r/teaching • • 23d ago

General Discussion Weekly Discussion: Sold a Story -- Episode 4

18 Upvotes

The mods let me know I could make a weekly discussion post about the new podcast season.

From the Sold a Story Podcast Website:

What Happened to Teaching

It's not just reading. The new season of Sold a Story takes on teaching itself — what makes teaching effective and why a method with a remarkable record of success never caught on.

Direct Instruction was created in the 1960s by Siegfried "Zig" Engelmann, a former steelworker and advertising man with no background in education. He designed a highly structured program that helped children from disadvantaged backgrounds make striking academic gains.

But even after a massive government study showed his program worked better than anything else researchers tested, many educators rejected it. Today, the National Institute for Direct Instruction estimates fewer than 200 schools use the program with all their students.

In Sold a Story's second season, Emily Hanford investigates what happened to Direct Instruction — and why deeply held beliefs about education often triumph over evidence.

Today, episode 4 "What can you do for my black children?" is out.

In a poor, Black neighborhood in Houston, Principal Thaddeus Lott transforms a struggling elementary school with Direct Instruction. Soon, his students are outperforming students at much wealthier schools. The results are so remarkable, some people think it’s too good to be true.

What did you all think of the episode or the season so far? What did you think of the last season? I'll give my thoughts later in the comments.


r/teaching • • Jan 20 '25

The moderation team of r/teaching stands with our queer and trans educators, families, and students.

1.2k Upvotes

Now, more than ever, we feel it is important to reiterate that this subreddit has been and will remain a place where transphobia, homophobia, and discrimination against any other protected class is not allowed.

As a queer teacher, I know firsthand the difference you make in your students' lives. They need you. We need you. This will always be a place where you're allowed to exist. Hang in there.


r/teaching • • 4h ago

Help Getting silence when they're mid-task – what actually works?

7 Upvotes

Student teacher here. I'm working on behaviour management, well, classroom management really, and the thing I keep getting stuck on is getting silence.
I use countdowns and they work some of the time. But my lessons are quite hands-on, so once the class is busy and chatting, getting everyone to actually stop and listen is another matter. Some of them stop. Most of them don't, or not straight away.
So what do you actually do in the moment? And how do you bring them back halfway through a busy practical task without losing the momentum of the lesson?
Would really appreciate any real-world tips. Thanks!


r/teaching • • 14h ago

General Discussion Nicotine pouches?

23 Upvotes

It took a lot, but I finally kicked cigs a few years ago and replaced them with pouches. I’ve had one in every single day for the past 4 years and have never been questioned. I can confidently say they are 1000% invisible. I definitely wish all this was not the case, but now I’m wondering if I’m the only person stuck here.

I mean back in the day teachers used to smoke in class. I don’t agree with that, but the way I see it, as long as the kids & coworkers DO NOT FIND OUT, it’s… not hurting anyone? Except me? Obviously do not want to be caught red handed, but it works for getting me through the day, and I think I’m alright at my job. Am I alone here? I don’t vape or anything just for clarification.


r/teaching • • 5h ago

Help How can I be teacher in and public high school? Being from Spain ?

2 Upvotes

I’m trying to move from Spain to another country and as a career and a teacher and I’m just trying to search for jobs and whatever in around the world but to work as a teacher, but I don’t really find nothing so I was just like someone can help me how to work in Switzerland as a teacher or in Australia or Canada


r/teaching • • 16h ago

Help Like Teaching but Scared to Commit

7 Upvotes

So I've been getting involved in my university's Reading Club where we have mentors (me) lead reading groups with ESL students to help them learn English and reading skills.

Honestly, it's one of the few joys of my week where I get to stretch my theater kid and gifted kid muscle, narrating the stories in an engaging voice and challenging my mentees to think critically about the text — relating paragraphs back to the title of the story, understanding the role specific paragraphs play, helping them learn new English words, etc. It's a great time to make reading/English fun and approachable, and I feel like I'm probably the most animated mentor in the club, though that may be my autism showing.

Something about this teaching experience seems to bring out the best in me in ways other things I've tried can't. It helps bring out this socialness and competence out of me. I thought that if teaching can bring out this life in me, then that would be a good direction to work towards. I live a relatively modest life and don't care about being rich. I just care about not succumbing to the throes of depression in other job roles I've worked at. Truly nasty stuff where I just stare into space not able to move a muscle for like an hour even when attempting to live a physically healthy life with medication (again, might just be my autism showing).

The problem is that I hear all the time about how teaching is only for a specific type of character who can manage the worst students and all the behind-the-scene things that people are not aware of. It makes me anxious and question if I'm making the right choice in wanting to pursue teaching, but the thing is that my experience working with the ESL students has given me more life than anything I've tried before.

