r/anime • u/OverlordPoodle • Jun 27 '22
Discussion What do newer anime fans say that hurts as an older long-time anime fan?
I'll start:
"I can't watch watch anything pre 2010, it looks too old and outdated"
Edit: Damn! Thanks for the silver!
Edit 2nd: Went to bed, woke up, holy shit! This thing went nuts...all for a post I busted out in 20 seconds lol!
2.6k
Upvotes
60
u/seesh_88 Jun 28 '22
“Y’all watched anime back then?”
119
u/Nick_BOI Jun 28 '22
When I was younger, manga readers (or just source readers in general) were the next level fans, the dedicated ones who rarely people would argue with them they critisised the anime adaptation based on the source material.
The phrase "the manga is better" had a lot of meaning, and got people interested.
Now if a source reader is the same way, people often don't care. Either it doesn't matter how good the original is if the anime they are watching is not, or to stop talking and let the people who don't know enjoy it if they do.
I like reading manga, light novels, visual novels-I like reading. In the past when discussing adaptations, people were interested in what I had to say. Now it's like treading a thin line to not piss anyone off or trying not to sound entitiled.
1.3k
u/kaidynamite :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kaidynamite Jun 28 '22
When they mistake resolution for animation.
2.0k
u/irisverse myanimelist.net/profile/usernamesarehard Jun 28 '22
"Can anyone recommend me an anime? I think I've seen all the good ones already. But no slice of life, no mecha, and nothing that's more than ten years old."
1.9k
u/octopathfinder myanimelist.net/profile/octopathfinder Jun 27 '22
"Best new gen"
"New big 3"
"Ufotable should remake this"
787
u/Ryan-Only Jun 28 '22
When watching an old anime and saying "ah, this is soo cliché. Every anime in this genre does the same".
Nah fam, this anime is the reason why every other anime in this genre is doing the same
514
u/ej_stephens Jun 28 '22
"Hot take" or "Is it just me" before saying something I've heard many times before and isn't even unique or controversial.
737
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jun 27 '22
"New gen" and "graphics" are two terms that make me cringe when reading them.
594
u/Warmsly Jun 28 '22
I died a little bit inside when someone said demon slayer is the pinnacle of anime "graphics"
454
u/Oppaipaisen Jun 28 '22
Said anime being in the Top 100 MAL ranking.
Boku no Pico.
877
u/banditta82 https://anidb.net/user/222784 Jun 28 '22
"Greatest of all time" lists that only go back 5 years.
515
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jun 27 '22
Whenever they say ask for recommendation and only say "I've seen all the good ones so don't recommend those" without listing any shows...
892
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '22
"According to MAL, X anime is better than Y anime because it has higher ratings."
691
u/ooReiko :Ey::Ez::E1::E2:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ooReiko Jun 27 '22
4k 60fps
337
u/Karma110 Jun 28 '22
“MAPPA should animate this” “Ufotable should animate this” And see that on repeat for every single manga in existence.
384
u/piruuu https://anilist.co/user/dvj Jun 28 '22
"I watch anime in 2x speed to save time"
71
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '22
245
u/BlandRestoration Jun 28 '22
"Midruto"
"Peak Clover"
"Mid Piece"
"Attack on Peak"
Like bro, they found out peak and mid were a thing and now instead of being like "This anime was decent, but had some bad pacing, 7/10" they add "mid" or "peak" to the name.
Also when they find out somebody doesn't like their favorite anime they just go "X negs ur fav verse" (looking at u OPM and DBZ fans)
514
u/Nielloscape Jun 28 '22
"The animation is bad" - translation: they don't like the art style/the art style looks old/they saw a poor and compressed clip of the show.
278
u/polaristar Jun 28 '22
"Is x a rip-off of y?"
No its not. Lots of series have tropes that can be traced back to various inspirations, all media can be traced back to things from the dawn of human story telling, nothing is as unique as you think, and when you finally realize it for the first time, its not a sign that things were "ripped off."
402
u/This_one_taken_yet_ Jun 28 '22
Usually far too recent anime named as "the first isekai".
