r/truegaming • • 1d ago

/r/truegaming casual talk

10 Upvotes

Hey, all!

In this thread, the rules are more relaxed. The idea is that this megathread will provide a space for otherwise rule-breaking content, as well as allowing for a slightly more conversational tone rather than every post and comment needing to be an essay.

Top-level comments on this post should aim to follow the rules for submitting threads. However, the following rules are relaxed:

  • 3. Specificity, Clarity, and Detail
  • 4. No Advice
  • 5. No List Posts
  • 8. No topics that belong in other subreddits
  • 9. No Retired Topics
  • 11. Reviews must follow these guidelines

So feel free to talk about what you've been playing lately or ask for suggestions. Feel free to discuss gaming fatigue, FOMO, backlogs, etc, from the retired topics list. Feel free to take your half-baked idea for a post to the subreddit and discuss it here (you can still post it as its own thread later on if you want). Just keep things civil!

Also, as a reminder, we have a Discord server where you can have much more casual, free-form conversations! https://discord.gg/truegaming


r/truegaming • • Aug 28 '26

/r/truegaming casual talk

16 Upvotes

Hey, all!

In this thread, the rules are more relaxed. The idea is that this megathread will provide a space for otherwise rule-breaking content, as well as allowing for a slightly more conversational tone rather than every post and comment needing to be an essay.

Top-level comments on this post should aim to follow the rules for submitting threads. However, the following rules are relaxed:

  • 3. Specificity, Clarity, and Detail
  • 4. No Advice
  • 5. No List Posts
  • 8. No topics that belong in other subreddits
  • 9. No Retired Topics
  • 11. Reviews must follow these guidelines

So feel free to talk about what you've been playing lately or ask for suggestions. Feel free to discuss gaming fatigue, FOMO, backlogs, etc, from the retired topics list. Feel free to take your half-baked idea for a post to the subreddit and discuss it here (you can still post it as its own thread later on if you want). Just keep things civil!

Also, as a reminder, we have a Discord server where you can have much more casual, free-form conversations! https://discord.gg/truegaming


r/truegaming • • 5h ago

Have Metacritic scores ever really reflected actual player experiences?

0 Upvotes

I've been thinking about how much value we should actually put into professional game reviews, especially Metacritic scores.

Two examples come to mind: GTA 6 and Clair Obscur: Expedition 33.

With GTA 6, you can already see people complaining about various aspects of the game, despite it being one of the most anticipated games ever. It makes me wonder how much expectations, hype, and the overall gaming culture influence how we judge games.

Then there's Expedition 33. It received extremely high review scores and widespread critical acclaim, but personally, it was one of the worst gaming experiences I've had. I disliked its storytelling, dialogue, characters, and overall presentation. I understand that reviews are subjective, but the gap between the critical reception and my own experience was enormous. I'm not suggesting that critics should share my taste or that high scores are automatically undeserved. What bothers me is how much authority we've given these aggregated scores in the first place.

I'd be interested in hearing how others approach professional reviews and whether these scores influence their purchasing decisions.


r/truegaming • • 1d ago

What Defines a 10?

0 Upvotes

I've read and watched a lot of controversy about game ratings due to GTA over the past few days and wanted to chime in. My biggest gripe is the idea that for a game to be a 10, it has to be perfect. "The game isn't perfect, how can it be a 10"?

The thing is people with this concern commonly compare it to school. "If you got a 100 on a test, that means you got every answer right", and that logic works but only in a binary setting of right or wrong. In a creative medium, there is simply no such thing as an objective 100. While we can argue for things such as polish and performance, I believe most ratings look at the core of the game itself: design decisions, narrative, gameplay. All of these things are subjective.

So how should a 10 be defined? I have always defined a 10 as "there is nothing I PERSONALLY would change to make this game better". And this does not automatically lower the bar for what makes a 10 either. I love Cyberpunk but I wouldn't give it a 10 because of how little dialogue affects outcomes. I adore Persona 3, but I don't like the characters as much as the other games, and I enjoy GTA 6 a lot but the dialogue doesn't feel as punchy as previous entries for me.

Moreover, many people acknowledge that a game for everyone is a game for no one and while GTA typically has had mass appeal, they've definitely leaned more into RDR2 and it seems like they serve that audience well. Consequently, although a RDR2 enjoyer might call 6 a 10, a GTA 5 enjoyer might think it's a 7 due to slower pacing.

Essentially, I think we should avoid this idea of arguing a game can't be a 10 because it isn't "perfect". Perfect is not possible in creative mediums. 10s should be thought of as the highest honor an individual can provide by stating they agree with all creative decisions made by the media.


r/truegaming • • 3d ago

Critics rate the best video game franchises so highly in a way no other medium does.

619 Upvotes

GTAVI is a 99, highest-rated game of all time for now, tying Ocarina of Time. What's crazy to me is how unsurprising that is. Like of course the biggest game of the year with the biggest budget is also highly-rated. But boy is it so different than in film. No one expects Avengers: Doomsday to both clean up it critically and smash box office numbers. It's very different.

And also how consistent these top game franchises can be. The main GTA titles are all super highly-rated on metacritic. GTA3 has a 97, GTAIV, 98, now GTAVI has a 99. The main 3D/HD titles range from 95 to 99, that's insanely consistent.

You look at the major franchises and their major entries, they're very consistent. Zelda, the lowest rated 3D one since Ocarina, mainline title, is a 93. You look at Mario, Uncharted, God of War, Halo, Metal Gear Solid, their main games are in the 80s and, mostly 90s. Very very very consistently highly rated.

In film, it's very rare that a director doesn't have a film that critics were eh on or outright hated. Nolan has Tenet, The Following. Spielberg has had a long career and some titles like Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of Crystal Skull, Ready Player One, were not loved by critics. Tarantino has a few not as beloved like Jackie Brown and Hateful Eight. Coppola made some of the best movies ever, and also Godfather Part III and Megalopolis which wasn't loved.

Switch to film franchises instead of directors and none are as consistent as the best in games. The MCU, Batman, Bond, and Star Wars all have their lows. None have been critical darlings the way GTA, Zelda, Mario, and God of War are

Sequels are another thing. In film, a sequel living up to the original is an uphill battle, and Godfather Part II, The Dark Knight, and Empire Strikes Back are the exceptions. In the top 25 games on Metacritic you see a lot of sequels. I know that’s partly because games are sequel-heavy to begin with, but it doesn’t feel like the same thing.

Metacritics for film usually are lower in general than games, but still, game franchises are way more consistent and have such a higher floor.

Why do you guys think this is? I’m not trying to imply paid-off reviews, like that critics aren’t actually enjoying these games. It seems so different from the world of movies in how franchises are received.


r/truegaming • • 1d ago

Spoilers: Deus Ex series A Machete Order for Deus Ex

0 Upvotes

TL;DR: Play Deus Ex, then Human Revolution, then Mankind Divided, then Invisible War, and skip The Fall. Playing DX1 first protects its reveals and avoids the whiplash of going back to it after the modern games, while ending on IW gives the series a more decisive finale than MD's cliffhanger.

And no, I didn't use AI to write this.

