r/AmItheAsshole • • Oct 03 '26

Open Forum AITA Quarterly Open Forum Oct - Dec 2026

71 Upvotes

AITA Quarterly Open Forum Oct - Dec 2026

Keep things Civil! Rules still apply.

Greetings Assholes!!! Happy All the Holidays between now and January 2027!! Way too many to list.

This quarter, we are going to go over Rule 3 - No Violence. A topic that’s dear to my heart and one that covers so many different scenarios.

The very heart of this rule is “Do not even mention violence”. Very simple on the surface, very complicated once you dive down. It sometimes seems like we are being too specific/granular on what constitutes violence - we get that. But violence tends to breed violence, so the most benign post/comment can spiral into some off the charts shit.

The violence rule break is often the result of a soft topic going off the rails. Example: Someone is put out by their partner picking food off of their plate. What we see: “stab them with your fork, that’ll teach them (assault)!” Or, someone is stealing lunches out of the break room - “just put some hot shit in there, that’ll teach them (poison/assault)” Or, the kid goes around hitting people (assault) begets “just beat their ass (assault)!” Simple, common things we’ve all said at some point in our lives. Still violence.

The hardest ones for us are those that deal with abuse of any sort. It’s easy to jump on that hate train. Truthfully, I’m probably on some of those trains, cause fuck abusers. BUT, we remove those comments/posts because they beget violence - it’s not that we don’t have opinions on those topics, far from it. These break the violence rule and, regardless of our personal opinion, it breaks the rule. It’s as simple as that.

We get MOD mails so filled with anger and spewing hateful shit because “How dare you remove that post for violence. Y’all must agree with them”. No, we don’t - violence is violence. There is enough of it out in the real world, we don’t need it here for any reason.

Finally, the real reason for reviewing this rule: Consent.

Very simply, if anyone touches you without your consent - this is assault. Sexual harassment counts! It is not ‘ick’, it is not ‘smile, they will go away’ - it is something covered by this rule. This is true regardless of gender. Understanding this will help the most when deciding if something is violence or not.


As always, do not directly link to posts/comments or post uncensored screenshots here. Any comments with links will be removed.

We'd like to highlight the regional spinoffs we have linked on the sidebar! If you have any suggestions or additions to this, please let us know in the comments.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 7h ago

AITA for refusing to buy a PS5 so that my girlfriend can watch me play GTA 6?

1.2k Upvotes

I (39M) have been dating my girlfriend (34F) for 6 months. GTA 6 just came out and she wants me to buy a $600 PS5 so she can sit on the couch and watch me play it. She doesn't want to play it herself, she wants to WATCH.

Apparently all her friends are watching their boyfriends play and she feels left out. She told me she "doesn't understand why I can't be a normal boyfriend."

I played a ton of Counter-Strike 1.6, Day of Defeat and Fallout 1 and 2 as a kid, but I haven't touched a game in years and I'm just not into them anymore. I don't see why I should have to play this whole ass video game just so she has something to watch.

AITA?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 6h ago

AITA for not opening the door when my friend came to "help" us move?

854 Upvotes

Happy weekend everyone.

My husband and I recently moved. I had a friend who texted me and asked if I wanted to hang out last weekend. I let her know that I was moving and we would be busy but maybe we could meet up in a few weeks. She immediately asked if she could help, which was very sweet.

The thing is though this friend isn't particularly helpful. We've tried to get things done before and she just stands in the way and gabs. Which is totally fine but we had movers and a service tech coming so I had a schedule to keep. Plus admittedly my husband and I always get stressed out when we move and having someone underfoot would have made the task even more unpleasant for both of us. So I profusely thanked her and told her that we had it handled, even saying that hubbie and I were terrible delegators and just liked to get things done our way. She said she understood, would text me later, and that was that.

Then last weekend, I'm in our apartment packing, movers are due in an hour, and I happen to glance out the window, and there is my friend, walking across the parking lot towards our building with two iced coffees in hand. I stopped for a second and was just kind of flabbergasted because again, I had said we would be busy.

She started knocking on the door and I just didn't answer and went back to packing in the back part of the apartment. I knew if I opened the door she would want to chat for a bit, or would try to invite herself in, and I just didn't have time for it today. I was also a little irritated because we were running behind and a few things had just gone wrong and we were moving after a really chaotic week and I knew I would sound a lot harsher than I intended to be. She probably was outside for about five minutes because she eventually stopped knocking and I saw her leave.

She texted me the next day and said she knew I ignored her and she just wanted to help. I haven't said anything back but I'm just not sure about the whole thing.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 11h ago

AITAH for refusing to leave our dogs home alone on Christmas so my BIL can bring his new puppy?

