r/U2Band • u/Vince2019 • 44m ago
The Blood Records zoetrope
I limited myself to only 3 out of the 64 different pressings of Carnaval de Luz. This one just looks cool.
This week's song of the week is "Midnight Sunshine". Kicking off the back fourth of the album, it stands, in a certain sense, as the album's conclusion--the beginning of the falling action after the climax. The ending of the climactic, Abbey Road-esque heart of the album. It harkens back to some of U2's earlier poppier tracks, "Wild Honey" or "The Sweetest Thing", but it's not "obviously" a pure love song. Instead, it summarizes the "way out" of the strife. NPR's Ann Powers calls the line "The stars are only there for us" pantheistic. Whether evocative of God, natural beauty, nights out on the town, a phone-screen, the song gives an answer to pessimism or even evil. To both contrast and connect with the "God" reading (for better or worse), there is something of a Terrence Malick-like "To the Wonder" approach. The song gives the listener something direct to grab a hold of toward the end of the treatise of an album.
You use the phrase “defiant joy”, which isn’t unusual for U2 – but you are releasing this album into a world of trouble. Was there a conscious decision not to make an album of angry protest music, to give people something more upbeat they could grasp onto?
EDGE: Absolutely. We do want to make reference to what’s going on in the world, but I think it’s how you respond is important. There’s some lines – “Catastrophising is the glamourising of the world’s pain/If you don’t want to make the devil bigger, stop repeating his name”. That’s how you respond. If you just sit there wringing your hands, and allowing the narrative and the agenda to be set by bad actors, then they win."
...
Reviews
“U2 show they’re nowhere close to a finish line on ***Carnaval de Luz***, whose central theme seems to be “it’s not too late”: It’s not too late to party (“Go [Carnaval de Luz]”), not too late to find God (“Midnight Sunshine”)…
The album’s best songs come toward the end, and they’re anything but quiet…“Midnight Sunshine” feels like it could be both a sex jam and an end-of-the-world party song, since Bono’s lyrics — “In the dark, we discover midnight sunshine” — are open to interpretation.” (Rolling Stone)
...
“Those who don't mind a little preaching will appreciate the way he continues to play with that tradition, as on "Midnight Sunshine," a bubblegum soul number that turns on the pantheistic punchline, "You say God no longer cares for us / I say the stars are only there for us to shine." Banal on the page, Bono's words gain the light they need from a melody that feels like a mnemonic tool or, yes, a prayer. This is something that he's said before, a tiny pep talk to stay connected. Dogma breaks things, but the night is illuminated; let's dance." (NPR)
...
But in other places, Carnaval De Luz collapses under its own weight. The classic pinging U2 guitar sound on “Street of Dreams” feels like part of an assembly of U2 moments, sharpening a cynical edge to the song’s optimism. On “Midnight Sunshine,” Bono seems pressed to come up with something joyful and resorts to cliché. “You say God no longer cares for us/ I say the stars are only there for us,” he sings, coming to a dramatic pause before concluding: “To shine.” (Glide Magazine)
...
He does return to the universal idea of following the light in a less intrusive way on “Midnight Sunshine,” but its chintzy soul, so completely out of place here, offsets the joyous abandon they hinted at earlier. (No Ripcord)
...
For a band often accused of bombast, there is a lightness of touch to songs such as Glorify that suits them. Similarly, Midnight Sunshine frets about an anxious world (“Time to take cover / In your bedroom or a bunker“) but within one of their sweetest, loveliest pop songs. (The Guardian)
...
Martin Garrix shows up for a co-write on “Glorify,” whose badgering topline sounds ripped straight from Imagine Dragons’ playbook. The same goes for the anodyne, anonymous “Midnight Sunshine,” a wet dream for advertisers commissioning a soundalike. It also features some of Bono’s worst-ever lyrics: “On a small screen you discovered not all people are good / That’s not such a surprise to me / That’s why your friendship’s such a prize for me.” (Paste Magazine)
...