One of the biggest downfalls of this magnificent series is the uneven narrative. The first Deus Ex and Human Revolution stand alone as great games on the strength of their stories and gameplay. Invisible War has its merits and Mankind Divided has its fervent devotees based on their own strengths. But Invisible War's gameplay pales in comparison to the original game, and Mankind Divided's ending is one of the least satisfying finales for any video game series. How can we reconcile those two games and their flaws with the series' high points? I propose a Machete Order for Deus Ex.

For those unfamiliar with the Machete Order, it's a fan-created watch order for the Star Wars movies to maximize the story's impact and keep things flowing in a satisfying way. Instead of going by the release order (4-5-6-1-2-3), the Machete Order removes the weakest movie (1) and instead suggests watching them as 4-5-2-3-6. This means you get to see the apex of the original trilogy, go back to see how we got to this point, and then return to the original timeline to finish the series off. Obviously with the sequel trilogy now in play, the Machete Order is a bit outdated, but the spirit is right and it's not like Deus Ex has that problem... yet.

My proposed Machete Order for Deus Ex is:

  1. Deus Ex
  2. Deus Ex: Human Revolution
  3. Deus Ex: Mankind Divided
  4. Deus Ex: Invisible War

And skip Deus Ex: The Fall.

Why do I think this works?

  • Softening the Mankind Divided cliffhanger - Instead of hitting a narrative wall at the end of the series, where Jensen's story remains painfully unresolved and questions stay unanswered forever, the player is transported back to the aftermath of the original game. This doesn't entirely resolve Mankind Divided's cliffhanger, but it does soften the blow by replacing Mankind Divided as the series' narrative end with Invisible War, which offers four much more decisive endings.
  • Downplaying the DX1-to-DX2 drop-off - Invisible War is a tough sell after playing a game like DX1. It's full of Xbox-era early-2000s jank with a broken cartoonish physics system, graphical overambition with poor execution (resulting in dull landscapes and zombie stares), small levels requiring frequent loading screens, and far less emphasis on stealth-based play. Moving from Mankind Divided to Invisible War is still a drop-off from a well-presented 2016 game to a tepidly-presented 2003 title, but I think that MD and IW, in the end, share more commonalities than DX1 and DX:IW. They both rely on smaller hub-based structures (Prague vs IW's hub cities) and their stories are driven by competing factions rather than a single conspiracy chase.
  • Frontloading the most acclaimed entries - Some may consider this a drawback, but I think it works. If you liked DX1 and DX:HR, you might as well try DX:MD and DX:IW. But this prevents anyone from having to power through a game they may find less fun or satisfying by presenting the two strongest entries first, which honestly could stand together as a two-game series. And if a player feels strongly enough about DX1 and DX:HR, they can proceed to the next two games.
  • Maximizing the narrative's callbacks - Playing the Jensen games between DX1 and IW maximizes the impact of Invisible War's callbacks, as well as the reemergence of familiar Illuminati figures in Mankind Divided. Instead of jumping straight into a sequel featuring characters you just saw, you get some distance. You meet the Illuminati's younger selves in the Jensen games, then see how those characters ended up in IW. Additionally, the game's final sequence returning to Liberty Island gives the series a neat set of bookends, which I think is a really satisfying way to tie things off.
  • Thematic progression - DX1 is, at its core, about uncovering who controls the world. The Jensen games are mainly about the effect of mechanical augmentations on people and society overall, with MD turning towards the ruling-the-world conspiracies of the first game. Invisible War ends on the future of humanity after handing the world to one of its competing factions. Ending on the most far-future, forward-looking question gives the Machete Order a better thematic arc.
  • Why skip The Fall? - This is Deus Ex's parallel to Star Wars: Episode 1. It's the weakest, most skippable entry, which adds almost nothing to the story's overarching narrative.

Okay, but if we're just trying to avoid Mankind Divided's cliffhanger, why play the Machete Order instead of playing through the games chronologically?

  • Dramatic irony - HR and MD, though they stand alone as the "Jensen series" just fine, were ultimately written for players familiar with the "Denton series." That means players would've been familiar with certain parameters of the world, like Illuminati governance, the Gray Death epidemic, the MJ12 conspiracy, and mechanical augmentation already becoming obsolete. In other words, just how much worse things will get in the quarter century that follows DX:HR. This knowledge adds a layer of tragedy to Jensen's story, because in the end, you know his fight is doomed. Without the context of DX1, none of that hits!
  • Protecting the original order's reveals - HR and MD assume you know who Bob Page, Morgan Everett, and the Illuminati are. HR's ending strongly implies things DX1 builds up as mysteries. Playing chronologically would undercut the "unraveling conspiracy" aspect of DX1's story. This keeps it fully intact.
  • Avoiding the graphical drop-off - Playing DX1 after HR and MD is a harsh jump, far worse than the drop-off from MD to IW. IW is rough, but its dynamic lighting and physics engine at least point toward modern games. DX1's storytelling is more mature than other games of its time, but it's graphically and mechanically every bit its age. DX1 is more like Half-Life, DX:IW is more like Half-Life 2, and Half-Life 2 remains the defining title for modern FPS games.
  • Gameplay whiplash, too - DX1 is a product of its time and doesn't possess the qualities of a 2011 or 2016 immersive sim. The skills system is archaic. The inventory system is clunky. There's no cover system. Combat is dependent on weapons and melee skills that start you off deeply incapable of fighting like the nanoaugmented super soldier you're supposed to be. And stealth depends on your ability to hold down the crouch button and stick to the blotchy shadows. Unless you're familiar with DX1 and expecting it, I think a series newbie would react really poorly to this.

I'm not expecting everybody to get on board with this, but I think it could be an interesting way to approach this series, and I might try it for my next playthrough. (Whenever that'll happen, I have an infant to take care of now... maybe we'll have a new DX game by then and none of this will matter)


r/truegaming • • 1d ago

I think high technical standards and graphical fidelity is starting to become an enemy of good game design.

0 Upvotes

I've been occupying myself with a livestream of GTA VI, and I think this is a certain watershed moment.

The game is truly a technical marvel. The amount of unique dialogue, unique high poly models, the polish, is unreal... And the scope is massive.

But at what cost? 1 - 2 billion dollars. 13 years. 6000 people working on the game. Tens of millions of man hours.

This got me thinking.... How could one even directly compete with GTA 6? No other game company could afford to spend such massive resources to every little asset and detail. The end result is guaranteed to be seen as a lesser of the two.

So should other game developers even try? I don't think so. If they commit to the same level of graphical detail and abundance of props, every single asset from vehicles to props to character models must then be modeled with the same great care and effort. Otherwise they would stick out like a sore thumb and destroy graphical consistency. If they commit to the same level of unique voice lines, they would need a massive amount of sound actors, thousands of hours in recording studios. Otherwise the dialogue and the NPC reactions would quickly start repeating itself. If they commit to the same level immersive animations, every single action from picking up objects, entering buildings and vehicles, interacting with the world, must be individually animated and any inconsistency would hurt the immersion.

