r/askmanagers • • Nov 15 '19

New Management, I mean, Moderation

63 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I'm christopherness, the new moderator of /r/askmanagers.

The previous moderator and creator of this sub has long since been inactive on reddit, so I made a request to take over and the reddit admins granted this request today, November 15, 2019.

In my observation -- for the most part -- this sub has moderated itself, and that's the way I propose we keep it.

Although we are steadily growing in subscribers, we're still a lean and agile group. For that reason, I don't foresee moderating taking up too much of my bandwidth. I promise to do what I can to keep spam and other types of nuisance in check. My only ask is that you all, the /r/askmanagers community, continue to ask questions, share ideas, provide guidance and continue to speak and act with integrity.

And because it needs to be said: bullying, doxxing and other forms of online harassment will result in an immediate ban from this community.

Last but not least, for those of you that are so inclined, I've added some flair that you can select for yourselves, which must be done on old.reddit. Available leadership positions are:

  • Team Leader
  • Supervisor
  • Manager
  • Director
  • VP
  • C-Suite (If you would like specific flair. Let me know, e.g. CEO, COO, CFO, etc.)

Please let me know if you think I've missed something. I'm always open to suggestions. Thanks so much for reading.


r/askmanagers • • 35m ago

Working on a School Assignment and need some managers to fill out a survey!

1 Upvotes

Hello, I am a college student currently in my junior year!

I was looking for about 2 managers to fill out a small survey for me which asks about the nature of your job and some functions in it. If you have the time to do so, please reach out to me in DMs or just reply under this post if you would be willing to help me!

Thank you so much for your time, I appreciate you all!


r/askmanagers • • 14h ago

“What expectation/preference do you have for your supervisor/senior manager”

5 Upvotes

Got asked this question in my interview, for managers here who have been interviewers, do you normally ask this question? What answers would you appreciate?

My answer was like “I would appreciate direct and clear instructions and feedbacks. Also, as a junior member of the team and new in my career, I would appreciate rooms for me to explore, grow and exercise my own judgment so I could eventually take on more responsibility and be more useful to the team”. (Not so articulate, but basically the idea…)


r/askmanagers • • 14h ago

How to ask for a pay rise

2 Upvotes

Hi Reddit,

I’ve recently been given a few extra responsibilities with my customer support role like managing social media DMs and am training for a finance and insurance rep role between my calls and emails which they’ve asked me and 2 other girls to do out of the team. Humbly, I am also one of our top performers and am one of the go-to for advice in the team.

I feel like my pay rate at the moment is something I should be grateful for already with this role ($29.8) but at the same time I feel like I do deserve a pay rise considering I perform better and have a few more tasks than my peers.

I’ve never really asked for a pay rise and would like some advice please? It’s just me so I don’t have anyone to talk to about these types of things…

Every year we have a chat around our new pay increase and this year was like 40c which I felt a little cut short on so if it happens again next year idk would be nice to get some perspectives and advice to prepare myself with haha.

Cheers!


r/askmanagers • • 1d ago

How to raise issues with an underperforming coworker? Do I at all?

7 Upvotes

Sorry in advance for being overly-vague, I get wary of discussing any specifics of my work.

I (24F) have been working in PM since graduating college. My manager has been happy with my work and I have taken on a lot more responsibility in the past year or so.

After about 1 year of working, my manager hired a new member to the team, let’s call him Joe (late 20s-early 30ish). My manager told me to divert smaller/more menial portions of my work to Joe, while I still oversee the bigger picture. I am NOT Joe’s direct manager, we share the same manager.

I like Joe a lot as a person. However, he consistently underperforms and, because I manage the “larger picture”, his shortcomings do not directly fall on me, but directly affect my work.

One recent issue I had was I had requested a report from him that we need prior to an important meeting with a vendor. Ideally this would come 2-3 days before the meeting, so there is time to review and prep for the meeting. I requested this to be done in ~1 week, 3 WEEKS AGO. This past week, it has gotten to the point that I message him every day that we need it done by the end of the day, and he replies with a “Yes!”. However, it has never been shared with me.