934 Upvotes

My partner and I have two dogs. One is older and has epilepsy, so we're generally careful about leaving him alone for extended periods.

Today, my MIL called my partner to discuss Christmas plans. The plan is drinks around 3–4 PM, followed by dinner around 6:30 PM. We usually don't leave until around 9 PM.

She asked us to leave our dogs at home this year because my BIL and his partner recently got a French Bulldog puppy who won't be fully vaccinated by Christmas. They're planning to bring him to dinner.

Our dogs are fully vaccinated. My partner explained that we aren't comfortable leaving them home alone for 6–7 hours, especially given our older dog's epilepsy. Finding a dog sitter on Christmas Day would also be difficult and very expensive.

We live approximately 1.5 hours away, so driving three hours round-trip just to attend for a short time isn't practical either.

My MIL's response was essentially that it's okay if we don't come and we come another day instead. What really surprised me was the apparent lack of interest in finding a compromise. Why couldn't the dogs be kept separate? Why is the solution automatically that our dogs stay home?

Now my partner has suggested that he simply goes to Christmas dinner while I stay home with the dogs.

I don't have family here (they live overseas), so Christmas with his family is also my opportunity to spend the holidays with family. The other couple is celebrating Christmas Eve with her family, so I'm struggling to understand why we're expected to make all the sacrifices here.

I understand wanting to protect a young, incompletely vaccinated puppy. But AITA for refusing to leave our dogs alone for that long and expecting my partner to spend Christmas with me and the dogs rather than going without me?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 14h ago

WIBTA if I don’t want to financially contribute to Thanksgiving dinner?

1.3k Upvotes

In the past years since I turned 18, everyone has brought a side dish while whoever is hosting prepares the turkey. This year my parents are hosting and they even get the turkey’s provided for free because my dad’s company gives them out for free for their employees every year for Thanksgiving. We were all assigned a side dish to bring which is completely fine with me. It wasn’t until my mom called today and said everyone needs to also chip in $20. I said for what, she responds saying that she plans to also get a ham this year and the ham is over $100. I said it’s ridiculous to get a ham when we already have two free turkeys and only a small minority of us eat ham. My mom ended the conversation saying if I don’t like it then I can go over my boyfriend’s for Thanksgiving and I said that’s fine. Now she’s mad, AITA?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 20h ago

UPDATE Update: AITA for not inviting my stepmother to my wedding

2.7k Upvotes

Original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/s/3WP7Avqx6K

So shortly after posting on Reddit, I texted my dad “Now that I've sat with it for a week, I really am uncomfortable with inviting name to my wedding given her repeated cruel behavior and maltreatment of not only myself but (half brother) over the years. I will not be inviting her to the wedding, and I understand if you will be staying at home with her. This is the day (my husband) and I will be starting our new lives together, and it doesn't need to include people who have blatantly mistreated me. I want to start my marriage surrounded by people who love me. This decision is final and I trust that you will respect it.”

He replied that I put him in an awful position but he respected it. Then he stated that by doing that, he would not be going to the wedding and neither would any of his side of the family. I responded that it is what it is and his family can do whatever they want, and that i would let them know I did not invite her.

I messaged his family and they understood. My aunt (his sister) was pissed at my father and came to the wedding anyways. A couple of my cousins came as well! My uncle/Godfather (his brother) said he was coming, and then I got a long message from him that was 100% AI generated that “increasing tensions between my father and I” put him in a position where he could not come to the wedding. I responded that I was disappointed. I later found out my dad had been texting him repeatedly telling him not to go to our wedding, that he wouldn’t if the roles were reversed. He blamed the whole thing on my mom (as usual).

He also ended up giving my half brother an ultimatum, basically me vs. him, so my brother did not attend either.

After the wedding, my aunt posted a photo of my husband and I in the church, and immediately the following day my husband, my aunt, and myself were blocked on Facebook by both my evil stepmother and my father. Lollllll. I haven’t seen my half brother in almost two years, but we text every so often. My father hasn’t spoken to me since that last text message. It’s honestly a relief not having to deal with them anymore and manage everyone’s emotions.

Despite the drama, our wedding was the most perfect day. I didn’t give him a single thought. I married the absolute best man I know surrounded by so many friends and family members that I loved and who truly loved and supported us. It was honestly all the responses I other on Reddit that convinced I wasn’t doing the wrong thing. So I really need to thank everyone that responded. It was the best day and I felt so supported and loved.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 16h ago

AITA for not inviting my husband's twin sister to my baby shower?

