New Subreddit Rules: https://www.reddit.com/r/amiga/about/rules
Following on from my prior community consultation I feel we've had enough feedback and no new comments appear to be gathering. See here;
https://www.reddit.com/r/amiga/comments/1xlubjz/possible_ai_motivated_changes/
The possible rule changes I floated were these four:
- Posts created through prompting AI will continue to be disallowed. That is, posts that consist in the main of only AI generated content (text, images or music) are not allowed.
- Software created with AI assist will continue to be allowed.
- Going forward, all posts will require post flair, there will be a new 'genAI software' flair and all genAI assisted software will be required to tag themselves as such. This will allow people who do not want to engage with such software to use the flair to avoid those threads. Importantly, arguing about/discussing the validity of genAI inside "genAI software" threads will be disallowed. Separate threads for meta discussion about genAI will be allowed, such discussion is not banned, but it would be nice if it didn't "poison" every software thread.
- WRT non-amiga games I think maybe we should disallow making a main post in /r/amiga. If you've made a Mac/linux/win port it should be posted in a relevant Mac/linux/win subreddit but we will allow crossposting to /r/amiga.
This attracted a fair amount of comments. So I went through and totalled up which changes recieved comments that were for or against;
| Suggestion | For count | Against count |
|---|
| 1 | 21 | 0 |
| 2 | 22 | 3 |
| 3 | 25 | 4 |
| 4 | 23 | 7 |
Generally the readership seems fine with continued AI development, though we should also cover AI assisted hardware design. Only 3 people voiced strict, anti-AI ban sentiments. And honestly there points about the environment and plagarism remain valid. But I think on balance we will continue to allow these as the board is here to serve the community as it is.
Point 4 about non amiga games attracted the most constructive feedback. 4 people specifically mentioned that these should be regarded as wholly off topic and banned outright, including crossposting. Which I am sympathetic to. 3 people suggested a better way forward might be to have a relevant weekly/sticky post for ports and that such announcements should go there rather than be posted in the main board. This sounds like a good idea, so I think that will be the way forward from next week. And we can revisit if it is working on not in the future.
Lastly two interesting points of feedback were;
"I think "AI assisted" tags won't age well"
Perhaps. Maybe all software and technical will become genAI assisted maybe it'll go the other way and genAI will fall out of favour. I don't know that we know how this is still to play out. Anthropic et al's business models are not sustainable but local models for coding are now very good.
"We can revisit again in a year if the world has completely changed again by then!"
I wholly agree here. All of this is contingent and if it proves not to work we can and will revise in the future
If you haven't done so already, please read the new rules
https://www.reddit.com/r/amiga/about/rules