r/vfx • u/ViralTrendsToday • 6h ago
News / Article David Fincher Defends AI Use Amid 'Cliff Booth' Criticism
r/vfx • u/ZiggyisStarman • Apr 30 '26
Hey fellow Visual Effects community stoked to share what we have been working on for the past year over at he VES Technology Committee call it a playbook and usage guide to map key data from on-set capture to delivery.
FYI I am one of the co-authors of the Guide. If you have questions or feedback make sure to reach out.
You can find the guide here : https://ves-on-set-data.org/dashboard/?tab=Introduction
Here is the full information on the release :
The Visual Effects Society (VES), the industry’s global professional honorary society, today released its VES On-Set VFX Data Collection and Usage Guide. Developed over the past year by the VES Technology Committee, this practical on-set resource maps key data sets and capture workflows – giving productions, vendors, and technology teams a shared playbook for using and capturing on‑set data more effectively.
The Guide was designed to establish a common language between on‑set VFX, production, VFX facilities, and technology teams, ultimately enabling clearer communication, smoother handoffs, and better-aligned expectations across departments. This comprehensive Guide explains the major on‑set data sets, their capture methods, their practical applications, and their intended stakeholders, so that every participant across the production understands what information exists and how it can support their work.
In addition to defining data sets, the Guide documents both current and emerging on‑set data capture workflows. This aims to inform stakeholders about potential data sources and to highlight how these choices impact production pipelines, timelines, and budgets, while also laying the groundwork for future efforts around data hierarchies, database development, and workflow automation.
The Guide also underscores that this data has significant value for every department on a production. It supports collaboration, optimizes workflows, and enables better-informed creative and operational decisions. By advocating for open access and visibility for these data sets, the Guide encourages all teams to engage with and benefit from this shared knowledge, strengthening collective outcomes and overall production efficiency.
“Our intent with this Guide is to streamline the filmmaking process by enabling every department to be more well-informed,” said Sheena Duggal, the Guide’s lead author and member of the VES Technology Committee. “Multiple departments can utilize the same data – for instance, the VFX team’s LiDAR scans can be repurposed across departments to support set construction, stunt planning, and other production needs. It’s just a matter of educating and communicating clearly so that everyone can benefit.”
“In today’s hybrid of real-time virtual production, AI, and traditional pipelines, the VFX department is responsible for not just post, but on-set data capture, continuity, and asset integrity from pre-production through final delivery,” explained Jim Geduldick, contributing author to the Guide. “That framework was the key lens that we used in thinking through these workflows and how they relate to each department.”
The Guide was created for the VES Technology Committee by Sheena Duggal, with contributions from Sam Richards, Jim Geduldick, and Jake Morrison, and technical support from Jean-Francois Panisset. It is licensed under the Creative Commons CC‑BY 4.0 Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, and build upon the material in any medium or format, including for commercial purposes, provided appropriate credit is given to the creator.
To view the Guide, visit: https://ves-on-set-data.org/
Join the VES for a webinar on May 12 to explore the Guide with some of its creators: https://vesglobal.org/event/webinar-introduction-to-ves-on-set-vfx-data-collection-and-usage-guide-online/
r/vfx
•
u/axiomatic-
•
Mar 15 '25
We've been getting a lot of posts asking about the state of the industry. This post is designed to give you some quick information about that topic which the mods hope will help reduce the number of queries the sub receives on this specific topic.
As of early 2025, the VFX industry has been through a very rough 18-24 months where there has been a large contraction in the volume of work and this in turn has impacted hiring through-out the industry.
Here's why the industry is where it is:
The combination of all of this resulted in a loss of a lot of VFX jobs, the closing of a number of VFX facilities and large shifts in work throughout the industry.
The question is, what does this mean for you?
Here's my thoughts on what you should know if you're considering a long term career in VFX:
Work in the VFX Industry is still valid optional to choose as a career path but there are some caveats.
Before you jump in, you should know that VFX is likely to be a very competitive and difficult industry to break into for the foreseeable future.