In a sense, the GTA franchise has made an extremely costly commitment of being the technical trailblazer of the genre. They have raised the bar extremely high, and are married to it. They are expected to surpass it in the future, or at the very least, preserve it. They cannot afford GTA 7 to be seen as a downgrade. This of course doesn't apply, if they make another Chinatown Wars, that is not held to the same standard. If Rockstar games, for example, would want to have three cities instead of just one, would it even be worth it, from a business standpoint? It's not like the game would sell three times more, despite costing hundreds of millions more and tens of millions of more man hours.

There's this discrepancy in modern games, between technical quality and the amount of content. For example in GTA V, you have this massively detailed city, but then you lack any gang mechanics, there's very few interiors in free roam, and there's not really that much to do in the end. GTA SA had three cities, trucking, gambling, quarry missions, gang mechanics and burglary missions.

I think this reality will sooner or later work against both Rockstar games, and the other AAA developers trying to reach the same heights. Instead of having 1000 car models, they will have 100 detailed ones. Instead of having countless of interiors filled to the brim with low poly objects, they will have eerie backroom tier office spaces with a handful of detailed objects. Instead of having a massive game world, they will have a single city.

However, if the developers pick a different route and different design priorities, the same resources can be used to expand the scope by the order of magnitudes. For example, if the art style emulates low poly PS2 or PS1 era, there can be thousands of props, all consisting of just a few polygons. A computer screen can just be a cube, with textures made in 2 minutes in MS paint. You can have 1000 unique vehicles, because modeling one takes 30 minutes. Character models could just have 300 polygons, and the animations wouldn't have to be as precise. If the dialogue is presented as just voice bubbles and text, a character referring to a specific location, or a specific character, is much easier to present as just dynamic text, instead of recording a unique voice line for every reference. If picking objects or interacting with the environment is just a red glowing circle and a bling sound, without any complex animations, creating every action will require 1% of the work.

If one chooses GTA Vice City tier graphical fidelity and technical standards, he could then have several different cities and massive game maps, more interiors, more side activities, more everything, and still retain the exact same inner mechanisms like storytelling, game economy, robberies, wanted system, or then just have more systems and mechanics.

So I think the real GTA killer will arrive, once some major developer gives up on trying to be equal on the technical side of things, and instead fully embraces a simpler and less resource intensive, but still aesthetically pleasing art style, while then dedicating the extra resources into expanding the scope and developing deeper game mechanics.


r/truegaming • • 3d ago

Academic Survey Participate in study to improve relationship with gaming.

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’m Ben, a researcher at The University of Queensland. The mods kindly gave me permission to share a study we’re running called Intentional Gaming.

We’re testing a simple online program where people reflect on their gaming and how it fits into their lives. You don’t need to play competitively or stick to particular games, and there’s no requirement to reduce or stop gaming.

The study runs over two weeks and takes approximately two hours altogether. It involves one 45-minute online session with a trained counsellor to discuss your gaming and goals, a short daily journal taking around two minutes.

We’re looking for people aged 18 or older who currently play video games.

If you’re interested, you can find out more and express your interest here:
https://uniofqueensland.syd1.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_b9skx7l3TmiSIRM

This is a small pilot, so completing the form doesn’t guarantee selection. We’d appreciate hearing from gamers and learning what you find useful or would change about the program.
The study has UQ ethics approval (2026/HE011853).

You can contact me at benjamin.johnson@uq.edu.au with any questions.
Thanks!
Ben


r/truegaming • • 2d ago

Why the removal of prostitutes from GTA VI makes perfect sense.

0 Upvotes

It's come out that GTA VI has no picking up of prostitutes, sleeping with strippers, or banging the crazy neighbor, and sex workers may also be completely removed from the streets in general (unconfirmed). This has been very controversial with the fanbase.

The officially stated reason is to focus on the relationship. People question why a criminal wouldn't cheat on his partner, but the bonds between criminals can involve levels of loyalty unmatched by any typical relationship. Gang members, mafia, and Bonnie and Clyde all show just how tightly knit and unwilling to betray one another criminals can be.

Rockstar is also clearly trying to move away a bit from the same cynicism and/or nihilism that has been present in every single 3D GTA and its characters from the beginning, towards something more grounded and emotionally meaningful. I think they were intentionally writing their characters that way in the past to keep player choices mostly "in character" for them, but now they're trying something different and restricting player choice in a few ways to preserve the characters and narrative.

For how intensely loyal the characters are supposed to be to each other, to give the player even the choice to hook up with random people would be completely antithetical to their personalities and their relationship. It's like if people complained about how you don't have the option to give all your money to charity and volunteer at a homeless shelter.

People complain about how it should be up to the player to guide the character's choices and stuff like that, but without all the extra development effort (writing, voice lines, animations, etc) to flesh out other relationship possibilities, the only reason to pursue other women is "monkey brain see, monkey brain want" with no narrative connection or anything unless the character specifically has unfaithfulness as a character trait.

But I think there's another reason for the removal, which becomes obvious if prostitutes are confirmed to be missing from the streets in general. Players picking up sex workers, sleeping with them, then killing them to get the money back, has unfortunate implications of the game encouraging a predominantly male playerbase to kill women with its game mechanics. If male sex workers were added, players would still be predominantly picking up and killing female ones. If the sex workers were left in without the option to pick them up, players would kill them anyway, for the memes or as "revenge for not sleeping with them", and posting clips of it online with problematic captions and comments immediately upon the game's release.

In GTA V, they changed it so that prostitutes don't give the full amount back when killed, likely to try and reduce this reputation, but killing sex workers was still a meme and tradition, and I'm not sure the change really made that much of a difference. In GTA 6, the amount of extra gore would make it all look much worse in any clips.

With the female protagonist and the love story, the potential for more appeal to a female audience is obvious, so there's an additional motivation to remove what could be perceived as the most misogynistic and tasteless aspect of the games. While having prostitutes in an open world game isn't really problematic, it's the combination of gameplay mechanics that made it an issue that couldn't really be solved. GTA 7 or a later update to GTA 6 may bring them back in some new form (finding sex workers online?) in the hopes that the tradition has faded.

At the end of the day, it was a shallow, small mechanic that added very little to the game. It was fun to have, but not really something you did more than once or twice unless you were serial killin'. The strip club and lap dances, however, were fully kept in, likely because you can't kill strippers and the strip clubs add a lot more to the game and the atmosphere, and it's something some people in monogamous relationships could potentially justify, especially if they attend as a couple.


r/truegaming • • 3d ago

Reassessing the cultural legacy of Elden Ring.

0 Upvotes

Today Jason Schreier tweeted out an appraisal of the apparently phenomenal GTA6 noting that this is the most engaging exploration he's experienced "since BotW and Elden Ring." Now typically I wouldn't pay too much mind to one random tweet and Schreier is certainly entitled to his own opinions. But as he's the most famous gaming journalist around and this is a rather common sentiment, I felt it was suitable to use this offhand comment as a sort of temperature-taking exercise of the legacy of some recent 'big deal' video games.

