r/writing • • 21d ago

Monthly "Would You Read This?" Thread

62 Upvotes

Welcome to Would You Read This (WYRT), our monthly feedback and brainstorming thread. Share your work in progress below and let other readers tell you if they'd read it. Top level posts should follow this template:

  • Title:

    • If you don't have a title yet, feel free to say UNTITLED.
  • Genre:

    • Please include at least Fiction, Nonfiction, Poetry, or another recognizable medium. You may also include more specific genres with a hyphen. Ex. Fiction - Romance, or Nonfiction - Memoir. Genre will help users find the specific kinds of posts they'd like to give feedback on.
  • Premise:

    • A few sentences about the project. Try your best to keep this short. Crafting an expert elevator pitch is all part of becoming a successful working writer. Please do not post an entire plot summary or query letter (those are better suited for r/pubtips)
  • Sample (Optional):

    • You may share up to 500 words(ish) of sample material, or one poem for those working in the poetry medium. This is optional, so if you only have a premise, you can post just the premise for feedback.

If you post for feedback, please take the time to give feedback to at least 2-3 other users. Replies should follow this template.

  • Would Read / Might Read / Wouldn't Read

    • You must begin your reply with one of those. You are then encouraged to add additional thoughts on why you choose your answer.

Rules:

  • Please post no more than two WYRT top-level posts. There is no limit on the number of feedback replies you can make.
  • Do not link to any offsite materials. All materials must be in the body of the post. This includes "click here to read more" or "DM me for the rest" types of posts.
  • Rule 3 is in effect in this thread - No generative AI. Do not post material generated by an AI platform in your premise or sample. Do not use generative AI to respond to user's work.
  • Rule 5 is in effect - Civility and Community. Stay constructive. Blunt, direct feedback is fine, but do not insult other users, their writing, or their genres.

Looking for the General Discussion threads? Click here!


r/writing • • 21d ago Bravo

Monthly "Promote Yo' Self" Thread

36 Upvotes

Welcome to our monthly Promote Yo' Self thread! Show the community what you put out into the world. Please follow this template:

  • Choose what you're promoting from the below options:

    • [Published Book]
    • [Article / Video / Project]
    • [Newsletter / Substack]
    • [Writing Community]
    • [Software / App]
    • [Call for Submissions]
    • [Milestone / Accomplishment]
  • Project Title

    • The title of your book, the name/title of your project, the name of your newsletter, the name of your writing community, the name of your software, or the title of your collection for which you are calling for submissions.
  • Description

    • A short premise or elevator pitch of your book, the subject matter of your newsletter, the purpose of your writing community, the purpose of your app, or the nature of your milestone.

      • Call for Submissions additionally require the following: Legal name of the entity calling for submissions, deadlines, fees, prizes, and rights requested.
  • Call to Action

    • What would you like r/writing to do? Buy your book? Subscribe to your newsletter? Submit a piece to your lit mag?
  • Discount for r/writing**?**

    • Share if/how the community can get a discount.

Rules:

  • Post no more than one top-level reply in the Promote Yo' Self thread each month, but you are allowed to post each month.
  • Rule 3 is in effect - No generative AI. You may not post projects generated by an AI platform, nor apps that use generative AI or expose writers' work to generative AI, nor may you post a Call for Submissions from an outlet that does not have a clear policy against publishing material produced by a generative AI platform.
  • Rule 5 is in effect - Civility and Community. Blunt, direct feedback is fine, but do not insult other users, other readers, or other genres.

Looking for the General Discussion threads? Click here!


r/writing • • 10h ago

Discussion Writing something that makes you cry, as a man who rarely does. Have you ever felt the same?

40 Upvotes

There's a tell after countless pages that I have something special. I tear up. I'm 32. I can count on my hands and feet how many times I've cried as an adult. In one hand, I can count how many times writing led to tears.

It feels like magic. To produce words that strike at the heart of an emotion and cripple any defenses. It feels better than any therapy session that I've ever done. How can a discovery so visceral happen without an external force?

Today, writing from a coffee shop with any overly expensive drip and an almond croissant was one of those days. I could hide the tears, but even after, I felt some looks. Like the energy released was still there.

It felt like a writer's treat. I wonder if you have ever felt the same? I hope so. Happy writing today.


r/writing • • 8h ago

Discussion Character Voice vs Technical Voice

12 Upvotes

I’m battling with a technical question and looking for opinions.