"Bono’s voice is isolated over a stacked synthetic choir as he specifically calls out the misrule of “the prince of the power of the air” (a title for Satan in Ephesians 2:2) who speaks through earthly “emperors of despair”. “We’ve got some words for your boss,” Bono sings, “you can go right back to hell.” For an album fuelled by political protest, Carnaval is noticeably unspecific about naming names. “Catastrophising is the glamorising of the world’s pain / Don’t want to make a devil bigger, stop repeating his name,” Bono sings on the limber, Motown-flavoured Midnight Sunshine (made with the dance producer Martin Garrix)." (The Telegraph. correction: this track was not produced by Garrix.)
...
"’Glorify’, meanwhile, quietly flirts with gospel, while ‘Midnight Sunshine’ sounds off the cuff, laid-back, everything revolving around the melody. Subtlety has never been U2’s stock in trade, to put it mildly, but here, it suits them." (NME)
...
Lyrics:
"(Yeah)
Time to take cover
(Yeah)
In your bedroom or a bunker
(Yeah)
In the dark we discover
Midnight sunshine"
Midnight sunshine: a paradox taken literally (one played with by U2 before on "Lemon", "midnight is where the day begins", but one that eases itself into the poetic register. I sit here now, writing to you on Reddit, at 10:30 at night, my screen lit up by the thoughts and words of several different people.
...
"I got a feeling like we're losing but it feels like a win
Here on the ceiling, watching more than the whole world spin
You can move, but always keep the same address
One eighty thousand miles per hour more or less we move"
There is a reference to 'home', like heaven or knowledge. But it, here, is subtle. You can move, but you always keep the same address...
"Yeah)
Time to take cover
(Yeah)
In your bedroom or a bunker
(Yeah)
In the dark we discover
Midnight sunshine
(Midnight sunshine)
Your heart is breaking now in ways you never knew that it could
On a small screen you discovered not all people are good
That's not such a surprise to me
That's why your friendship's such a prize for me
Sing me a song like a boxing glove
(Don't sing me a love song)
Sing me a song that the world is afraid of
(Don't sing me a love song)
And if you're mad at this world and you've had enough
(Don't give up, no)
In the imagination of God we are all made up"
U2's relationship with technology has been interesting. That dates back to the earliest criticisms of The Edge's Guitar playing (in some ways, still having its roots in the "Dylan goes electric" circus, to ZooTV, up to "Unknown Caller" from No Line on the Horizon. The small screen could just as well represent a cruel break-up playing out through Instagram, a mean comment section, and anything 'distasteful' you can imagine all the way up to literal videos of bombs being dropped on villages, people being burned alive, etc. Perhaps this is a line, even, addressed to the gen-z or younger U2 fans.
Then, we get a bit of urgency that leads into that 'pantheistic' idea referenced by Powers--here bordering on a kind of Berkeleyan idealism, "We are all made in the imagination of God". Given the rest of the album and context on the track, I do hear this as a kind of playful thesis more than a serious commitment. This is one of the more extreme versions of Christianity, perhaps played with, at least, by the band on The Joshua Tree--and here it stands as both a confident 'appraisal' and a wink to all us non-believers. What else can we do? Well, it doesn't seem like the more totalizing concept of "Midnight Sunshine" (which, if anything, sounds pretty Eastern) leaves anyone out. This leads into the next lines.
"Catastrophising is the glamorizing of the world's pain
Don't want to make a devil bigger, stop repeating his name
You say God no longer cares for us
I say the stars are only there for us
(Midnight sunshine)
To shine
(Shine)
We’re midnight sunshine
Midnight sunshine
We’re midnight sunshine
We’re midnight sunshine"
Referencing "stars being there for us" sits in a slightly different register than the idealism above. It's grounded in the material world with a kind of teleology. Bono sang on "In A Little While", "A man dreams one day to fly/A man takes a rocketship into the skies/He lives on a star that's dying in the night/And follows in the trail, the scatter of light" and on albums like No Line On the Horizon (leaning into this also on the 360 Tour) that WE are made of "star stuff". Noted agnostic thinker Carl Sagan put it like this,
"The cosmos is within us. We are made of star-stuff. We are a way for the universe to know itself".