This is not the highest-stakes report ever, mainly for internal preparation requested by other managers. However this has been so frustrating and honestly a last straw on my part, and I really need some advice on how/if I should raise this issue with my manager.

Also, please tell me if there is something I can do differently to successfully lead people who do not directly work for me. I end up having to cover a lot of his work to ensure it gets done on time for successful projects (even with multiple reminders to him), when this happens I mention the work I did to my manager and he always mentions to me to “let Joe do as much as he can on his own”. Again, the work needs to be done because, although it would reflect on him, it trickles down to the portion of my job, then affecting my workload.

I understand my manager wants me to effectively lead Joe, and especially given this is the first person in my career I have ever “managed” (even though not officially), I feel like saying something to my manager will reflect poorly on myself and my leadership skills.

As managers, I would love some advice or insight. Thanks so much.


r/askmanagers • • 23h ago

What do I do?

1 Upvotes

For context, I had been working at the same company for 5 years before making a big career switch and joining a pre seed startup at a very high position and pay.
It has only been 3 months but because the company is still pre seed, my employer has withheld my salary since 2 months telling me to be a team player and think long term keeping the esops in mind. And he has promised to pay whatever is due once the company gets funded.
Thing is, I’m living alone, I need regular source of income. I have enough to survive but I am genuinely not able to sleep at night thinking about what happens when I run out of savings.
I thought about moonlighting, getting another job on the side or even switch fully. But everyone is asking me why I want to switch so quickly and no one is able to match my current package.
I am seriously stuck and I need to make the right decision. Any advice will be much appreciated.

- 27f, New Delhi


r/askmanagers • • 1d ago

Doing the same work as senior colleagues without the title or compensation. Is HR worth involving, or should I just leave?

3 Upvotes

I’m on a team of seven, and over the past five years I’ve taken on increasingly complex responsibilities. At this point, I independently own the work for an entire business unit and do essentially the same work as the senior level ICs on my team. We have the same responsibilities, decision making authority, and level of ownership.

For the past year, I’ve repeatedly brought up the lack of distinction between my role and the senior positions. The difference isn't just the title or salary, either. Senior employees receive annual bonuses that I'm not eligible for. I also feel like my current title is holding me back when applying externally because it doesn't reflect the level of work I'm actually doing.

What's especially frustrating is that two former managers independently recommended me for promotion. The first recommended me after a previous reorganization, before the current VP joined the company. She later left, and I inherited her responsibilities. Her replacement also recommended me during the most recent review cycle but was subsequently laid off.

Since then, the new department head has continued pushing the conversation to future review cycles. We had one in September, but nothing happened. Now he's saying he wants to wait until a replacement director is hired and potentially revisit things in another year.

I'm honestly at my breaking point. I enjoy the actual work, but I'm starting to feel taken advantage of. It's becoming difficult to stay motivated when I'm expected to perform at the same level as senior colleagues without the recognition or compensation.

I've started pulling back from going above and beyond because I don't see the point anymore. I don't want to damage my reputation, but I also don't want to keep taking on senior level responsibilities indefinitely with no clear path forward.

Has anyone dealt with something similar? Would involving HR actually accomplish anything, or would I just be putting a target on my back? At this point, am I better off focusing entirely on finding another job?


r/askmanagers • • 11h ago

How do I manage employees who think it’s a “holiday week”?

0 Upvotes

Yes, Thanksgiving is on Thursday but that doesn’t mean it’s a holiday “week”. You’re still working Monday through Wednesday. You better stay busy.

I even overheard an employee, known for slacking off, saying it’s going to be a “chillax“ week in the office. Should I make up additional projects for him to work on?


r/askmanagers • • 1d ago

Do you get time to step back or does firefighting take over?

2 Upvotes

I’m curious… I know a fair few managers who find their week swallowed by firefighting.

A few months back I started doing short weekly reviews on Fridays reviewing what happened, what patterns I’m noticing and one thing to change. It’s been quite useful.

I’d love to know whether other managers step back regularly, what works for you and what gets in the way, or does firefighting and being busy take over?


r/askmanagers • • 1d ago

Why do people laugh at me for using LinkedIn?