1.0k Upvotes

AITA for not inviting her to my baby shower or gender reveal. My husband and I had an intimate dinner with a select 16 people and my MIL felt some type of way my SIL/her daughter wasn't invited. I explained my reasoning as to why: she's called me a racial slur, she blatantly ignores me at any family gathering (funerals, wakes, holidays, or just going over). To be honest, I do not engage with her at any point once the slur was used so I understand my contribution to the distance. That being said, I dont want a relationship but my MIL seems to try to force us to talk to her. I told my MIL that she shouldn't be involved and my SIL has not once tried to reconcile. My MIL refused to acknowledge her wrongs and just kept saying "but they're twins, theyre family", and "but this baby is a way to bring the family together". I dont think my child should be used as an "opportunity" nor do I think I should invite her just because.

Side Note: My husband doesn't talk to her for his own personal reasons.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 4h ago

AITA for refusing to help my boyfriend plan his trip after he ditched our vacation plans?

114 Upvotes

My boyfriend and I have been together for three years, and we’ve NEVER taken a vacation together. Last week, we spent an entire day planning a trip to Mexico. We looked through resorts, reviews, and hundreds of photos. I was so excited that we were finally going to have our first trip as a couple.

A week later, he called to tell me he’s going on a trip with his longtime best friend (a woman) instead. Apparently, they’ve been talking about going together “forever.” If that was the case, why didn’t he mention it while we were planning Mexico?

For context, he’s already gone on multiple vacations with his friends throughout our relationship. I’ve never tried to stop him. It just hurts that after three years, he’s found time to travel with everyone else but me. I thought this time would finally be ours.

He’s also going away for longer than we had planned. His birthday falls during the trip, so I won’t get to spend that with him either. He’s still in the closet, which means I already won’t get to see him around Christmas. Between all of that, I feel like I get whatever time is left over.
Then he had the AUDACITY to ask me whether he should stay until the 19th or the 21st.
Seriously? Am I your boyfriend or your fucking travel agent? Why would you ask me to help plan the very trip I’m already hurt about?

I told him I want absolutely nothing to do with it. I won’t discuss hotels, flights, or plans, and I’m certainly not driving him to the airport. I’m still incredibly angry, and I haven’t forgiven him.

I want to be clear: my issue isn’t that his best friend is a woman or that he wants to travel without me. It’s that we spent an entire day planning something special, and a week later, it felt like our plans meant absolutely nothing.
His explanation is that they’ve wanted this trip for a long time, but that doesn’t change how it feels to be pushed aside.

After three years together, watching him take multiple vacations with other people while we’ve never had one together genuinely hurts. Especially when I already have to accept that I can’t spend certain holidays with him because our relationship is still a secret.
I’m not asking to be included in everything. I just want to feel like a priority for once.

So, Reddit, AITA for refusing to help my boyfriend plan yet another vacation without me, refusing to drive him to the airport, and still being angry about the whole situation?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 4h ago

AITAH for kicking 9yo out of bed?

98 Upvotes

So for context I’m a woman, we’re a lesbian couple.

Me (27F) and my gf (26F) were on vacation with her family. We shared a room and her nephew (9M) was in a room across the hall with other family members. Last night he was hanging in our room until bedtime. Her nephew kept saying he didn’t want to leave and my gf was like well just sleep here with us! And he happily got into bed with us with my gf in between us and they went to sleep.

I was uncomfortable with this because I just don’t really like the idea of sharing the bed with a 9yo boy I’m not related to — I know other people might not care but it made me uncomfortable. Also 3 of us in bed felt super cramped, I was hanging off the edge and couldn’t get comfortable. And lastly, he smelled bad. He had refused to shower for like 2 days lol and idk if she just didn’t notice but he smelled like dirty socks and armpit. Did not want him sleeping nearby. But my gf didn’t give me much of a chance to mention this and he seemed so happy about it so I felt bad and let it go, although I was really bothered she didn’t ask me first.

But after about 20 minutes of tossing and turning in bed and trying to be comfortable with the situation I tapped my gf and told her how I felt. She was really annoyed and was like “you seriously want me to send him back to his room now? It’ll hurt his feelings” and she said he had mentioned wanting to sleep with her and since it was the last night of vacation they wouldn’t get another opportunity. I told her I wish she’d asked me before inviting him and we could have figured something out. I really would have switched rooms with somebody or gotten my own for the night so they could sleep together. They are super close and I felt bad but I asked her to please send him back to his room. She did but she was pissed about it. AITAH?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 47m ago

AITA for not letting my 13 and 14 year old play GTAVI ?

47 Upvotes

2 teenage boys begging for the game but Im not sure its appropriate for them. I mean I was doing way worse at their age but thats not the life I want them to live.