We are told to find our unique writing voice (which I believe I have done) and to follow all the writing rules. Ie. don’t use three words where one will do.

We are also told to write in the voice of the pov character. Especially important in multi pov novels.

Which one takes priority?

For example, I have a character who comes from a place where literacy is low and survival is the main focus. In a recent revision it was noted her vocabulary was too advanced for her ‘voice’ and history, because I was falling into my own writing style. But in order to make her voice stronger, I would need to ignore a lot of the ‘rules’ and make even the prose, which is from her viewpoint, weaker. Which no doubt would get flack from readers. Her dialogue would be easy to change, but it’s the prose I’m unsure of.


r/writing • • 1d ago

Advice A wise woman once told me: Do what you can do

152 Upvotes

Everyone is different. Some writers are more technical. Some work emotional mysticism. Some are avant-garde. Some are derivative.

I've known writers who crippled themselves artistically because they just couldn't stop comparing themselves to others. They tried to be everything and ended up as nothing.

There is no greater enemy than an artist's own mind.

Don't worry about the quality of your work. Don't try to be like anyone else. Just do what you can do and let the chips fall where they may.


r/writing • • 1d ago

Beginner Question How did you get through editing hell?

15 Upvotes

Hi writers! I come to find some motivation and reasurance on this sub. I know I'm not the only one stuck in editing hell, so I'd be happy to know how you overcome this if you're going through it now, or how you made it to the other side if you finished a project.

I've been working on a series for many years and now have all 3 books written (1st in 3rd draft stage, 2nd on 2nd draft stage, and the last book is still a very messy first draft). I'm still working on the plot to make everything coherent, develop characters, build foreshadowing... Then I want to improve my prose, which for now is pretty basic. It's a nice project, I like working on it, but at the moment I'm a little desperate. Editing is not my favourite part of the process and it feels like I've been doing nothing but editing for a while, and will be doing nothing but editing for a while too.

How do you stay motivated through this stage? What has helped you edit efficiently?


r/writing • • 1d ago

Discussion Which creative writing book helped you the most?

281 Upvotes

I'm gonna treat myself to one for Christmas. Which one should it be?

I've already read On Writing by Stephen King, so not that!


r/writing • • 21h ago

Discussion [Daily Discussion] General Discussion - November 21, 2026

5 Upvotes

Welcome to our daily discussion thread!

This is the place to discuss anything writing related! Got silly questions? Brainstorming ideas? Need help with research? As long as rules 1, 3, and 5 are followed, this thread is your oyster!

Please refer to the monthly threads for sharing your work and for self-promotion.

---

FAQ -- Questions asked frequently

Wiki Index -- Ever-evolving and woefully under-curated, but we'll fix that some day

You can find our posting guidelines in the sidebar or the wiki.


r/writing • • 1d ago

Advice Is narrative distance easier to manage on the second draft?

17 Upvotes

I'm roughly 23k words into my first novel and I'm finding that I'm struggling to write from inside my characters' heads. Instead, it's lots of "he/she saw, felt, noticed, etc." And my descriptions are coming out more like 3rd omniscient with lots of distance and objectivity when I'm meant to be writing in 3rd limited and more personality from the POV character.

I've written 1st-person short stories in the past that were well-received and the closeness of the POV was extremely easy to write. (That being said, those stories were either creative non-fiction or told in a voice identical to my own, so I didn't really have to consider another character.)

Now, I'm working on a dual-protagonist horror novel using 3rd limited for both, and I'm finding it much harder to get fully inside the character's head. I've done lots of background work on the characters (motivations, fears, history, wants, goals, needs, flaws, vocabulary levels, etc.), but I'm still learning/discovering who they are with each new scene. They are still surprising me and evolving as I move forward. I've got an ending in mind for the book including themes and foreshadowing that's coming very organically, and I outline about 2-4 chapters ahead of where I'm currently writing. Think I'm somewhere between a pantser and a plotter. But maybe I can't get in their heads because I'm not ready to pin down their exact personality yet?

(I'm considering trying to write a chapter or two from first person for each protagonist to see if that helps, but I'm nervous of confusing myself and wanting to start over when my priority is to finish the first draft and figure out the full story first.)

