r/WoT • • 15d ago

Mod Message The Report Button, AI, and You

50 Upvotes

RULE UPDATES

First, I want to start out by mentioning that some months ago, we re-wrote the rules to hopefully be less confusing and more consolidated. Nothing about the spirit of the rules has been changed, we simply wanted them to be easier to read, and shorter to read so people didn't have to wade through pages of text to understand everything. As always, the rules are listed in the sidebar, and you can access them on our wiki. There are two primary reasons for this post, however.

AI CONTENT FARM SITES AND ARTICLES

The first is a discussion about AI, in multiple parts. I think the easiest part to deal with is concerning websites that spit out AI-generated articles that don't really share new news, or don't do it well. I think we can all agree that links to those articles don't really add anything to our community. If there is legitimate news, then a serious news source will report on it. So, I'd like to compile a list of known content farms and place a blanket ban on articles submitted by those sites. I know www.screenrant.com is one such site that we get frequent submissions from. Feel free to list others in the comments below. And if you see a submission for a slop article, please report it, citing Rule 7: No Piracy, AI, or Bots.

Regarding the above point, if you have an argument for allowing posts from these sites and not creating a blanket ban on them, please share your thoughts. We want to consider all possibilities with this and other AI issues.

AI ART

The next part is regarding AI-generated art. We don't intend to change our stance on that. If your post contains art that was AI-generated, it's going to be removed. What makes this hard to enforce is that the models are getting too good and becoming harder and harder to recognize. Part of the updated rules state that art submissions should indicate how you created a piece of art, or where you found. We know not everyone is going to read this rule, so pictures won't automatically be removed if they don't have that information. However, if someone suspects a picture is AI-generated, or it receives a report, we'll remove the post and the only way to have it restored will be to provide the missing source information.

VIBE CODING

Now we come to something slightly controversial. How do we want to deal with websites that were coded with AI? The reality of the matter is that software development has changed. Almost no one is actually writing code that is completely free of AI assistance anymore. And if they are, there's no good way to prove it.

The previous part will still apply. If the site has any AI-generated artwork or text, then it will be removed. This is largely in response to a recent post someone made about a map/timeline website they created. Their original submission did have some small bits of AI artwork as place holders, and AI coding assistance was used to help develop the site, but most of the work was done by a human.

We purposefully ignored the reports on the original post because the AI-generated content was minimal, the post was highly upvoted, and the comments were generally positive. At the same time, that submission got more reports that any other post or comment in the last year. So we're asking for thoughts on these types of submissions. They have removed all AI-generated artwork from their sites and we allowed the new submission. But the code of the site was partially made using AI tools. As moderators, we think this is an acceptable use of AI, but we want to get your thoughts on the matter. There is a different between AI assisted coding and completely vibe coded content. I think regardless of what gets decided, any site that looks potentially dangerous in the way it was coded, or is clearly vibe coded and shows incomplete or broken functionality, will be removed under the No AI rule.

BOT ACCOUNTS

This next part is about LLM bots used as karma farms, or being built to sell later, or just used to train an LLM. We had a string of these recently. Here is an example:

I think there's a fourth one I missing and couldn't quickly find, and there have been a couple more after these that we've removed. They were all made by different accounts, created within days of each other, with similarly formatted names, and posting in the same pool of other subreddits. They are all talking about a shift in opinion about the same character. (Reminder that this is a No Spoiler post, so I don't want to discuss the contents of those posts in any detail).

There are a few issues with these kinds of bots we need to talk about. The first is that the sophistication of these is growing too complex. We moderators alone can't necessarily identify these kinds of accounts by ourselves. This one happened to be a bit too obvious, and we think it was assisted by vote manipulation, because their submissions are all a bit higher in upvote count than we'd normally expect. That said, all of the comments in the comment section of these post were good content. Possibly repetitive due to the nature of the subject, but largely legitimate discussion, which is something we want to foster.

The accounts above have been banned, but the posts are going to remain, largely so we can link them in this post and give others the chance to see what we're talking about. Combatting this kind of bot behavior is hard. Especially because repeat topic posts aren't unique to bots. We can get 4 different, legit post about Elayne in a single day.