At the risk of being too much of a curmudgeon, I'll just lead with the point: Elden Ring does not deserved this level of status. That's not to say that it's not a high quality, exhilarating game. It's clearly a popular and beloved entry from a celebrated developer. But the same could be said for plenty of games. I don't think I've seen games such as Doom Eternal, Horizon Forbidden West, Diablo 4, etc. described in the same glowing terms as Elden Ring: revolutionary, generational, liberally brought up in every "greatest games" conversation. They're recognized as excellent exemplars of their series/genre that fans ought to checkout but not necessarily landmark titles. Typically that's reserved for games that do something totally novel or at least introduce an unprecedented level of realized ambition via fidelity and scope.

While I don't think Breath of the Wild is a perfect game and I can certainly see how it could bore some players (the dungeons in particular are a bit of a letdown), I think even the staunchest critic must admit that it indeed delivered some of this "Wow! I've never seen that before!" spectacle. The total freedom it affords the player expressed through expertly blended and elegantly intuitive mechanics is, I think, genuinely new and exciting. I mean you can drop a flint rock from your inventory, strike it with a weapon to create a spark, watch it ignite the grass around you, then take out your paraglider and ride the updraft from the flame. Now that's an innovative mechanic!

Does Elden Ring do anything similar? I'd argue no. It's mostly a bigger iteration on the Dark Souls formula adapted to an open world format. I think there was maybe some pre-release trepidation that embracing the open world zeitgeist would involve watering down some of Fromsoft's unique gameplay staples (as has occurred with so many other devs who chased that trend) and subsequent relief that the developer managed to resist that temptation. That is certainly a creative decision worth celebrating, but it's not the same thing as innovation.

Elden Ring's open world brings a scale and verisimilitude to the Lands Between that had not been experienced in any previous Fromsoft title. If you're a Fromsoft fan I can certainly understand why this would be your favorite game of all time. But it's not like the open world is actually doing anything impressive or new across all of gaming. It's a fairly static environment, no random events or intricate physics/AI systems. The esoteric and opaque storytelling should be familiar to anyone that's played a Fromsoft game before. The lack of quest-markers is intriguing but BotW did that too and with subtler sign-posting. The chalice dungeons are notably more engaging than a standard "?" bandit camp in many other open world games, but I don't think they rise to the same level as Skyrim where almost every dungeon has its own story woven into the environmental design.

It's not like it's an expertly polished game either. While the user interface is perfectly functional there's some pain points that have remained since Dark Souls. I won't hold asset re-use against them but there are some places that received notably less attention, e.g. the back-side of Stormveil Castle. The hitboxes and camera can feel a bit finicky sometimes. The graphics are fine and while the art direction can be breathtaking, it's still mostly just an iteration on Fromsoft convention. I suppose emphasizing the objective as a permanent fixture that subsumes a large portion of the horizon is pretty cool but one art asset does not a landmark title make.

None of this precludes Elden Ring from being a generation-defining game. In fact, what often makes a game truly novel and generation-defining is when it does something outside of the expected; spending resources on some bold, new experiment no one was even thinking about. For instance, Fromsoft could have chosen to forgo all of this and instead focused their efforts on something else. Perhaps instead of clipping through the terrain, enemy attacks have collision with the environment and the game is balanced for the player to utilize this behavior to tactically position themselves. I think that would be a cool, revelatory feature and in keeping with the slower, more deliberately-paced combat style in these games. But I don't see evidence of any similarly ambitious mechanic.


r/truegaming • • 6d ago

Does Spider-Man 2 actually make you 'feel like Spider-Man'?

52 Upvotes

Whenever a new Batman project releases like Matt Reeve’s latest cinematic outing, or the incredible new Absolute run, I always find myself thinking ‘man, I should really replay Arkham Knight’. As Whitelight detailed is his gargantuan 12 hour AK retrospective, Rocksteady in their final entry of the Arkham franchise endeavoured to make the ultimate Batman sandbox. If you see Batman do something in a comic or movie or cartoon, you can probably replicate in this game. You don’t just feel like Batman, you can feel like any Batman.

I noticed after watching that despite having a deep love for Insomniac’s Spider-Man outings, the latest MCU movie or animated series very rarely fills me with the desire to boot up Spider-Man 2 because the Spider-Man fantasy feels incomplete or actively undermined. This comes down to combat, traversal, and the world map.

Spider -Man 2018’s combat was an absolute triumph and captured the character of Spider-Man to a tee. Game director Bryan Intihar spoke about how the guiding philosophy of combat design was Spider-Man as the ‘acrobatic improviser’. While dishing out the hurt on goons, you never countered their attacks, you evaded, bounding over their heads and leaving them flat footed as you prepared your next strike. Crowd control and interrupting heavy attacks was fairly difficult to do, so you’d quickly scan the arena looking for something in the environment to help you out. Even the gadgets which often get derided as ‘different flavours of stun and instakill’, played into Peter’s nature as prankster, and the synergies gadgets had with each other made you feel intelligent for using them.

SM2’s combat feels like a serious step back in almost every way and that’s in great part the fault of the new gadgets and super moves added. Spider-Man no longer feels like an acrobatic improviser, but more a clumsy brutalizer, even when not wearing the symbiote. Both Spider-Men are so strong in this game that instead of dodging your foes and using the environment to your advantage, it is often optimal to sit in place, parry and spam all of your abilities on cooldown until the fight is over. The gadgets, once employed tactically for maximum effect, can only be deployed lazily and indiscriminately. The only positive additions I feel are the added dodges and the new web yank. Puppeteering your enemies around and bowling them into other foes is classic Spider-Man, but it further highlights the absence of webs as Spider-Man’s main tool in combat. The fact it’s been 21 years since we were last able to hang bad guys from a street light feels wrong.

Traversal has been the one unambiguous upgrade in SM2. While 2018’s web swinging was hugely impressive for its time, the slow movement, lack of expressive options, and painfully low skill ceiling limited a lot of the enjoyment. No such problems exist here. You tumble and rocket through the air at breakneck speeds, the eye-popping animation on tricks brings so much flair to movement, and the ability to disable swing-assist finally adds a fail-state to swinging that makes tough manoeuvres feel like they came at some risk.

As good as the swinging is, the traversal again is an incomplete fantasy. Swinging is fast, cool and expressive, but it’s imprecise. If you want to make exact landings or thread needles, you are still restricted to point launches or the new web wings. There’s been a lot of discourse on these so I won’t harp on too long, but the fastest and most efficient way to get around the map being a Just Cause 3 wing suit feels incongruent with how we traditionally imagine Spider-Man. All this movement is also only as good as the map it’s being used in.

2018’s Manhattan was perfect, an elegant blend of a realistic New York, dotted with all kinds of iconography from the greater Marvel Universe. While the swinging was limited, it also meant that you developed the familiarity with NYC that a friendly neighbourhood Spider-Man should. I could feel the difference in leaping from the mid-rise rooftops of Greenwich, swinging from the concrete spires of the financial district, and playing the cursed game of Hopscotch that was trying to get through Central Park. The power of the new traversal systems makes New York feel small, and worse, it feels like you spend more time flying over it rather than moving through it. Further breaking my immersion is how the sky gets dotted with huge neon indicators to drag my attention to side activities, and all of the weird enemy factions that make me painfully aware that I am playing as Peter Park in a video game.

