r/reddeadredemption • • 5d ago

Q&A /r/RedDeadRedemption Weekly Question & Answer Thread - Week 46, 2026

3 Upvotes

All common questions about the game should be directed here. This includes both single-player and online questions. When asking a question, it is often beneficial to share which mode you are referring to in order to get an accurate response. Also consider sharing any relevant information that may help someone answer your question.

All story spoilers must be displayed with the proper format:

>!RDR is a great game!<

gives you:

RDR is a great game

If you're not sure if you should use a spoiler tag or not, err on the side of caution and use one. Also, it's a nice gesture to visibly indicate the general nature of your spoiler before the tag, so people know what you're spoiling.


Submit Red Dead Online feedback here


r/reddeadredemption • • 2h ago

Screenshot May I Stand Unshaken

Post image
324 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption • • 11h ago

Picture My High Honour Bic

Post image
414 Upvotes

Found it at a gas station and it reminded me of my boy Arthur! It’s been my favourite ever since!


r/reddeadredemption • • 6h ago

Speculation What if Red Dead Redemption and GTA actually exist in the same universe, but there's a twist nobody has really considered?

181 Upvotes

I have a theory that the events of Red Dead Redemption actually happened in the GTA universe, but the games themselves are based on fictional novels written by Jack Marston.

1. Jack Marston, the author

At the end of RDR1, Jack shows a strong interest in literature and writing. He even dreams of becoming a writer.

Now, in GTA V, there's a book titled Red Dead written by "J. Marston" in Franklin's house.

What if J. Marston is actually Jack Marston?

What if he eventually fulfilled his dream and wrote a novel about his family's history and the dying days of the Wild West?

2. Red Dead Redemption as a historical novel

This could explain why certain locations and details in RDR are different from the GTA universe.

Perhaps Jack changed the names of certain places, characters, and events when writing his novel.

In other words, the Red Dead games could be depicting the events of a historical novel written by someone who actually experienced that era.

3. The mysterious banknote in GTA VI

In GTA VI's trailer, we can spot a banknote featuring President Hardin and Thaddeus Waxman, two figures associated with the Red Dead universe.

This is particularly interesting because it suggests that these historical figures might also exist in GTA's version of American history.

4. The Cowboy's Prayer Is to Die Young

This might be the most interesting piece of evidence.

In GTA VI, there's a book titled The Cowboy's Prayer Is to Die Young, written by Elijah G. Rubens.

The book references several locations and characters from Red Dead Redemption, including:

New Austin Armadillo, Blackwater, Mexico, Flaco Hernández. It even references Flaco's death, which is directly connected to the events of RDR2.

What if these aren't just random Easter eggs, but references to actual historical events in the GTA universe?

Here's what I believe:

The events of Red Dead Redemption actually happened in the GTA universe. Jack Marston eventually became a writer and documented his family's history through novels. However, he might have fictionalized certain names, locations, and details. The Red Dead games, then, are essentially adaptations of those novels. This would explain why Rockstar can include references to Red Dead in GTA without necessarily showing the exact same world or geography.

Wdyt? I think it's an interesting possibility worth discussing.


r/reddeadredemption • • 9h ago

Picture On my way to save Micah from hanging, wish me luck.

Post image
147 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption • • 12h ago

Fan Art I crocheted Charles Smith from RDR2!

Thumbnail
gallery
224 Upvotes

I crocheted Charles Smith! I did this project over the summer and realized I never posted him. So the last two photos are Charles next to my Christmas tree, months after I completed him LOL.

Regardless I’m incredibly happy with how he turned out, this was my first attempt at crocheting long hair for one of my characters! Charles is hands down my favorite RDR2 character, I find him incredibly cool. Hope I did him justice! :)


r/reddeadredemption • • 1h ago

Picture This paint spill looks like a cowboy

Post image
28 Upvotes

Is the universe sending me signs?


r/reddeadredemption • • 10h ago

Speculation That’ll do Dutch, that’ll do

Post image
93 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption • • 13h ago

Screenshot I did it

Post image
122 Upvotes

I’ve never posted in here before but I’ve used loads of good posts to achieve this so thank you everybody and now I can finally play GTA VI


r/reddeadredemption • • 1d ago

Picture Average RDR fan without a PS5 while everybody else is playing GTA VI.

Post image
4.7k Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption • • 21h ago

Question Some guy just offered to pay for ANY gun in the Valentines gun smiths. I’ve been told the Springfield rifle is a good choice but not sure. Any suggestions?

Post image
295 Upvotes

This is my first play through so idk what’s best.
((EDIT)): I chose the Springfield. Very good gun. One tapped a bison with it.


r/reddeadredemption • • 8h ago

Discussion Favorite antagonization lines?

25 Upvotes

Mines gotta be "Ya sour old HAG" to susan, and "Ya goddamn maggot!" ive heard that last one countless times but it never ceases to make me laugh


r/reddeadredemption • • 18h ago

Video In-game benchmark has John instead of Arthur after you finish the game

168 Upvotes

Was trying out optiscaler's frame gen when I noticed this.

Couldn't find anything about this on Google.


r/reddeadredemption • • 9h ago

Fan Art Arthur sketch I did

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption • • 46m ago

PSA Update On The OpenRevolver & Red Dead Revolver Reimagined Projects.