We think the easiest solution for this kind of situation is to report them under Rule 6: Prioritize Unique, Discussion-Focused Content. (The wording is fancy for No Reposts and No Low Effort content). This will let us quickly find duplicate submissions and remove them. On the off chance that the submission isn't created by a bot, but is just coincidentally posting a similar topic, removing a post under this rule isn't as offensive to legitimate users.

If you suspect a particular account is a bot and have some evidence, you can also report it using the No AI rule, but it would help us if you provide a comment in the post (or send us a modmail) with why you suspect it's a bot. That helps us investigate infractions and deal with them faster.

We're also open to suggestions on how to better combat the bots on a more fundamental level. Our primary hang-up is that we don't want to make legitimate new readers and/or new reddit users jump through hoops in order to be able to contribute to our community. We don't have karma requirements, and we don't prevent new accounts from creating posts (although we do hold them for manual review).

EDIT: I have installed a Bot-Bouncer Devvit App. It's actually flagging these pretty well, so hopefully we can see a reduction in these kinds of posts and comments. But please still report anything that might slip past.

REPORT BUTTON

This last section is a plea to users to engage with the report button more. It's never going to be possible for us mods to read every single comment. Something has happened in the last year or two, but this community used to be pretty good at policing itself and helping us find infractions by reporting them. Overall, the number of reports we get has significantly decreased.

This means that sometimes when we find infractions (90% of the time it's just people being rude to each other), two or three people have been yelling back and forth at each other for an hour or two. If someone insults you, report them and don't engage. If you see two people insulting each other, report them both so we can cut off the chain of insults before it pollutes half the thread.

In the same vein, if you see someone being racist or sexist or some other hateful content, report it and don't engage with them. There are certainly times and conversations that warrant talking about difficult subjects like that in the wider context of the text itself, the fandom, and the author, but you don't need to be insulting while having those conversations. Report those making bad faith arguments and let us clear them away so that everyone else can have civil and well-reasoned discussions.


r/WoT • • 10h ago

All Print The AUDACITY of Cadsuane Spoiler

194 Upvotes

On my second time through and once more I am astounded at the sheer audacity of Cadsuane. The way she treats people is truly remarkable. Can’t stand her. Excellent character.

That is all.


r/WoT • • 21h ago

No Spoilers Approaching Tar Valon

Post image
352 Upvotes

r/WoT • • 11h ago

Knife of Dreams (FIRST TIME READER) IMMEDIATE DAMN REACTION TO KoD CHAPTER 10 Spoiler

30 Upvotes

YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSS WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

SHE'S FRICKEN ALIVE

I KNEW IT

I CALLED IT I CALLED IT I CALLED IT I CALLED IT

I just didn't know how to fricken prove it BUT I COULD FRICKEN CRY RIGHT NOW, MY WHOLE DUDE MOIRAINE IS ALIVE AND-

F**k Lanfear, she got off so damn easy for having the fricken DO one her side to give her a get out of jail free card, that's so SCUMMY

But the letter. I cannot explain- I wish you all could have seen how much I was cackling reading that LETTER- MY GOD YES, WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Robert Jordan is INCREDIBLE. I do not know how you have such patience to pay off something set up eleven books prior, BUT DAMMIT HE'S TOO GOOD (him and Oda, holyyyyy)

Ya'll were right, this book is fricken incredible, I cannot believe the absolute peak I just read, holy frick


r/WoT • • 3h ago

Lord of Chaos I think Robert Jordan Foretold dissolving fillers Spoiler

5 Upvotes

This is entirely about Siuan and Leane. It's a joke. But yeah I've always imagined Aes Sedai faces as having Botox and fillers, and after being stilled, Siuan and Leane got them dissolved. And they look 20 years younger!!! The man even Foretold that fillers age you terribly if you get them too young


r/WoT • • 11h ago

All Print So does the Wheel on my first re-read turn.. Spoiler

Post image
20 Upvotes

As I started this reread I was curious how I'd find the following things this time around. On my first read I found Aiel Waste to be boring. Now I didn't mind it. On my first read I did not mind the slog so I was curious if I would now. Well, I had a break up so it became a slog because I just didn't read during that that much..