The synthesis of these views is one of the poetic strong points of the song. Along with the, above discussed by the Edge, way it stands as a kind of final answer. "Don't make the devil bigger". In that moment, it's hard to not look back to the SOE tour era and wonder, "Is that Trump?", but the mere pervasiveness of the theme of 'evil' takes it beyond that. And begins to get into Bono's own ramblings on the song. He wonders "Why won't the GOP come home"...
"Bono: We didn't want to— there's a line in Midnight Sunshine which goes, catastrophizing is the glamorizing of the world's pain. If you don't want to make a devil bigger, stop repeating his name. So we, you know, we just didn't want to talk about certain stuff. And, you know, can I go on here for just a second?
The Daily: Sure. You've never stopped before.
Bono: I know. I'm so sorry about that. But You know, if you can separate a discussion about this administration from a discussion about the left and the right and conservatives and liberals, then I'm fine to go ahead with it because I think this is the most extraordinary moment. I mean, I think this is the greatest heist in the history of the world, stealing America. And it's, it's, it's not a caper movie. It's real and it's happening. And, and I can, you know, I'm not— I just don't want to, want to, want to put off good people who vote conservative, who vote Republican. You know, their, their party's been hijacked. It's an aggressive takeover of the GOP. I want to invite them back. I want them to return. I want to make— they, you know, because people vote conservative for all kinds of reasons that are okay. So if we can talk about it without getting to the usual logheads, we can say, but this is a serious problem. And I have serious personal dealings with this because 25 years of work in development." (From The Daily podcast).
...
"Catastrophising is the glamorizing of the world's pain
Don't want to make a devil bigger, stop repeating his name
You say God no longer cares for us
I say the stars are only there for us
(Midnight sunshine)
To shine
(Shine)
We’re midnight sunshine
Midnight sunshine
We’re midnight sunshine
We’re midnight sunshine
(Yeah)
Time to take cover
(Yeah)
In your bedroom or a bunker
(Yeah)
In the dark we discover
Midnight sunshine
Midnight sunshine"
...
The track is catchy, smooth, and deep. It is one of the most "U2" songs on the record. I enjoy/agree with the points from The Telegraph (on the track's connection to the rest of the album) and NME (on the track's subtlety). It's still early-days for the album though. I haven't listened to it (the song or album) enough to really try to tie a bow on it yet like I try to do in these posts at times. But I hope the quotes and light analysis above will be appreciated by some of you.
"'Midnight Sunshine' is one of the catchiest, poppiest songs U2 have produced. It’s the sort of song that sticks in your head long after the album has finished playing. After all these years trying to craft the perfect pop song, perhaps it was only when they stopped trying so hard that they finally got there. It seems to come more naturally here than previous attempts. There are a number of songs on the album that simply stick in your brain, yet seem far less laboured than past attempts.
This song felt instantly familiar, although it took me a little while to work out why. Eventually it was Bono’s vocal delivery that gave it away. In 2023, Bono and The Edge took part in a special with David Letterman. As part of the A Sort of Homecoming documentary, we see Bono and The Edge working to craft a song for Letterman called “Forty Foot Man”. “Midnight Sunshine” has some roots in that earlier song. You can hear the connection in the vocals and in parts of the music. In the documentary, “Forty Foot Man” plays over the final credits, but it has not been released separately. “Forty Foot Man” was crafted while the documentary was being filmed in late 2022." (U2songs.com)
...
Sources:
r/U2Band • u/mancapturescolour • 10d ago
🎩Come-all-ye fellow travelers, true beLIEvers, churchgoers, better angels, devils, fans, and friends...!🤫
Welcome, welcome one and all!