I'm worried that I'm not "that character" who can survive (and hopefully thrive) in teaching. I'm worried that I'm only exposed to the cream of the crop and that I'm setting myself up for failure when I leave this club and do "real" teaching.


r/teaching • • 11h ago

General Discussion High School PBIS rewards?

2 Upvotes

Do rewards work in high school? I haven’t found research that targeted grades 9-12 (in the US).

I’m on the committee developing our PBIS matrix and plan. Basically, everyone on the committee is skeptical about the reward element of PBIS. I’m wondering if any high schools have found successful ways to implement this part of a PBIS strategy. Is there research that I’m not finding that studied grades 9-12 independent from lower grades?


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Humor when my students ask if im playing gta vi

Post image
84 Upvotes

they know i game lol. and i started playing hkia again after the newest update and have been genuinely grinding hahaha


r/teaching • • 13h ago

Vent Testing Drama

1 Upvotes

Gave a long test today to level 1 language class. One student tried turning it in within 8-10 minutes and kept repeatedly commenting he was done even after my marking his paper twice to have him focus on unanswered work (IEP student). Kept demanding the writing prompt instead though but he finally did the first section. Where the drama occurred is my having said something that gave my admin ammunition to come after me by saying that the kid would get a zero for the writing prompt work (had momentarily confused him with someone else in earlier class who looks like this kid) and done what I asked first student about). My admin has been on me with targeted harrassment since September (I am new here though experienced) and literally everything I do the principal documents and finds fault with... and didn't help that he came in this morning unannounced to observe the earlier class (the one where the kid is who had the actual issue).

I am beyond exhausted defending myself constantly with overloaded class sizes, admin who does not respect or support me at all, trying to get out and find something else beyond this school and some of the worst behavior I've seen in over 30 years - and ridiculously demanding kids/parents expecting instant grading/results 24/7 regardless of when work is handed in. Everything I am trying and doing to cope is having limited results and I want out so much but can't afford to leave (single teacher).


r/teaching • • 22h ago

Curriculum Looking for elementary math series input

0 Upvotes

Good morning all. Second grade teacher here, our school uses McGraw Hill My Math but will be switching next year. We’ve had PD and received samples from a few options but I’d love real teacher feedback on what you use.

Things we are looking for that My Math lacks:
-spiral review- we have to supplement heavily in this area
-strong number sense foundation
-it’s just.. boring at times. Very slow moving in some ways.

Programs we are considering:
-Eureka math
-IXL
-Amplify
-IM Math

All of these seem to be very different in their approach from what we are doing now with My Math. I would love to hear the good and the bad about any of these! Thanks.


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Humor I’m a teacher with short leg issues

Post image
8 Upvotes

Sister is pregnant but I could have told her the potty stool for free


r/teaching • • 1d ago

General Discussion Some positive aspects?

18 Upvotes

I’m finishing up my bachelors degree right now and preparing to get my teaching license. I am very passionate about this career, but I only ever hear about the difficult parts of it from people around me. I know it’s a hard job, I know it doesn’t pay the most. I’m starting to get really bogged down by all the negativity :( Teachers, please share your favorite parts of the job!


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Career Change/Interviewing/Job Advice Switching from Special Education to General Education (or vice versa)

5 Upvotes

I’m currently a special education teacher in middle school. I have started to burn out on all the paperwork - not the IEPs (which I am generally fine with after four years), but the staffing, functional behavior assessments, behavior plans, applying for unique accommodations, etc. I know “the grass is always greener” but I also feel like I need at least a year or two without all the paperwork.

I’m aware that general education is not by any means “easier,” but I am very interested at trying my hand at a job that does not require this many forms and deadlines, while being a jack of all trades running around campus putting out fires. I love math and am particularly interested in teaching middle or high school math. I daydream about having my own space and actually teaching content. (ETA am also certified in math.)

Your stories would be much appreciated!


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Vent Frustrated. Miserable. All The Things.

6 Upvotes

As the title says, I’m absolutely over it. I have a Masters degree in education from a top school in the country. Taught for two years but left the field to do my dream job. If I would’ve taught for one more year, I would’ve had my certification. I thought the dream job would be endgame for me but my health said otherwise. So, back to teaching I went. I’m good at it. I enjoy it. However, I forgot how bad the bureaucracy is.

In my new state, they don’t look at your degree(s) to see if you’ve taken the required courses they need. If you don’t have your certification then you HAVE to take courses at their state institutions.