I was also curious of Sanderson's parts as I read half a dozen of his books after I last finished with this series. But they didn't do it for me. So here I am reading his parts of the wheels of Time and enjoying these once again.

What I really missed in between my first and second read was the pace and prose. I really love Jordan's writing but then again I come from being a Tolkien fan and he can describe a tree with two full pages. Most other authors feel rushing all the time. Damn, slow down and take your time!

There are no endings in Wheel of Time. This is not the end but an end.


r/WoT • • 18h ago

All Print Failed Reactions to the Dragon Spoiler

67 Upvotes

With so many factions in WoT, there is a wonderful diversity of reactions to the Dragon's rebirth. Most of them fail, because they're fighting against fate. I find some of the failures are particularly amusing:

Pedron Niall

The Plan: Let Rand cause chaos for a while, then swoop in to be the hero that defeats him. After that, just keep giving orders.

Was It A Decent Plan?: Decent enough, if Rand were a false Dragon. It's a strongly utilitarian plan driven by his messianic impulses ("sure some extra people will die, but it's worth it if I save the world for the Light"), but it's rational and considered.

Fatal Flaw: For some reason, Pedron Niall only believes in some of the Prophecies. He believes there will be a Last Battle but apparently not in the Dragon Reborn. Fanaticism is a hell of a drug.

Alanna (and various other Aes Sedai, I'm sure)

The Plan: Bond Rand to track/influence/control him (and bond the other ta'veren also, while we're at it)

Was It A Decent Plan?: Yes, based on what she knew about bonding. It's a deeply disturbing violation of Rand's consent when she does it, but the world's on the line and she was ready to pay the price.

Fatal Flaw: Bond compulsion does not work on Rand, and he's strong enough to whoop her ass both with and without the Power. (She never gets a crack at Mat after he gets healed in TDR. For Perrin, it's that Faile would murder her.)

The "Kill Rand and Forget The Stone Fell" Crowd

The Plan: Kill Rand, forget the Stone fell, pretend the Dragon was not reborn.

Was It A Decent Plan?: We know it's not rational, but it's an understandable reaction to living in exciting times.

Fatal Flaw: Denial doesn't solve the Dark One problem. They'll need the Dragon eventually.

Sevanna

The Plan: Marry Rand and wield power through him

Was It A Decent Plan?: No

Fatal Flaw: It's utterly insane.

Are there any failed reactions to Rand's arrival that you enjoy?


r/WoT • • 19h ago

No Spoilers Lanfear fanart by me

Post image
72 Upvotes

r/WoT • • 23h ago

The Gathering Storm Chapter 33: A Conversation with the Dragon Spoiler

Post image
86 Upvotes

I never wanted to hug a character as much as I wanted to hug Rand the first time I read this.


r/WoT • • 14h ago

Knife of Dreams (first time reader) A thought on the Dark One Spoiler

9 Upvotes

No spoilers past KoD chapter 9 please.

So, this is a touchy subject considering the place I am within my read. Obv, I'm books away from the end of the whole thing, I don't know as much as I need to right now, there's a lot of RAFO left to go, so I don't expect any confirmations or answers.

But as I was laying down and contemplating the end in sight for my reading of the story, I found myself, as I often do, going back to how everything in this story, everything in this world, ends up returning to two figures: the Dragon and the Dark One. The endless battle, as Herid Fel implied. As the Wheel turns, the Champion and the Dark One battle eternally, and so shall they be until the Wheel stops its turning.

So...with that in mind, and my not knowing how THIS Battle will turn out between Rand and the Dark One, I found myself wondering what knowledge the DO possesses that can easily break Rand's mind. When you really think about it, the DO should remember each time he fought the incarnations of the Dragon. Breaking Rand's mind is as easy and showing him every single time they fought and making him so unsure of himself that for one split second...snap. He kills Rand. We don't know how many revolutions the Wheel has made, but who's to say the DO doesn't?