Spider-Man 2 is a great game, but it is not a great way to roleplay as Spider-Man in an interactive format. Where Rocksteady insured that everything was a servant to the goal of being the dark knight, it feels like Insomniac distorts the vision of Spider-Man to fit the mould of a AAA open world action game.


r/truegaming • • 6d ago

Is the issue with Western "choice-based" games really budget?

0 Upvotes

One thing that bothers me about a lot of Western "choice-based" games is the illusion of choice.

Take Telltale's The Walking Dead for example or Life is Strange. You can make various choices throughout these games, and the games try to convince you that some of those are very important.

However, rarely any of them are. At most, the choices slightly alter some dialouge or a character's attitude towards you. If you're very lucky, you might even get one or two slightly different scenes.

But never do your choices actually result in something new, something unique and different that you wouldn't have seen otherwise, and puts the game's themes and world into a new perspective. Never does a choice actually diverge from the narrative.

But take Japanese visual novels for example. They have ecxelled in choice-based narratives for way longer and way better than the West has. Choices you can make in visual novels give you bad ends, special character routes, and may even change your ending depending on what you chose throughout the game.

-In Zero Escape, depending on which doors you go through and who you team up with, the story can play out in drastically different ways.

-In Steins Gate, sending text messages affects the relationships you build and allow for special character-ends that all place a new perspective on the game's themes.

-And as a more modern example, The Hundred Line: Last Defense Academy offers over 20 unique routes and 100 endings aside from its 40-hour common route.

And sure, the main point people make is always budgetary constraints. Western interactive story games can get expensive, and there isn't enough budget for every choice to have a dramatic affect on the story. And yes, visual novels are comparatively cheaper.

But what I'm missing from these Western games is the part of choice making visual novels have that actually make you feel like your choices have an effect. In visual novels, you choose to spend time with a character and get unique scenes and endings with them. You chose to be a bad person throughout and potentially get a bad ending as a result.

Where is that in games like The Walking Dead and Life is Strange aside from some slightly different dialouge? You can save Kate Marsh from her suicide attempt or fail and let her die, but that doesn't have any large consequences and barely gets brought up again. You can be a good parental figure to Clementine or a terrible one, but she and her relationship with Lee end up mostly the same.

Why shouldn't you, for example, get a unique bad end in The Walking Dead for raising Clementine poorly? Why, in Life is Strange, shouldn't you get unique scenes and maybe an ending for saving Kate and letting her affect the narrative even a little bit, maybe by having her work with Max and Chloe?

Those aren't massive things. Those aren't Hundred Line's, "You've changed the whole course of the narrative and nothing is the same" kinds of choices, because that would be a lot to ask.

Those are smaller things that still fit within that same story, but still have a big effect that makes the players feel the impact of their choices.

And you just don't really see that in these games. If budget really stops you from achieving that, why make a choice-based game in the first place? Couldn't you cut the number of episodes in your game from five to three or four to use that budget in making branching choices?

Couldn't you add just one or two little branches that get you unique character endings like in Steins Gate? Those developers could do these things, but they don't.

Sometimes I wonder if the main problem is a lack of budget, or mainly a lack of imagination.

(Side Note: I do have to say, though. Detroit: Become Human is an exception. That game really makes choices matter, even if its story is flawed.)


r/truegaming • • 8d ago

What if Sega didn't bail out Nvidia?

46 Upvotes

Firstly, I recently read about this from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nvidia#Products_and_development

Nvidia's first graphics accelerator, the NV1, was designed to process quadrilateral primitives (forward texture mapping), a feature that set it apart from competitors, who preferred triangle primitives. However, when Microsoft introduced the DirectX platform, it chose not to support any other graphics software and announced that its Direct3D API would exclusively support triangles. As a result, the NV1 failed to gain traction in the market.

Nvidia had also entered into a partnership with Sega to supply the graphics chip for the Dreamcast console and worked on the project for about a year. However, Nvidia's technology was already lagging behind competitors. This placed the company in a difficult position: continue working on a chip that was likely doomed to fail or abandon the project, risking financial collapse.

In a pivotal moment, Sega's president, Shoichiro Irimajiri, visited Huang in person to inform him that Sega had decided to choose another vendor for the Dreamcast. However, Irimajiri believed in Nvidia's potential and persuaded Sega's management to invest $5 million into the company. Huang later reflected that this funding was all that kept Nvidia afloat, and that Irimajiri's "understanding and generosity gave us six months to live".

When people discuss what caused the Dreamcast to fail, apart from piracy, it's the graphics and third-party support that come up.

Often development time and how easy it is to onboard your team to the console are big factors for 3rd parties. If Sega had gone with a chip that was more industry standard, it stands to reason that this would have been an easier choice to make. Both console and emerging PC game devs would have had an easier and faster time creating or porting titles to the platform.

If Sega had swapped vendor then there's a good chance the graphics would have been on par with the PS2.
Edit: Sega did swap vendor see RealAmaranth's comment, though the chip still was still relatively esoteric.

An extra 5 mil in the bank isn't to be ignored as well.

Do you think Sega could have stayed in the console market? What devs/games might we have seen on the system?

Would 3dfx be the rightful king of gpu's (I loved my Voodoo, sue me) on PC or was ATi already breaking ahead?


r/truegaming • • 8d ago

/r/truegaming casual talk

7 Upvotes

Hey, all!

In this thread, the rules are more relaxed. The idea is that this megathread will provide a space for otherwise rule-breaking content, as well as allowing for a slightly more conversational tone rather than every post and comment needing to be an essay.

Top-level comments on this post should aim to follow the rules for submitting threads. However, the following rules are relaxed:

  • 3. Specificity, Clarity, and Detail
  • 4. No Advice
  • 5. No List Posts
  • 8. No topics that belong in other subreddits
  • 9. No Retired Topics
  • 11. Reviews must follow these guidelines

So feel free to talk about what you've been playing lately or ask for suggestions. Feel free to discuss gaming fatigue, FOMO, backlogs, etc, from the retired topics list. Feel free to take your half-baked idea for a post to the subreddit and discuss it here (you can still post it as its own thread later on if you want). Just keep things civil!

Also, as a reminder, we have a Discord server where you can have much more casual, free-form conversations! https://discord.gg/truegaming


r/truegaming • • 8d ago

Realistically, how many genre-games are there?

0 Upvotes

Whenever I practice window-shopping on Steam (Which sometimes turns into actual shopping), I have a small thing I do, which is look at the games there and say, in my mind, what they're clearly inspired by: "OK, this is Vampire Survivors, this one is Celeste, this one is Slay the Spire, this one is Dark Souls, this one is Quake, this one is Hades, this one Mega-Man, etc".
I don't see it as a demerit whatsoever, though this did begin when I looked at the bundles for Hell Maiden being all other Vampire Survivors-likes and asked myself "Why buy multiple copies of what's essentially the same game?".

So I began thinking: How many "unique games" exist, in the sense that they're platonic games which all others are rehashes in some form, maybe we could call those "ur-games" or "genre-games".
I initially guessed around 40, then increased my guess to 100, then to 200, and now I'm not even sure because... it's a bit hard to count.