Mind you, I was starting my doctorate but between first year back teaching, these certification classes, and the doctorate, something had to give. So, I withdrew from the doctorate program. Now, I owe them thousands for changing my mind. I’ve always hated the fact that I have to take courses I’ve already taken and received A’s in again. It’s really eating at me right now because I shouldn’t have to do this, especially when I have to pay for it on top of paying my Masters off. The classes being asynchronous help but it’s so much work and I keep saying “I’ve done this, I’ve done this”. I want my time and my life back

I’m also upset because I passed up a job opportunity (with a better schedule, potentially better pay, and more flexibility) because I didn’t want to do that to my students or the school (who has looked out for me so much). Now, I’m regretting that decision. If I didn’t HAVE to take these courses, I would be able to manage. It’s the fact that they won’t even consider the classes I’ve taken and my previous work experience (where my students scored in the top 10% in the state).
For a system that says they need teachers, they make it so hard for people who want to be one.

What would y'all do if you were in my shoes?

Sincerely,

A Teacher Who Just Wants To Teach


r/teaching • • 2d ago

General Discussion Have you ever cursed on purpose/accidentally in front of students? What happened?

59 Upvotes

I haven’t but sometimes I think about it in my mind. I hope I never curse at school and get in trouble


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Vent I guess teaching little kids ain't that bad after all🥹

3 Upvotes

Okay so I'm 24F and a college assistant professor who's working contractually and thankfully I get enough time to pursue other things. One of my colleagues recommended me to work as a part time english teacher at their coaching centre and since the pay was good I couldn't deny. Now fyi I've always had the experience to teach from XI to TY batches it was my first time encountering 8th standard in a classroom atmosphere. I was worried how I'm gonna handle them but ARGHHH it turned out to be so wholesome, the kids were cooperative in those 2 hours, they complemented me and one of the kids even gave me a chocolate bar and they kept calling me a "baddie pookie ma'am" cus of my piercings, by the end of the class we even clicked a picture 🥹🫶

TLDR - experienced teaching 8th standard class, kids complimented me


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Classroom/Setup Classroom Needs

1 Upvotes

Hello! Taking over a middle school ela/ss class. I feel like my room is so empty compared to the others around me. I know they have been teaching much longer, but I just feel like I don’t have a lot. What are some things that improve the classroom experience or that you would recommend for a first year teacher?

I’m set on posters/decor, more just thinking things for my comfort/student use/etc.


r/teaching • • 2d ago

General Discussion I am starting to empathize a lot more with the parent(s) of “those” kids due to parallels with my own father

31 Upvotes

The kid who’s never absent. The kid who derails a lesson for shits and giggles.

You call home 3+ a week, and if you’re lucky enough for the parent to pick up, they sound so defeated. “sigh I’ll talk to them”, knowing damn well that conversation will last only 10 seconds.

My dad lives alone and has a LOT of health problems, a lot of which are mental (I think he’s developing dementia but that’s neither here nor there). He has a caregiver that’s been beneficial to his day to day needs. But I get at least one text message a week from his caregiver letting me know of something asinine he did or said. I can’t do anything but tell them thanks for the message. So I am truly becoming a bit more empathetic.

And what am I supposed to do? He’s a grown man. I can’t ground him. I can’t take away his phone. I can’t make him behave. All I can really do is thank her for keeping me informed and occasionally offer advice. It’s made me a little more empathetic toward those parents who seem completely defeated whenever the school calls.

Sometimes, you really are doing what you can, and the person you’re responsible for still acts a fool.

And because there’s always that one person in the comments: Yes I’m fully aware that parents generally have more authority over their minor children than I do over my grown father. I’m not saying the situations are identical. I’m saying I now have a better understanding of how frustrating it can be to repeatedly hear about someone’s behavior when you have limited control over what they actually do :)


r/teaching • • 2d ago

Humor 5th graders are the most dramatic people on the planet.

98 Upvotes

I told my students we can play blooket today if (and only if) we finish the lesson. This is a very chatty class and several students were goofing off and having side conversations. One of my students REALLY loves blooket, so he was getting pissed off by the students not listening and kept screaming “SHUT UP!” at them. I kept telling him that it does not help when he does that, it only makes it worse and causes more disruption. By the end of class he was PISSED.

We did get some time for blooket, and all my students had joined except him. He was sitting in his chair still fuming. I asked him if he was going to join, and he ignored me. I asked again and he shook his head no. So I went ahead and started the game. When I started the game he got mad because I started without him. I was like “then you should have joined when I asked.”

For the rest of the day (6 full hours), he refused to even look at me. As I moved around the classroom, he would literally adjust his chair so his back was constantly toward me.

I know it’s a hard age, they have so many hormones causing emotions they don’t understand. We’ve all been there. But the keeping his back to me was just so over-the-top, it’s hilarious. I’m giggling about it now as I’m typing this. Poor kid, I hope he gets some rest.


r/teaching • • 3d ago Bravo

Vent Hot take: Before requesting an IEP, parents should have to explain what the hell THEY have done to help their kid.