So yeah: How easy is narrative distance to manage on first draft vs later drafts? How well do you really know your characters' perspectives on the first draft? Is this a sign that I might be more of a 1st-person author than 3rd-person? Lol


r/writing • • 13h ago

Discussion Hot Take: Do Not Worldbuild

0 Upvotes

It's fun. We all do it. And it's not storytelling. Let's be honest, you probably don't even need to try to do the worldbuilding. As Tolkien said in a letter to Milton Waldman: "It is difficult to say anything without saying too much: the attempt to say a few words opens a floodgate..."

When does the worldbuilding stop and the novel begin? Worldbuilding alone isn't enough. And it's almost like procrastination from writing the story. The worldbuilding is going to happen naturally, so write the characters, their lives and what happens.

I never fell in love with a lore document.


r/writing • • 1d ago

Advice Scrapping 2/3 of the book after editor review

22 Upvotes

Contemporary romance book: my beta readers and editor has given me some feedback on the last work sent in. All of it valid all, of it good, and all of it making me re-think, have I been writing a thriller this entire time with a side story of romance?

The good news, my characters, world read well, but I am throwing so much external force at the couple and so many plot twists that the reader is tired.

I am going back and can save the first 1/3 with minimal editing but now removing things that were massive in the storyline,

1 removal of a kidnaping

2 removal of a mother who was supposed to be dead, but surprise isn't!
(I'm actually letting her stay dead now)

3 Removal of a pregnancy for a side character which added to my "found family" plot

because the plot has changed so much, my strategy needs to change, the ending is the same a HEA.

I am a plotter and usually write the islands, but I am not seeing how I can do it now, start at the end and work backwards perhaps?

I think I can re-work almost 1/2 of the emotional beats with some effort but not sure of the rest.

I am okay with the amount of re-work because I am still finding myself as a writer and I do see that I have been using exciting events as a crutch to move the story along.

any ideas when your salvaging half? I am at about 100k words for reference. (average in sub-genre I am writing)

edited for clarity.


r/writing • • 1d ago

Discussion Favorite Subgenre/ -punk Genres?

3 Upvotes

From my understanding, the first (or most known) -punk genre was steampunk, which is still quite popular today. However, there has been a birth and rise of different -punks, from the accpeted dieselpunk and solarpunk to the debated sandalpunk and hopepunk.

Furthermore, there are many different subgenres or niche genres that often get lumped in my their parent genre, but show a lot of distinction! My first thought with this is progression fantasy (lumped into fantasy or isekai) and LitRPG (often fantasy or, again, isekai).

What subgenres do y'all like the best?

EDIT: When I was writing this I somehow forgot about cyberpunk!


r/writing • • 1d ago

Discussion [Daily Discussion] General Discussion - November 20, 2026

10 Upvotes

Welcome to our daily discussion thread!

This is the place to discuss anything writing related! Got silly questions? Brainstorming ideas? Need help with research? As long as rules 1, 3, and 5 are followed, this thread is your oyster!

Please refer to the monthly threads for sharing your work and for self-promotion.

---

FAQ -- Questions asked frequently

Wiki Index -- Ever-evolving and woefully under-curated, but we'll fix that some day

You can find our posting guidelines in the sidebar or the wiki.


r/writing • • 1d ago

Resource Can anyone recommend a good stand alone TV drama for studying emotional responses?

0 Upvotes

I write litfic, and know that one of my weakest areas is writing what people's faces and bodies (externally) are doing. I have The Emotion Thesaurus which helps a great deal, but I still need to watch something which will show me a decent range of emotions I can study the physicality of. Looking for something standalone so I don't get hooked and eat into my writing time.

Any suggestions would be much appreciated!


r/writing • • 2d ago

Discussion How do you approach descriptions that pause time and don't progress the action forward?

44 Upvotes

This is partially a mindset problem, so hopefully my explanation makes sense and you can offer some advice.

When I'm re-reading my work it's like time never stops. Descriptions fit within the moment and are driven by the action, and there's rarely scenes where the narrator hits "pause" and digs into longer descriptions.

When I try to "hit pause" I feel the story grinding to a halt, or I think it reads like an amateur writer rattling off history in a prologue. But I'm outlining a new book that I know will benefit from more description and narrating in an older, more drawn out style.