Please have a seat! The Greatest Show On Earth from the North Side of Dublin is about to restart and reboot itself! After years of anticipation, U2’s 16th studio album, "Carnaval De Luz", will arrive this Friday, November 13, 2026!
With less than 48 hours to go until release day, this submission will serve as our central hub for this new album release.
Whether you are counting down to when the day begins, heading out to a record store listening party, or hosting one yourself at home, use this hub to share excitement, first-listen reactions, and meetup info.
After listening to recent community feedback, we are not locking all album coverage inside a single mega thread. Here is a brief guide about what goes where over the next week or so:
For information on the many variants, we recommend u2songs.com Discography:
Apple Music - https://music.apple.com/us/album/carnaval-de-luz/6812412381
Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/album/07Q9bUJarYrFjhxofoenM0
YouTube Music - https://youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_lP5wEx9FgsCWG8XYaC1N1G3_EJUjxtQms
2026-11-11 iHeart Live Premiere of Album and Interview
2026-11-11 SiriusXM Performance and Conversation
2026-11-12 Appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live
2026-11-25 Netflix Halftime Show for the Packers vs Rams football game
The Greatest Show on Earth World Tour 2027: Kicks off for the first of three initial legs on February 23, 2027, in Mexico City, Mexico. Leg 2 starts in Europe on Wednesday April 26 2027 with three dates in Stockholm, Sweden. Leg 3, North America, is expected to be announced this month.
Additional legs of the tour are yet to be confirmed or announced but the Greatest Show On Earth Tour is expected to go into 2028 and conclude with a homecoming show(s?) in Dublin, Ireland according to The Edge himself.
Additional resources:
For a more complete archive of the reviews for "Carnaval De Luz", see u2songs.com promo campaign pages
r/U2Band • u/Vince2019 • 44m ago
I limited myself to only 3 out of the 64 different pressings of Carnaval de Luz. This one just looks cool.
r/U2Band
•
u/VirsaBags
•
4h ago
Here is my list of some lost gems of U2, they deserve our love, it seems like we will never enjoy them in their original and magnificent version. I miss this side of U2, without song overproduction, like in their earlier days. When they did not try to be a band like Coldplay. Maybe U2 is the band with the BEST unreleashed songs. I also sent "Star's Don't Go", it's a finished song, but almost nobody knows about it.
Most of the songs must come from the period around 2006 and later, during Rick Rubin Sessions and later during Songs of Ascent era etc. Some are snippets that fans captured from studio recordings I think.
I wish that ALL MY LIFE (2nd song I attached) could be fixed with AI, it would have been great to have it even like that... It's a truly amazing song, one of best U2 songs. I also love the first uknown song I attached, it shows great potential. Eno please come back!