0 Upvotes

About 4 years working in corporate at different organizations in accounting and insurance. I didn’t start using is consistently until 2-3 years ago. My network was non existent but it slowly started growing.

I got put on a pip two jobs ago and this specific job was actually a toxic environment but I didn’t fully realize until once I left. My manager found it slightly funny I could tell (I’m not trashing the organization but my manager is questionable at times).

He consistently asked me to "open up" to the team and even wrote it in my mid year review saying everyone would love me if I was more open. When I tried being more open no one liked me and they used what I shared against me.

I later came to find out that this team had a private group chat where they just bully others in the company they don’t like (I happened to be one of them). I never did anything bad to them though, they just didn’t like me as an individual. I won’t disclose how I know this but let’s just say I had someone show me the group chat and my manager wasn’t really participating when I was getting bullied in the chat but he would react with laughing emojis.

This whole "my door is always open" or "I’m all ears" thing makes me think it was just a way for me to lower my walls so they could make fun of me for who I am. I was also the only black guy on the team. They’ve all known each other for years and go out together even outside of work.

When I quit during the pip my manager called me and started the call with a heavy depressed performative voice saying ´hey (my name)" and wanted me to go back home to think about it before quitting (he really just needed time to organize it with HR bc he gave me a pip without involving HR it was just sent via email from him saying he would go to HR if I didn’t complete his "PIP".

I don’t understand why they were laughing at me for being myself. Do other black people deal with this kind of stuff from white people


r/askmanagers • • 2d ago

Would you report to HR comments that made you uncomfortable when there’s a chance they’re innocent?

17 Upvotes

One of my direct reports is kind of ditzy to be blunt. We had a work trip this last week where several members of our organization stayed in a hotel. For context, we are similar ages, mid-30’s, and both married.

Shes always had a history of complimenting me, and being somewhat touchy. Nothing that strictly crosses the line, but will touch or rub my arm/back.

This last trip had a few instances where I was very uncomfortable. She twice had asked if she could come to my room or if I could go up to hers. The first time was that she had a work-related question I responded to and told her she didn’t need to come by.

The 2nd instance was at the end of the night where everyone had a few drinks and I was leaving to go to my room and sleep. She says she’s tired too and wants to head up to her room. I’m already on edge but still trying to be cordial so I mention something like “oh man I should’ve gotten some water before I headed up” and she says “I have extra bottles in my room. Do you wanna come by and grab one?” I immediately decline again and head to my room (which was luckily on another floor).

There are just other things like her using heart emojis when texting, and when I was running late for one meeting, she texted “you’re pretty enough lol, come on over and get breakfast. Everyone is here and breakfast is ready”

There’s a possibility this is all just her being ditzy and not reading the room, but I can’t imagine anyone in this day and age would think it’s okay to try and go to your MALE MANAGER’s room solo. I draw a very hard line on work being work, and not getting close with teammates. I like them and am cordial, but I have absolutely no interest in doing anything outside of work since I spend 40 hours a week.

I’m not sure if I’m overreacting, but I feel like I need to make some sort of report to HR in the event she ever tries anything. At this point I’m not comfortable ever being alone in any situation with her. I just wanted to get other’s opinions and see if I’m in the wrong here.


r/askmanagers • • 1d ago

How do I stop overthinking silence from a hands-off manager after coming from a workplace behavior PIP from my last job?

0 Upvotes

r/askmanagers • • 1d ago

Hiring managers: What could an inexperienced entry-level candidate demonstrate that would make you interview (and potentially hire) them?

0 Upvotes

I'm curious about something, particularly from people who are involved in hiring for entry-level positions.

Let's say you're hiring for an entry-level position that, according to the job description, requires 2 to 3 years of experience.

A candidate applies who has no relevant professional work experience. However, instead of simply submitting a resume and hoping you'll take a chance on them, they've independently completed specific tasks, projects, or exercises intended to demonstrate their ability to perform the actual work involved in the position.

What, specifically, could this candidate demonstrate or show you that would make you willing to interview them despite their lack of professional experience?

I'm interested in answers across all industries and fields, not just one particular type of job.

For example, what actual tasks, responsibilities, or skills would you want them to demonstrate? What would a convincing demonstration look like? What would they need to produce, complete, or show you to make you think, "This person doesn't have the experience we're asking for, but I'd like to talk to them"?