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Hey, everyone.

Since my last update on the projects, I discussed that we'd be heading one of 2 ways, developing OpenRevolver into a Mod Manager or working on Red Dead Revolver Reimagined. I'm now announcing that both projects are being planned out, with OpenRevolver already having way more work done on it to be compatible with the new TGP Xbox Recomp.

We've added a Game Start Config menu where you can Toggle some features we're building in such as "Enhanced Combat" which adds a natural zoom to aiming on weapons, slide & taking cover, fixing headshots that don't instantly kill enemies etc. For some of these features, you can Toggle off or on individual parts of their functions to optimise your experience. We've also added a way for you to port the RDR1 Character Models Into RDR1. The screenshots I have for you are admittedly a bit old now(the subtitles and necks are fixed) compared to the progress thats been made, and many things still need to be fixed.

Here is a list of features "Game Start Config" will include.

-Enhanced Combat

-RDR1 Characters

-RDR1 UI

-Waves and Safe Mode for Showdown

-Showdown With Story Levels

- Multiplayer/Splitscreen Story Mode

-New Game+

-Playstation Controller UI(still also has some bugs)

-Remove Grain

-Remove Blur

-Cheat Menu

-Photo Mode

-Built-in Trainer

Built-in Mods

- Wardrobe/Tailor

Enter the Tailor in Brimstone, talk to the Tailor before opening up a wardrobe with your character and a list of outfits to scroll through(as of right now the only outfits are the coloured variants from Showdown.

- Expanded Bounties

After clearing out a gang hideout(Twin Rocks, Widow's Patch, Fairgrounds, Rogue Valley etc), a new "gang" and their leader takes over the hideout. The player/players can go to a Bounty Board in Brimstone and start a mission to clear out the Hideout before cashing out. The stores also randomly stock up on new items and weapons.

- Online Multiplayer

Play Showdown or Story Mode with online friends.

Red Dead Revolver Reimagined

Red Dead Revolver Reimagined is going to be a much much larger project and OpenRevolver is laying the very early foundation of what we're going to be using to help with modding the original game and planning for how we're gonna translate the Original Red Dead Revolver into Red Dead Redemption.

The Discord server has not been made yet but I'm going to be releasing a trailer for OpenRevolver I may include it but I might release it earlier on github incase people wanna mess around with it. The Discord is going to be made once I have the confidence that there's gonna be a large number of people who want to see this and want to contribute with their 3D Modelling or Modding experience.

That's all I have for this update but I will be releasing more updates soon.


r/reddeadredemption • • 1h ago

Discussion Playing on 65' TV has changed my opinions entirely on RDR2

4 Upvotes

I'm on my second playthrough (Still playing on PC) but i setup my pc to my new TV and man what a gamechanger seriously, if you've only played this game on a 24' monitor like i have, i highly advise you to replay, because this game is MEANT for a tv experience, 4k 60fps with HDR is just so nice, like at points im just like wow this is a game.... and actually being able to soak in the game & environment is something really new that i didn't really realize when i first played a couple years ago.


r/reddeadredemption • • 14h ago

Discussion I was able to ride The Count

Post image
41 Upvotes

I'm really not too sure how. It was my first playthrough, chapter 2 or 3 I believe? I didn't really know I wasn't supposed to, and I told a feller a while back I was able to and he didn't believe me. I didn't think it was unusual so I said nothing or recorded it.

Now I'm thinking it was at Clemens point, I rode him by the braithwaite manor and cannot for the life of me remember what else. I think I crashed and didn't like him so rode my main horse instead.

Has anyone else been able to do this?? This was a few months back now so I don't remember what point in chapter 3 I was able to so I can't help anyone do it beyond this lol


r/reddeadredemption • • 16h ago

Discussion Why is RED DEAD free?

Post image
63 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption • • 1h ago

Video Got absolutely wrecked! 😬

3 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption • • 2h ago

Picture Just me and a local eugenics supporter waiting for the train

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/reddeadredemption • • 1d ago

Picture Sandstorm shot

Post image
338 Upvotes

I was sniping them lobos then a sandstorm came,

Got to farm some aura first before continuing.

Okay, I'll talk to you later then.


r/reddeadredemption • • 4h ago

Discussion should the main character die in rdr3?

4 Upvotes

now personally i kinda hope they move away from the van der linde gang (otherwise we’d just know if the mc died or not) but i also feel like if they just make the mc die after doing it the past 2 times it’d be sort of predictable and potentially hold less emotional impact. besides, you don’t have to die to redeem yourself, you could just commit an act of redemption. i think maybe the high honor ending should be staying alive or something but then the low honor one should be them dying, idk tho


r/reddeadredemption • • 4h ago

Rant Arabian Couple

4 Upvotes

Got an Arabian Pair. Both tamed myself from the wild. I wish there is a feature to breed them and see what kind of baby we get.


r/reddeadredemption • • 1d ago

Question Question regarding Mr. Black and Mr. White.

Post image
877 Upvotes

I went to Rhodes cuz the map said there's a bounty mission, but I met these two outside of town first, and I got the mission to remove their posters.

If I went to town first, would I have gotten the mission to capture these 2?
Or could I have turned them in to the law?