So, looking at the election map Dems picked up a good number of freshmen for their new class of 2026:
- Troy Jackson (ME)
- Abdul El-Sayed (MI)
- Sherrod Brown (OH) ...err not a freshman but okay (also up for reelection in 2028 anyways and might not be around for any real legislation passing)
- Josh Turek (IA)
- Adam Hamilton (KS)
- James Talarico (TX)
- Anne Andrews (SC)
Possible Pickups:
- Scott Colom (MS)
- Mary Peltola (AK)
My question now is, how will these senators behave and will they attempt to moderate to get reelected in their seats in less blue years?
Right now the Dem Senate coalition is quite unified. Back in 2022-2024 the only true bipartisans they had were Manchin and Sinema and most others were pretty much unified on what they wanted to do. However, this probably also had to do with the fact that most Senators they had were from Blue or swing states, and all their true mavericks bar Manchin basically had lost.
With this new class, we'll be seeing a return of many red state blue senators for the first time, and I'm curious how they will navigate this.
One possibility is they just decide to run like normie Dems (or even more progressive than normie Dems) and either write off their reelection entirely or pray that it will be an environment that suits them enough for them to get reelected anyways. I think El-Sayed is the most likely to fit here, he's quite arrogant, refused to really moderate during his campaign, and also ran as the progressive candidate anyways. I cannot see him caring about electability even a little bit.
Second possibility is they try to balance party line votes with moderating on more unpopular issues. From what I saw, I feel that Adam Hamilton and Josh Turek are most likely to fall into this category, Turek already ran a campaign trying to cater to bipartisanship and Hamilton seems to want to keep his "relatable pastor" persona. Either way, I have a feeling they're going to be more likely to work with Reps and/or break with Dems to try to balance popularity in their states. Peltola if she gets elected would also fall into this category based on her voting record from 2022 to 2024.
Finally, we have the nobody knows category due to a lack of nationwide electoral experience.
- Anne Andrews was a medical professional before and I don't exactly know what her policies are apart from her belief in reforming the healthcare system and expanding Medicare/Medicaid. South Carolina obviously is an R state to begin with but I don't know if she is a resistlib, progressive, or genuine moderate.
- Scott Colom according to Wikipedia served in the judiciary for quite some time. It looks like he had received bipartisan support for his nomination to the US District Court including the other MS Senator Roger Wicker (so I think they might genuinely get along not too badly tbh) and some former MS officials. Overall given the partisan lean of MS and his history I think he has a good shot of being quite moderate.
- Troy Jackson I have no clue, he was a Republican before but also is a progressive darling apparently. Maine is a D leaning state so he probably could get away with being quite progressive anyways.
- James Talarico has a pretty progressive history but he is also a pretty acute and intelligent guy. I think he'll understand he can't overdo it but I doubt he has it in him to truly become a moderate. I feel he will try his best to look moderate but will ultimately for things like nuking the filibuster.
Overall I feel like this is what would happen based on a number of key issues:
Vote To Nuke Filibuster For Specific Generic Bill NOT pertaining to Court packing or DC Statehood (something like BBB)
Yea: Jackson, El-Sayed, Talarico, Andrews, Brown
Nay: Turek, Hamilton, Colom, Peltola
Vote For Filibuster Removal + Court Packing
Yea: Jackson, El-Sayed
Nay: Turek, Hamilton, Colom, Peltola, Brown
Tossup: Talarico (he said he would be interested but not sure if he'd follow through), Andrews (if she has bad political instincts or decides to YOLO a 1 term office)
Vote for Filibuster Removal + DC Statehood Bill (Shrink Federal District, Strip 3 EVs from Fed District, Make new "Douglass Commonwealth")
Yea: Jackson, El-Sayed, Brown
Nay: Turek, Hamilton, Colom, Peltola
Tossup: Talarico (same as before, but more lean Yea), Andrews (same as before)
Vote for Filibuster Removal + PRO Act (Repealing Right To Work, amongst other things)
Yea: Jackson, El-Sayed, Brown, Talarico
Nay: Turek, Hamilton, Peltola
Tossup: Colom, Andrews
Overall Estimated Grading:
Progressive: El-Sayed, Jackson
Standard: Brown, Talarico (could be more bipartisan or progressive depending on how he adapts)
Blue Dog/Bipartisan Leaning: Turek, Hamilton, Peltola, Colom
Wild Card: Andrews