r/youtubegaming • • Jul 11 '26

Community Meta r/YouTubeGaming community rules — an Explainer & Roundtable Discussion

8 Upvotes

Good morning!

As there has been a recent spate of users coming to us in modmail confused as to why their submissions have been removed, I though it would be appropriate to write up a little explainer regarding the details and the origins of the rules of the community; as well as to open up a roundtable discussion regarding the rules if anyone would like to offer any public feedback, or discuss any potential changes publicly.

There will not be any action taken against any users offering genuine feedback in this thread — except for if the feedback is an obviously egregious Rule 4 violation.

----

Rule 1: No promotion, uploaded videos, or non-newsworthy YouTube links

I mean, does this one really need to be explained much more? Without this most basic rule, the community here would be a massive stinking link dump from people desperate for views and validation.

The emphasis on "non-newsworthy" YouTube links is because there is still a scope for sharing videos discussing updates to the YouTube platform; to creator guides with tips and tricks for recording, editing, thumbnail creation, title curation, etc.; or to videos with useful content for all creators, such as the recent Tom Scott WIRED interview, where he answers a ton of questions about being a creator far better than any of us can.

This rule also applies to comments, so attempting to respond to someone else's post by shilling non-newsworthy content will also result in Rule 1 violation removals.

Reddit-uploaded videos had to be added to this rule as some users tried to skirt the link ban, by instead uploading their content directly to Reddit and adding their channel name in the post/comment to encourage you to go there afterwards.

Rule 2: Conversation should be about YouTube as a gaming video platform

The community here was made primarily for us gaming YouTube creators to discuss the YouTube platform and its workings; as well as for viewers of gaming videos to discuss the UI and any problems. After Rule 1, this is probably the rule that results in the most removals. I'll discuss in more detail some examples of items that get removed under this rule:

"I don't know what games to play"

No-one here can answer that for you. Only you know what games you enjoy and would therefore make good content for your channel. Trying to force yourself to play something you don't enjoy, just because it is popular and might gain views, will be clear to the end viewer.

Besides, all you need to do is use the genre search on Steam, Microsoft Store, PlayStation store etc. to get some great recommendations.

"How do I get more views/subscribers?"

Let me be blunt. If we knew the answer to this question, we wouldn't be here discussing it with you. Audiences and the algorithm are finnicky bitches, and they work in mysterious ways that no-one here can reliably predict.

"Why don't my Shorts get views?"

The Shorts feed is even more volatile than a normal audience. The Shorts algorithm attempts to cycle every piece of content uploaded through the feed at least once, but with the absolute glut of Shorts uploaded, getting around to it can often take quite a lot of time.

Additionally, you need to consider that the long-form audience and the Shorts audience are for the most part a Venn diagram of two completely separate circles. There is very little if any overlap between them.

"Am I shadowbanned?"

No, you're just impatient and expecting instant gratification. Uploading to YouTube is not just pressing a button and magically getting millions of views and subscribers.

"I want new channel recommendations"

This isn't discussing the platform for the benefit of gaming YouTubers. This is just you looking for new content. The YouTube algorithm is generally good at trying to surface newer channels/videos in your recommendations, so make use of that area.

Additionally, posts like this get removed because it just results in other users then trying to promote themselves in the comments, in violation of Rule 1.

"Help me find this particular video/creator"

This isn't tipofmyyoutube, and again does not discuss the platform for the benefit of gaming YouTubers.

Rule 3: The feedback rule

This rule had to be implemented because far too many users tried to skirt around Rule 1 by just adding something like "feedback request" or "how's my editing" to their link dump. It became far too tiresome to moderate, so it was decided to outlaw them entirely.

Another concern is that too many people try to post their entire video and request a spectrum that is far too broad such as "the editing" across the entire video. Feedback requests only work if the area being requested is focused on one particular aspect, such as a specific transition, zoom, music sync beat, etc.

We are considering re-allowing feedback requests via Reddit-uploaded images and video clips, however these will be very tightly moderated — to the point of possibly being approval-only — and clips will be restricted to snippets under one minute.

