kid.” If a task is extremely difficult or impossible and you still owe it because you did act X, then simply don’t do X.
  4. Acting is signing an unread contract. A should only act if he knows the consequences of the act. If he acts anyway, he has already accepted every possible permutation of it, read or not. He signed anyway.
  5. Kids should help parents, but that isn’t owing. We should help our parents in every possible way, out of love, but nothing is owed.

The conclusion: the kid owes nothing, the parents owe everything, and parents who can’t deliver shouldn’t have had the kid.

Attack it.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 11d ago

A different perspective can make your own problems easier to solve.

4 Upvotes

Recently came across Solomon's Paradox. Apparently, we're better at reasoning about other people's problems than our own.

Your friend gets heartbroken? You're a therapist.

You get heartbroken? Suddenly, common sense has left the chat.

But here's a thought.

What if we wrote our problems in third person? Instead of "I'm confused about my future," write "There's this guy who's confused about his future. What advice would you give him?"

Turns out psychology has a similar concept called self-distancing.

But here's what I'm wondering: If we know we're pretending, can we actually fool our brain into thinking more objectively?

Or will our emotions find a way to ruin that too?


r/RealPhilosophy • • 11d ago

Crime predictions by biological sample

4 Upvotes

Had an interesting thought experiment that I know is probably pretty deep and controversial but wanted to bounce it off this philosophy Reddit. Not trying to bait anyone but curious what conversations come of it (I know “Welcome to Reddit new guy!”)

If one day we could predict whether someone will engage in criminal activity by taking a biological sample - for example if someone had x amount of production of a certain hormone so therefore we predict with 99.999% certainty that they will kill someone - and we could determine this at birth, what action if any could or should be taken if any to prevent the murderers from murdering?

I know this seems bland and nonsensical. But I’ve heard arguments that pedophiles are predisposed to their attraction to children. So then I thought, do we actually know this? Shouldn’t we have to test everyone in the world to come to a finer conclusion? Which then led me to this thought experiment - what if there was one day a 100% mandatory test for pedophilia aptitude for all newborns ever and we find a strong correlation between a certain brain composition and the offense that it was undeniably certain? What would society do?

And I say this in light of AI because data is now more compiled and easily referenced and refined than ever with no end in sight to the ceiling of data science and our ability to track this data. In 10-20 years, I think it’s absolutely possible something like this could happen. Maybe not with crime but maybe with disease which would lead to great advances in medical science. But what about in the hands of the government that seeks instead to predict non compliant behavior?

Kind of a hodgepodge of thoughts… am I crazy or is this a philosophical question that we must address soon?


r/RealPhilosophy • • 12d ago

You’ve Died multiple times. Nobody (including you) cared.

0 Upvotes

Remember when you were you were a kid or had certain phases. Those were versions of you. They died, those ‘people’ (versions of you) have no ability to think or act anymore. They effectively died.

You likely haven’t given much thought to them nor remember much if anything from that person. You may have few memories some of which are fabricated.

When that version of you died they were replaced by you. It’s not really you though, some of the same memories, same or similar face.

Nobody remembers all the versions of you nor care.

You know nothing about you in 3 months, might be the same or completely different, you don’t know what he thinks nor if his the same as you rn. Effectively a random person replacing you.

Don’t let fear of death control you negatively.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 13d ago

Your duty and life’s purpose Philosophy

2 Upvotes

Life isn’t about living your best life. It’s about making each life that lives better than the one before it. Every life including your own eventually comes to an end. What truly matters more than you think is how you choose to live, what you choose to change, and what kind of future you leave behind for the people who come after you.

A thing to remember even if it take’s years from now that you understand it. A calling is a calling, a want is a want, and a need is a need. Sometimes there is something deeper within you that you cannot quite explain but you know you need to pursue it. If you feel that calling don’t be afraid to follow it. You don’t have to follow someone else’s expectations or what you feel will make you a slave to the machine or chase a future you don’t believe in. But understand that every opportunity you take, every chance you get, every lesson you learn, every effort you make, every future you imagine has a beautiful spark of potential to build something greater than yourself.