If I may bring you all back to something...

flicker, flicker, flicker...

I have won again, Lews Therin.

My endless desire to know how this Battle turns out grows with impatience, if I may confess. I am patient enough to keep reading word by word, yet worried enough to fear how I will feel when this Battle comes around. It's genuinely frightening as a reader, and a new one. The DO is so large a figure that this fight can turn out in any possible manner. He is so large a deity, so large a mystery as a character, that he can possibly do anything and kill Rand in the process.

I felt the need to get this out of my system, just how MASSIVE the character of the DO is as the Last Battle looms overhead. With the winds carrying the scent of sulphur, ripples in reality breaking perception, the Last Hunt already begun and the Blight breaking silence through its many Ways, the Pit of Doom stirs and the seals shatter.

And to me, the Dark One's knowledge grows ever deeper.

We know the Fourth Age happens after, Herid Fel insinuated that the DO cannot be killed, only sealed. But how much of Rand's blood must be shed on the black rocks of Shayol Ghul? How will he feel finally facing his eternal, spiritual antagonist? How will we feel immersing ourselves in the vastness of the Dark One?

Read and find out. The Wheel weaves as the Wheel wills. I've ordered the last three books but...I feel like this is the most fear I have ever felt consuming any form of media.

flicker...flicker...flicker...


r/WoT • • 11h ago

The Eye of the World Thoughts Early in My Fourth Reread Spoiler

3 Upvotes

I just started EotW yesterday, and there’s a lot I’m catching this Turning which is surprising me.

Rand touches The Male Half much earlier than I thought. (He wills strength into Bela in their flight from the trolics. I always thought that happened when he blew the wall of the inn to bits with lightning to escape Darkfriends with Matt.) Knowing what I know now, Fain is so obvious; it’s almost funny. Aram was always too angry for The Way of The Leaf. (Perrin describes the look he receives from Aram when Perrin gets between his flirting and Eguane as “very unlike The Way of The Leaf.”) The taint of The Dagger starts worming its way into Matt extremely quickly when he starts justifying why they’re free from Mordeth. I can’t decide if it was The Power or Ta’verin which caused those Whitecloaks to take a bath in mud thanks to loose barrels on a cart. Bale Domane speed-runs a list of important locations for later while Matt, Rand, and Thom are on The Spray.

That’s it for now. I may post more later as The Wheel turns more.


r/WoT • • 19h ago

All Print The Great Trees Spoiler

15 Upvotes

Are they a specific species of tree, or just any kind of tree that has been grown to giant sizes by treesinging?

Not sure if there is any firm "canon" on topic, as there isn't really any reason to even ask the question... right up until AMoL, when Rand Sings a whole bunch of them into existence in on open field, seemingly out of thin air... Not an "impossible" thing for the Wheel to arrange for some lost seeds(or given some feats of the Voice, even splinters might do) to "just so happen" to be in that exact spot, but... seems like a hell of a lot of work, for something rather minor and random.

Topic just crossed my mind over the last week or so, so thought I'd just ask what other people thought.


r/WoT • • 14h ago

The Fires of Heaven Min's viewing in chapter 28 Trapped Spoiler

5 Upvotes

Okay, but why does Bryne die if they're apart too long? I get why Siuan might need him around. What the hell does she have to save him from? Is she going to have to ride after him and let him think she's that committed to his washing? 😂

So, he just told six Aes Sedai that if they raise an army and then make peace with Elaida, it'll cost him his head. Now I'm wondering if one of those sisters is going to offer him up to buy her way back into the Tower. Ugh, I can just imagine Elaida's smugness.

When do I find out?


r/WoT • • 17h ago

All Print If you could have a book/show/movie/game about any time period in WOT, what would you want?

8 Upvotes

For me I wouldn’t actually want to see after the epilogue, I prefer it as a mystery to me.

I would love to see more about the trolloc wars as we know of almost no characters from that time. However we know there were dreadlords so I would be interested to see how that functioned and also to see more powerful aes sedai compared to the modern chaste.