The concept of going to another world is a really old one. Like it we consider bodily transported to another world to be isekai, Dante's Inferno is an isekai.
421
u/Apprehensive_Foot139 Jun 28 '22
Calling any anime from a genre other than shonen "overrated".
232
u/babydave371 :Ej:myanimelist.net/profile/babydave371 Jun 28 '22
The three would be:
This conveniently forgets that art direction and shot direction are a thing, as there is an implicite focus on animation...which forgets the insane animation in some of those 80s and 90s OAVs.
99.9999% of the time it hasn't and there has been a long history leading up to this point or they have been doing it since the 70s.
222
u/BluePhantomHere Jun 28 '22
"Older artstyle/character design suck"
42
u/OM3GAGRIZZLY Jun 28 '22
"I've actually always watched anime".
42
u/superhakerman Jun 28 '22
"If you haven't watched Naruto/demon slayer/one piece, you haven't watching anything good"
DUDE FUCK OFF, I WATCH WHATEVER THE FUCK I FEEL LIKE.
185
u/SpoonsAreFriends Jun 28 '22
"I don't watch old shows, only seasonal"
181
u/Ragnaroark_56 Jun 28 '22
Calling some anime “Peak Fiction” makes me want to die inside
112
u/toehoefrogpin Jun 28 '22
Probably the general impatience or sense of entitlement. Obviously not everyone is this way and I think it stems from a combination of factors. General influx of fans because it's now more socially acceptable to like anime and people, especially younger fans, being used to all digital content just being at their finger tips. But when something gets delayed or theres a hiccup or mistakes in subs, or theres an unexpected recap episodes, etc... theres fans (hopefully a minority) that go absolutely ballistic spewing so much vitriol and anger.
As someone who grew up only being able to watch what was (rarely) picked up for broadcasting (Pokemon/DBZ) or hunting down the occasional VHS and eventually moving over into downloading partial or incomplete fansubs over the span of weeks or months using download managers... it's honestly amazing how quickly and efficiently everything is done now. Not only do we basically get same day Sub releases for just about every seasonal show but within a week or two Dubs as well. It's mind boggling considering barely over 10 years ago there really weren't many ways to legally stream anything. Crunchyroll was still very much an unlicensed streaming site, and relying on fansubbers was absolutely required for most things.
As a bonus point, I'm envious of younger fans in that I was definitely made fun of for liking anime in school and didn't have anyone to even talk about anime with. It was a lonely hobby and interest that really has only significantly changed for me in the last 7ish years. But I'm happy younger fans can openly enjoy and engage with anime now.
288
u/susgnome https://anime-planet.com/users/RoyalRampage Jun 28 '22
"Animes"
The plural for "Anime" is "Anime".
197
u/daxuded Jun 28 '22
When they act like this is the first time they see fanservice in ECCHI anime, and they are shocked and saying how problematic this is.... Cough... Dress up.. Darling... That show really show which one is new tourist and long time anime fan.
Or when they say " older anime doesnt have fanservice like now" Lmao ROFl even
100
u/redhillducks Jun 28 '22
I've had friends not want to try new anime unless it's Studio Ghibli. They feel that Studio Ghibli is the pinnacle of anime. Of course, everyone's entitled their own taste. But I feel like they're missing out a whole world of great stuff that they'd really enjoy.
Edit: Don't get me wrong, I'm definitely a Studio Ghibli fan too.
24
u/ElmekiaLance Jun 28 '22
It's annoying when newbies get preoccupied with demographic labels and treat them as if they're all deep and meaningful. Some fans can't even seem to talk about anime-original series without first mentally labelling them as shounen, seinen, etc.
142
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '22
I would say much more than any specific opinion, what really gets under my skin is the lack of desire to engage with anyone else's viewpoint on the medium. Admittedly, this is a sub-set of a larger problem that's been made worse by social media, but over the past decade or so, I feel like every anime board has turned into /a/ where you're just expected to have a set of stock opinions and anything outside of those gets you ridiculed.