If you're interested in any highly competitive career then you have to really want it, and it would also be a smart move to diversify your education so you have flexibility while you work to make your dream happen.
While some people find nice stable jobs a lot of VFX professionals don't find easy stability like some careers.
Because a future career in VFX is both competitive and pretty unstable, I think you should be wary of spending lots of money on expensive specialty schools.
With all of that said VFX can be a wonderful career.
It's full of amazing people and really challenging work. It has elements of technical, artistic, creative and problem solving work, which can make it engaging and fulfilling. And it generally pays pretty well precisely because it's not easy. It's taken me all over the world and had me meet amazing, wonderful, people (and a lot of arseholes too!) I love the industry and am thankful for all my experiences in it!
But it will challenge you. It will, at times, be extremely stressful. And there will be days you hate it and question why you ever wanted to do this to begin with! I think most jobs are a bit like that though.
In closing I'd just like to say my intent here is to give you both an optimistic and also restrained view of the industry. It is not for everyone and it is absolutely going to change in the future.
Some people will tell you AI is going to replace all of us, or that the industry will stangle itself and all the work will end up being done by sweat shops in South East Asia. And while I think those people are mostly wrong it's not like I can actually see the future.
Ultimately I just believe that if you're young, you're passionate, and you want to make movies or be paid to make amazing digital art, then you should start doing that while keeping your eye on this industry. If it works out, then great because it can be a cool career. And if it doesn't then you will need to transition to something else. That's something that's happened to many people in many industries for many reasons through-out history. The future is not a nice straight line road for most people. But if you start driving you can end up in some amazing places.
Feel free to post questions below.
r/vfx • u/ViralTrendsToday • 6h ago
I've been building Kayzee 3D, a free native app that opens and renders scenes from a classic 1997 3D program. I studied its file formats to match the renderer. The app code is mine and uses the MIT-licensed stecyk3d renderer as a base.
Not done yet: saving to the original format, 8 scenes still failing, some older sky/object files unreadable.
Testers needed, especially on Windows. The Windows build has only run under Wine, not on a real PC.
Download: https://github.com/lefotugrapher/kayzee-3d/releases
Tell me your OS, GPU, what broke, and a screenshot if you have one.
Only Blender book is the one i owned.
others borrowed and haven't given back ever since.
r/vfx • u/Lower-Needleworker46 • 9h ago
Hey everyone! How's it going?
I've been working on a little tool on and off for a while and thought I'd share it here to get some feedback.
It's basically a simple pipeline generator for post-production workflows (compositing, 3D, AI, etc.). It creates a folder structure based on the type of project and also generates the corresponding project files with some basic settings already configured.
It also includes a small project/shot manager, kind of a very simplified ShotGrid, where you can review shots, add notes, open them, render and manage deliveries, all in one place.
It's still very much a work in progress, and I'm sure there are plenty of tools out there that already do this much better, but I wanted to build something lightweight and flexible that could work across different types of projects.
It's a standalone executable, so there's no installation needed. Just point it to your working directory and you're good to go.
I'd love to hear what you think, what might be useful, what doesn't make sense, or what could be improved. It's also open to anyone who wants to contribute or suggest ideas.
Thanks!
r/vfx • u/Imaginary-Sun1350 • 11m ago
r/vfx • u/RegularFrosting7513 • 7h ago
I recently installed MochaPro, but it doesn't appear in After Effects (CC V.26.3), and when I select Update, it doesn't work. What can I do?
r/vfx • u/beforesandafters • 12h ago
This is part of the 'Great Effects Moments in History' series:
r/vfx • u/draculasdiaper • 22h ago
r/vfx • u/Gloomy-Detective-922 • 13h ago
Hey guys , need a vfx artist for a music promotional video next week.
Small job, just need a specific object passing through a security scanner screen.
Paid. I am UK but you can be anywhere.
Pm me portfolio and I can let you know details :)
2 shots, a few seconds. That's all it took for everyone to pinpoint AI usage in the new David Fincher movie. Cliff Booth.
