news Justice Sotomayor signals support for Supreme Court term limits
r/scotus • u/orangejulius • Jan 30 '22
Let's clear up some ambiguities about banning and this subreddit.
On Politics
Political discussion isn't prohibited here. In fact, a lot of the discussion about the composition of the Supreme Court is going to be about the political process of selecting a justice.
Your favorite flavor of politics won't get you banned here. Racism, bigotry, totally bad-faithed whataboutisms, being wildly off-topic, etc. will get you banned though. We have people from across the political spectrum writing screeds here and in modmail about how they're oppressed with some frequency. But for whatever reason, people with a conservative bend in particular, like to show up here from other parts of reddit, deliberately say horrendous shit to get banned, then go back to wherever they came from to tell their friends they're victims of the worst kinds of oppression. Y'all can build identities about being victims and the mods, at a very basic level, do not care—complaining in modmail isn't worth your time.
COVID-19
Coming in here from your favorite nonewnormal alternative sub or facebook group and shouting that vaccines are the work of bill gates and george soros to make you sterile will get you banned. Complaining or asking why you were banned in modmail won't help you get unbanned.
Racism
I kind of can't believe I have to write this, but racism isn't acceptable. Trying to dress it up in polite language doesn't make it "civil discussion" just because you didn't drop the N word explicitly in your comment.
This is not a space to be aggressively wrong on the Internet
We try and be pretty generous with this because a lot of people here are skimming and want to contribute and sometimes miss stuff. In fact, there are plenty of threads where someone gets called out for not knowing something and they go "oh, yeah, I guess that changes things." That kind of interaction is great because it demonstrates people are learning from each other.
There are users that get super entrenched though in an objectively wrong position. Or start talking about how they wish things operated as if that were actually how things operate currently. If you're not explaining yourself or you're not receptive to correction you're not the contributing content we want to propagate here and we'll just cut you loose.
Having a license to practice law is not a license to be a jackass. Other users look to the attorneys that post here with greater weight than the average user. Trying to confuse them about the state of play or telling outright falsehoods isn't acceptable.
Thankfully it's kind of rare to ban an attorney that's way out of bounds but it does happen. And the mods don't care about your license to practice. It's not a get out of jail free card in this sub.
Signal to Noise
Complaining about the sub is off topic. If you want the sub to look a certain way then start voting and start posting the kind of content you think should go here.
The current mod list has been here for years and have been the only active mods. We have become more hands on over the years as the users have grown and the sub has faced waves of problems like users straight up stalking a female journalist. The sub's history isn't some sort of Norman Rockwell painting.
Am I going to get banned? Who is this post even for, anyway?
Probably not. If you're here, reading about SCOTUS, reading opinions, reading the articles, and engaging in discussion with other users about what you're learning that's fantastic. This post isn't really for you.
This post is mostly so we can point to something in our modmail to the chucklefuck that asks "why am I banned?" and their comment is something inevitably insane like, "the holocaust didn't really kill that many people so mask wearing is about on par with what the jews experienced in nazi germany also covid isn't real. Justice Gorsuch is a real man because he no wears face diaper." And then we can send them on to the admins.
r/scotus • u/orangejulius • Jan 09 '26
This is SCOTUS. Talk about scotus. Talk about the opinions issued. If you want to criticize them that’s fine but have something to back it up.
Complaining about “tRump”, trump, motorhomes, “scrotus”, or any other number of things where you react to something instead of respond to something isn’t going to fly. The bar is very low. Almost all of you are tripping over it.
r/scotus • u/novagridd • 1d ago
r/scotus • u/FollowingFeisty5321 • 18h ago
This hearing on January 11 will determine if you can be held in contempt for violating the "spirit" of an injunction. This week the last amicus curiae briefs were filed, so now there are a handful in support of reversing the contempt and a handful in support of upholding it.
Apple was held in contempt for violating a court order that prohibited them from banning apps having links or buttons to 3rd party payments in competition with their own In-App Purchases from which they collect a 30% fee. Apple circumvented this injunction by creating a 27% fee that, with transaction fees on top, made using 3rd party payments more expensive than their own In-App Purchases and implemented policies and mechanisms to ensure the links and buttons were ineffective if implemented. The effect was no developer implemented third party payments.
The core issue for Apple is the fee on IAP, they collect $10+ billion/year in fees from apps and to sustain that they need third party payments to yield a comparable fee if they must be allowed. Reversing the contempt would allow them to collect a maximal fee on 3rd party payments to the threshold of a non-prohibitive fee, which they argue in a related remand proceeding is 15%. Upholding their contempt could see them left with a lesser fee or no fee at all, as the 9th circuit appeal ruling recommended basing it on their costs incurred when apps use third party payments, which turned out to be nonexistent. So for Apple the stakes are very high.
Apple argues the contempt should be reversed because the fee was not explicitly prohibited by the text of the injunction. Various amicus curiae have posted in support arguing contempt requires a clear textual violation and without that there was "fair ground of doubt" Apple's conduct violated the injunction at all.
The DOJ, who will speak for 10 minutes during the hearing, support neither party. They argued that punishing the "spirit" of injunctions would adversely affect anyone subject to injunctions including the United States. They note contempt can be warranted within the context of rulings, but take no position on whether that is applicable to this instance.
Epic argues Apple mischaracterized the ruling, that the court found the prohibitive effect of the 27% fee violated the text of the injunction which was upheld on appeal. Various amicus curiae have posted in support of upholding the contempt, arguing that the text of the injunction must not be read in isolation but in the context of the ruling which was to allow third party payments in competition with Apple's IAP, that legalizing circumvention would render injunctions unenforceable, that an abundance of precedence punished similar circumvention, and that Apple's perjury, falsifying evidence and abuse of document privilege to conceal their plans eliminate any possibility of "fair ground of doubt".
r/scotus • u/bloomberg • 1d ago
r/scotus • u/Jumpy-Mix-9078 • 3d ago
I misunderstood the meaning of this poster, but I agree let’s pack SCOTUS! For Spidey!
r/scotus • u/Person_756335846 • 2d ago
r/scotus • u/Film_Lab • 3d ago
An analysis of Supreme Court confirmations across US history shows how the power to shape the court has been distributed among presidents.
r/scotus
•
u/Achilles_TroySlayer
•
4d ago
r/scotus • u/DoremusJessup • 4d ago
r/scotus • u/thedailybeast • 4d ago
r/scotus • u/Person_756335846 • 4d ago
Very excited to see this go to SCOTUS soon.
r/scotus • u/RawStoryNews • 5d ago
r/scotus
•
u/Used_Intention6479
•
5d ago
r/scotus • u/Fickle-Ad5449 • 5d ago
r/scotus • u/Person_756335846 • 3d ago
r/scotus • u/RawStoryNews • 7d ago
r/scotus • u/thenewrepublic • 8d ago
Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito is complaining about “abuse” of power.
r/scotus • u/RawStoryNews • 8d ago
r/scotus • u/dpcthpost • 8d ago
Alito would rather eliminate the supreme court than abide by an election. WTF??