They reckon all their mates have it and its not fair etc etc.

Am I just being overprotective or is it the right call? Help a dad out haha


r/AmItheAsshole • • 9h ago

WIBTA For Making my Daughter wake up earlier to bring her brother to school?

171 Upvotes

I have a 17 year old daughter who’s a senior in high school, and a 14 year old son who’s a freshman. They go to two different schools, and my daughters school starts 20 minutes later (8:20) than my sons (8:00), and she’s usually at school by 8:10 now that she’s a senior is luckily was able to secure a parking pass this year.

Where we live, now that’s it getting cold I’d like for her to bring her brother to school 2-3 days a week when me or my wife can’t, and she’s kind of against it because it means she’ll have to wake up maybe like 15-20 minutes earlier to bring him to school at around 7:40-7:50 instead of getting ready for school. This isn’t anything we’re having raging arguments about, just that she doesn’t really want to do so. My wife and I talked to her about and she brought up the sleep thing, but its Only 3 days a week (sometimes 2), and we were the ones that bought her the car in the first place…that we pay the insurance, gas and upkeep for so I don’t think my wife and I are asking for too much here.

It seems I might take the by force route, but my wife and I don’t really know if that’s the best path to take, even though it seems like it’s kind of something we should do and have no issue with.
WIBTA?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 5h ago

AITA for letting my sister take the kids outside

60 Upvotes

I have 2 kids, 6f and 8m. I have primary custody. We live roughly 9 hours from their dad.

Their dad was born and raised an area where 60 degrees is considered cold and it rained a couple times a year. The kids and I are in an area where it doesn’t snow, but it comes pretty close. It’s rained for the past 10 days. The kids and I live in a two bedroom apartment so there isn’t much room to play. The kids were bouncing off the walls so I took them to my sister’s house.

My sister has 3 kids: 12, 6, and 4, all girls. She doesn’t like screens and has all of her girls stay very active. Her 12 year old does competitive dance, swim team, and does archery and horseback riding. Her 6 year old just started competitive gymnastics, does swim class once a week during the school year and weekday mornings in summer, and goes to a program similar to 4-H where the kids raise chickens and rabbits, garden, cook, and bake. The 4 year old has soccer, gymnastics, swimming, and the 4-H like program. She has a playroom where the walls are rock walls, have climbing bars, monkey bars on the ceiling, swings hanging down, crash pads so the kids can jump from the ceiling, etc. and a massive outdoor play structure. The tv is for 1 movie a week and she has a Wii with 3 games that can be used when it rains or when it’s above 90 degrees outside

My sister offered to watch the kids so I could get some Christmas shopping done if I dropped her 12 year old off at archery and picked her up and picked up a few things at Costco. It did not rain today so after lunch my sister told all of the kids to get their coats, got their bikes, and took them to the park. She did not take them home until it started to rain at 4-ish. It was about 48-53 degrees outside with 10-15 mph winds. Cold but not freezing and everyone had coats.

I picked them up at 5-ish and the kids FaceTimed their dad on the way home. They told him that they went to their aunts house, climbed the walls, jumped from the ceiling like spider man, and then went to the park from after lunch until it rained.

Their dad is pretty overprotective (as in he refused to let me teach our son to ride a bike when he was 6 because he was convinced that he’d fracture his skull and tried to take me to court over me getting my kids bunk beds) and keeps our city saved on his weather app so he could check on the weather here.

He asked me why I’d let her take the kids outside when it was this cold out. I told him that they needed exercise, they had fleece lined windbreakers, and they go outside whenever it doesn’t rain at school.

He said that their school forcing them to go outside for 20 minutes doesn’t mean it’s ok for my sister to force them outside for at least 3 hours.

He wants to file a CPS report against me and my sister over this so now I’m wondering if I should have put limits on how long they could stay outside


r/AmItheAsshole • • 14h ago

AITAH for reporting my coworker and not letting him bring his dog to work?

252 Upvotes

Throwaway account. I (23F) and my coworker (45M) work together at a small company. we have maybe 10 employees here. One person runs the office, one person runs the heavy equipment.

I have had issues after issues with this coworker. He was supposed to be fired for getting injured during work (i.e., sticking his hand inside of running machinery to "pull trash out", and getting injured, leading to all of us getting drug tested) He also leaves for work consistently for 2 hours (which is allowed) and when I asked him to run home today for 15 minutes since i forgot my electrolytes, (i have health issues, they keep me going) he refused to watch the office so i could leave.

The "office" is a tiny shed with a portapotty. Theres barely enough room for 2 people to sit a comfortable distance from each other.