I do think if there were to make a game it should be within a time period where the white tower had greater influence and structure, and it would be really fun to play as a sister.


r/WoT • • 21h ago

The Shadow Rising Aiel behaviour Spoiler

10 Upvotes

I am half way through the fourth book.

I just find this weird, funny and interesting that aiel are so much interested to talk about relationship and love.

Like bain and chiad are so interested in relationship of perrin and faile,also gaul he keeps smiling inwardly in tight situations.

There are more like aviendha and aiel who help elayne finding good makeout spots.

I have this question why?


r/WoT • • 1d ago

All Print The ironic part of complaining about the Shaido. Spoiler

123 Upvotes

Over the years there have been lots of people complaining that the Shaido stick around for too long. There are complaints that they should have been wiped out at the Battle of Cairhein, or fully eliminated at Dumai's Wells. But instead, despite large battles that cost them heavy casualties, they keep coming back up. Even being scattered by Sammael and forced into mostly small detachments that operate as basically guerrilla warriors or pure raiders.

They aren't a significant player in the greater conflict of the War against the Shadow. They are at best pawns and proxies of various Forsaken, just propped up as useful tools.

So the Irony comes from people complaining that this doesn't make sense, or wasn't realistic, or that Jordan didn't have a good plan for Perrin and just used the Shaido as a way to buy time.

Now add the context that Jordan was a Vietnam veteran, and look again at the the long, bloody, and ongoing fight against the Shaido.

A foreign people divided to the point of war by ideological differences. Both sides being backed by larger powers (the Light and the Shadow) as opposed to Communism/Capitalism of the Cold War. Heck, the opening engagement of the Shaido War was started off by kicking the Cairhienin's asses...and the Cairheinin are heavily coded as French.

They keep showing up and causing all kinds of damage or trouble, but lose lots of major battles with much higher casualties than the opposition. They couldn't be killed of entirely initially because of the threat of potential open warfare with other undeclared factions. At Dumai's Wells they are completely overwhelmed by the mobility and firepower of the Asha'man. They send wave after wave of people but just get destroyed and can't land the major knockout blow they needed. Despite this they just keep sticking around and keep being a threat for book after book.

It's obviously not a 1-1 parallel, but I'm pretty sure Jordan was more annoyed than any of his readers.


r/WoT • • 1d ago

The Great Hunt Dude I’m so sus of Two Characters Spoiler

349 Upvotes

I’m currently reading the Great Hunt, just finished Chapter 31 and I’m finally starting to see the vision. (For a while there it was really starting to kinda drag for me, especially with the Selene stuff, but I’m loving Cairhein), and I just wanna put my thoughts into wording regarding two characters: Ingtar and Selene. Calling it now, one of them is a dark friend.

First ingtar which I think is more Sus, but the fact that they learn where Rand is staying THE DAY the inn gets burnt, and then Ingtar’s over obsession with the horn “I must! I must!” Being so gollum-like is crazy. Also his general cadence is leaving a lot to me thinking he’s a dark friend.

Second Selene who has less, but just in general we don’t know jack booty about her. Not to mention she’s lowkey one of my least favorite characters thus far, she pops in at seemingly the most random of times, then Trollocs happen to be there as well or have already shown up.

Mostly putting this post so I can say “I told you so” when both are revealed to be dark friends.

Great book tho so far, better than Eye of the World.


r/WoT • • 1d ago

All Print More art revealed for The Broken Bindings Wheel of Time 1-3 special editions! Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
231 Upvotes

Artist is @ariilustrador on Instagram. Looks stunning!


r/WoT • • 23h ago

Towers of Midnight (first time reader) I finished Towers of Midnight and here are my impressions Spoiler

3 Upvotes

Hey.

Reading the 13th volume in a week is quite an achievement—though, to be fair, Sanderson’s writing (when he isn’t bogged down in world-building details) is very quick to get through.

Let’s start with the epilogue.