Any advice for how you approach this? Or great examples of writers who take their time without feeling stuck?


r/writing • • 2d ago

Advice Don't become your own worst enemy by thinking too much

74 Upvotes

If you could only be a doer or a thinker, which would you choose?

Of course you'd be a doer.

Thinkers worry too much about their skill.

Thinkers fancy the opinions of others more than their own.

Thinkers plan more than they write.

Develop the skill to turn your brain off and simply express yourself.

Get things done, regardless of quality, profit, or prestige.

Be a doer.


r/writing • • 3d ago

Discussion Do you write for readers or write to write?

146 Upvotes

I find a good amount of comments that suggest not considering the reader when writing anything for the first draft. I find this quite odd.

In my writing process I consider the reader a lot. I keep myself very mindful of what they know, what they don't know, what they can infer. I consider the reader's emotional bandwidth when decided the order of chapters/scenes. I consider the reader when evaluating sentence variations.

And I do this because my goal is to write something that people would like to read. I think writing something without consideration of a reader is leaving a lot to pure chance.


r/writing • • 2d ago

Discussion How do you show text conversations in your books?

1 Upvotes

What is your favorite way to show text conversations in novels? Do you prefer using speech bubbles, bold, italics, or just regular dialogue with "he/she texted" as the dialogue tag? I typically just do bold (ie, "Hi," he texted), but I'm considering switching to speech bubbles since I've been seeing that so frequently.


r/writing • • 3d ago

Advice Criticism Is Part of the Game, My Friend. Believe in Your Story or You’re Doomed.

94 Upvotes

I’m used to the rejections. Criticism is part of the game of creating stuff. Anytime you put something out into the world, people are allowed to say whatever they want. You have to accept it. It’s hard to deal with in the beginning, but you get used to it, or you try to get used to it.

People will criticize the hell out of you. Support is what’s hard to come by. Don’t take it personally. Most people won’t believe in it the way you do. Believe in your story. If you don’t believe in your work, it will become apparent.

I believe in the more-than-half-dead internet theory. They say 55 to 65 percent of the internet is made up of bots. Then there are the trolls. Brace yourself, there is a lot of toxic negativity on the internet. You put yourself in a vulnerable spot.

Creating stuff is the easy part. Getting people to actually consume it is the most brutal sport. Just be thankful people are even criticizing your work. Just think back to that writing class you took and how critical your peers were. Sometimes the criticism will be constructive. Other times, it’ll be destructive. Everybody is a critic, and they’re entitled to their criticisms. Most of the time, people will just ignore your work. Taking it personally will doom you. People don’t care about all the work you put into it. They’ll judge what’s presented to them. And you’ll be judged harshly.

That's my TESTalk.


r/writing • • 2d ago

Advice Embrace the pain of being a writer

0 Upvotes

Writing isn't about showing off your intelligence, making a profit, becoming famous, or finding acceptance.

Sure, all of those things are great, but they're not how writing truly rewards you.

The jewels you'll find from summoning the discipline to consistently explore the caves of your mind are:

  1. Knowlege of self
  2. Overcoming loss

Every time you put words to a page you're learning more about yourself. Every idea is a part of you, and your stories become intimate portals that reveal aspects of who you are. Personally, that's why I don't believe in ever writing for anyone. The purest stories you'll ever create are those that have nothing to do with someone else's dreams or expectations.

You also shouldn't ever expect to "win" when writing. More than anything, writing will teach you how to lose. Even the best stories almost die. Millions of writers have found themselves stuck at some point while putting something together. They stare, and they stare, and they wonder how the fuck they'll ever finish what they started.

Sometimes it's possible to persevere and salvage our creations. Sometimes it's not. Sometimes writing will teach you how to give up and start all over again, but it won't ever teach you how to be defeated. That's always up to us.

Never forget that an artist's greatest enemy will always be their own mind.

So find the strength to persevere. Regardless of what you think about your ability, if you've ever written a sentence with the intent to share a tale in your heart, you can follow through and create something spectacular.

You can do it. I know you can. Just be sure to accept all of the pain that comes with it.


r/writing • • 3d ago

Discussion Came back on a story I abandoned. It hurts.

217 Upvotes

So, when I was 18, I started writing a big story. I was young and naive, always saw it as a movie. So I wanted it to be my first full length feature. I know the whole plot, everything. It's so clear in my mind. Went into filmmaking, tried to be a screenwriter, , director for years. I loved writing. Until I realized I didn't like the industry.