Well, he's been bringing in his dog to work for a while. She did fine for a minute, but if extended time passes she gets too nervous staying in the shed office with someone she doesnt know, while he is out running equipment.

This dog whines ALL DAY. ALL 12 HOURS. i bring noise cancelling headphones to drown it out and she whines LOUDER than my headphones.

I have to be in and out of the shed constantly helping customers. To get customers to pay I have to go back and forth between them and my computer in the shed. This is where things get messy.

His dog ran off while i had 5 people waiting. She wont stay in the shed and will flip out if someone leaves her. Ive been stuck squeezing inbetween the door and desk so she doesnt escape. it MAJORLY slows me down, which isnt viable for this job. I fucked up a couple tickets because I had to find the dog (she has run UNDER vehicles im trying to help in the past) and coworker came in and yelled at me for letting things through that shouldnt have been let through.

After he got after me, I was fed up. I got after him and made some passive aggressive remarks, like "im not feeling great, im sick of the whining, shes not happy in here with me. etc." He leaves work and wont let me leave, he leaves his whiny dog here that causes me problems, and hes really just not bright.

I texted my boss the following: "hey, can \[coworker\]not bring his dog to work anymore? i get stressed out cus she runs out the door everytime i do and runs under cars or off somewhere. i dont want to be responsible or hold that guilt if anything happens to the dog."

I dont feel like i should have to watch her. shes not my dog, nor am i a free babysitting service.

The dog has separation anxiety and cant be left alone. AITA?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 3h ago

AITA I hate watching TV with my friend

33 Upvotes

I really hope she never sees this. So my newish friend has just gotten me to watch all of a TV show (it's an animated show on Disney+, thats all I'll say) and she has basically ruined the entire experience for me. she got me to watch it by skipping through "filler episodes" and only watching things relevant to the plot that way we could get through it faster, but after going back and watching those episodes they are totally relevant and the reason why I'm having such a hard time understanding it is because of all of the context I'm missing.

Another thing that sucks is because it's her favorite show that she's seen 16 times she does this thing where she will not only sing along to all of the songs, but with CONSTANTLY RECITE ALL OF THE LINES IN IMPORTANT SCENES AS THEY'RE HAPPENING. I miss half of what's going on sometimes because I just hear her talking and have to rewind. I'm not trying to listen to her act the scene out next to me I'm trying to watch the show FOR THE FIRST TIME. I don't know how she doesn't realize how obnoxious this was. Also whenever the big important scenes would come up she'd turn to me and say things to add dramatic affect like "the entire season was leading up to this" or something to that effect.

I sort of want to tell her how this has completely ruined the experience for me and that I don't want to watch anything else with her but I feel like an asshole. I'm just glad I can watch the show alone now, process everything in order the way they creators intended, and not have her distracting me the entire time


r/AmItheAsshole • • 17h ago

AITA? Not wanting to visit my wife's parents.

273 Upvotes

AITA here? It's my birthday in a couple of days and my wife's parents want us to go and visit them next weekend ( for context they live 6 hours away and we drove down to see them a couple of weeks ago, both retired early but refuse to drive to us to visit).

We have plans next weekend for my birthday, cottage booked and a quiet getaway for a long weekend. We spoke to them to say we couldn't visit that weekend because we're busy and they started getting childish and making demands and started the emotional blackmail.

My wife is and has always been easily persuaded by her parents and they usually end up getting exactly what they want and we've had to cancel plans in the past to suit them.

Sitting next to my wife I could hear the conversation turning and the persuasion attempts starting to take a hold, calmly and as polite as I could I asked my wife to pass the phone and told her parents we had plans and weren't changing them again to which they hung up on me.

Now my wife is getting txt messages saying I'm a horrible person and a terrible husband and trying to drive a wedge between them and my wife. In reality, I just wanted to spend a weekend away with my wife before the Christmas chaos starts.

So, AITA?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 2h ago

AITA for telling my adoptive father he failed

16 Upvotes

My sister passed away a year ago. During the time when she passed, they excluded me and my brother from the funeral arrangements. They didn't allow me or my brother to be there for my sister's daughter when they told her that her mom had passed away.

Instead, they allowed the 10 year old granddaughter of a woman my adoptive father had been having an affair with to console my niece. This 10 year old girl had lost her own mother years ago, and her grandmother takes care of her. My adoptive father also takes care of her and considers her his daughter. When my niece was told that her mother had passed away, this little girl started crying and screaming, which only made things worse for my niece.

Fast forward to today. They cleaned out my sister's room even though I specifically told them not to touch anything because I wanted to go through it with my cousin. I wanted to keep certain things in remembrance of my sister, and my cousin wanted to do the same. We also wanted to keep things for her daughter to have as memories of her mother.