For starters, many of those would be games simple enough that any rehash wouldn't be different enough to save itself from copyright. Pac-Man is one such example.
Also, how much weight we give "structure" and "aesthetics" for separating what are "different games": The term "Metroidvania" is a good example, because pretty much all that follow it's tradition mainly take 90% of "how things work" from Castlevania rather than Metroid, and I don't think we could say that Castlevania and Metroid "are the same game".
When I say "aesthetics", I don't mean in the sense of "one is sci-fi, the other is fantasy", but in the sense that, for instance, all the games from the ICO trilogy are the same game because they can be boiled down to "atmospheric puzzle game".

This creates a whole plethora os questions like "Is Tetris' case the same as Pac-Man, or are Dr Mario and PuyoPuyo Tetris?
I started thinking about that partially as a defense of "Vampire Survivors", because as much as many people might it "a cancer upon the industry", I do have a level of respect for it for essentially "creating a new genre-game".


r/truegaming • • 12d ago

Ghosts 'n Goblins having extremely unbalanced weapons is actually a good thing

97 Upvotes

For those who don't know, the Ghosts 'n Goblins series is comprised of arcade / arcade-like, 2D action platformers. In every game in the series there are multiple weapons you can choose from; most are made intentionally horrible or at most very situational while the knife is notoriously overpowered. I think that this, in combination with a few other mechanics, makes the game much more fun and strategic at high-level.

In every game you start with basically a worse knife and the main way you change weapons is with vases. Each level of each game has one or two enemy types that get spammed at you constantly, those usually have a chance to hold a vase. When you kill the enemy then the vase falls and breaks on the ground, revealing either score or a random weapon. The real reason this is so important is that when you pick up a new weapon you lose your previous one and you have to get it again from a different vase. It's generally hard to dodge weapons that have fallen because of Arthur's (your character's) horrendously slow and limited movement, you get one movement speed (no running), one jump height, one jump distance (not affected by momentum), and you can't move while in the air at all.

All of this synergises to make a comeback mechanic of sorts. Good players with good weapons are discouraged from breaking vases to not lose their precious knife, meaning that they have to use their skills at moving Arthur's fat ass around the screen to manoeuver around the enemies and terrain at the same time something which is very difficult and needs true mastery of the games mechanics while also having many nuances and a lot of interesting risk management attached to it. On the other hand, bad players with bad weapons get a chance to roll for a better weapon and also don't have to deal with all that moving around the enemies shit, they can kill them from a safe distance and then go through with ease.

The fact that some non-knife weapons do actually have situational uses also puts good players in the dilemma of throwing away the knife to make this section easier but the next section harder or keeping it for a harder section now but an easier section later. This lets players express their playstyles by showing what the prioritise, which of the two sections they find harder and how much risk they're willing to take, as I said vases give random weapons so you're not guaranteed to get another knife in the next section. It's not like you can re-roll infinitely either, not only is there a hard time limit but there are also constantly spawning enemies with unique abilities and varied terrain to make sure that you're constantly active and engaged even when farming vases to make the little vase farming you can do more interesting.

Having many simple game mechanics interact to make something this complex is the peak of game design. This all probably wasn't intentional, it was probably a lot of decisions they made due to hardware limitations coming together in an unexpected way, which worries me because there aren't any hardware limitations anymore. I'm afraid that we won't be seeing any more of this type of design unless it's being grandfathered in from already well-established genres and series. I'm worried that even if those things did somehow emerge a modern developer would change things in the name of 'quality of life' and 'player freedom'.


r/truegaming • • 13d ago

Does online gaming need more consequence for bad behavior?

42 Upvotes

This is something I've thought about a lot. I'm getting to be an old gamer, at 40 years old and having played games online for as long as that's been an option. I also play a lot of team sports out in the real world. Most gamers that abstain from online gaming will say one version or another of the same thing: They don't play online games because of the people that play online games.

Now what's the difference between a competitive activity online vs. in the real world? Why is it that in the real world, people can compete in a team environment and most of the time just have fun with each other, and not be dicks about it if a teammate makes a mistake or isn't playing at the level of the rest of the team, where in a similar situation online people would jump at their throats over it?

This is where my argument comes in. I think online gaming would be so much better and so much more inclusive if we had social consequence similar to that of the real world. The big reason why people are more civil in these kinds of activities in the real world is consequence. If you join a sport community and are constantly starting fights and getting into arguments with fellow players, you're not going to be allowed back. If you're kind of a dick, you're going to have someone set you aside and tell you to cool it down.

I argue that the only reason people behave worse online is simply that they get away with it. And yet at least most of those same people are able to control themselves in real world situations because they've internalized that they in fact cannot get away with it in that environment.

A lot of my formative gaming experiences were on Counter-Strike and TF2 community servers. Those servers all had their own rules and people to enforce consequences. If you found a good community the vibes would always be excellent, people were kind to each other, and as a side effect of being smaller communities where people would return regularly, you'd even actually make friends over time. People that were assholes, like in real life, would be ejected and barred from returning, either temporarily as a warning/time out, or permanently.

Do we need modern games to have community admins, like was the norm in gaming of past decades? I'd say yes, but I'm also curious to hear other takes on it.


r/truegaming • • 14d ago

The Soulslike genre is stuck at copying Fromsoftware

400 Upvotes

Soulslike games are trendy, every year there are at least a few of them coming out from bigger or lesser known developers. I love the original Dark Souls games made by Fromsoftware, naturally I am interested in checking out other soulslike. The overall quality is a mixed bag. While some of them are certainly better than others, some have quality that can even rival the best of Fromsoftware, I feel like the entire genre is stuck at being "replacement meal" for Fromsoft games before they eventually release their next big title.

Soulslike developers all seem to treat Dark Souls 1/2/3, Bloodborne and Sekiro as some kind of sacred standard, and the competition between soulslikes feels like they are competing to be the best at imitating the works of Fromsoft. Lies of P and Wuchang Fallen Feathers are exactly like this. They are both solid games that follow the design philosophy of the soulsborne games to a T. The differences are mainly in aesthetics and some tweaks in combat. You get the exact same kind dopamine kick as in the Soulsborne games.

Nioh I think is the soulslike franchise that is really confident at its own identity and it merely borrows elements from the mainline Souls games. The souslike elements are there to facilitate level design but the progression system and the "kick" are quite different from the souls game. By the third game no one compares it to Fromsoft anymore.

If we review the history of the soulslike genre, it couldn't be clearer that developers are just waiting for Fromsoft's signals to make changes before it is applied universally. Lord of the Fallen 2014 is seen as the first soulslike and the game is a direct clone to Dark Souls down to its medieval fantasy aesthetic and weighty combat. Bloodborne by Fromsoft came out at 2015 and it shows some significant divergent from the Dark Souls formula, including having a Victorian setting and a faster-paced combat system. Soulslike after that would have more diverse-setting other than medieval fantasy. Sekiro came out at 2019 and soulslike after that loves to add a deflect mechanic to the combat. Elden Ring came out at 2022 and I am very confident that we will see more developers attempt the openworld + soulslike design combo, in fact we already have Code Vein 2 which is like that.

