I run several independent travel websites. I've recently received a copyright claim from 79 Pixels Inc. concerning a photograph of Sant Maurici lake in the Spanish Pyrenees.
The photograph is by David Iliff (Diliff) and was originally published on Wikimedia Commons under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 licence.
The image was supplied to me by somebody else. I didn't know its original source at the time. After receiving the first notification, I tracked down the original, checked the licence and added the photographer's attribution, a link to the original image and a link to the licence on my website.
I've now received a Letter Before Claim demanding £345, with a stated full claim value of £995. The accompanying evidence dossier is around 25 pages.
I dispute the claim and have sent the response below. I've asked ten specific questions covering copyright ownership, authority to act, the licence, the alleged breach, the calculation of the fee and the legal basis of the demand.
I'm sharing the correspondence because I'd be interested in hearing from other bloggers and independent publishers who've encountered similar claims. I'm not looking for a pile-on against the company or the photographer; I'd simply like some informed opinions.
My response to 79 Pixels:
Dear 79 Pixels,
I have received your Letter Before Claim, your 25-page evidence dossier and your pro-forma invoice demanding £345.
Let me make my position absolutely clear: I reject your demand and will not be paying your invoice.
The photograph in question was supplied to me by a third party. At the time it was provided, I had no reason to believe that the person supplying it was not entitled to do so. I was unaware that the photograph was the work of David Iliff or that it was subject to a specific Creative Commons licence.
When I received your initial correspondence, I investigated the matter. Having identified the original photograph and its author on Wikimedia Commons, I promptly added attribution to David Iliff, a link to the original photograph and a direct link to the applicable Creative Commons BY-SA 3.0 licence.
I have made no attempt to conceal the photographer's identity, misrepresent his work or pass it off as my own. On the contrary, I have taken steps to identify and acknowledge the photographer and direct visitors to his original work.
Your own published rate card acknowledges that photographs released under Creative Commons licences may be used without charge when the relevant licence conditions are satisfied. The licence itself expressly permits commercial use.
Your company cannot simply disregard that arrangement and present its own retrospective licensing fee as an established debt.
I am particularly unimpressed by your approach of quoting an arbitrary £995 rate, offering a supposedly generous 65% discount and then applying a short payment deadline to create pressure. A discounted demand does not establish liability, prove infringement or demonstrate that the amount claimed is legally recoverable.
Before I will consider your allegations any further, I require explicit written answers to each of the following ten points. Please number your responses to correspond with the questions below. General statements, references to your website or simply directing me back to your evidence dossier will not constitute answers.
Information and evidence formally requested
1. Copyright ownership
Please provide documentary evidence identifying the legal copyright owner of the specific photograph at the relevant time, including confirmation that David Iliff owns the copyright and has not transferred or assigned the relevant rights to another party.
2. Your authority to act
Please provide documentary evidence that 79 Pixels, Inc. has been expressly authorised by David Iliff to identify alleged infringements, pursue claims, negotiate settlements and demand payment in relation to this particular photograph. Please clarify the precise scope of that authority.
3. The applicable licence
Please confirm the exact licence under which the photograph was published on Wikimedia Commons, including the version and date. Please explain how your claim takes account of the permissions expressly granted by the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 licence, including its permission for commercial use.
4. The specific alleged breach
Please identify every individual condition of the Creative Commons licence that you allege I breached. For each alleged breach, explain precisely what requirement was not met and why. A general allegation of unauthorised use is insufficient.
5. Evidence of the original publication
Please provide the dated evidence upon which you rely to establish when the photograph first appeared on my website. Please include the original screenshots, the URL recorded, the date of capture and any other evidence used to establish the alleged infringement.
6. Consideration of subsequent corrective action
Please confirm whether your assessment takes account of the fact that, upon receiving your initial correspondence, I investigated the photograph's origin and promptly added the photographer's attribution, a link to the original Wikimedia Commons file and a direct link to the applicable Creative Commons licence.
Please explain how this corrective action has been considered when assessing your claim and proposed settlement.
7. The calculation of £995
Please provide a full breakdown of how you arrived at your claimed retrospective licence fee of £995. Identify the underlying pricing evidence, comparable licensing transactions and the methodology used to determine that this is an appropriate fee for this particular photograph and use.
Simply referring me to your own published rate card is not an explanation of how the figure represents a legally recoverable loss.
8. The legal basis of your claim
Please identify the precise legal cause of action upon which you rely, the relevant statutory provisions and the basis on which you believe I am personally liable for the amount demanded. Please also explain how your claim accounts for the original Creative Commons licence.
9. Jurisdiction and the identity of the claimant
Please clarify the legal basis on which a Wyoming-registered corporation is pursuing this claim against a UK domain registrant, including the jurisdiction and applicable law upon which you intend to rely should proceedings be commenced.
Please also confirm the legal entity that would be named as claimant in any proceedings.
10. The proposed settlement and payment deadline
Please explain how your proposed settlement of £345 has been calculated, why you consider it proportionate and legally justified, and the basis on which you believe failure to pay by 23 November entitles you to increase the demand to £995.
Please also explain why such a short payment deadline was imposed when the claim involves an alleged historic use of an image published under a Creative Commons licence.
My position
I have not removed the photograph from my article because, having investigated its origin and added the relevant attribution and licence links, I have no reason at present to accept that its continued use is unlawful.
If a genuine licensing issue is established, I will consider the appropriate action, including removal. However, if the photograph is ultimately removed, the accompanying credit and direct link to David Iliff's work will disappear with it. That is hardly an outcome that provides the photographer with additional exposure.
I run an independent publishing business. I take copyright seriously, credit photographers and respect legitimate licensing arrangements.
What I will not do is pay an unexplained retrospective fee simply because a company sends me an intimidating quantity of paperwork and attaches a deadline to an invoice.
I formally dispute your claim in full. I do not admit liability and I do not accept your proposed settlement.
I expect a substantive written response addressing all ten numbered questions individually. If you cannot provide the requested information or evidence for any particular question, please expressly state that rather than leaving it unanswered.
Please direct all further correspondence concerning this matter to me by email.
Regards,
I've not received their response yet. I'll update the discussion when I do.
For anyone interested, I've also written about the background to this on Clive's Detours:
I Used a Wikipedia Photograph. Now Someone Wants £345.