1.5k Upvotes

I’m probably going to piss some people off with this one, but I genuinely think parents should have to fill out a questionnaire detailing what THEY have done to support their child’s education. Because the lack of parental accountability is getting ridiculous…

I recently got dragged into an IEP-related meeting that I was informed about at the last minute. Annoying as hell, but that’s beside the point. Mom was concerned because her daughter had a D and a couple of Cs. According to her, her daughter had “never gotten anything below a B.”
Okay. Fair enough. I’d be concerned, too.

So we started asking questions.

Have you been regularly checking her grades?
“No.”

Have you been checking Canvas to monitor assignments and academic progress?
“Well, I’m busy, so I only get around to checking it a couple of times a month.”

MA’AM. 😭

THANK GOD THIS MEETING WAS OVER THE PHONE. Because the way we all looked at each other…

So let me get this straight. Your daughter has supposedly NEVER received anything below a B, she’s now bringing home Cs and a D, and you haven’t thought to regularly check her grades? Her assignments? SOMETHING?!
But somehow we’re all sitting in a meeting discussing what THE SCHOOL needs to do. Of course, we gave the usual response about continuing to monitor her progress.

Lemme drink this damn margarita


r/teaching • • 2d ago

Help Storaging Materials

0 Upvotes

Hey, so I'm a teacher in my second year and I'm not sure how to organise all my materials since I don'twant to redo it the next time I need it. How do you do it? Is there a trick?


r/teaching • • 2d ago

General Discussion Sold a Story: Weekly Discussion - Episode 7: It's Up to Us

4 Upvotes

From the Sold a Story Website:

Zig Engelmann's Direct Instruction has a strong evidence base -- so why is it so hard to find in schools? We look at why schools jeep giving it up and visit a charter network in North Carolina that's stuck with it for more than a quarter century.

Episode 7 Overview:

Direct Instruction has been rejected by the education system again and again. Why does something that works face so much resistance? And what does that tell us about ourselves? In the season finale, Emily offers some final thoughts. And we hear how Zig Engelmann viewed his life’s work and what he left for others to do. Plus, some of the best podcast production credits you’ve ever heard.

This episode was the final episode of the season. What did you think about this episode and the season in general? Honestly, I was emotional listening to the end of the episode where they played Zig Engelmann's speech. I also thought it was very creative that they had the teachers and students of the Roger Bacon school read the credits. This season of the podcast did successfully convince me that Direct Instruction (when done right) can provide better outcomes for all students, including students from low income communities, and, at this point, I would try anything that can do that.

The question that came to me while listening: So, how does Direct Instruction fit into solutions for the literacy crisis, if at all? America is so dysregulated politically, economically, socially. Could implementing Direct Instruction successfully in schools actually undo some of the damage (focus on standardized testing, lack of phonics teaching, lack of core skills teaching and rote memorization, just to name a few big players) that's been done to the education system?


r/teaching • • 2d ago

Vent is this a normal maths question?

0 Upvotes

Our son got the following maths question

"The company where Eduarda works is experiencing financial difficulties and, for this reason, management has proposed that, next month, all salaries will be reduced by 10%. Eduarda has calculated that she will receive €1,080 per month. What is Eduarda's salary before the reduction?"

Is this normal?


r/teaching • • 2d ago

Help Texas teachers of tomorrow FBE reflections

1 Upvotes

I need help with writing reflections on FBE virtual portion of the course. I watch a video and keep taking notes on whatever I see or teacher says. I literally fill 4-5 pages writing these observations on each video I watch. But I am confused about how to write a reflection. I mean how long should it be. Like whether it should be a one page short or 2-3 pages long I have no idea. Any sample reflection would be really helpful. TIA


r/teaching • • 4d ago

Vent I had a first grade PE class sit on the floor in silence for the entire period today.

598 Upvotes

I have a class of first graders that has slowly gotten worse behavior-wise. I’ve tried writing home multiple times and the parents just say that the students can’t understand me (I teach ESL). Every time I have PE with the students they go absolutely wild, they scream, they injure each other, and act horrible and I’m sick of yelling at them.

Today, within the first 5-10 minutes of class, I had two kids get injured and so much screaming the other kids said their ears hurt. So I separated them, had them sit across the room from each other, and had them sit in silence for the whole hour.

We’ll see if it works in the future. Maybe I’ll get in trouble for doing this, but I don’t care. I’m sick of these kids acting like wild animals and teachers are expected to either suck it up or just magically be able to get them to act normally. Writing to parents doesn’t change anything, so then they don’t get to play or have any activity.