My impression to the overall soulslike genre is that, many of them are hiding behind the label of soulslike, but in reality they are closer at being souls-clones. But Souls-clone sounds degratory seems it implies lack of creativity, so they called themselve "like" instead. Soulslike isn't the only genre that is named after one pivotal game. Roguelike and Metroidvania are the other ones that I can think of. And both Roguelike and Metroidvania have transformed so much that new games coming out are no longer being compared to the original Rogue or Super Metroid. I would even argue that games like Hades/Vampire Survivor and Hollow Knight effectively become the new blueprint for developers to follow instead of the original. Will that happen to Soulslikes one day? I am not so sure.


r/truegaming • • 13d ago

About recent discussion I've seen surrounding Shadow of the Colossus

9 Upvotes

This may be a very specific topic, but today I've been thinking about this and maybe some other people feel the same. Recently (and with "recently" I mean in last few years), whenever I see Shadow of the Colossus mentioned in Reddit it seems people only talk about its technical properties. People say "Oh, they designed it this way for technical reasons", "they could/couldn't do this because of technical reasons", "it was very innovative at a technical level when it was released" and, yes, this game was clearly good at a technical level when it came out, it still impress me that the PS2 could run this, even with the frame drops in some scenes. But I also think this recent focus on the technical side of things is very reductive and it saddens me because I've seen a few people trying the game just for that aspect, and later not feeling much after completing it.

I think the real main achievement of Shadow of the Colossus was it game design. I think (and this could be debatable) that this was one of the first games that achieved this so sought status of "art", it wasn't simply a set of mechanics to pass a good time, it was an "experience". What made it innovative is that from a game design point of view it tried to do a few things, mainly evoke feelings of solitude, magnitude and contemplation. Almost any videogame at the time would have put some mobs before the colossus, maybe some dungeons a la Legend of Zelda, but this game instead followed a minimalistic approach, everything was minimalistic, from its gameplay to its UI and its narrative. Instead of pushing the limits adding more and more mechanics it focused on the few things that achieved the emotions it was trying to convey.

From a narrative point of view, even if it was very simple, it also was effective, it made you feel bad for advancing through the game without telling you that you were doing something questionable (at least until the end). And even if the map was mostly empty the architecture and the environment seemed to tell some kind of story. I think this was a precursor of what Dark Souls would later popularize as "environmental storytelling".

Lastly, from a gameplay perspective it was also quite innovative. At the time you had games like God of War where Kratos quickly climbed colossal beings making you feel powerful, in fact, many of the AAA games were trying to push that "power fantasy" feeling. In contrast to this, Shadow of the Colossus made you feel powerless. Magnitude comes with a subtheme, your smallness compared to these Colossi. You are just some dude, not particularly powerful that wants to bring back his loved one to life. As you are not a powerful legendary warrior this is a battle of wits and endurance. The Colossi always tries to shake themselves to throw you off, and you endure however you can while trying to identify a weak point to attack with your little sword.

I think today, in a time where every AAA videogame tries to be bigger and bigger, introducing more and more mechanics, thus diluting the experience and turning into a set of superficial systems barely interconnected Shadow of the Colossus is still a breath of fresh air. Compared to modern games the game is objectively small, but it still feels big in my opinion and that cohesiveness is still hard to find nowadays.


r/truegaming • • 15d ago

/r/truegaming casual talk

22 Upvotes

Hey, all!

In this thread, the rules are more relaxed. The idea is that this megathread will provide a space for otherwise rule-breaking content, as well as allowing for a slightly more conversational tone rather than every post and comment needing to be an essay.

Top-level comments on this post should aim to follow the rules for submitting threads. However, the following rules are relaxed:

  • 3. Specificity, Clarity, and Detail
  • 4. No Advice
  • 5. No List Posts
  • 8. No topics that belong in other subreddits
  • 9. No Retired Topics
  • 11. Reviews must follow these guidelines

So feel free to talk about what you've been playing lately or ask for suggestions. Feel free to discuss gaming fatigue, FOMO, backlogs, etc, from the retired topics list. Feel free to take your half-baked idea for a post to the subreddit and discuss it here (you can still post it as its own thread later on if you want). Just keep things civil!

Also, as a reminder, we have a Discord server where you can have much more casual, free-form conversations! https://discord.gg/truegaming


r/truegaming • • 16d ago

Academic Survey How much of "game sense" can actually be taught?

12 Upvotes

One thing I've been thinking about, is the difference between knowing how to do something and being able to explain how to do it.

Take League of Legends as an example. Experienced players often seem to know when to engage, back off, or when an opponent is about to make a mistake. But when asked to explain their decisions, they might just be like "it felt like a good opportunity" or "just play more."

We have plenty of guides explaining mechanics, builds, rotations, and macro strategies. But I wonder, how much of that "sense", of what makes someone a good player, can actually be communicated through explanations.

I'm particularly interested in how this kind of knowledge is shared between players. Can experienced players effectively teach their intuition to others? Does learning through observation, replay reviews, or playing together communicate something that traditional explanations cannot? When players give advice to less experienced teammates, how much of their own understanding do you think gets lost in the process?

About our research

I'm a researcher at Northeastern University, currently working on a study about how skills and knowledge are acquired and shared within League of Legends communities, particularly knowledge that is difficult to explain in words.

We're conducting 30-60 minute online interviews through Microsoft Teams to better understand these experiences.

We're looking for participants who:

  • Are 18 years or older
  • Are currently located in the US
  • Have played League of Legends within the past month
  • Are comfortable communicating in English

All skill levels and game modes are welcome. Participation is voluntary and unpaid.

If you're interested in participating, you can find the study information and sign up here:

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScXuzmkmigh23fcn7qZkBui3p6XmN0curLq1cUvOV6K2QlrGg/viewform

For questions about the research, you can also contact the Principal Investigator, Dr. Erica Kleinman, at e.kleinman@northeastern.edu.

I'd also love to hear everyone's thoughts on the discussion itself, regardless of whether you're eligible or interested in the interview.


r/truegaming • • 17d ago

I asked over 100 people what goes wrong when they play co-op games with their partner.

246 Upvotes

Earlier this year I ran a small survey about couples who play video games together, or try to. 104 people answered, mostly between 25 and 40, almost all living together.

68% said one of them is very comfortable with games and the other finds it complicated or stressful. Only 14% play together every day, and 67% picked "rarely, we'd like to but we can't find what to play".

The one that really spoke to me: 66% have stopped suggesting a game because they were afraid their partner would have a bad time. 25% said it happened so often they gave up.

When a session goes wrong (you could pick several), the top answers were someone getting annoyed at the game or the controller (50%), and the partner who struggles feeling like a "burden" or "dead weight" (49%). An actual argument was "only" 18%.

When I asked what discourages the less comfortable partner the fastest, dying again and again until you're stuck came first. Then the camera, moving it with the right stick while walking, and having to react fast. Too many buttons came last, which I didn't expect. A few people also mentioned motion sickness, or 3D games giving their partner headaches.

