Apologies if this counts as self-promotion. I think it would be of interest to the community and worthy of discussion. Feel free to delete if inappropriate.
This post was originally published on my blog in 2011. Stay tuned for a 2026 update at the end.
It’s an age-old battle between writers and the “experts” – agents, publishers, writing teachers, and so forth. You (the author) have written a story unlike anything that’s ever been published before. It’s going to set the world on fire with its deathless prose, stunning turns of phrase, brand new characters and settings, and brilliant themes. It will blow away agents and publishers. You can’t wait for the bidding war to start.
And then you get your manuscript back with a form rejection letter: “not our market.”
Originality is one of those words that’s hard to define, but (as a Supreme Court justice said about pornography) we know it when we see it.
But how original does a story have to be? Does anything spring whole cloth out of nothing?
Every story has antecedents – ideas, stories, characters, situations that it refers back to and which it was influenced by. Even Harry Potter, that benchmark of children’s literature these days, is basically a story about a kid who becomes a wizard. This concept is not wholly new – J.K. Rowling merely added her spin on it. And this is a good thing. Even if you’ve never heard of Harry Potter before, you probably know what a wizard is, so you have some idea of what Harry’s books are about.
Growing up, I was a huge fan on the first Star Trek series, which was unlike anything else on TV at the time. But even Star Trek had antecedents. It was a spin on Wagon Train (an earlier TV series about people exploring the Wild West), Horatio Hornblower (a series of books about a 19th century British naval officer), and, well, just about every science fiction series that came before it.
The experts tell you that if you want your book to be published, know what market your book best fits into, understand what readers of those books want, and tailor your work accordingly. And they’re right. Here’s why:
Book publishers publish what they think will sell. Obvious? Yes. But how do publishers arrive at their opinions? They watch what has sold in the past and what is selling now. It’s not an exact science, but trends can provide indicators of what an audience wants. Consider the popularity of vampire novels.
I read a newspaper headline yesterday which asked if The Hunger Games was going to knock vampires off their lofty perch. I don’t know (or care) if it will, but the headline illustrates a point. Popularity of a particular type of book plays a key role in determining what publishers will publish.
Human beings like to read what’s familiar. We crave comfort through characters we can identify with, settings we recognize, and situations that are similar to those we’ve experienced. Harry Potter is about a kid going to a new school – everything else springs from this simple and universal concept. Star Trek was about exploring new lands (or worlds) on a ship – a call to adventure that is central to the human spirit.
This does not mean there is no room for originality. But originality works best in small doses, when it adds a fresh ingredient to the stew. Gene Roddenberry may have built on existing works when he created Star Trek, but he also added social themes (unheard of on television at the time), an optimistic future (unusual for the Cold War era), an interracial cast (also new to TV then), and serious, intelligent science fiction stories (going completely against the grain for TV).
And Roddenberry knew what TV viewers wanted (or at least what the experts told him they wanted) – that’s why you see ray guns (phasers), fist fights, and battles with aliens on Star Trek!
So, go ahead. Be original! But know when not to be.
Related articles
2026 Update
I wrote this post before the publication of my first novel, The Power Club (self-published in 2013, traditionally published in 2017). I was still learning the ropes of publishing myself and passing on what I had learned. The advice is still sound: You have to know your market, and it helps if your book is similar to something your audience already likes but just different enough to have a fresh spin.
But there is much more to publishing and marketing a book than a dash of originality, as my post may have implied.
The writing market always seems glutted with the talented, the would-be’s, the wannabes, and the dreamers. Separating which is which—and which category you fall into—can be a challenge.
“Write your passion,” some writing experts say. “Tell your story.” That’s fine, but don’t take it for granted that anyone will want to read it, pay money to do so, or like it if they do read it.
Case in point (and Star Trek tie-in): For the last decade, various Star Trek shows have been made. Each falls into the category of “similar but different,” but those differences draw ire from a lot of fans. Starfleet Academy (which in my view was original yet true to the spirit of Star Trek) was lambasted by fans and internet trolls alike and failed to find an audience. Why this happened could be the subject of another post (or a dissertation on media literacy), but the point is clear: Similar but different does not guarantee success.
Some may point out, with justification, that writing a Star Trek series differs from writing a novel about vampires or spaceships or cyber cowboys, or whatever genre in which one happens to write, but it is really so different? Strange New Worlds was probably as close to “traditional” Star Trek as we are likely to get. It is set on the USS Enterprise a few years before James T. Kirk took command and follows the exploits of characters we’d only gotten glimpses of before, including Captain Christopher Pike Number One, and Dr. M’Benga. For Star Trek fans, it should have been a recipe for success. And, for a while, it was.
But this is where the similar but different aspect comes in. The creators of SNW understandably wanted to put their own spin on the Star Trek universe. But their spin has involved characters turning into Vulcans, a musical, at least two horror episodes, stoner comedy, and puppets (yes, puppets). Some fans have loved these romps. Others have hated them.
So, how different can a story be?
To answer that question, we have to delve back into the previous generation (pun not intended) of Star Trek shows, specifically The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine, and Voyager. Each ran for seven seasons—a success by Hollywood standards. Each built upon the foundation of Star Trek and added a few spins: a bald captain who rarely left the bridge, a Black commander of a space station, and a female captain of a starship lost in another quadrant. Everything else (pretty much) was still recognizably Star Trek. Contrast those shows with Enterprise, which dared to have a pop song as its theme and changed some elements of the Star Trek back story (or canon). Enterprise was less well received and, while it seemed to find its footing in its third and fourth seasons, it was too late.
Moral of the story: If you’re going to offer something different, know what it is you are offering and why. What is your intended effect on the audience?
None of this is meant to discourage anyone from writing. But it does lead to a caveat: Approach your trade realistically. Begin by delving into the reasons why you want to write in the first place. Do you have a story to tell? How important is it that you tell it? Are you willing to put in the hours and years to tell it? And are you willing to face disappointment if it is not as well-received as you imagine?
And don’t forget to live. Don’t let writing obsess you to the point where you think of yourself only as a writer. Be a dancer. Be a husband, wife, partner, parent, social worker, teacher, bus driver. The more experiences you have, the more you will have to write about.
And then you can worry about being original.