I tried posting a newly uploaded 2008 Nathan Fielder documentary to r/TheBigPicture, the subreddit for The Ringer's movie podcast. I thought the documentary would interest listeners, particularly given the podcast's discussions of Fielder's work.
The post was awaiting moderator approval, so I reached out through modmail.
The moderator explained that the subreddit requires original opinions and discussion prompts rather than simply linking to videos. Fair enough. I explained that I'd submitted a revised post with my own opinion and a discussion starter.
That's when things escalated.
The moderator accused me of copying an AI-generated summary and wrote:
"You must either not understand what an opinion is, or have never formed one and dont know how, or just don’t care at all and think you and your lazy links are special."
They continued:
"Idgaf what your deal is, but I’m tired of being patient with behavior like this."
I explained that I'd tried to follow the rules and asked why the conversation had become so hostile.
The moderator responded:
"Like I said - you copied it from an ai summary of the press release, I just fucking checked. Way to ignore the whole damn point again buddy"
And then:
"We’ve all been incredibly patient with you specifically. Probably because we feel bad that it seems like spamming subs with video links is all you’ve got going on. I no longer feel bad."
I asked the moderator not to swear at or insult me and mentioned that I'm neurodivergent, which can sometimes make communication difficult. I wasn't asking for an exemption from the rules, just a respectful exchange.
The moderator responded:
"I’m a grown fucking woman I’ll say whatever words I damn well please. And I’m a neurodivergent one, at that. So don’t try to play that card with me"
She continued:
"It’s not a neurodivergent thing, it’s a whiny, self involved, prick thing. So stop giving all of us a bad name by playing that card."
I again asked her not to speak to me aggressively, explaining that I'd simply thought the documentary would interest the community and that I understood if the moderators disagreed.
I was then permanently banned from the subreddit and permanently muted from modmail.
To be clear, I don't dispute that moderators have the authority to reject posts that violate subreddit rules. The moderator also said I'd been warned about similar posts before.
But there's a difference between enforcing community rules and repeatedly swearing at someone, making assumptions about their personal life, dismissing their neurodivergence, and calling them a "prick."
All of this over a documentary link.
I've included screenshots of the exchange so people can judge for themselves.