Rule 4: Remember the human

Unfortunately, this is the internet so this has to be explicitly defined. Don't be a dick to other users. It's fine to have different opinions, but respect those opinions and do not go attacking the other user for it.

This was definitely put to the test on several occasions in the recent AI thumbnail thread, where a fair few users went off the boil for someone daring to post an opinion they disagreed with...

Rule 5: No actions that are against the YouTube Terms of Service

I mean, this should be obvious. If we as gaming YouTubers want to remain on the platform, we need to follow the Terms of Service.

Rules 6 & 7: Services and Collaborations

These rules were originally implemented as service/collab posts effectively became just as spammy as link dumps and bad feedback requests.

Service posts have way too many people these days offering editing services, and all they end up doing is running the clips through some AI compilation software. On top of that, some people tried to showcase their portfolio which was basically just link dumping their own channel — which also violated Rule 1.

Collab posts aren't really discussing the YouTube platform, and also end up mostly just being thinly veiled promotion dumps.

Rule 8: Polls must use native Reddit polls, or Google Forms

Anonymous polling sites were the bastion of low-effort polls many years ago, in addition to being easily brigaded and influenced. Since then native Reddit polls have become more feature-rich, particularly with the option to show the votes from "core contributors" of a community.

----

If you wish to offer feedback on any of the rules, please ensure that you make it clear which rule number(s) you are talking about. Also do consider how easily enforceable any particular changes are — a suggestion may sound simple on paper, but prove to be incredibly hard to put into action with the limitations of the Reddit platform!


r/youtubegaming • • Aug 10 '26

News Starting February 2027, YPP entry requirements for ads and Premium revenue sharing will increase to 8,000 watch hours in the last 12 months, or 20M Shorts views in the last 90 days.

Thumbnail
blog.youtube
22 Upvotes

Additional reading: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/12843009

Creators currently in YPP are unaffected.

The requirements for a channel to remain active in YPP are also changing. A channel is considered active if one of the following are true:

  • 1,000 qualified watch hours in the past 365 days
  • 1M qualified Shorts views in the last 90 days
  • 2 long-form videos or 5 Shorts uploaded every 90 days

r/youtubegaming • • 20h ago

Question Editing gameplay walkthroughs

6 Upvotes

Curious Question for anyone : Do you edit your gameplays/ walkthroughs? If so what are the parts that you cut out?


r/youtubegaming • • 19h ago

Help Me! Suggestions

2 Upvotes

Hey! I'm trying to help a small gaming channel that's currently at 436 subscribers and aiming to reach 1k. Growth has been pretty slow, and I'm trying to figure out what could be holding it back.

For those of you who have experience with YouTube, what would you recommend focusing on first? Are thumbnails and titles the biggest factors, or should he work more on editing, video ideas, upload consistency, or livestreaming?

I'd also love to hear which games are worth focusing on for a smaller gaming channel and what strategies actually help with discoverability.

Any constructive advice would be appreciated. I'm mainly looking for ways to improve the content and help the channel grow organically

Channel Name IGoPrime


r/youtubegaming • • 21h ago

Hardware For content creation is an elgato capture card HD which is around 10/11 years old doable ?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/youtubegaming • • 18h ago

Software New to YouTube, need advice.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/youtubegaming • • 1d ago

Question How do you separate fun from content

2 Upvotes

I'm back into gaming on YouTube and it's going slowly but well, but I'm running into the problem I forgot nuked my motivation the first time around. It's Saturday morning and I want to play games for me, not for content. Where I can be quiet and chill and half dead and look shit up and be bad lol.

But every time I think of a game I'd like to play I'm stopped by the voice in my head that says but that could be content. That's first playthrough where I'm allowed to not know what I'm doing and mess up. Where I don't have to be an expert.

So that leaves only the games I've already played but I'm not in the mood for a repeat game.

