r/ShouldIbuythisgame • u/Blyskacz • 1h ago
What to choose: Onimusha: Way of the Sword or Phantom Blade: 0 (Or something else???)?
First of all. I don't want to comparison "Which game is better" (as it is usually popularity contest). I am looking more: "What is gonna be more for my taste"- that's why I will try to describe my taste first. Of course if you think if you compare: "Omnimusha because it has better X or Y and it seems like it is important for you" that's great.
I like Action Adventure Games and Action RPG (I rarely finish them, but I like them ;) ). In terms of games which may be somehow similar to Omnimusha and Phantom Blade:
Elden Ring - to be honest I liked it to some extent but I am not a fan. I like when story is more explicit to be honest. Also in terms of fighting system I didn't like that I felt that "ok now roll, roll, roll, wait for the window, attack once or twice, repeat" with every boss. Also even if I changed weapons etc. I didn't feel very different while playing. I didn't feel that I am learning new moves etc.
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice- I really liked it, parrying system was snapy, there were some elements which I like in Action RPGs (gaining new moves), story was more explicit than in souls. I even felt that during the fight I have more options than in Elden Ring, like I don't have to be so "defensive" If I don't want too. Flow of the fight was great. Finished this one.
Nioch 3: Combat system is great, every weapon has own skill tree. In terms of combat it is masterpiece. What I don't like: Mechanics are pretty hard to grasp to be honest, magic is strong, but looks very boring in terms of visuals, story "IS THERE" and that's all. I felt that it is there only because it has to have some story. ;) Also I feel that game starts to be "real" with NG+ and I rarely go this far.
Lies of P: I finished this one. It was very similar to Elden Ring in terms of fighting system, but it has story which is pretty interesting, also I felt that I can be more proactive during fights.
Black Myth: Wukong - I loved that I can learn new moves, how I could just my style of fight (because 3 "trees" for fighting with stick were very different. Graphic was good, atmosphere was great. I didn't finish it for some reason (probably as always, I started playing some multiplayer shit again). I liked that fighting is fluid if you know what I mean.
Valor Mortis: first half of the game was fun, but second part was boring (0 new enemies, 1 transmutation clearly OP, parrying less useful at the end).
Assasins Cread's (the one in Egypt and Viking one) - I really liked that there are skills/ moves to learn but it started to be very easy and not engaging because of it. I usually had some lvl and was going to the bossess above my lvl to see that they are easy to beat but it just take a lot of time because of lvl difference.
Witcher 3- great story, world etc. but fighting and character customization (only swords, boring skill trees) switched me off.
Cyberpunk 2077- I love this one, but it is mostly shooting game, so probably not the best for comparison.
Control Resonant- Great world, I love it. Fighting is funny for me, but pretty easy too (even with bosses), I am at the start of the game I think (3 or 4 resonants beaten). I see leveling powers, weapons and skills is funny and gives nice options and you feel progression very well.
Looking at both games It seems like Phantom Blade is faster, gives you more options, but also seems pretty easy (from what I see in gamplays, I didn't play), graphic is pretty, fights are snappy and very fluid. On the other hand Omnimusha seems to have more developed combat system which gives you more interesting options (but again, only from some gameplays).
What do you think, which one I should try first?