I'll start this by saying that parents having favorites isn't something I usually condone -- unless one turns out to be a violent criminal or something. "Why is Axl the favorite?" is a question that pops up on this sub from time to time and while it's true that the usual given responses (Axl is handsome, athletic, popular and the first born male) may be factors here...I think it goes a lot deeper than that.
First off, of the three kids, Axl requires the least time and energy from Mike and Frankie. They're not exactly the most productive parents on the planet. And whereas Sue is one of my favorite characters on the show, she also talks incessantly, is always trying out for some sport or team and requires lots of money, time, attention and resources from her folks. Brick, while requiring less of these things, nonetheless has a tendency to spring things on people (particularly Frankie) at the very last minute, forcing her to drop everything and scramble around to help him with some homework assignment that could have been done a while ago. For two parents that like to veg out when they get home, Sue and Brick can be a literal nightmare. Axl, on the other hand, likes to veg out himself and is much more the type to get by on his own devices. He requires the least and usually just likes to be left alone.
Which ties into point #2 - Axl is the most like Frankie and Mike. Sue is ambitious and likes to try out for things. Brick is intelligent and very well-read. Axl, like Frankie and Mike, enjoys relaxing and having time to one's self. He is like them. They see themselves in Axl.
Thirdly, for a mother like Frankie, who is all about "Keeping up with The Joneses" and having things to boast about to Nancy Donahue, Axl is a dream come true. Football is HUGE just about everywhere in America and with Axl being on the football team, it gives Frankie and Mike an endless supply of bragging rights. I absolutely admire Sue for her endless optimism and determination but there's a difference between saying "My kid made the team" and "My kid tried out for the team". And Frankie isn't going to say "My son read a book", which is just about all Brick is interested in for a good portion of the show.
So I think all three of those things are pretty big factors as to why Axl is favored. As a final note, I should also point out that I think Frankie and Mike secretly worry about Axl the most, which might explain why he gets the most attention. This show draws frequent comparisons to Malcom In The Middle and one of the most famous quotes from that show is when Lois (the mother) utters this line: "I would sell Malcolm down the river to save Reese" -- for those that have never seen the show, I'll provide some context: No, Lois really wouldn't sell Malcom but she worries about him a lot less because he's a genius and she's not worried about him landing on his feet. I would suggest something very similar occurs with Mike/Frankie and Brick. He's super intelligent, extremely well-read and has a terrific memory. They don't worry about him making it in life. Nor do they with Sue, who has endless determination and doesn't quit and has faced a lot of tremendous hurdles and conquered some of them. They do worry about Axl because he somewhat falls under the "brilliant but lazy" category and they could easily seem him as ending up just like them -- spending his middle age barely scraping out an existence and not being totally happy.
Forgive the marathon-length post here but I felt it was important to fully explain things.