Just as an example: If someone legitimately thinks Demon Slayer is the best anime ever made, more power to them, but I would really love an explanation of why they think that, and for that explanation to not just be a bunch of canned phrases they picked up either from "Anitubers" or here on reddit. The same goes for literally any opinion. I have had interesting conversations with people I've totally disagreed with on basically everything anime-related, but because we're willing to explain ourselves to each other it doesn't feel like I'm talking to a brick wall. (The one I always get grilled hardest for is not liking Cowboy Bebop very much, but that's another conversation.)
And I'm aware that just by being on reddit I'm contributing to the problem, but almost every linear forum about anime is totally dead and has been for years, so there aren't many other places to talk about this stuff.
If you want another specific example; a week or so ago I talked to someone about Haruhi Suzumiya and they refused to give it a try because "[they] heard it's cringe." They would not elaborate on what they meant.
44
u/KarakorumIronbark Jun 28 '22
Hard to remember something and not make it sound like a strawman but
"I wanna watch Gintama but skip the comedy filler"
My last 3.41 braincells die a little when i see someone say that.
145
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '22
I find that a lot of newer anime fans think that older adult oriented shows are pretentious. LOTGH, Eva, GiTS: SAC, etc...
Also probably a really common answer but not wanting to watch past decades classics because of early digipaint or the color limitations of cel animation. I don't think they're necessarily aware of those aspects but they just know they don't like the look. Completely disregarding the quality of the story and/or characters.
127
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '22
Only shounen or fighting type anime are good or the anime and manga debate and even sub vs dub debate
18
u/DarthVantos :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DarthVantos Jun 28 '22 edited Jun 28 '22
It's so weird when I found our next generation of anime watchers don't dig the Old Gem anime and have a "no longer than 10 years ago" thing. Imagine hearing someone say they won't watch berserk or cowboy bebop because they are OLD. But i don't think they are as numerous as people in the comments make it out to be.
Since plenty of Gen Z are into one piece. And you gotta start from 1998 animation to get started.
30
u/mortemdeus Jun 28 '22
This is probably just because I am way too old now...but "there is nothing to watch." There is more Anime in a single season today then there was in the average decade when I started watching.
85
u/edgefigaro Jun 28 '22
Any sentence containing both the words "subjective" and "objective" piss me right the fuck off.
Edit: I just read this comment and I'm already angry.
91
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '22
When they only want to watch one piece from the wano arc and refuse to watch from episode 1
37
u/chrikris91 https://myanimelist.net/profile/chriskris91 Jun 28 '22 edited Jun 28 '22
When they say "it's too old, so I'm not gonna watch it." And people who watch it on XX speed...
64
u/nates514 Jun 28 '22
Ehem......"wth is gurenn lagann?"
62
u/animepig https://myanimelist.net/profile/ChickenDan Jun 28 '22
Asking for recommendations here when r/animesuggest exists
12
u/Merkyorz Jun 28 '22
Referring to absolutely anything that contains scenes that are not explicitly action or drama as "slice of life."
Its original meaning notwithstanding, it used to simply be a useful descriptor for certain iyashi-kei series. Nowadays, every sitcom, romcom/romance, coming of age drama, etc, is a "slice of life." And often many series that have no business being anywhere near that label, like adventure/hero's journey and sports series.
One of my favorite semi-recent examples is YoriMoi, which is constantly referred to and recommended as a slice of life. In what universe is an expedition to Antarctica to search for someone's dead mother a "slice of life?" Whose life could that possibly be a "slice" of?
21
u/vantheman9 Jun 28 '22
labeling anything fantasy as isekai
It's a pretty worthless hill to die on, but I still get annoyed every time.
on the subject of isekai, I've got another
"I don't like isekai because I miss traditional fantasy"
bruh traditional fantasy is getting made and nobody watches it. Magatsu Wahrheit was great where were you. Grimoire of Zero with zero viewers! Remember Pirate Princess Fena and how it didn't even make the karma top 15 in a dry-as-desert season?
I'm convinced the people who say they miss traditional fantasy are actually saying that they don't like light novel writing. Nobody saying that line is stoked about Dungeon Only I Can Enter or Last Dungeon Boonies (both NOT isekai, but definitely LN garbage) - they want more Made in Abyss and Magus Bride. Which, okay fine, but LN garbage isn't replacing that kind of thing by any means because they're adapted on an entirely different business schedule.