I've read so many artists complain about how hard it was for them to deliver shots to David Fincher. Endless notes in shots, a ton of work redone for the sake of "perfectionism".
But here's the thing: AI is good at imposing limits. "If you want a new generation, pay more money". And this is where things get a weird. Humans will deal with endless notes, spend nights and days trying to achieve the perfect look, but AI will work only after payment. It's hidden behind a platform and if the results are unsatisfying, the filmmaker can only try again, change the platform, or give up and accept defeat. The "unperfected" shot is used and looks like shit.
r/vfx • u/ViralTrendsToday • 2d ago
First is Patrick's reaction, Second is Next Best Picture article, Third image is Louis Peitzman's confirmation.
Generative AI Supervisor confirmed in credits.
r/vfx • u/slimshadysghost • 1d ago
I recently purchased an 8-week Rebelway course for Houdini/Unreal. Despite the course still using Houdini 17.5 and Unreal Engine 4.2 (a bit ridiculous; this should be updated by now), it has been pretty fun to follow along with.
However, access to a Discord channel was advertised for this course, and despite starting Week 3 today, I still do not have access. Unless I am mistaken, this is something that is supposed to come with all courses. You can find mentions of it in reviews on the Rebelway website, in personal posts on places like Reddit, in emails you get when you sign up, and you get told to join the Discord in the Rebelway Dashboard.
So, I tried to join the Discord before the course even started. Yet, I couldn't find any link to join. I figured that I just had to wait until the course actually started. Day one comes around, and there's no link. I sent a message to support about this. They replied, "Our fall session discord channel is not yet available, Once its created You will be able to join our Private Discord chat channel directly from your dashboard. You will have that option on your dashboard right next to the course. once you click on (JOIN THE DISCUSSION) you will be part of our chat community."
I found this a bit odd because I felt like this should be available on day one, but okay, whatever. Week 1 goes by and Week 2 starts... still no access. So, on 11/16, halfway through Week 2, I send another message asking why there is still no Discord access. By 11/18, I have received no response, and at this point I'm pretty annoyed. I sent another message, demanding to know why, when nearly done with Week 2 of a $600+ course, I do not have access to something directly advertised for the course. I am supposed to have access to my instructor and other artists. I also attached a message in a .txt file to my Week 2 homework submission to see if the TA knows anything.
Fast forward to today, 11/20, still no response. So I sent another message clarifying that this is my fourth message about this, not including the one attached to the Week 2 homework submission, and informing them that they have 24 hours to resolve this, or I will be pursuing any means of getting my money back because it is unacceptable that I do not have access to this advertised feature.
Has anyone else experienced this with Rebelway? Do you have any advice? I am extremely disappointed, and frankly, pissed off.
r/vfx • u/villamossnake • 1d ago
I'm a 2D/3D animator and motion graphics artist. I work mainly with Blender and After Effects, creating animations, 3D models, VFX and motion graphics.
Here's the original video that this breakdown is based on:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rKXVv684rVo
My animation showreel:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uyDJwq0apn4
r/vfx • u/Several-Fish-7707 • 1d ago
I was talking with a friend about moving to China to work in the "new rising film industry" as 3D and FX Artists. They had offered him 3,600 RMB for a junior position (not a fresher), but when we looked online, the salaries seemed to be quite a bit higher.
Is this normal? Are salaries actually that low in certain areas of the industry? And is the industry in China actively looking for foreign talent, or are they mostly hiring locally?
What kind of salary would you realistically expect when moving there for work? And are living costs in China really that low to make these salaries reasonable?
Would be interesting to hear from people living or working there, especially in the film industry.
r/vfx • u/BedLost1601 • 2d ago
Sorry to add to the continuous bombardment of AI doom that this sub is already enduring. But it seems like most people fall on one of two sides. AI is the worst thing to happen to humanity, or AI is a great tool to make artists more efficient.
If you're on the latter side of this, I have a question. What should TDs do? We were the go to wizards who can make your lives easier, replicate your craft across 10s (sometimes 100s) of shots and assets, ensuring everything runs smoothly through the pipeline. Leaving you to worry about making things look good. It seems like our only choice now is to become a full pipeline developer, which arguably could be obsolete in the next 5 years, or learn how these AI tools work and use our technical knowledge to do it better, resulting in less jobs for artists.