Do you ever struggle with this? How do you separate fun gameplay from content gameplay? Do you kind of compromise with yourself? Or just make some games you're really passionate about just for you channel be damned?


r/youtubegaming • • 1d ago

Help Me! Can't stream at 1440p

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I have streamed 1440p 60fpr in the past. But the last month youtube only shows 1080p 60. What do I do?


r/youtubegaming • • 1d ago

Discussion Anyone else feel like superchats don't really get your question answered?

1 Upvotes

Genuine question for people who donate or superchat during streams.

I've sent a few superchats to streamers I love wathcing, usually because I wanted their take on something specific (a build, a strategy, the meta). Most of the time it gets read out, they say something quick like "oh good question, yeah I'd probably go X", and chat moves on. I don't regret it, I like supporting them, but I never feel like I actually got enough of an answer.

Curious how it is for others
- What do you usually superchat or donate for? Supporting, getting noticed, or actually asking something?

- When you had a real question where you wanted a bit more constructed answer, how did you even go about getting it? Superchat again for a bigger amount, dm somewhere, or pay a Patreon tier?

Not hating on anyone, streamers have hundreds of messages flying by. Just wondering if it's only me. I know it depends a lot on the streamers tho, still curious as to how people feel generally


r/youtubegaming • • 2d ago

Discussion Small streamers - how do you keep going when you’re putting in the effort but growth feels slow?

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, it’s RySlayTTV here! 👋

I’ve been streaming for a few months now, absolutely loving it, and putting a lot of time into improving my content, setup, clips, and social media. But let’s be real, growing as a small streamer can be tough when you’re putting in the effort and aren’t always seeing the results just yet.

I’m curious, for those of you who have been through this stage or are currently in it, what has genuinely helped you grow? Was it networking, consistency, clips, social media, finding your niche, or something completely unexpected?

I’d love to hear your experiences, advice, and little wins. We’re all figuring this out together! 🫶


r/youtubegaming • • 2d ago

Question Voice recording for youtube videos using PS5

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/youtubegaming • • 2d ago

Question Tried streaming but don’t have a face cam and multistream didn’t work so a question

1 Upvotes

Would just doing normal videos and my playthroughs I’ve been doing if I can’t fix the multistream and then using shorts I cut end up working for the channel?


r/youtubegaming • • 2d ago

Question Gaming on Twitch and editing for YouTube.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/youtubegaming • • 3d ago

Software Is there any way to record/ stream gameplay without the capture card?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

So, I recently got my PS5 and have been trying to stream the game. I dont have a facecam or anything as I dont have that kinda budget right now.

For streaming:
I just do it directly via the broadcast feature on PS5 but dont get the facecam on youtube and it plays on 1080p which is a turn off. I have also tried OBSStudio but my laptop has 8gb RAM with GTX 1650 so I tried doing remote play but failed miserably as the live stream was lagging way too much. I guess no capture card no streaming in 4k?

For recording:
Now since I know I can’t stream I thought of uploading gameplays like RadBrad. I recorded in 4k (ofc) and then comes the hassle of converting that webm to mp4 using handbrake. The clips are in HDR so the conversion takes up a lot of time. Plus copying to USB drive first from console takes time. Then taking that clip to handbrake. Then I use a phone as a face cam then upload those clips or transfer them to my laptop.

I feel I am spending more time in executing and putting in efforts to upload my gameplay than actually playing the game.

Is this something normal for everyone doing this? or am I just taking the long stupid way?


r/youtubegaming • • 3d ago

Discussion I give up today

0 Upvotes

worked a whole year for being a gaming content creator got 250 subs on youtube and 3000 followers something on instagram (10m views)
but when i really wanted to worked it out
got 40 view on GTA 6 stream i felt so worth less
stopping everything for now i love gaming when something doesn’t work out it feels wrong so
i will play the game alone without any stream
will sell my all my gadgets for content creation
may be its just not for me


r/youtubegaming • • 4d ago

Question Do you cut loading screens out of your gameplay footage?

7 Upvotes

I record long story sessions about once or twice a month (live service games, I know), these can run for 5h at times. While I enjoy rewatching the story after a while, cutting these loading screens manually means my videos take too long to publish. Not that anyone would watch them, but... entertain my curiosity for a bit.