So, Graendal is going to be punished... Why does this only ever happen to the female Forsaken? Lanfear—as Cyndane—and Moghedien have essentially become Moridin’s "lapdogs"; Messana was punished by Shaidar Haran, and now Graendal is set to face a similar fate at his hands. Only Semirhage managed to avoid this, though the "spankings" she received from Cadsuane were humiliating enough in their own right. Why hasn’t a single male Forsaken been subjected to such degrading treatment?

It seems that, with Elayne away, Caemlyn is under attack by the forces of the Shadow—and in world some "dark" Aiel have appeared.

On another note, Rand encountered Lanfear in a dream, and well... it certainly looks like a trap. Then again, as Cyndane, Lanfear is effectively Moridin’s slave. She mentioned a "slayer of hope" and someone who is torturing her—if I recall correctly, "slayer of hope" refers to Ishamael/Moridin. Does this mean Rand is going to end up on a mission to rescue Lanfear/Cyndane from Moridin’s clutches? It feels like a classic, tempting scenario: the hero saving a beautiful woman.

I’m not sure what Sanderson has in store, but I hope Lanfear/Cyndane’s role in the final volume is at least somewhat meaningful.

Overall, I found the storylines involving Perrin and Galad to be the most enjoyable in this volume. They share similar personality traits, and I happen to like them both. Perrin has finally come into his own (the scene where he forges his hammer using the One Power was excellent), and Galad, early in his journey as a commander of the Whitecloaks, has learned to think with a bit more flexibility.

All in all, I’m fine with the relationship between Berelain and Galad. I like both characters, and I’m glad that it likely points toward a happy ending for Berelain, rather than her simply ending up as the "loser" in a love triangle.

I was pleased to see Morgase and Galad reunite. I quite like this dynamic—simply because they aren’t related by blood. Elayne and Gawyn are bound to care for Morgase because they are her children; Galad, however, is not her biological son, yet he still loves her like a mother.

Generally speaking, Perrin’s storylines in previous volumes were okay, but I can’t recall the last time I actually looked forward to his chapters, rather than just tolerating their existence. Maybe that hasn’t happened since the third book?

The only things that bothered me about his arc were the dream sequences and his rivalry with... well, I’m not even sure what to call him, as the Polish version uses three different terms: "Zabójca" (eng. killer/murderer), "Slayer" and "Oprawca" (eng. Tormentor/Executioner).

To put it simply: while I enjoyed Perrin’s storyline in the waking world, I couldn’t care less about the dream world. Sorry—not sorry.

Surprisingly, Elayne didn’t irritate me this time around. Perhaps that’s because she spent her time interacting with characters far more interesting than those in the succession plotline—people like Mat, Morgase, Perrin, Faile, Egwene, Nynaeve, Galad, and Gawyn. I still don’t like her, but at least her chapters didn’t feel like a chore.

Egwene’s storyline was fine, and I’m glad she and Gawyn finally cleared the air regarding their feelings. Mesaana’s end was disappointing. Gawyn’s fight against the three assassins, however, was really cool.

The coalition of Aes Sedai, Aiel Wise Ones, and the Sea Folk worked well as a counterweight to the Seanchan—the same goes for the coalition led by Elayne.

It’s grim that, according to Aviendha’s vision of the future, the Seanchan would win and destroy the entire world, turning literally every woman who can channel into a damane. I do have one question, though: after the Shaido embodied everything worst about Aiel culture, wouldn’t they have learned that their traditions don’t actually work?

Regardless of the outcome of the Last Battle, I hope there will eventually be a way to defeat the Seanchan—unless they manage to change for the better.

Especially after that brief POV from Tuon... It’s just sick that she finds the sight of damane being "broken" to be soothing. Until she—and her people—learn to see damane as human beings, my personal headcanon (regardless of what happens in the final volume) is that their empire will fall; in its current form, and with its current views on those who can channel, it has no right to exist.

It seems Elaida is suffering, but that brings me no joy at all—because her suffering is a triumph for the Seanchan... and I absolutely loathe Seanchan triumphs.

Every time Rand appeared, he stole the show.

