r/xmen • u/cheerztwist • 14h ago
Comic Discussion Thoughts on Gail Simeone as X-writer?
Personally I think its decent!
*Gail Simone. Sorry for the typo
r/xmen • u/AngelEyes360 • 4d ago
Unlimited and Other Releases 11/18
Other
r/xmen • u/AngelEyes360 • 11d ago
Unlimited and Other Releases 11/11
Other
r/xmen • u/cheerztwist • 14h ago
Personally I think its decent!
*Gail Simone. Sorry for the typo
r/xmen • u/leaf57tea • 10h ago
r/xmen • u/Jules-Car3499 • 7h ago
The monologue from Magento, and seeing Charles (will miss you Patrick) and Erik holding hands, and Cyclops omega optic blast gives me the chills. Whoever edited that trailer deserves a lot of praise.
r/xmen • u/JavFiore • 9h ago
r/xmen • u/Scarlet_lord09 • 18h ago
r/xmen • u/LavendersMoon • 5h ago
He has been collecting these for the past 10 years.
r/xmen • u/Decent_Memory4202 • 20h ago
Personally, my dream X-Men video game would be an RPG/JRPG (or maybe an RPG with Hack and Slash combat) where you can create your own character and be a student at the X-Mansion. Certain stats level up based on the missions you go on, how your training in the Danger Room goes, how well you do in class (the teacher you have could also accelerate the progression of a particular stat), the mutants you hang with, etc. Romance options would be a thing too, along with a ton of customizable options for your character. Yes, I may or may not be describing Persona with a little bit of X-Men Legends, and I may or may not have watched Cosmonaut Variety Hour's video from a few years ago, lol.
However, if I'm not looking to make a JRPG styled game, I would definitely get inspiration from Hogwarts: Legacy. This would really emphasize the single player, open world RPG experience, and I think that would be really fun to experience in an X-Men setting. But anyway, that's just me. How would y'all make your dream X-Men video game?
r/xmen • u/ComiX-Fan • 10h ago
I was reading the Magik and Colossus duo book and it was interesting to see the difference in their personalities and than shifting to the x-men book and seeing how aligned Illyana and Cain are when it comes to casuing all sorts of trouble.
Magik brags about this cool move she did in battle to Pete and he was like she needs to be careful, while Cain and Yana are in a constant competition to see who can cause more destruction. Add to the fact that Pete and Cain have a history of Cain trying to bully Pete...would be interesting to see Pete's reaction to the budding platonic relationship (built on their common need to throw themselves head first into trouble/fights) between his beloved sister and his bully in during his younger days.
I like X-factor investigations a lot, so I immediately thought of Layla Miller when they revealed Betsy would be going by butterfly. I also was recently reminded that butterfly was also the name of minor character from new X-men, Lucy Priest, who is the top result when you google “x-men butterfly”. That search also brought up a bunch of photos of Angel Salvadore and Pixie since they are both butterfly-like mutants that people may not know the name of.
I know the reason that Psylocke became Kwannon’s name was branding, and i assume that Betsy giving up Captain Britain is also a branding thing. I just can’t understand why anyone thinks giving her another name that already required a disambiguation page is the right call.
I personally love Betsy as Captain Britain since it was directly tying her back to her pre-body swap character. Taking her brother’s code name that she always wanted makes far more sense to me than a more generic name that has already been used by several people she has no connection to.
r/xmen • u/CaliforniaBoundX • 14h ago
r/xmen • u/sonzoldyck • 19h ago
Despite both their…troubled pasts, I somewhat trust Emma to lead the X-men slightly more. However I don’t that either of them would be totally horrible leaders
r/xmen • u/Powerful-Ad4837 • 20h ago
Graymalkin Prison is a total black mark on Uncanny X-Men by writer Gail Simone. Despite a few defenders, there is really nothing to defend—it is a bad storyline, a mystery that goes nowhere, and a complete waste of time.
Even the creative team seemed to realize it was a weight around the series' neck. Writer Gail Simone openly acknowledged fan frustration on platforms like Popverse, admitting the plot had to be pushed back. While there was collective relief when the book finally moved past it, the arc remains a glaring flaw in the run.
It feels like there was never any real faith in this storyline. It likely came down as an editorial mandate that she had to try to make sense of, and even a strong writing team couldn't salvage a premise this broken. It is surprising Marvel thought this would work at all.
The worst element is how the rushed execution plays right into the very tropes Gail Simone has spent her career fighting against. For example, Banshee's daughter, Siryn, wasn't just brainwashed—she was mentally and physically abused and forced to wear a bomb collar around her neck. Yet instead of letting her get her own payback against her abuser, her father steps in to do it for her. That completely undercuts the whole narrative and makes it look like a textbook case of "Women in Refrigerators."
On top of that, Dr. Ellis herself isn't redeemable in the slightest. In her final issue, the story tries to make her somewhat sympathetic, which falls completely flat when you look at the horrible things she has done. She tortured prisoners, threatened their lives, and even beat up Beast. Nothing about her is redeemable—she is bigoted, manipulative, and just as sociopathic as her brother. It is impossible to believe she didn't know they were building weapons when she was literally creating Sentinel Hounds. Trying to give her redeeming qualities only makes it worse, because she is honestly no different from Reverend Stryker or Victor Creed—flat-out unsympathetic, awful people who can never be seen as sympathetic by the audience, using a slight personal tragedy as an excuse to inflict massive cruelty on others.
If anyone wants to try defending this storyline, it honestly isn't worth the effort. There is nothing to it, and it was a huge waste of an idea. Even the writer ended up wrapping the whole thing up abruptly because it was damaging the book and needed to be cut out—though that still doesn't excuse how rushed the ending was.
I have nothing against Gail Simone's Uncanny X-Men run overall, but it includes baffling ideas like this prison subplot. A massive mutant torture facility inside the old mansion is far too big to be ignored. Defenders try to argue it was just a "skeletal plotline," which is a made-up excuse that falls flat on its face when you look at how central the stakes actually were.
Could a plot like this have been salvaged? Yes—but you don't push it into the background. Good stories take front and center; they don't happen off-panel. Unlike what some defenders claim, Chris Claremont didn't just leave the Genosha torture camps sitting in the background while the team ignored them. That is the kind of focus this prison storyline needed, and there were a few clear ways to do it right:
The only real satisfaction to come out of this entire mess didn't happen until Uncanny X-Men #38, when they finally tore the place down. Watching Dazzler lead the charge and completely humiliate those government officials and ONE* agents trying to drag their feet was easily one of the most enjoyable scenes in the book—a long-overdue moment of catharsis after months of watching this awful subplot drag the series down.
r/xmen • u/Northern-Michael • 15h ago
Sweet photo op at Dunkin Donuts on Chicago Ave promoting Avengers: Doomsday. Sadly, they were sold out of the X-Men mugs.
r/xmen • u/TilDeath1775 • 21h ago
I’m pretty sure it came with a wolverine toy. Why is the kids toy so chest detailed.
r/xmen • u/Educational-Meet-697 • 8h ago
I’ve been thinking about this lately. how old is she during the course of Excalibur? I haven’t read it in a few years, but I always kind of assumed as a goofy little kid looking through it that she was the same age as everyone else, but thinking wise that doesn’t make much sense.