So I've been rewatching The Good Place (for the fourth time, I think?) and at some point I started noticing little things that reminded me of A Man on the Inside.
Both shows are by Michael Schur, both star Ted Danson, and both are about people becoming better through their relationships with others. Nothing particularly suspicious there.
But then Michael suggested that Chidi call himself "Charles Brainman" when meeting Tahani, and my brain immediately went "HEY, CHARLES! LIKE CHARLES NIEUWENDYK!"
Yeah, I know. It's a common name. Confirmation bias is a thing. XD
But then there's D'Arcy Carden appearing in A Man on the Inside, and I started joking to myself that maybe Charles is actually Michael, living another human life.
And that's where things got completely out of hand.
What if there was a little The Good Place miniseries that secretly served as a prequel to A Man on the Inside?
Here's what I've come up with.
Michael eventually dies after living his human life. He expects to enter the afterlife system he helped create, except Shawn decides to be an absolute pain in the ass about it.
He goes to the Judge and argues that Michael shouldn't qualify for the human afterlife system. He was a demon for countless Bearimys and a human for only a tiny fraction of his existence. Sure, he helped save humanity and redesign the afterlife, but his reward was getting to BE human. Nobody actually decided what happens to him AFTER he dies.
And honestly? Shawn kind of has a point.
The Judge agrees that this is a weird legal loophole, and after a lot of arguing decides Michael should get another chance. This time, however, he'll have to undergo a completely new test: an entire human lifetime, with no memories of his previous existence.
Since most of the original gang have already gone through the final door, Tahani and Janet are the only ones left to defend him.
Tahani volunteers to design the test. She's an architect now, after all. In fact, I'd love for her to casually mention that she became the highest-ranking architect only 47,294 Jeremy Bearimys ago, making her the fastest-promoted employee in history, even faster than her dear friend Michael Jackson was pushed into performing by his father.
You know. Just a completely normal Tahani thing to say.
But Shawn points out another problem.
Tahani and Janet LOVE Michael. How can the Judge possibly trust them to make his test fair? They could just give him the most wonderful life imaginable, where doing good is practically effortless.
So the Judge decides that Shawn has to help them design it, and she'll personally approve the final version.
And that's basically the premise of the miniseries. Tahani, Janet and Shawn working together to design Michael's new life.
I imagine it taking a few episodes because Tahani and Janet keep trying to protect Michael from anything unpleasant, while Shawn keeps suggesting increasingly horrible things.
At some point there's an entire episode where Tahani and Janet try to convince Shawn that he's becoming a better person by helping them.
And it almost works.
They eventually arrive at this beautiful conclusion about how good needs evil to exist, because without bad things happening to us, we'd never learn to overcome adversity and become better people.
Shawn looks genuinely touched for a moment.
Then he starts laughing.
He tells them that's the stupidest thing he's ever heard. Even HE knows good doesn't need evil to exist. People can be good and keep becoming better without ever having been bad. Just like someone can be evil and keep getting worse, which is exactly what he intends to do.
Then he quotes Army of Darkness:
"I may be bad... but I FEEL good!"
And here's a tiny detail I'd absolutely love: he starts laughing in EXACTLY the same way Michael did when Eleanor first figured out they were in the Bad Place.
Then, for just a split second, he makes a disgusted face because he realizes he just imitated Michael.
Nobody acknowledges it. It's just a little blink-and-you-miss-it joke for people who remember that scene.
Anyway, eventually they manage to design a genuinely fair test.
Not a perfect life, not a horrible one. Just a normal human life where Michael can experience happiness, suffering, love, grief, make mistakes and actually have opportunities to become a better person.
Shawn doesn't magically become good, by the way. He's still Shawn. He simply understands that the test needs to be fair, and being incredibly good at making people's lives miserable turns out to be surprisingly useful when designing realistic challenges.
But now there's another problem.
They need PEOPLE.
They can't use demons pretending to be humans, because that would make Michael's relationships fake. And they can't just take actual humans from somewhere else and force them to participate.
So Janet suggests creating the people for the test.
Except Tahani is getting nervous about the whole thing and suggests asking Derek for help.
Yes. Derek.
Derek has been rebooted so many times that he's developed abilities nobody fully understands anymore.
They ask him to help create a population for Michael's new life.
And Derek, being Derek, accidentally creates an ENTIRE UNIVERSE INSIDE HIMSELF.
Not just a fake neighborhood. An actual functioning reality with real people, their own history, relationships, free will, everything.
I can practically hear Janet saying "Derek, what have you done?" while he proudly responds "DEREK!"
The Judge examines this ridiculous new reality and, surprisingly, decides it qualifies. The people are real, their choices are their own, and even the architects can't control everything that will happen.
Because Janet was involved in creating it, some people in this universe happen to resemble people from Michael's previous existence.
And that's my explanation for familiar actors appearing in both shows.
Michael gets an entirely new identity, new memories and a new life. He's no longer an architect. Now he's a bridge engineer.
He's still kind, curious, a little awkward, and fascinated by other people, but he has absolutely no idea he used to be a demon.
He falls in love, gets married, has a daughter, experiences loss, and eventually becomes the Charles we know from A Man on the Inside.
And remember D'Arcy Carden showing up in that show?
In my version, that's actually Janet, checking in on Michael to see how he's doing.
He doesn't recognize her, of course.
I also thought it would be hilarious if the miniseries never actually mentioned A Man on the Inside until the very end.
The final test gets approved. Everyone is relieved. Even Shawn has finally stopped complaining.
Tahani asks Janet what Michael's new name will be.
Janet looks it up.
"Charles Nieuwendyk."
End credits.
And there you have it. I started with two characters having the same first name and somehow ended up inventing a Netflix miniseries involving supernatural bureaucracy, Shawn's pathological hatred of Michael, Tahani's character development, and Derek accidentally becoming God.
I know this isn't canon. I'm not even claiming any of these coincidences were intentional.
But I would absolutely watch this.
And now I kind of want to write it. XD
What do you guys think? Does this actually work as a story, or have I officially watched too much Michael Schur?