I’m glad that Nynaeve is now officially an Aes Sedai, without any reservations, and has taken on the bond with Lan. She can finally focus on important matters instead of worrying about nonsense—like whether her personality fits the typical Aes Sedai mold or if she’s even "worthy" of being one. Now that she has Lan as her Warder, I won’t accept any ending other than both of them surviving and having plenty of children in the future.

As for Mat’s storyline... honestly, the version of Mat written by Sanderson just feels less interesting. With all due respect to Sanderson as an author, I don’t feel his take on Mat is as good as the original.

It’s great that they rescued Moiraine, though her relationship with Thom feels a bit too sappy to me. And the fact that Mat didn’t pick up on their feelings—seriously? Thom kept reading that letter from Moiraine over and over; how did Mat not realize there was something more going on?

It’s a shame about Noal.

It’s also strange that Thom was the only one who didn’t have to pay a price.

Honestly, when Morgase found out about Rahvin while eavesdropping on Perrin’s conversation, I had a sense of déjà vu. Wasn’t there a similar scene elsewhere, where it was revealed that Lord Gaebril was actually Rahvin?

Finally, my 10 favorite characters at the moment:

  1. Nynaeve
  2. Mat
  3. Siuan
  4. Thom
  5. Rand
  6. Perrin
  7. Lanfear/Cyndane
  8. Berelain
  9. Logain
  10. Leane

All in all, I’m not sure what to expect from the final volume. It looks like I might have laser eye surgery on December 3rd (I’ll make the final decision on Monday). This would make it impossible for me to read books normally for at least two weeks, yet I’m really keen to finish the series this year. In theory, I could manage to get through the final volume before the procedure—but should I really rush the conclusion of the story? The finale is just around the corner, and I’ve become a bit obsessed with finishing the series within this year. I need to think this over; I don’t want to have to wait until my eyes have recovered to reach the end.

We’ll see. Another option would be an audiobook, though I’m not sure if listening to the final installment—without having experienced the rest of the series in that format—is a good idea, especially since I’ve never listened to an audiobook before.


r/WoT • • 1d ago

Knife of Dreams I miss the old books Spoiler

9 Upvotes

I was just looking at my friend's copy of Fires of Heaven and skimming through it, and it made me realize how much I miss the old books sometimes.

I'm not even finished with the series yet, but I keep remembering reading Rand see all his ancestors back in time in Rhuidean, shattering the Aiel apart at Alcair Dal, and chasing Couladin, leading a whole army for the first time. And Jasin Natael a.k.a. Asmodean, how I will miss him too.

And Mat gathering men together and leading them into battle with his new knowledge for the very first time, somehow beating the Aiel through grit and intellect.

And Lanfear pulling up and bombing the place, and Moiraine sacrificing herself.

And then Rand jumping Rahvin with pure rage because Rahvin literally killed Mat and Aviendha. The insane traps and tactics that went into that fight, seeing Rand use new weaves for the first time, and then Nynaeve forcing Moghedien to pull up with the assist. Then Rand balefiring him and somehow reversing their deaths??? pure awesome

Maybe it was a different time, maybe everything is just pretty bleak now (i still love the series!), but those days I will always remember. It felt epic to me. I really miss it.


r/WoT • • 1d ago

The Great Hunt Is there anybody here who didn't like the first two books but came around as the series went on? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Did anyone grow to like these books instead of enjoying them from the start?

Main gripes I have are:

Multiple things are left vague, like the magic system and how it's taught. Why is Rand able to use so much magic straight away without learning anything? Or how he can defeat blade masters who spent decades training just because he can touch the 'void.' Why does spring return at the end of the first book if Rand didn't defeat the Dark Lord? Why weren't the three boys told about how dangerous Mordeth in Shadar Logoth was. They legit say that if its power got loose it would mean the end of the world, and Moraine just lets them go for a stroll and pick up a soul-destroying dagger or whatever. Also they just suddenly started talking about the Green Man without any explanation as to what he is. Even if these things are explained adequately later on, I'm not gonna be interested enough to get there if there isn't SOME justification for them in the beginning.