They threw everything away and said they were going to redo her room. My niece started crying and was really upset about it.

I confronted them, and their excuse was that I was busy with school and work and that my cousin was busy too. When I told them they could have communicated with me and called me so I could come down and help clean out her room, they had nothing to say. Instead, they took it upon themselves to do whatever they wanted, completely disregarding what I had specifically asked them not to do.

I am heartbroken. My niece is heartbroken, and so is my cousin. They don't seem to care about anyone else's feelings, emotions, or input. They just do whatever they want regardless of how it affects everyone else.

My adoptive father got defensive and angry when I confronted him about it. I am now not speaking to either of them, but I plan on confronting them once we drop my niece off back at her father's house.

I am seriously considering cutting them out of my life as well, which is something I have wanted to do for years. I was already on the verge of doing so before my sister passed away, but after she died, I continued keeping contact with them for my niece because she loves me, and I love her. I promised her when her mother passed away that I would always be there for her.

However, I am scared to cut them off because both my adoptive father and his fiancée are narcissists, and I feel like they will use my niece to gain some sort of control over me by keeping her away from me.

My niece's father only contacts my adoptive father and only wants him to have his number and be in contact with him. I'm not sure what I should do. We have not seen her in two months and my adoptive father does not communicate at all. He has his fiance text me last minute when my niece comes over. I feel like they deliberately keep us out of the loop and then use my niece's father as an excuse.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 46m ago

AITA for not hanging out with my grandfather because he acts weirdly

11 Upvotes

I am 15(m) my grandfather 89(m) he has always loved me but recently I’ve been trying to not stay near him because of the way he has been acting. Now I know he was born in different times but according to my mother he has tried to get a co workers number who was 22-23 at the time while he was mid 70s and tried to date her and whenever he comes to “hang out with me” he will always no matter what try to hold my hand and kiss it thst or pat my head like a dog and whenever I try to pull my hand away or tell him to stop he acts like hes the victim and will tell me I don’t love him at all. Along with those he is very religious and will always bring up god in a conversation and is the main reason i have stop going to church. and now I’ve been pulling away from him more often because I don’t feel comfortable around him anymore so please tell me if I’m being mean here or if it’s ok to not be near my grandfather


r/AmItheAsshole • • 2h ago

AITA for not wanting my bf to live with me in his time of need?

13 Upvotes

im a masters student (23f) in italy and my family doesn’t support me financially. i have a scholarship which is roughly €8000 per year and it’s only enough to get me through the year.

my bf (28m) is also a masters student in the same uni. he lost his scholarship (he was going through a rough patch after he broke up with his ex after 7 years of relationship so he couldn’t study) and he cut ties with his family. he couldn’t find a job because he doesn’t know italian and now he has no money to pay rent.

so he asked me to let him stay in my room only at nights (i only have one room for myself so i have other flatmates) so he wouldn’t end up in the streets.

i accepted because i would guilty if i didn’t but im scared that if my flatmates find out, i would get in trouble with my landlord. i also don’t want to live with him after only 7 months of having a relationship.

im also paying for his daily meals and other emergency expenses and to be honest it’s putting me in a lot of financial distress. it’s hard for me to work while studying because i should maintain good grades and an engineering tournament i participated in so i have no other sources of income. he keeps saying he will pay me back everything asap but im not so sure if he could.

i keep feeling guilty for not wanting to help him financially in his time of need so i keep doing it… but it’s getting too much for me now.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 5h ago

AITA for blowing up at my family and telling them I’m done playing the "mom" role and listening to everyone's problems?

22 Upvotes

I (21F) live in a guest space on my mom’s property, and I’ve basically become the default stand-in parent, driver, and emotional dumping ground for my whole family.
My mom barely looks out for my younger sisters, so I’ve been helping care for them since they were newborns. Meanwhile, I was there for my older sister (25F) during her postpartum period, help with her babies, and am the one she calls about her marriage or in-laws—yet she rarely checks in on our younger sisters since getting married, and nobody listens when I need support. Even my grandma and aunt talk behind my back, yet still call me when they’re lonely or need rides and help.
Yesterday, I offered to take my younger sisters for matcha and to church. Nobody was ready on time, they lost their money, and then someone didn't have her bag, so I called it off. My mom immediately called to yell at me for having a "bad attitude."
Today, I reluctantly agreed to drive them somewhere else, only to find out one of my sisters had secretly texted our mom to pick them up—and admitted she’d lied yesterday that I was going to yell at her in the car.
I snapped, cussed them out in the car, and told them I’m done giving rides or favors to people who throw me under the bus—and that goes for the whole family. Later, my oldest sister texted lecturing me for cussing at my sisters as she was informed I did , and calling her toddler "menso" (dumb in Spanish as a joke as he was about to spill a drink when I was at her house previously ), and saying my younger sisters look to me because our mom doesn't step up. I told her I’m not their mom, I’m emotionally exhausted from carrying everyone’s problems,and I’m done.
I put my phone on Do Not Disturb and finally feel a weight off my chest, even though I’m second-guessing myself. AITA?
Like I’m just 21 a woman I want to feel free and have peace I’m currently already battling depression and being a constant dumping ground and being told i ruin everything have been burrying me deeper and deeper into the dark mental space.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 20h ago