The most surprising one: for "I would play more often with my partner if I knew that...", almost half picked "we could do very short sessions (20-30 min)". Way above difficulty (27%) or the risk of an argument (24%).

I also asked what a co-op game absolutely needs to feel relaxing. The two top answers: you respawn right away with no penalty (60%), and you win or lose together (58%).

And when I asked which mechanic would reassure them the most, it was a tie at 36% each. On one side, an easy game where you're there for the story and the landscapes. On the other, one person playing the hard hero part while the other plays something that can't die, like in some Nintendo games. Not everyone agrees though. One person wrote "We dislike when one of us has a 'dumbed down' role."

Obviously not a scientific study: people chose to answer, and most of them were the gamer of the couple. What strikes me is how little of this is about skill. The free camera, punishing deaths, sessions that only make sense if you have two hours: these are design choices.

I shared these results in r/CoOpGaming yesterday, but I'm curious how a more design-focused crowd reads them.

Which co-op games do you think get this right for two players with very different experience, and which ones look friendly but fall apart once the less experienced player picks up the controller?


r/truegaming • • 18d ago

Genuine question from someone feeling pretty indifferent about GTA 6: What does a $1B to $2B budget actually achieve that a $100M-$200M game can't?

299 Upvotes

Not trying to ragebait or be contrarian here, I'm genuinely curious to hear from people who are super hyped for the game.

​Right now I'm honestly pretty apathetic toward GTA 6. Maybe that changes once reviews and raw gameplay drop since Rockstar still hasn't done a proper gameplay deep dive, so I'm just waiting to see how it actually plays. And don't get me wrong, the lighting, graphics, and animations look great. Calling them bad would be crazy. It's just that being on PC, I've already seen what high-end visuals can do, so graphics alone don't really move the needle for me anymore.

​For context, Vice City was my first open-world game and it blew my mind as a kid. I played it day and night. But by the time I got around to GTA 5, I had played a lot of other games and honestly didn't find GTA 5 that great. So I already have some built-in skepticism going into 6. (I did really love RDR2 though, aside from how overly restrictive the mission design was, but I digress).

​What I really can't wrap my head around is the budget. Whether it's $1 billion or the rumored $2 billion, that is an incomprehensibly massive amount of money. If you look at games that pushed crazy mechanical ambition or defined genres, their budgets look like pennies next to GTA 6 even when adjusted for inflation:

​Half-Life 2 (~$40M, or ~$70M adjusted) revolutionized physics and environmental storytelling

​FEAR (~$15M, or ~$25M adjusted) and Alien Isolation (~$35M, or ~$50M adjusted) set benchmarks for tactical and adaptive AI that modern AAA games still haven't beaten

​STALKER (~$5M-$10M, or ~$15M adjusted) simulated an entire living zone offline with A-Life

​Skyrim (~$85M, or ~$125M adjusted) built a persistent sandbox so modular that unpaid modders are still turning it into completely new games

​Shadow of Mordor (~$50M-$100M) created dynamic procedural rivalries with the Nemesis system

​MGS V (~$80M, or ~$110M adjusted) had enemy AI dynamically adapting to your tactics and loadouts

​Witcher 3 (~$81M total, or ~$110M adjusted) set a huge benchmark for open-world quest writing

​Death Stranding (~$100M, or ~$125M adjusted) turned literal walking and terrain balance into a deep mechanic

​Tears of the Kingdom (~$100M-$120M, or ~$130M adjusted) pulled off an interconnected physics and chemistry engine on ancient Switch hardware

​BG3 (~$100M-$150M, or ~$165M adjusted) set a massive bar for branching quest reactivity

​KCD2 (~$41M) delivered deep systemic RPG mechanics and NPC reactivity on a fraction of a modern AAA budget

​Even RDR2 (~$170M-$240M dev cost, or ~$500M total with marketing / ~$650M adjusted) cost way less than what is reportedly being thrown at GTA 6.

Hell, even unpaid modders working on massive STALKER (like Anomaly/GAMMA) and Skyrim overhauls manage to stitch together deeper interconnected survival and world systems than most modern AAA studios just through smart design rather than brute-force cash.(its quite crazy)

Few more example - Crimson Desert ($133M), Elden ring($100M approx), dragons dogma 2($67M), cyberpunk 2077($442 M)

​So my question is, what kind of mechanical(including NPC AI related improvements) jump can a video game actually make going from a couple hundred million to over a billion dollars? Does ambition and scope actually scale like that in game dev, where throwing 5,000 devs and endless money at a project equals a proportionally crazier game?

​No other studio gets the luxury of that kind of manpower and budget for years on end. If smaller teams can pull off genre-defining mechanics, smarter AI, and crazy systemic depth with way less resources, what are you guys expecting Rockstar to pull off here that nobody else can? Because just going off the trailers so far, I haven't really felt that gap. Genuinely curious what you guys think.

Edit: To clarify my original point, I was thinking primarily about gameplay mechanics, systemic depth, and AI. I'm admittedly biased here, as I personally feel that pushing animation and graphical fidelity past Red Dead Redemption 2 hits diminishing returns. Cosmetic polish is fine in moderation, but pouring resources into superficial details doesn't necessarily make a better game for me. While RDR2 is packed with granular details, very few of them translate into meaningful gameplay or world reactivity. Contrast that with Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2, where those details are thoughtfully integrated into the core mechanics and story. By comparison, Rockstar's approach feels a bit like a museum. impressive to look at and talk about, but mostly not that deeply interactive & shallow. As a result, it gets stale, and the novelty wears off pretty quickly since it isn't useful in any meaningful capacity. When playing games, my intention is always to see how far things can go in terms of simulation and what the game accounts for. If you give me a system, I will try to abuse it just to see what crazy things I can do but Rockstar prioritizes observational and physical realism (how the world looks, sounds, and physically reacts to impacts) over systemic simulation (how underlying infrastructure systems dynamically interact with one another, its called object affordances and emergent synergy) so it's not really doable.Rockstar spends millions creating the appearance of a living world, but gives you zero meaningful verbs to actually play with it. all show and no substance, it looks like a living, breathing world. But the moment you step in to interact with that simulation, the matrix breaks down, it's the Deception of passive, cinematic immersion.


r/truegaming • • 18d ago

"Cozy" has become a genre label, and I can't work out what mechanic it actually describes

0 Upvotes

A roguelike or a metroidvania tells me roughly what the loop is going to be. With "cozy" all I can really picture is the pastel Steam capsule.

Take the usual claim that cozy means no failure state. In Stardew you still pass out at 2am and lose gold. Animal Crossing has real-time gates a lot of players resent. Spiritfarer carries the tag and it's largely about saying goodbye to people who are dying.

The closest I've come is that cozy describes permission more than mechanics. It lets you decide when something counts as finished. I spent time with Petit Planet recently, where you farm, fish, cook and shape a small planet, and I rarely felt pushed to do any of it in a set order. A farming game built around crop deadlines shares the tag and not much of the structure.

So is there a mechanical core I'm missing, or is cozy just an art direction and a promise about tone? If it is a design category, what disqualifies a game from it?