I started out as an artist and have worked in pretty much all aspects of vfx over many years. But recently, my job has gone from developing artist workflows, creating tooling, providing support; to "Here's this tool I've made using Claude, add it to the pipeline"... "Why is it not done yet? I already had it working fine". "Oops I made whoopsie and broke the pipeline".
It's been putting out fires for over a year and I'm honestly burnt out. We put policies in place to limit what artists are allowed to do. But let's face it, you're waiting on pipeline to add your tool for weeks, you've typed some things into whatever llm and it made your dreams come true, you solved a problem, and now you're hooked. I get it. It's the reason us TDs do the job. Solving that problem gives you the dopamine hit and it's hard to do go back.
All of this long rant to ask, what should I transition to? What are you other TDs doing? And also a gentle reminder that when you're messaging a TD or pipeline developer, we're people and slack is not an AI prompt window. Thank you.
r/vfx • u/StarkTiger_6488 • 1d ago
The issue, When i render my sequence all geometry don't load . how to fix this because i don't have time . Already as much i knew to tried .
Now i don't know what i do ?
r/vfx • u/Delicious-Champion-2 • 1d ago
I'm interested in what software people are using to manage motion/video/vfx projects - including pre-production, ideation, pitch decks, shot tracking, feedback and approvals and anything in between.
And crucially, which of these completely suck, and why?
r/vfx • u/sharn_art • 2d ago
Hy, I just made my second Live action CG character composition in blender, I used AI to create a dragon model but Retopo , Rigged and animated by myself, I don't know if I still did good or not lol, I also designed the sound FX myself for this from Birds animals sounds,I tried my best hope I did good🤞
r/vfx • u/jonaskluger • 2d ago
Browsing a big HDRI library by its flat lat-long thumbnails never tells you much about how an HDRI would actually light a shot. So we created a small script that renders any HDR in a proper lighting preview instead.
It drops the HDRI into a studio scene with an 18% grey sphere, a chrome sphere and a color checker in the X-Rite ColorChecker Classic reference colors, and writes out a preview image.
.exr and .hdr and outputs .webp, .png or .jpg--rotation turns the panorama and lighting without touching the source file.blend file, so you can swap the camera, objects, materials or render engineUsage:python3 /path/to/hdri.py --input sky.exr --output sky_preview.jpg --width 1920 --height 1440
It's free on Nukepedia: HDRI Preview
Would love feedback, especially on what you'd want in the default scene.
r/vfx • u/Sagielee • 2d ago
Looking for tutorials (free on YouTube or paid) preferably using Cinema 4D, After Effects, or Mocha/Lockdown.
Hiii I've studying 3D, CGI by myself !
And found really nice VFX effect to learn.
Please if you have kind of these tutorial, please let me know!!! Huge Thanks!!!
r/vfx • u/immortalartscom • 3d ago
Hi VFX artists!
I'm Nikolaus, a 3D/VFX artist from Vienna with 20+ years of rendering. I built my own render delegate for Houdini 22 Solaris: karles22, bringing Blender's Cycles into Solaris. It's MaterialX native, Karma scenes switch over as they are. Speed is min. 2x of Karma.
I'm mostly an in-camera artist, so I wanted the look to come straight out of the render: real lens simulation (spherical and anamorphic, traced element by element), photon caustics, and post FX like halation, glow, streaks, aberration and grain in the beauty, optionally as separate passes. Cryptomatte and light AOVs for comp.
Everything in the video is recorded in real time, no speed-up.
I'm looking for people who'd like to test it on their own scenes and give honest feedback. Just DM me! Testers get a time-limited full version, no watermark and no viewport limit, unlike the demo.
It's a paid plugin: try it with the free demo, and if you like it, it's a perpetual license, no subscription. also have a look at the "rendered with karles²² gallery at: https://tools.immortal-arts.com
Cheers!