46
u/GachiplsThanos Jun 28 '22
Mfs that like only the most popular anime and the rest is trash (looking at you, AoT, DS, JJK and MHA fandoms)
65
u/ErfanTheRed Jun 28 '22 edited Jun 28 '22
People who refuse to watch anything older that 2010 or not a shonen.
Also seinen anime constantly get slandered on twitter for showing mature themes and adult scenes. That's the whole point of seinen.
The whole "next gen" "new big 3" and other titles. No, these can't be the "new big 3" because nobody can ever agree on which ones should be on the big 3. The reason the original big 3 exists is because back then everyone, and I mean EVERYONE. Accepted that bleach, naruto and one piece were the best shonen anime. Nowadays everytime a new shonen comes out everyone starts saying its gonna be the new big 3 only for it to either get cancelled or vanish from mainstream eyes(black clover to an extent) or drop in quality(mha)
Constantly slandering any and every SoL or Romance anime that gets released
Constantly complaining about the animation and ignoring the story altogether.
Spending hours trying to defend characters who are clearly a bad guy(ex: eren). While it's not new to the anime community it has gotten far worse in the current decade. You can like villainous characters without trying to justify their obviously horrible actions.
41
u/LostMyInhibiterChip Jun 28 '22
Honestly a lot of the stupid shit said by newcomers also comes from older fans. I know a guy who is a big longtime anime fan and genuinely thought that Avatar The Last Airbender was an anime. He also refuses to watch dub unless it’s ghost stories.
29
u/carenard Jun 28 '22
insert decent battle shounen is peak anime comment(looking at you... black clover, naruto, one piece, etc...).
62
u/Rarietty https://myanimelist.net/profile/Rarietty Jun 28 '22 edited Jun 28 '22
Basically anything about Japanese-to-English translation from a new anime fan who clearly doesn't speak Japanese
A lot of translation discourse seems rooted in the idea that accurate English subs for most seasonal shows always existed immediately after they aired in Japan, but that's a really new phenomenon. Anime was a lot more likely to be edited down for Western markets in the past before simulcasts became a thing. If anything, censorship is less common in translated Japanese media than ever, and we're in a better time than ever to be a fan of Japanese content as we are more likely to receive accurate, prompt translations than ever, yet it seems common for newer fans to think that it has become more common over time for Western ideas (like English slang or pesky ~politics~) to impact translations (clearly never living through the 4Kids era). It's also a huge pet peeve of mine whenever anyone acts like translation is an objective science that always has one correct answer. At least some creative writing is necessary to convert Japanese to English, as there are rarely 1-to-1 translations for anything.
7
u/goukaryuu https://myanimelist.net/profile/GoukaRyuu Jun 28 '22
This may be anyone saying it, but calling anime itself a genre. It isn't anime is a medium with many genres in it.
29
u/AssaultRider555 Jun 28 '22
"Can someone recommend me a good anime but no Mecha"
This is why Gundam as a fandom cannot expand wider at a faster rate nowadays.
13
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '22
How old are you?
26
u/Sivitiri Jun 28 '22
Its more than 100 episodes? How do you have the patience?
6
u/HokageDateByo Jun 28 '22
Call me stupid I've never seen any of this "new gen" or "graphics" shit lol maybe don't associate with little kids?
6
u/Chadjirou Jun 28 '22
"Carried by animation"
"Mid"
"X is better than y"
"Greatest new gen of all time"
6
u/M_Drekinn Jun 28 '22
Indirect variations of "I don't like that anime and in conclusion nobody is allowed to like it because it hurts my self-esteem when other like it."
24
u/Shinji-Chair https://myanimelist.net/profile/Shinji-Chair Jun 28 '22
The phrase Animes and Mangas. The plural for anime and manga is anime and manga. And people who hate on Mecha and Idol anime without watching them saying things like “they’re generic” or “It’s all the same.”