I'm not looking for general answers like "initiative," "a good attitude," or "willingness to learn." I'm interested in the specific, practical abilities you actually look for when hiring in your particular industry.

Ideally, imagine this candidate is trying to get your attention and earn an interview. What could they put in front of you that would make you reconsider passing over them simply because they lack professional experience?

And taking this a step further: If a candidate successfully demonstrated everything you've described, would you genuinely consider hiring them, assuming they also performed well in the interview? Or would their lack of professional experience still be a deciding factor?

If there are additional requirements or reservations you'd have before actually hiring someone in this situation, I'd be interested in those, too.

And if your experience requirements really are non-negotiable, I'd be interested in understanding that as well.

Specific, real-world examples would be greatly appreciated!


r/askmanagers • • 2d ago

How to handle the site lead for a contractor whose negligence is resulting in the need to detonate 5 tons of lead azide showering neighboring communities in lead dust?

75 Upvotes

Hi! I hope this lovely community can help me.

You see there is disagreement amongst the chain of command on how to handle a mistake that's been building for 20 years but became especially critical this March.

We pay a private contractor to manage our environmentally hazardous material for us. Technically we are ultimately responsible for the material. Well we checked the report which were all clear but never checked physically (heheh oops), and it turns out the contracted company kind of let the encapsulation liquid completely evaporate. Of course all their reports suggested they were checking and everything was within normal parameters. But instead the lead azide crystalized outside of its storage barrels when the liquid evaporated. We could have deactivated chemically but like, that costs money man and it would have taken 22 days. Instead we waited 234 days for the needed weather patterns and then requested an emergency EPA permit to blow the load tomorrow. We let those pesky citizens know that yes there will be toxic lead in the air. No big deal. But uh any kids under 6 you should probably keep them inside.

Well the townies blabbed to the news and now the word is sort of out! We have this pesky senator elect trying to delay the blast. Total nutso stirring up panic for no reason.

So yeah my question. Do I promote the site lead just once or twice? Some people are saying prosecute but that's laughable right?

Would love your advice!

This is a satirical letter since I don't actually work in the US Army and have no control over the leadership of American Ordinance LLC or it's parent company Day & Zimmerman LLC


r/askmanagers • • 2d ago

Do any managers that you've known use deeper techniques to motivate or change worker behavior than incentives, punishments, and letting them go?

4 Upvotes

When I was an electrical engineer, I noticed that there was a general mentality in management. One day my boss told me, "So, I heard that the operators can get their GED, and we legally have to let them run the machines. That's a really low level of ambition for operators, isn't it?" I remember that mentality blowing my mind. The way my boss thought about workers was not in terms of skill, ability, or anything. It was heavily based on ambition. However, I was never a manager. So, if that's how companies are run, he would know I guess.

However, that interaction made a lot of the industry make sense. I've watched a lot of low motivation employees let go, and I always kept wondering, "Isn't it the managers job to motivate them? It seems like instead of doing their job, the manager just hopes to hire someone who is extremely ambitious and then the manager just leaves them alone or helps them reflect on mistakes." Once I heard that my boss hired on ambition, the fact that all my other bosses leaving me alone instead of mentoring or coaching me, giving me processes to follow, or do any kind of real training made sense.

So I have seen incentives like pay raises, promotions, giveaways, etc. I've seen disincentives like writeups, managers screaming at employees, straight up insults. I have seen cognitive reframes where for electricians, the supervisor wrote one of them up, and when the electrician made excuses he said, "Well, keep doing it as much as you want to get let go." Then the electrician's attitude and behaviors completely changed. I started using that framework on myself to motivate myself a lot too, "Do action x as much as you want consequence y."

However, I've never seen managers use deeper frameworks, tricks, or techniques to motivate employees. Have any of you heard of such a thing? Like, one trick I have used on friends is that they will start to get defensive if you point out one of their flaws that you notice is holding them back, and when they start making excuses, I validate the emotion, and then they get less defensive. Then I ask a question to help them reframe or something like that.

