r/solarenergy • u/DeepSpacePilgrim • 14h ago
Technology Thought Stream: Tracking Adoption
(At Reddit's suggestion, this is being posted here after an initial posting in another sub.)
Open line of thinking.
Sources: recent graduate work (primary), Clayton Christensen's "The Innovator's Dilemma"
Note on sources: These are simply the resources motivating this stream of thought--it should not be assumed that deeper investigation into these sources will result in a stronger argument. It may be true there is content forgotten by the user making this post which, once revisited, would invalidate assumptions.
Summary of note: Do not regard this post as scientific fact. Do your homework.
Solar Physics
- From the perspective of a fixed point on a planet's surface, the sun traverses the sky. The angle of incidence between the face of a fixed panel and incoming solar rays will change with time.
- There is a relationship between the magnitude of the angle of incidence and a panel's electrical production. (The precision of this change is presently unknown to the user making this post, but is assumed to be ascertainable with minimal effort.)
PV Panels
The largest source of waste over the life of a PV project is the panels.
- Material production is sufficiently advanced that avenues exist where the structures upon which to mount the PV panels can be produced with minimal material waste.
- Based on a polling of datasheets and public statement, industry has unofficially adopted lifespans of 20-30 years for panels.
- Question: Is this any sort of formal requirement? Is there presently any legal guardrail that says "you cannot mass produce solar panels with lifespans less than (#) years."?
Economic assumption: Given the ecological impact of production and the cost associated with re-paneling (parts & labor), a panel with less than a 20 year lifespan is presently not a viable input to a PV project intended for local electricity production for a residence or commercial/industrial installation.
- Question: what is the likelihood of seeing a panel with a 40-50 year useful lifespan?
Tracking
- Comes in multiple configurations ranging from single- to multi-axis and with passive to active.
- Presently shows greater benefit further from the equator.
- Increases daily production by as much as 30%.
Inclusion of electro-mechanical sub-systems greatly increases capital cost. This can be seen using the "three legs" model:
- Performance: increases. More electricity is produced over the course of a day.
- Cost: increases. The system necessary to achieve greater daily production is more complex.
- Time: decreases. For a given array size at a given location, the tracking machine can achieve a specified kWh value in fewer days than a fixed-position assembly.
- Tracking machines have increased O&M costs stemming from the use of actuators, sensors, and electronics.
- Question: What is the groundwork cost difference between a fixed-position assembly and a tracking machine?
- A tracking machine may reduce the overall footprint of a system for a specified kWh production.
Storage
Though battery storage is not required for system operation, even small storage capacity greatly enhances usefulness by providing two functions:
- Electricity in excess of normal demand (where "normal demand" is the electricity required to operate connected loads) can be used to charge the battery.
- In times when production is insufficient to meet normal demand, the battery can subsidize the PV input to satisfy normal demand.
The effectiveness of a given battery for a system can be characterized by answering the following questions:
- What is the relationship of the battery's usable capacity to the normal demand?
What is the relationship of the battery's usable capacity to the system's excess electricity production?
- What is the relationship of the battery's charge rate to the duration during which excess electricity is produced?
- How many charge/discharge cycles are specified for the battery?
- What are the fire suppression requirements for the battery?
Like PV panels themselves, significant thought should be given to the sustainability of the battery. This extends beyond the charge/discharge cycles and may be characterized with questions like:
- Is a battery that does not require fire suppression more sustainable than one that does?
- What is the toxic content of the battery?
- How easy is the battery to recycle?
Using the bullet points above, the following is considered:
- A tracking system is not likely to compete where the philosophy of 'just add more panels' is seen as an acceptable alternative. If panel consumption has no limit in the eyes of the developer/owner, there is little incentive to adopt a tracker.
It may be useful to do a comparison of the number of panels necessary over a project's life. For instance, if a tracking machine requires 16 panels to meet a given specification and a fixed-position system requires 20, the fixed-position system will require these additional 4 panels every time it's re-paneled.
- This alone is not likely to produce a silver bullet for tracker adoption, but it could be useful planning information.
- It should be considered that the benefits of increasing array size is still constrained by the other system components, which all have electrical ratings. Increasing panels in series raises the bus voltage and components (most notably the inverter) have a specified maximum voltage. Increasing panels in parallel increases bus current, which impacts conductor and overcurrent protection sizing.
Might be more to come. Just wanted to get all this out of my head.