27
u/Elitealice https://myanimelist.net/profile/Marinate1016 Jun 28 '22
Mfs who worship meathead studios like mappa and think ufo is the best studio ever
And powerscaling and mosaic mfs on Anitwt. “Who the best new gen mc”
5
u/ZapsZzz https://anilist.co/user/Zapszzz Jun 28 '22
"Will mecha matter anymore?"
"What's this show about - "Haruhi"?"
5
u/TheDraugr https://anilist.co/user/Luvpon Jun 28 '22
That old cel-animated series have ugly "graphics".
5
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '22
The hyperfocus on action stuff, with a determination never to try SoL and romance. I get it, I've been there myself over a decade ago; but that's why I know what they're missing out on, and how at least how at least some of them would be really into some SoL anime if they only gave it a chance.
5
u/trashdilan Jun 28 '22
"animation should be 60 fps and 4k, here's a youtube video example"
5
u/Skirroz_vG Jun 28 '22
“All anime are trash if the rating on MAL is below an 8.00! 🥺’
5
u/k4r6000 Jun 28 '22
"I watched Anime X at 4x speed so it would be over in 6 minutes and am now fully qualified to comment about everything about it."
5
u/Shionkenobi Jun 29 '22
Admiting to watch something at 1.5X speed (or more), while mostly playing with smartphone, and yet then b*tch about "but I dont get the plot, what is this!" (no shit, kiddo, at least if it's a plotless episodic comedy is doable, not ideal, but passable, if is plot driven, full of dialogues and lore dumps, you literally DID NOT WATCHED THE EPISODE). Has seen this with lot's of Re:Zero newbies around, back in season 2 early.
Blind watching episode 1 of everyhing seasonal, and then compalining the genre is something they hate, like the yuri of Executioner Isekai, as the most recent example. Buddy, at least read the tags and read the synopsis, even if you dont wanna spoilers, that does the trick 99% of times.
Not want to be watching anything from 10+ years bacause is "ugly" and "dated". Kara no Kyoukai and Ghibli movies laugh at a far distance. Also, lower framerate of VHS era DOES NOT qual bad animation, okay?
Overhyping seasonal isekai harems with OP pseudo-"underdog" MC (look, I DO watch-more like read- some of them, but they are mostly guilty pleasure at the very BEST, not worth of hype, Grimgar, Log Horizon, Konosuba and Slime being the 2010's exceptions).
"New big 3", usually dumb yt videos. Look, Naruto and Bleach were NEVER even close to OP level, that's a artificial construction the western fandom did. Japan NEVER equalized those works. HxH, jiatus aside, was usually best selling than Bleach most of time.
"10/10 Masterpice to be remembered as a cult classic and redefined animu" -5 months later, almost everyone, including all those who posted stuff like that forgot about the show entirely, as the seasonal substitute does the same things, perhaps with better budget.
Prep your *sses for Chainsaw Simps, the manga is indeed very good and worhty it's dark shounen reputation, (some) fans are...a issue. 2 many degenerate awwoooo memes, 2 much cringe waifu wars, 2 much overhyping and overthinking about le symbolism for basic scenes. Also, Fire Punch was a bit better sorry.
9
u/MrPringles23 Jun 28 '22
All the people who shit on DBZ without understanding how big it was in the west and how much it paved the way for all the shows they love now (MHA, Demon Slayer etc).
(Also all the people who were totally into it when it was airing, but shit on it because its cool to shit on it).
8
u/CuriousTsukihime Jun 28 '22
Someone posted on this sub a while ago asking for a serious discussion on who could beat Goku. My dumb ass thought it might be an actual conversation and suggested at least 2 magical girls, Lain, Saitama… poster said he hadn’t seen most of what I suggested. If you’re not gonna watch anime and just wanna ride Goku’s dick, say that.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '22
Tf is new gen
4
u/Mystic8ball Jun 28 '22 edited Jun 28 '22
Something that gets me is the sheer amount of unfounded rumors that a lot of younger anime fans just pick up and spread around just because a popular Tiktok said it. My younger brother actually tried telling me that Berserk would continued by Hajime Isayama since a viral Tiktok said it.
Of course older anime communities fell for false rumors too. But it feels like every day someone on Tiktok makes something up just for views.