Don’t measure the value of your life by how much money you make or have, how many people know your name, or how much recognition you get. Measure it by what you contribute, what you teach, and the lives you touch, and most importantly what message you want to leave behind.

Learn enough to save a life. Have enough compassion to remind someone why their life matters. Then take it and share what you’ve learned so that others can do the same. Because the greatest impact you leave behind might not be something people associate with your name, but something that continues changing lives long after you’ve gone.

Whether you become rich in money or rich in life depends on the choices you make and the hard work you’re willing to put in. 

But always remember you don’t have to change the entire world to make a difference. Sometimes changing one person’s world is how something much bigger begins.

And what I want you to take away from my philosophy is that it’s not about who you are and how powerful you are or how wealthy you are  or famous you are, Power and money and fame can easily be erased or forgotten with enough time it’s about leaving behind something that will make a anther life better than your life and allow it to grow far beyond your own life until it inspires someone to do the same as you but better it.

Final statement “The end goal isn’t to have people follow in your footsteps forever, But to give them something worth building upon forever.”

Final quote “Live life to the fullest while leaving blue prints to a fuller one”

Thank you for reading my philosophy.

If you have any questions feel free to ask I’d love to see what people think of my philosophy.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 13d ago

Am I right? Or wrong? Utilitarianism and Kant

7 Upvotes

I'm a grad student and have two pretty basic questions on an exam that were scored in a way different from what I really think the answers ought to be. Reducing a complex topic to just a T or F statement isn't ideal, but here's what I'm working with:

1. Utilitarianism seeks to minimize harm for the greatest number of people. T or F

2. Immanuel Kant argued that we should never treat people as a means to an end. T or F.

  1. Although incomplete, this seems true. Utilitarianism holds that the right action is the one that produces the greatest overall good (or utility/happiness) for the greatest number of people affected. It focuses on the net balance of benefits over harms across everyone involved. So I marked true. The test says false.
  2. Immanuel Kant argued that we should never treat people merely as a means to an end. But that key word is omitted and it matters. Kant absolutely talks about times a person can be used as a means to an end ethically. "You may use a mason as a means to build a house, and a mason may use you as a means to obtain money." (Kant, the Feyerabend Lectures, Ak. 27:1319). I marked false. The exam says true.

Can you help me understand how I might be wrong? Or just let me know how you would have answered these?


r/RealPhilosophy • • 14d ago

Little Corruption Thesis ( it my first philosophy)

0 Upvotes

The Little Corruption Theorem deals with how individuals can become corrupt based on their differing philosophies to a group’s shared ideals. A group will have similar (but not necessarily identical) views on the world and will develop a set of principles to guide their actions. Individuals can be labelled corrupt or criminal if they discover loopholes, contradictions or weaknesses in the principles and act outside of the group’s philosophy. This may not necessarily mean that the individual acted against any moral truth but could be due to the group’s interpretation of morality.

However this brings up a bigger issue of moral truths. If moral is created by humans through experiences, agreements and interpretations can any one system claim to be the absolute truth? Whilst humans create principles, there may still be aspects of reality that aren’t made up. For example, whilst we create axioms, definitions and properties in maths, there isn’t necessarily any randomness in the conclusions we come to. We create mathematical systems but irrationality of √2 is an inevitable conclusion from the known properties of integers and rational numbers. Perhaps the universe has innate principles that we discover over time and create our own systems to represent.( it my first philosophy thesis my sorry if there any mistakes)

Sometimes the corruption seen by a group can just be an individual acting outside of the groups known philosophy. However this doesn’t mean that the individual is necessarily correct for finding a loophole. The main point is to question whether morality can be determined purely by consensus and try to understand the difference between principles created by humans and principles discovered in reality.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 15d ago

A Question About a Man and A Tree. Does Knowledge grant authority over existence?