AITA for asking my friend to replace. the necklace she lost after borrowing it?

314 Upvotes

Im 21F and my grandmother gave me a necklace for my 18th birthday. It wasn't expensive but it was the last gift she gave me before she passed away, so I wear it on special occasions.

A friend of mine asked if she could borrow it for a graduation dinner because she really liked it. I said yes and told her just to be careful with it. She returned home that night without it. Apparently she took it off in the bathroom because the clasp was bothering her and forgot it there.

When she went back to look for it, it was gone.
I was obviously upset, but she kept apologising and said she had already asked the restaurant if anyone had found it.I told her I understood it was an accident and wasn't angry at her for losing it, but I was really sad because it meant a lot to me.

A few days later I asked if she could at least help me look for a replacement that was similar. I found one from the same jeweller, but it was quite expensive.
She told me she couldnt afford to buy me another necklace and that I shouldn't expect her to replace something just because she lost it accidentally.
I said I wasn't asking her to buy it immediately and we could figure something out, but she got upset and said I was making her feel guilty over an honest mistake.

I havent brought it up again, but I keep thinking about my grandmas necklace and how I probably won't ever get it back. My friend says she feels terrible already and that asking her to replace it is making things worse. I genuinely don't know what else I'm supposed to do here.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 9h ago

WIBTA For Skipping Thanksgivings?

39 Upvotes

Hello! First time posting.

My parents divorced 18 years ago, and my dad received full custody of my sister. About 14 years ago, he met Sue. We've always been civil, although she's generally negative and enjoys complaining.

Over the years, I've noticed a difference in how Dad spends time with our family versus hers. Sue's daughter has three boys, while my brother has one son. Dad visits Sue's family twice a month but has visited my nephew only 11 times in 11 years.

Recently, Dad suggested monthly dinners with my siblings and me. My brother requested these be just us and Dad, without Sue. Somehow, Sue turned this into us hating her.

My younger sister recently moved to Texas with her wife. Around that time, Sue deleted my siblings and their partners from Facebook, then accused them of not making time for her because they hate her.

On Monday, Sue started a group chat with Dad and all of us, saying we needed to act like adults, discuss the issues, and stop hurting Dad.

I've always been the peacekeeper, but I finally spoke honestly. I explained that we don't hate her; we just want time with our father. We're tired of feeling like an afterthought, being talked about behind our backs, and having every interaction feel like we're navigating her first. We're not asking Dad to leave her. We just miss spending time with him. An important quote is "Holidays shouldn't be about Hallmark Quality food and images." [My text was 5 paragraphs long and ran past 3k characters alone]

My dad responded:

"Hallmark House? I never thought of it as that. I guess that's as good as name as any. And now I understand better what's bothering you guys.

We have a nice house. It is not a McMansion, not even close. I can show you McMansions.

We like to take care of our house. It's no different than when we went to Grandma's. They asked that we take care of their homes. Keep your shoes off the furniture. Don't place a cup on the table; use a coaster. That sort of thing. For whatever reason you all forget. That's how it is when you visit the grandparents' house. And we're the grandparents now.

I'm sorry that you all do not feel comfortable in our home. We want to change that. You guys are welcome to come over any time you want. Thank you."

That's the entire exchange.

I feel like Dad completely missed the point. This was never about his house or coasters. It's about wanting a relationship with our father without feeling like an inconvenience or an afterthought.

So, would I be the asshole if I skipped Thanksgiving this year? I'm tired of trying to explain how I feel and still not being heard.


r/AmItheAsshole • • 4h ago

AITA For tell my friend through text that I don't want her to move in with me?

15 Upvotes

I(32f) I'm currently helping out my friend(29f) who is going through a breakup and got "kicked out" of her apartment. She's currently staying with me at my parents house in a small shed in our backyard.

Because I'm limited to 3k characters I have to skip over some key points but basically my best friend Carmen(29f) and I have had a plan to move in together for about 2 years now.