Another thing that gets me are people saying that older anime are just inherently inferior than newer titles. It can be animation or even 'we've gotten better at storytelling since then' but regardless it stings to see someone dismiss a critically acclaimed classic from the 90s just because it's animated on cells.
10
u/htisme91 Jun 28 '22 edited Jun 28 '22
"I can't watch anything pre-2000, it looks too old and outdated."
"Computer animation is better than hand-drawn cels."
"Dragon Ball looked like it'd be boring so I started with DBZ" because god knows how many people skipped the best part of the franchise because they judged a book by its cover.
10
u/NOTKingInTheNorth Jun 28 '22
Those girl hairs from 2007-2010 look like ant antennas
13
u/posidon99999 Jun 28 '22
Try 177013
They don't even know some of the far more cursed shit like 200948, 215600, and 228922
64
u/Mahou_Shoujo_Ramune Jun 28 '22 edited Jun 28 '22
"I hate how 'problematic' anime is. It should change to meet modern standards"
Or
"How dare you enjoy x anime content!? That is unacceptable and makes you a [derogatory term] anyone who enjoys or defends this show is one too!"
I miss the days when anime fans loved anime and treated others with respect. Now I can't be myself without a slurry of personal attacks.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '22
Death Note is adult themed.
8
u/No_Effort1198 Jun 28 '22 edited Jun 28 '22
Before I say this, I'm below the age of consent in my country.
When people say "animes taking place in high schools and sexualizing teenagers is creepy" it mainly comes from Americans. tons of american TV shows and movies have tons of sexualization of teens and nobody even cares and those are with real people who are "supposed" to look like teens. Twilight, Harry Potter, Riverdale, tons of horror movies, stranger things, and yeh these are adult actors in most cases. But anime characters aren't even real to begin with, drawn by some old dude being paid not enough. No matter their age they all sort of look the same, there is never any distinction that would normally make you differentiate between an adult and teen since the artstyles anime use is normally pretty simple. sometimes when the character is old or they're trying to exaggerate time passage they give the character a wrinkle or two but really there is hardly ever any visual difference between adults and teens in anime, not to mention they are voiced by adults. Where I draw the line personally is when they sexualize a character who clearly resembles a child. Like Lolis that shit creeps me out.
I think the issue is blown out of proportion alot. I just like big tiddie anime chicks bro and I can associate and relate to people being in school so it's what I like
3
u/VespertineQueen Jun 28 '22
People that call themselves as “anime experts” but they won’t watch a serie because it’s not on Netflix.
3
u/Aki008035 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Raibyou Jun 28 '22
"Slice of life is boring"
3
u/InsaneInTheRAMdrain Jun 28 '22
Someone told me bleach is that old anime they didn’t watch because it ended before “their time”.
Same person said AoT was a basic bitch mainstream anime.
Both of which I watched episode by episode from pretty much the first ones :’(.
Sure they’re cleche now but they felt special at the time, just like my gray hair /cry
3
u/Psych0killer16 Jun 28 '22
Judging a show by only its first episode
"The quality sucks, unwatchable."
"Demon Slayer is the best anime of all time."
"Old anime are dying, new big 3."
"Slice of Life isn't good."
"It has low score so I won't watch."
"I will only watch if they have powers."
3
u/mr_quincy27 Jun 28 '22
"What's Bleach ?"
3
u/Jeffrey_DS Jun 28 '22
My friend asks for a good series that will have him hooked because of the story so I recommend some shows with those (steins gate, re:zero, psycho pass, Fullmetal alchemist brotherhood), the following week he proceeds to tell me how he's hooked on this isekai where the main character uses a smartphone to be over powered, 6 months later "Oh man I'm watching this show FMA brotherhood and I wish I watched it sooner", me:🤦♂️
3
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '22
“Code Geass and/or Gurren Lagann is the first mecha about the characters”
3
u/Metabohai Jun 28 '22
Bro upscaling everything to 4k and using interpolated pics for 60 fps.
3
u/Yarzu89 Jun 28 '22
Calling a show that feels like it just aired a few years go an "old classic"
But that goes for more than just anime