2 Upvotes

I came up with this thought experiment or parable, if you can call it that, trying to understand something I was reading. I'm not much of a philosophical thinker so I'm hoping I can get some good input. It goes as follows:

A man plants an acorn and tends and nurtures it for its whole life. He studies it and records everything in notebooks and journals as it grows, noting every part of its life and growth. His notes are perfect and complete, down to the last cellular division. When he has finished, he cuts the tree down and lets it rot or burn, with no trace of the tree remaining.

The man then turns to the world around him. He studies every living and nonliving thing he comes across, observing, recording, and learning all he can. He ventures out into the wider world and does the same, again and again.

Once he has studied and recorded something, he destroys it. Whenever he comes across something he has already studied, he destroys it immediately and with indifference. His records of these things survive in his journals and notebooks.

Later, the man becomes a teacher, and his pupils learn from his studies of the world. By now he has destroyed everything that existed before him: rock, fish, and tree. Everything that inhabits the world now came into being after he finished his studies.

What, then, is the man? Does the tree have a life of its own, or is it permitted to live through the man’s dissemination of that tree?


r/RealPhilosophy • • 15d ago

Qu’en pensez-vous? Que devrais-je améliorer en ce qui concerne le style d’écriture?

3 Upvotes

Souvent, il me vient à l'esprit des termes, que je leur adresse tant d'interrogations. Dernièrement, l'expression "argument d'autorité"; l'expression est utilisée dans le champ scientifique pour désigner ce qu'un penseur, dans une discipline donnée, a comme avis ou pensées sur un sujet.
Je me rappelle d'une anecdote de mes années de scolarité, et qui, son souvenir, trace encore sur ma mine un léger sourire. Il n'y avait pas si longtemps un prof qui nous a enseigné la philosophie, et que je chérissais jusqu'à maintenant, ledit prof, un jour corrigeant un sujet d'examen, nous a prévenu de tenter définir les concepts philosophiques sans requérir et faire intervenir un "argument d'autorité", sa phrase, qui résonne encore en moi, je cite "qu'es-tu pour dire: je pense ceci ou cela à propos de tel ou tel concept".
Cette phrase, dans le moment, a fait éclater la classe de rire. Mais la voici après tant d'années m'interpelle.
Excusez moi ce détour, mais cette phrase est si nécessaire, fût-ce ridicule qu'elle soit. Par un effet réversible peut de même être posée à celui qui détient ce pouvoir d' "argument d'autorité", je dis pouvoir car il attribut à quelconque propos un poids argumentatif. J'ai un une part de vérité, infime qu'elle soit, parce que tel ou tel théoricien a pensé ainsi.
Tout cet illogisme, soulève en moi un tas de questions. Qu'est-ce qui donne un quelconque théoricien cette légitimité? Est-ce les années consacrées pour divulguer le phénomène en question? Ou bien son audimat et le nombre de lecteurs? Ou, si entretenant le sujet d'un point de vue rationnel, c'est la véracité de ses propos?
Et puis comment peut-on vérifier? lorsqu'il s'agit des sciences humaines, en l'occurrence la philosophie. Autant de concepts que la pluralité des définitions et de points de vue, les laisse au sort de l'indéterminé.
Rajoutant à tout ce que j'ai évoqué ci-avant, la vérité de la morale, ou de l'esthétique, etc... est-elle une? Ou c'est un agglomérat de vérité? Ou , tout simplement, il n'y en a aucune? Et finalement tous ces concepts restent captifs du relativisme.
Si l'on entretient les choses de ce point de vue, celui de la pluralité des vérités, et ce qui est le cas, alors "l'argument d'autorité" s'effondrera. Et je pourrais dire sur ces concepts-là ce que je pense réellement d'eux, sans m'intéresser sur ce que dit tel ou tel penseur.
Même si mon prof de philo d'antan ne souhaitera guère cette entreprise.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 15d ago

In a hard sense, if you believe there is no a priori knowledge, why?

10 Upvotes

To me it seems perfectly rational to hold that there are truths that can be known a priori. Take the law of non contradiction. This can be understood by the definitions of words (this word means its definition, not the definition of another word).