Unknown : https://youtu.be/OKKHfhiPjMc?si=0xrN8BorS9XJIEL7
All My Life : https://youtu.be/EO8arThAKfk?si=bUN5g-tXUwM-blmj
Thank You For The Day (amazing with the waves) : https://youtu.be/QNRjCUULz1o?si=mjecIf_djVZ-btnS
We Love You (maybe alternative version of Please?) : https://youtu.be/YwWN0NBux3s?si=ZakOFu4yNU2K6dSQ
Moving Out (Joshua Tree era) : https://youtu.be/lnMTGJ7u4mc?si=iaDhXYlFQTI8XiE5
Womanfish (Joshua Tree era) : https://youtu.be/OGFmF59EBCU?si=qMWgx4nDvcH6UqIY
Be There (War era) : https://youtu.be/oXxmOGvCB28?si=Nt6gKiAYeVlWMN8G
Unknown no2 : https://youtu.be/l8hfnzrqAew?si=GREdklA7ebWu4Z8M
Glastonbury (became American Soul, unfortunately) : https://youtu.be/tJm_vPIxlR8?si=Xfzz0SNmdDphy2sq
Boy Fall From The Sky : https://youtu.be/ULboD3Dcbns?si=dcp_n8y0J-wJKx26
Soon : https://youtu.be/vM_iW9EtUgA?si=FjO40PbNnDKQlPCZ
Winter : https://youtu.be/4QGlH8551Sk?si=887F0ebbkPHIb2ua
Stars Don't Go (RIP Avicii) : https://youtu.be/fD4dZRv4ZSM?si=Px0Jm942oOmbUOE5
PS. Something out of context, when U2 were planning to play MOFO on Vertigo Tour, Edge's guitar is awesome: https://youtu.be/mDZT9vlOFVE?si=f7RVpeVqmdH8Dmst
r/U2Band • u/Swimming_Morning_113 • 20m ago
Anyone feel like this is Adams album, everyone talks about the edges brilliant guitar work but the bass on la reina, the mirror maker, silencio, GSOE and superficiality must be some of Clayton best work in years
r/U2Band • u/BeerWithDonuts • 16h ago
Like his contemporaries, Lanois has produced some of the most iconic hits of the 20th century. Why doesn’t he get his due flowers?
r/U2Band • u/WandaGoronski • 7h ago
I’m talking promos, albums, LPs, 7” singles. What’s your most coveted special U2 piece of memorabilia?
It has gone from great first impressions to what I think is an incredible collection of songs. There is some real energy in a lot of tracks, as a collection of songs they just work, and it's the first album I can remember that I choose to listen to in order, beginning to end (except I skip s u p e r f I c I a l I t y).
This just has to be played loud to appreciate the bass.
r/U2Band • u/MoistPorkchop • 9h ago
Update: contacted customer service and they said “these items are currently still in production and are not yet ready to ship. Please rest assured that your order remains in queue and will be fulfilled once production is complete.”
Am I crazy or does that sound like some BS?
r/U2Band • u/barrenillusion • 3h ago
this used to be on youtube and i would listen to quite often. i can't find it now. can any of you help me place the demo/song based on the below description?
it sounds like a jamming session. initially edge is playing a few repetitive chords and adam's matching it with the bass. bono is scatting. no discernible words. this repeats for a couple of minutes before the song picks up a little pace and larry 's drumming comes into the picture.
the youtube thumbnail photo was that of a recording studio. it's been running in my mind and any leads/thoughts are welcome.
r/U2Band • u/farwent • 22h ago
Listening to the "Track by Track" playlist for Carnaval de Luz on Amazon Music, which has the Edge talking for a minute or two about each song before it plays. Not sure if the band have mentioned this before, but I was pleased to hear him say this about "The Greatest Show on Earth":
"Lyrically, it could be read as just a straightforward love song. Or it could be read as a song bemoaning the end of Western civilization. [Laughs.] Or the end of a certain sort of movement in organized religion."
I feel like the conversation here has focused on the "straightforward love song" reading, and that's never fully satisfied me. It's always sounded to me as if, from the very first lines, Bono is singing to the audience, or U2 fans, or probably something even bigger, because it includes people who might not care for him at all.
For most of their career, U2 have been a sort of musical avatar for what you might call the modern liberal world order ("liberal" there being used not in the popular political sense but in the sense it's used in "liberal arts," not that there isn't plenty of overlap). It's what he's singing about in "Miracle Drug": Love and logic keep us clear / Reason is on our side, love … In science and in medicine. A major element of it is faith in a benevolent power beyond our comprehension blended with trust in our senses and what they tell us about the universe.
That world order is crumbling, and it's not clear yet what will replace it, but it makes sense for Bono to celebrate it even as he mourns it—it is flawed but has saved a lot of lives. Regardless of whether you agree with his feelings, it's pretty interesting he put them in this song.
r/U2Band • u/HansFranz92 • 22h ago
Nothing earth shattering but the fan club version CD, at least, has a different opening also. not as different as the vinyl version. In fact similar to the digital version with a loud “GO”…right before Bono kicks in. just something I noticed. That is all.
r/U2Band • u/mrjosh72 • 1d ago
I really like the album version of Silencio, but the live versions have been awesome.