The characters are all so bland, like they've got zero personality, and the romance just feels so forced. Min never seemed to be a likely love interest for Rand at any point of the first book, until she suddenly fell for him at the end of the second, and there's barely any build up/development of Elayne's feelings for him either. Also I'm just assuming that this is what happens because of Min's prophecy, but I personally don't like polygamy, especially when it's one man and multiple women, reminds me of Jobless Reincarnation.

Many people might like this about the series, but It's just way too similar to LOTR. Three young men from an out of the way village in the West of a large continent, where people aren't involved in wars and are completely ignorant of current world events, set off on an adventure. They cross a ferry, get involved with cursed treasure (dagger in Shadar Logoth), meet wraiths in dark cloaks and savage beasts who serve a Dark Lord, etc etc. There are so many similarities it's probably intended to be like LOTR, but I can't get behind it.


r/WoT • • 1d ago

All Print What were Moiraine and Suian planning to do? Spoiler

54 Upvotes

So, I was rereading the series, and I think it's a pretty clear symbol of Rand entering Tar Valon only after he solved his madness, and White Tower reunited and cleansed the Black Ajah. This is pretty intentional I think, and I think that it was the Pattern's intention for it to happen immediately after. But this got me thinking, what would happen if Moiraine did get Rand to White Tower in book 1?

Even disregarding that 1 fifth of all Aes Sedai were black, I don't really know how they would go convincing others that Rand is indeed The Dragon Reborn. They would probably believe that Suian and Moiraine genuinely think that Rand is the Dragon, but it would spark an insane amount of chaos. They would immediately start arguing if what Gaitara said was even a prophecy, how can they confirm that Rand is The Dragon, what to do, should they still him, how should they teach him if they are to, etc.

Also, both Moiraine and Suian were clearly aware of the Black Ajah problem, even if they didn't know the extent of it. I don't think they could in good conscience reveal that they found the Dragon Reborn. I just can't think of any way it could work, and Pattern didn't allow it to happen for a good reason


r/WoT • • 2d ago Heartwarming

No Spoilers Rosamund Pike's audiobooks

Post image
988 Upvotes

It seems that Rosamund might continue narrating the audiobooks after all. This was mentioned last night during Inter Alia stage door.


r/WoT • • 2d ago

Lord of Chaos Oh I ADORE Semirhage!!!!! 😈 Spoiler

102 Upvotes

Where was this woman all this time????? I think she's my favorite Forsaken!!!!! Her chapter in early Lord of Chaos was SO FUN. I'm at chapter 6 (absolutely amazing chapter btw). Also, my god this series has long chapters. I don't need to know to height of every single random character Robert 😭😭😭😭

In any case, Semirhage, my god!!!! She's brilliant!!!! For once, a smart Forsaken!!!! This line sums up one of the reasons I love her so much. Talking about other Forsaken:

"They had never learned that power came only from the Great Lord, handed out as he chose, for his own reasons. At his whims."

Finally a smart one!!!! Like you all serve the literal Devil from the Bible guys!!!!! Stop getting airs, thinking you can outsmart the Dark One!!! You cannot!!! This lady is so smart!!!! She understands that, as a Darkfriend, she's in a weak position, despite everything. She can never be free, her soul is bound to the Dark Lord. Each of them are subservient to Him, and their ego is their downfall.

Also, the reason she became a Darkfriend in the first place is perfectly reasonable. She's a psychopath, a sadist, and enjoys torturing people more than literally anything else. Before the Bore, mind you, lol. She was caught, given a choice between not being able to do it again, or being stilled. So she joined the Dark One. Makes sense! She doesn't lie to herself, or at least not to the extent the other Forsaken do. She actually manages to have an alliance that has lasted decades, if not centuries, with two other Forsaken.

So yes, Semirhage is the best one, I love her, she's fun as hell to read, and she's everything a Forsaken should be. Also, she's not weirdly sexualized or anything like that. Just an evil doctor, pretty common irl btw (this is a joke, although many doctors are shockingly unempathetic), and completely practical and down-to-earth, as Forsaken go. Love her!!! Love her down!!!

"Who needs compulsion when psychology exists?" ~Semirhage, probably