Have any of you heard of doing tricks like that, or has every manager you hired just assumed that the paycheck and ambition will motivate employees, and that's all there is to it?


r/askmanagers • • 1d ago

New manager, how do I enforce company RTO without lowering morale?

0 Upvotes

I recently stepped into a management role for an existing team. Under their previous manager, the culture was very relaxed about remote work, and some members were remote.

However, the company now has an RTO policy, and it’s now on me to get everyone back in the office.

Since I'm still building trust and a good relationship with my team as the new manager, I do not want to come in swinging, enforcing day one and ruining team morale, especially for a policy that I am not part of. At the same time, I can't let them ignore a company mandate.

For managers who have navigated this:

  • How did you communicate the shift without sounding like "the bad guy"?
  • Did you use a phased approach, or rip the band-aid off?
  • How do you handle pushback from high performers who threaten to leave over it?

r/askmanagers • • 2d ago

What should I do before I leave this job?

1 Upvotes

Been at my company for more than 10 years, with lots of advancement and years of positive performance reviews. I was demoted while on parental leave and have found a new job elsewhere. Yes, I have engaged an employment lawyer.

In order to maximize my payout of accrued vacation time, my last day will be before the end of the calendar year. Beyond renewing prescriptions, scheduling appointments to max out my benefits and ensuring my lawyer reviews both my new offer and my separation agreement, what else should I do before my last day?

Regarding RRSP/401K matching, I am located in Ontario, Canada, and have a defined benefit pension plan, which will transfer to my new employer.


r/askmanagers • • 3d ago

Hiring managers: How would you judge a candidate with a visible missing tooth?

100 Upvotes

I'm job hunting, and missing a tooth on my top teeth. My insurance has limited dental coverage, so getting that fixed has been very difficult.

I'm aware that a missing tooth can make a bad impression; The catch is that I have a hard time finding a way to get it fixed because of my financial situation. If you were interviewing someone who had a visible missing tooth, what would you think?

And how should I handle this for now? Bring it up? Not mention it? Something else?


r/askmanagers • • 2d ago

Performance Review, from a Managers perspective

1 Upvotes

I’m looking for some perspective from managers here on how you all handle a certain aspect of annual reviews regarding addressing performance for the year.

More specially, I’m trying to figure out why my managers (owners of the company) might do things the way they do, and how I might be able to push back.

Usually our reviews involve goals for next year, comp adjustments, and discussion about performance.

Every year, without fail, my two managers bring up any mistake(s) made within the last 4-6 weeks preceding the review meeting and highlight them - sometimes this is something as small as a formatting error in a document (they feel compelled to find something).

It’s like they ignore the rest of the year, good or bad (especially anything good). Their feedback in the review is even harsher than when whatever mistake actually occurs, and it’s not constructive, more punitive in nature.

I’ve talked to another coworker and this happens to them as well, so it’s not just me. I otherwise do well in my reviews, but it’s as if my bosses can’t allow a review to be entirely positive.

Is this normal? I’ve had some significant accomplishments & handled some difficult things that popped up this year, and don’t want it to get ignored like in prior years.

I’ve been here about 5 years and it’s my first job where I received annual reviews.


r/askmanagers • • 2d ago

Forced to work as an intern under a former university classmate

0 Upvotes

Hi, I’m a recent statistics graduate. The only opportunity I had (which I accepted) was an internship at a corporate company , where I report to a former classmate who was hired for a permanent position.

She made it clear from the start that things wouldn’t be like they were at university, where we were equals; she is now my supervisor, and I’ll have to get used to this new dynamic. She also warned me that she will be the one to decide on any potential internship extensions or future hiring.

Is it normal for her to seem to derive a satisfaction from managing me, while I feel uncomfortable being her intern?
For instance, when we’re introduced to others and it comes up that we were university classmates, but now I’m her intern and she’s my boss, it feels awkward.


r/askmanagers • • 2d ago

Peakon Survey - Really anonymous?

0 Upvotes

There is a survey raised my company. I want to give honest anonymous feedbacks. Would be using ChatGPT to do it. But is it really anonymous? Does the manager know who has answered which questions?