Greatest Show on Earth is already my favorite recent U2 song by a long distance, but the live version at the Tate was absolutely extraordinary and hit a lot harder for me.
Can't Stop Us Now is a song I liked on the record, but the live version recorded for Sirius XM is incredibly energetic and absorbing. It's so cool to watch all the parts fit together. I appreciated the drum and guitar parts so much more. And Bono's singing.
My guess is that La Raina, Mirror Maker, and Superficiality (which I honestly really like—the lyrics are "superficial" on purpose, obv) will be incredibly dynamic and exciting live. And will we get to hear The Tears of Things? In a Life? I really hope so.
One of the best things about the band, for me, is finding out how the live versions extend the recorded versions.
r/U2Band • u/SisuSuperior • 22h ago
Since they announced there will be a queen of the carnival for each show on tour, I think that will start on Wednesday night. And I wonder if that queen will be Rosalia and she will perform—either one of her songs—or duet with Bono on something. That would be incredible because she is such a cool artist and it would be a massive stage for her. After seeing footage of the rock hall of fame performance I’m excited for what they’ll do next week!
r/U2Band • u/luminimattia • 1d ago
Welcome home Carnaval de Luz
Just addicted to this record
r/U2Band • u/ArugulaOriginal1860 • 21h ago
Anybody notice a slight change in tone for pride in the name of love? Bbc and the rock n roll hall fame
r/U2Band • u/Media6292 • 20h ago
r/U2Band • u/Wild_Mycologist_6140 • 15h ago
You can hear it throughout the song, but especially during the choruses (0:51, 1:55, and 3:06). Does anyone know what instrument it is?
r/U2Band • u/Outrageous-War5079 • 1d ago
After sitting with CdL for a week, this is what I’ve got:
80s:
90s:
21st Century:
Overall:
r/U2Band • u/Wild_Mycologist_6140 • 1d ago
For years I thought that the whole reason that Innocence and Experience were produced so badly, was because of Jackknife Lee. I audibly groaned when I heard that he would be producing Carnaval de Luz. I assumed that the reason the EPs sounded so good were because the were rushed and Jackknife didn't have enough time to ruin them. But maybe I was wrong. I have my problems with CDL, but none of them are about the production. Could it be that Jackknife was not the issue with the Songs of era? Maybe CDL sounds so good because Eno was involved, but either way, a Jackknife Lee produced U2 album sounds good. Maybe not as good as Achtung Baby, but the best they've sounded since NLOTH. I will no longer assume the worst when I see Jackknife's name attached to a U2 project. That being said, I would not complain if the went back to Eno for the next one.
Has anyone else been on a similar journey throughout the year?
r/U2Band • u/indiehart • 1d ago
I heard two u2 songs in the game so far and they are great choices too imo and here they are, Lemon and Unforgettable Fire! Unforgettable Fire was in a very cool non scripted emotional moment and i loved it, and Lemon came on during a sunset and it was just perfect. It was also the first band i heard two songs from in the game. Gta 6 is awesome btw don't listen to the haters who think patching up a house while waiting for your girl who you have a kid with together is being a cuck.. Amazing experience so far and i loved hearing my favourite band in it! That's it and have a nice day everyone. Got the album on repeat ya better believe it!
r/U2Band • u/Commerical-Pea2068 • 1d ago
The dreaded Apple incident, im just curious, if the album that was pushed was one of their best, would people have been as mad?
I remember when it came onto my phone as a kid and I was like what is this garbage and obviously wanted it off, I feel like if it was AB and or JT I would’ve been way more inclined to keep it on my phone.
What do others think? Its a 10 year old incident so it is old, but this subreddit is all about things U2 does/has done in the past and present