Hello! First time posting.
My parents divorced 18 years ago, and my dad received full custody of my sister. About 14 years ago, he met Sue. We've always been civil, although she's generally negative and enjoys complaining.
Over the years, I've noticed a difference in how Dad spends time with our family versus hers. Sue's daughter has three boys, while my brother has one son. Dad visits Sue's family twice a month but has visited my nephew only 11 times in 11 years.
Recently, Dad suggested monthly dinners with my siblings and me. My brother requested these be just us and Dad, without Sue. Somehow, Sue turned this into us hating her.
My younger sister recently moved to Texas with her wife. Around that time, Sue deleted my siblings and their partners from Facebook, then accused them of not making time for her because they hate her.
On Monday, Sue started a group chat with Dad and all of us, saying we needed to act like adults, discuss the issues, and stop hurting Dad.
I've always been the peacekeeper, but I finally spoke honestly. I explained that we don't hate her; we just want time with our father. We're tired of feeling like an afterthought, being talked about behind our backs, and having every interaction feel like we're navigating her first. We're not asking Dad to leave her. We just miss spending time with him. An important quote is "Holidays shouldn't be about Hallmark Quality food and images." [My text was 5 paragraphs long and ran past 3k characters alone]
My dad responded:
"Hallmark House? I never thought of it as that. I guess that's as good as name as any. And now I understand better what's bothering you guys.
We have a nice house. It is not a McMansion, not even close. I can show you McMansions.
We like to take care of our house. It's no different than when we went to Grandma's. They asked that we take care of their homes. Keep your shoes off the furniture. Don't place a cup on the table; use a coaster. That sort of thing. For whatever reason you all forget. That's how it is when you visit the grandparents' house. And we're the grandparents now.
I'm sorry that you all do not feel comfortable in our home. We want to change that. You guys are welcome to come over any time you want. Thank you."
That's the entire exchange.
I feel like Dad completely missed the point. This was never about his house or coasters. It's about wanting a relationship with our father without feeling like an inconvenience or an afterthought.
So, would I be the asshole if I skipped Thanksgiving this year? I'm tired of trying to explain how I feel and still not being heard.