So I quit it and went on multiple side quests. I tried a lot of things, kept writing and decided to try writing it as a book... and gave up midway through. I didn't know why at the time... just convinced myself I didn't want to do that anymore. So I stopped writing for a few years, tried going into another industry...

Lately, I started making some money writing erotica. It was a side hustle for little money at first but then it grew bigger. A month ago, I decided to leave everything and focus on writing. It's what I always wanted to do.

And now here I am. Full time writer and I know I don't just want to write erotica. It just pays the bills. Started thinking about what else I could write, and my abandoned story keeps coming back in my mind. So I sat down, reopened the document, read the last few pages I had written.

It wasn't great, bad prose and dialogues weren't clear... but it wasn't that bad. There's something to it. So I just... resumed the story from there... 12 years later.

Not gonna lie, writing that hurts. I keep thinking about the time I wasted by putting it aside. It's comedy, but it's also about me when I was younger, all my experiences... so it feels weird to relive that. Face my emotions, write about my flaws.

I'm getting back some bad thoughts... Keep picturing it as a movie, see myself make a huge hit out of it. That's why I stopped it. I didn't like having those dreams, I shot them down to avoid feeling hurt. I'm hoping it's a hit, but I'm also actually afraid of it working out and becoming too proud, or letting success get into my head.

But I knew it's a pretty good story and even thought it's hard... having a goal and motivation is good for me I think? Better than just stalling like I've been doing. It's such a weird feeling. I wonder if any of you ever felt that way.

Maybe I should write something else... Something that's less painful. But if that one makes me live all those emotions... maybe it's the one I truly need to write^


r/writing • • 2d ago

Discussion [Daily Discussion] General Discussion - November 19, 2026

5 Upvotes

Welcome to our daily discussion thread!

This is the place to discuss anything writing related! Got silly questions? Brainstorming ideas? Need help with research? As long as rules 1, 3, and 5 are followed, this thread is your oyster!

Please refer to the monthly threads for sharing your work and for self-promotion.

---

FAQ -- Questions asked frequently

Wiki Index -- Ever-evolving and woefully under-curated, but we'll fix that some day

You can find our posting guidelines in the sidebar or the wiki.


r/writing • • 2d ago

Discussion how do critics pick what piece has the best writing?

1 Upvotes

This all started because I canr fathom at all how they choose the writing winners in olympiads. Ive applied a couple of times and wrote essays but didnt really get past the first phase, and yet to my surprise, people who seemed incredibly shallow in opinions and not even in the least bit artistic, seemed to actually get past me! And at this point, I genuinely dont even know where Im supposed to improve if I seek to do so (for my own stories), assuming something about my writing isnt good enough since EVEN SUCH PEOPLE could pass. And its really not jealousy its just genuine confusion and need to know the truth in order to get better.

Im confused on peoples opinions on my writing in general too. When I was a little kid, everyone praised me for my storytelling skills, then in middle school my literature teacher said I have no talent, then in highschool suddenly all of my literature teachers started liking me and considering me talented, and they were the ones who suggested the olympiads. But something one of my literature teachers in highschool said did again confuse me, and it was that the structure/syntax or whatever she meant wasnt right, bur at the same time her writer husband had really loved my piece so she wouldnt lower my grade.

So then, what does all of this mean? Anyone has a similar situation?


r/writing • • 3d ago

Advice What is the best way to incorporate the past (like childhood memories) into the present narrative?

19 Upvotes

Hi! When it comes to stories that heavily depend on the past/childhood of the main cast, what is the best way to incorporate past memories and character relationships without having it become jarring and unnatural?

Is it better to have small snippets of information sprinkled throughout the story? For example, a woman makes her morning coffee, and notes that her childhood friend has a matching (insert series) mug. Or through dialogue exposition maybe?

And what are your thoughts on flashbacks? Is it better to insert the flashbacks in the middle of the chapter when prompted? Or to have them be a whole chapter? Maybe not have them all together, except from in the prologue?

If one does opt to write flashbacks, is it better to have them whenever prompted, for example, a character gets black out drunk reminiscing about their childhood, or is it better to have stand alone flashbacks during downtime between scenes/arcs?

Which one do you prefer? And which books are good examples of this?