Big creators in the games I play seem to just leave loading screens in, teleports, small sections of just walking to a place.

So I'm curious, do you leave them, cut them by hand (and how, scrubbing/panning, 1.5x playback, RT playback?) or use a tool? Do your viewers even care?


r/youtubegaming • • 4d ago

Question Is GTA VI Clipping Actually a Real Business Opportunity or Just Another Hype Trend?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone! 👋

For the past few days, I've been seeing tons of content about GTA VI launching on November 19 and how people should start learning clipping to earn money through YouTube Shorts and Instagram Reels.

Different people are recommending tools, strategies and platforms. Honestly, I'm getting overwhelmed by all this information.

I just want to understand whether gaming clipping is actually a sustainable income opportunity or just temporary hype around GTA VI.

A few things I'd love to know:

1. Can beginners realistically make decent money clipping gaming streamers' content?

2. Where does the actual money come from - platform monetization, paid clipping campaigns or brand deals?

3. Is it better to build your own clipping pages or work directly with streamers?

4. What would be a realistic earning potential after 3 - 6 months?

5. If you were starting today, what strategy would you follow to turn this into a long-term business?

I'm not looking for generic advice like "post consistently" or another list of editing tools.

I want to understand the actual business model, earning potential and whether it's worth investing my time in this.

Would love to hear honest opinions and experiences. Thanks! 🙌


r/youtubegaming • • 4d ago

Question Should I make a new channel

0 Upvotes

Should I make a new channel for gta 6? I have a channel for cod content I dont have many videos. I have 46 subscribers.


r/youtubegaming • • 5d ago

Discussion Would the release of GTA 6 temporarily bring back yt lets plays?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/youtubegaming • • 5d ago

Hardware Elgato 4KX, PS5, and Audio over my headset.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/youtubegaming • • 5d ago

Question Can faceless content creators have a YouTube channel and make money by playing story..based games, like Let's Play YouTubers

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/youtubegaming • • 6d ago

Question How do you deal with doxxing?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/youtubegaming • • 8d ago

Help Me! Converting packaging from AI to doing it myself

6 Upvotes

Hello, I started my gaming channel a few months ago using AI thumbnails etc (I'm a professional writer and a somewhat older, very experienced gamer, but it felt so beyond me to DIY thumbnails etc. when I was trying to learn how to get videos up, edit, etc, at all. So not knocking anyone who uses AI -- but I want to convert everything to made-by-me. I'm at a loss for whether, for example, to use my face (with reaction related, but not over the top) in my thumbnails. I'm a redhead from Volcano, Hawai'i, and like everyone try to use whatever I have to stand out, but obvs no one knows who I am lol. Lots of gamers in my niche (mystery, detective, horror, anything Rusty Lake, puzzle etc) seem to use their mugs, whether they have a real following or not -- simple rule of thirds style thumbnails, grabby game art, bright background, text only as needed. Wanted to consult those in the know before doing this master overhaul though. In what direction are thumbnails going? Is there a backlash against AI in the gaming community so more basic thumbnails are getting better CTR? (I'm on thumbnails and packaging groups -- I just want to ask the creators and gamers.) Many thanks for any insights you have.


r/youtubegaming • • 9d ago

Discussion Yotube gaming is being killed by kids

0 Upvotes

Didnt anybody notice that most youtube gaming content now is focused mainly for kids ? maybe they play minecraft and add terror mods, make a story up etc, if you watch this as an adult it looks ridiculous but a kid of 7 years old or 9 may feel like he is watching something he is not supposed because this terror content is for adults and he watches more and more not being able to distinguish a shitty content at that age, also the 100 days playing this, hyper edidted videos etc like this is content ive seen small kids scrolling and watching withought adult supervision. like its the first time in history a whole generation of small kids have access to internet devices like we have today and i think youtube only cares about rentention and kids are taking it all with this shitty content they watch, i feel very dissapointed with the current state of youtube to this day.