What view is available to managers? What things are included in the dashboards? Do they get a response wise view or a question wise view? So that they should not ba able to track my other responses based on a particular response in my survey.


r/askmanagers • • 2d ago

OK to give a client-facing job to a tech-strong person w/o client-facing experience over a tech-weak person w/ client-facing experience?

0 Upvotes

This weird thing happened for an interview. The manager said that I was very technical but asked if I had any client-facing exp. I said no, but I worked w/ external vendors, non-tech teams, etc. The manager notes that client-facing exp is vital and there are other ppl w/ that exp.

I thought rejected but I moved to the final round. I talk about my tech work and ask q's for the role. At the end, I finally ask director if any concern and he repeats that I am very technical, but I have no client-facing exp and they have ppl w/ that exp?!?!

No surprise rejected, but WTF was the point of me going to director round? Surely, it was a waste of time for all of us. I think I should have been rejected at recruiter round as client-facing exp seems to be a hard requirement, but recruiter never asked jfc.

Nth example of me not knowing WTF these managers, recruiters, etc. are doing lol.


r/askmanagers • • 2d ago

Bombed my first review with a department head who rarely sees my work. How do I recover?

1 Upvotes

I’m five months into an entry-level job at a nonprofit. My supervisor is the head of the department, even though there are several levels between us (associate, manager, coordinator, etc.). He oversees my work directly because my whole role is dedicated to a project he started with the person who had my job before me. He calls the project his baby and has said my predecessor was “like a son” to him.

I had my first periodic review today, and it went badly. Over the past few months I’ve finished a number of projects that went well, and he gave me a sentence or two of “great job” on each in emails or over slack. In the review, though, he focused almost entirely on three assignments that I admit I didn’t get right the first time. I expected some criticism, but not this much, because I rarely see him. He’s almost never in the office, and when he is, he’s in meetings.

What bothers me is how far he took it. The mistakes in my opinion were minor, and most people looking at the final product wouldn’t have noticed them. They still shouldn’t have happened and I need to fix them, but his reaction felt out of proportion.

During the meeting:

  • He raised his voice at me several times, then laughed it off like he was joking.
  • He said I “clearly did not have a fundamental understanding of the work we’re trying to do here.” That was based on three assignments, five months in.
  • When I tried to take responsibility and explain my reasoning, he cut me off and said he didn’t want to hear excuses. I get that, but I wasn’t trying to excuse anything. I wanted to walk him through why I made the calls I made so he could show me where I went wrong.
  • More than once, when I tried to explain what I was going for, he looked me in the eye and said, “You don’t know anything.” Verbatim. That shut me down.

At one point I wanted to show him that I notice my mistakes and learn from them, so I brought up a small error I’d made in an internal newsletter. He cut me off mid-sentence: “Yeah, why are you screwing up with this damn newsletter 3-4 times?” I told him I’d fixed it by adding notes to a recurring email reminder I set for myself. He said: “Don’t make everything a systems issue. Just do it right the first time.” Which I get. But, harsh, no?

When we got to what I need from him, I said I’d felt intimidated bringing small questions to someone so senior, especially as a new hire, and that it’s hard to ask him anything when he’s barely in the office. He responded by saying that he has never had that issue and that I should just feel comfortable asking him questions.

I'm new to the workforce, ~a year out of grad school/college. Is this normal? How do I handle the next few months? Is this worth raising with HR?

TL;DR: Five months into an entry-level nonprofit job, I report directly to the department head. In my first review he skipped past the work I’d done well, raised his voice about a few minor mistakes, and told me “You don’t know anything.”


r/askmanagers • • 3d ago

Advice for starting off with new team

2 Upvotes

I am starting a position at the end of the month managing a small staff of 7 people in a new-to-me department. I stopped by today to meet them and they were all…chilly towards me. This is a well-established group of older people that has been working together for many years so I knew they wouldn’t be thrilled about getting a new manager. But I was still a little taken aback.

I am not looking to come in and start immediately shaking things up too much, if something isn’t broke I don’t want to fix it. I was planning on taking the first few weeks to get my bearings and observe how the team currently functions, what their work styles are, and what personality issues might be at play before I consider any changes to the status quo.

What else can I do to earn their trust (and respect)?