Ever since my other friend has moved in she's constantly asked me about moving in with Carmen and I when we two plan to move out even tho I've told her multiple times that we don't want to live with a dog (she has a German shepherd) because we want our cats to live in a dog free environment. She seems to skim over this fact every time and tells me that rent will be cheaper if the three of us get a place together.

After having what may have been the 4th conversation with her about this I decided to text her and tell her that moving in with us isn't an option but I don't mind helping her look for a place for herself. Ever since I texted her she has been in a bad mood, smoked right outside my back door so no my room smells like cigarettes and isn't talking to me.

AITA for not telling her in person?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 3h ago

AITA? Starting to get sick of my depressed, lonely friend

13 Upvotes

Hey I'm 18F and my friend is 20M. I've known him for a good few years. I'll call him K for clarity because I have another friend named Z who's also a guy (19M).

K's an extremely pessimistic person and his attitude tends to bring himself down, but lately he's been using it to drag other people down with him. Z's more active in K's life than I am, because I got sick of it after a while.

I want to make it clear that I didn't mind that K vented about his problems all the time. I knew he was going through a hard time due to feeling isolated. I had a problem with how he was doing it.

He'd constantly complain about how lonely he was, but would refuse to use any methods I suggested to help himself. When I said something that even barely challenged his mindset, he'd go off on me and be passive aggressive. We had our conversations on Instagram, so he'd put something like "..." or "M" or "Shut the fuck up", on his notes.

Sometimes, when I needed some time away for myself, he'd also put "How do I feel being isolated and alone? Great.", in his notes. Then when I asked him about it and apologized, he'd continue being passive aggressive and likes to say that I never do anything for him. Since then I've been slowly backing out of his life.

Z listens to him vent all the time. He gives both advice and a listening ear for when K doesn't want anything to be said. He checks in on him, he tells him that he's proud of K for doing his best everyday and for being so strong for making it through everything he's been through. He makes so much time for K and he's way too nice. And yet K is always shit talking Z behind his back.

Z's a very busy person, so K will take jabs at it and act like Z doesnt try or gives a shit. He's said that Z's efforts aren't enough, aren't cutting his "needs", and that Z is at least "something" over nothing. He says this to other people behind Z's back, but he'll also say it directly to Z's face and act surprised when Z doesn't feel like talking to him because it feels like nothing he does for K matters.

Recently it was K's bday. Z sent K a happy birthday message with a hand drawn gift. I didnt send any hbd things because I was geninuely over it. Z sent a message about how he knew the year had been hard on K, and he was so proud of him for everything he accomplished. He ended it off with hope that it would get better and said that K deserved happiness and fun.

Now I know maybe it's wasnt the right thing to say to a person that's suffering from depression, but the way K reacted to it made me reach my breaking point. He pulled his usual passive aggressive behavior and then instead of talking to Z about it, decided to screenshot it and make fun of him to everyone else. His usual shit talking method but worse.

I'm genuinely so sick of it, even though I know he's struggling from his isolation and depression. I'm in no means trying to say that depression doesn't get ugly or that I want K to have perfect reactions.

Am I or Z the ass?


r/AmItheAsshole • • 4h ago

AITA for sending a friend of mine to jail?

14 Upvotes

For context, this event happened four years ago, but I was feeling a bit introspective yesterday and I might as well ask if I really was the asshole in that whole ordeal.

I, 18 (M) at the time, discovered in an instagram story that a friend of mine and someone I didn’t know were swimming in the pool of my gated community. Intrigued, I called my friend as to how he gained access to come in the first place, of which he says, “Oh, I told them I was you.”

(Extra Context: I’m not an American and I still lived with my parents. I was abroad with my parents at the time, our timezones had a 12-hour difference; midnight for me, and midday for him.)

It would’ve been fine if it was only him, since I didn’t really care if he decided to crash at my place at any point in time (I gave him the password to our gate and front door in the past and we haven’t changed it since), but he was with a stranger, a person I haven’t seen on campus or anywhere else really.

I didn’t exactly shrug it off and pretty much ended our call without further explanation to tell him that I don’t really like what he’s doing.

So, out of concern of my parents’ place, annoyance from his act, and sheer tiredness due to travelling, I used my father’s phone to message the security office to send someone to check our place without much explanation and I went to bed right after. Unbeknownst to myself, I might as well have given the order to arrest my friend for trespassing since I didn’t express further why I told the office to check out the house.

It wasn’t an isolated incident on the account of my friend using my identity. According to the police investigation, my name and my parents’ place were basically used as his persona in the Tinder account he made, of which I wasn’t made aware of until I went home.

So, AITA, besides the fact that he used my identity to trick a lot of girls and guys, for calling security on him as an alleged trespasser?