Not trying to ragebait or be contrarian here, I'm genuinely curious to hear from people who are super hyped for the game.
Right now I'm honestly pretty apathetic toward GTA 6. Maybe that changes once reviews and raw gameplay drop since Rockstar still hasn't done a proper gameplay deep dive, so I'm just waiting to see how it actually plays. And don't get me wrong, the lighting, graphics, and animations look great. Calling them bad would be crazy. It's just that being on PC, I've already seen what high-end visuals can do, so graphics alone don't really move the needle for me anymore.
For context, Vice City was my first open-world game and it blew my mind as a kid. I played it day and night. But by the time I got around to GTA 5, I had played a lot of other games and honestly didn't find GTA 5 that great. So I already have some built-in skepticism going into 6. (I did really love RDR2 though, aside from how overly restrictive the mission design was, but I digress).
What I really can't wrap my head around is the budget. Whether it's $1 billion or the rumored $2 billion, that is an incomprehensibly massive amount of money. If you look at games that pushed crazy mechanical ambition or defined genres, their budgets look like pennies next to GTA 6 even when adjusted for inflation:
Half-Life 2 (~$40M, or ~$70M adjusted) revolutionized physics and environmental storytelling
FEAR (~$15M, or ~$25M adjusted) and Alien Isolation (~$35M, or ~$50M adjusted) set benchmarks for tactical and adaptive AI that modern AAA games still haven't beaten
STALKER (~$5M-$10M, or ~$15M adjusted) simulated an entire living zone offline with A-Life
Skyrim (~$85M, or ~$125M adjusted) built a persistent sandbox so modular that unpaid modders are still turning it into completely new games
Shadow of Mordor (~$50M-$100M) created dynamic procedural rivalries with the Nemesis system
MGS V (~$80M, or ~$110M adjusted) had enemy AI dynamically adapting to your tactics and loadouts
Witcher 3 (~$81M total, or ~$110M adjusted) set a huge benchmark for open-world quest writing
Death Stranding (~$100M, or ~$125M adjusted) turned literal walking and terrain balance into a deep mechanic
Tears of the Kingdom (~$100M-$120M, or ~$130M adjusted) pulled off an interconnected physics and chemistry engine on ancient Switch hardware
BG3 (~$100M-$150M, or ~$165M adjusted) set a massive bar for branching quest reactivity
KCD2 (~$41M) delivered deep systemic RPG mechanics and NPC reactivity on a fraction of a modern AAA budget
Even RDR2 (~$170M-$240M dev cost, or ~$500M total with marketing / ~$650M adjusted) cost way less than what is reportedly being thrown at GTA 6.
Hell, even unpaid modders working on massive STALKER (like Anomaly/GAMMA) and Skyrim overhauls manage to stitch together deeper interconnected survival and world systems than most modern AAA studios just through smart design rather than brute-force cash.(its quite crazy)
Few more example - Crimson Desert ($133M), Elden ring($100M approx), dragons dogma 2($67M), cyberpunk 2077($442 M)
So my question is, what kind of mechanical(including NPC AI related improvements) jump can a video game actually make going from a couple hundred million to over a billion dollars? Does ambition and scope actually scale like that in game dev, where throwing 5,000 devs and endless money at a project equals a proportionally crazier game?
No other studio gets the luxury of that kind of manpower and budget for years on end. If smaller teams can pull off genre-defining mechanics, smarter AI, and crazy systemic depth with way less resources, what are you guys expecting Rockstar to pull off here that nobody else can? Because just going off the trailers so far, I haven't really felt that gap. Genuinely curious what you guys think.
Edit: To clarify my original point, I was thinking primarily about gameplay mechanics, systemic depth, and AI. I'm admittedly biased here, as I personally feel that pushing animation and graphical fidelity past Red Dead Redemption 2 hits diminishing returns. Cosmetic polish is fine in moderation, but pouring resources into superficial details doesn't necessarily make a better game for me. While RDR2 is packed with granular details, very few of them translate into meaningful gameplay or world reactivity. Contrast that with Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2, where those details are thoughtfully integrated into the core mechanics and story. By comparison, Rockstar's approach feels a bit like a museum. impressive to look at and talk about, but mostly not that deeply interactive & shallow. As a result, it gets stale, and the novelty wears off pretty quickly since it isn't useful in any meaningful capacity. When playing games, my intention is always to see how far things can go in terms of simulation and what the game accounts for. If you give me a system, I will try to abuse it just to see what crazy things I can do but Rockstar prioritizes observational and physical realism (how the world looks, sounds, and physically reacts to impacts) over systemic simulation (how underlying infrastructure systems dynamically interact with one another, its called object affordances and emergent synergy) so it's not really doable.Rockstar spends millions creating the appearance of a living world, but gives you zero meaningful verbs to actually play with it. all show and no substance, it looks like a living, breathing world. But the moment you step in to interact with that simulation, the matrix breaks down, it's the Deception of passive, cinematic immersion.