r/classicwow • • 12h ago • Bravo 2

Forever Blizzard is now removing blue drops from leveling dungeon bosses, and it's not a good sign

Post image

The WoW streamer Ahmpy discovered that by entering Uldaman from the side entrance, he could kill Obsidian Sentinel, vendor the loot, and make decent gold per hour. As a result, Blizzard wiped everything from the loot table for this boss, making it so the boss gives no loot whatsoever. This includes Axe of Lingering Dread, which could be combined with Axe of Inevitable Ruin from another boss to form Pendulum of Doom, a powerful blue axe for leveling characters.

This is a bad precedent. It's not sustainable. What happens when more dungeon boss farms are uncovered as potential gold farms? Are they gonna keep removing loot from bosses until there's no possible source of gold left? With dungeons already giving less XP than they used to, there's even less incentive to do them if loot is actively being removed from them.

In my opinion, this is insane, and I'm surprised not more people are upset about it. They could have reduced vendor price for the boss drops or come up with some other solution that isn't so harmful to normal leveling people running the dungeon, but they went with the most extreme solution of removing all the loot altogether. Pendulum of Doom is now impossible to get in WoW Forever.

4.4k Upvotes

2.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

269

u/Touchd93 12h ago • Bravo

What we can take from this is that it's impossible to ban the bots at the rate they respawn

101

u/Suzushiiro 11h ago

It's always been an arms race between Blizz and the bots and it always will be, there's no way for them to get rid of them permanently. That's why you have to both go after the bots directly and slow down/stop any farming methods they use that you also would rather not encourage legit players to use either.

88

u/AppleMelon95 10h ago • Bravo

Call me fucking dumb despite having a computer science degree, but in my world this sounds like an easy input-check or behavioral check that could easily detect the bots. Like, obviously a character is a bot if it grinds mobs for 20 hours.

Google can apparently catch bots with a simple captcha where you press a button but Blizzard can’t figure out how a Hunter doing the exact same inputs when it enters a dungeon for 5 hours is a bot or not. Make it make sense.

35

u/AbleDiscipline 6h ago edited 6h ago

Runescape tried the captcha a long time ago and everyone hated it. They added a fatigue system, when doing activities in the game, you would slowly gain fatigue. Once you hit 100% you were unable to do anything in the game. The way you clear fatigue was using a sleeping bag that prompted the user to enter an easy captcha and it would reset their fatigue back to 0.

What bots did to combat that, was the free version of the botting program would reward users a premium currency to sit there and answer other bot's captchas. It was a way to unlock premium bot scripts without paying money and it pretty much defeated the reason the sleeping bag was implemented. Now im assuming large botting farms could easily defeat captchas.

and on the 1 button click captcha, im pretty sure thats just to stop headless (CLI) bots, its a graphical captcha that headless programs wouldnt be able to see. Simply adding a "click here" would easily be defeated by any bot.

16

u/RASTAGAMER420 5h ago

That's true for runescape in the 2000s, but OSRS basically wiped out all visible bots this very year. Basically by just investing a lot of time and effort into it and considering it important (interview with CEO available on youtube).

•

u/Flaky-Contest62 4h ago

Is this true though? So you believe the ceo?

•

u/DefinitionOfResting 1h ago

They sent a cease and desist to like 19 of the top 20 botting platforms. I know because i got one. They didn't really change the system so much as target the suppliers and developers.

Blizzard made the precident case for this like a decade ago but seemingly forgot. Can't bot if the programs developers quit and you update the game once. Changing the memory address of everything.

•

u/RASTAGAMER420 4h ago

I believe what I saw in game

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

46

u/DarlinSteeze 9h ago

That's always been the argument, this was a serious problem in osrs with upto 30% of active players at some points being bots

They got a new CEO and for atleast a time it dropped to sub 1% after some 6 months of work, maybe they're back now I've not been playing osrs

But it's an arms race and ban wave has always been a standard practice for osrs to obfuscate what triggered the ban

68

u/desperateorphan 9h ago • Bravo

All you have to do, and this is what OSRS did, is ban them within hours, not weeks/months. The second you make it not possible to be financially profitable, the bots will stop and move on. This is a job for these people.

Blizzard, however, lets them go for months at a time and then bans them making the entire effort pointless from a quality standpoint. It's great for blizzards financials. It's just a cost of doing business for the botters.

Nothing will change until someone at the top of blizzard cares about the quality and integrity of the game.

8

u/RJ815 5h ago

AKA the "we slap you with a $15 fine after you've made hundreds maybe thousands" method

5

u/ActurusMajoris 5h ago

Oh dang. Then we are cooked.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/Sakebadger 8h ago

Input checks dont work botting programs can still bypass them. Aion 2 has a captcha system to help prevent botting when it comes to gathering and sadly only affected the actual players more than the bots. So they've double downed by locking how much each account can earn per day eg: can only farm 1000 gatherable nodes a day, can only make 1mill cash a day, no trading, sub required to use the AH. Alot of people don't think these new restrictions are working but after putting in 600hours since early access and seeing my server for 2 weeks be nothing but players respecting one another on a node to then infested hell of fighting for nodes back to majority player respect/massively less bots shows me this is the only way to tackle botting.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/High-Yield-Only 8h ago

Like, obviously a character is a bot if it grinds mobs for 20 hours.

As somebody that transferred from Old School Runescape, that is a very funny comment.

5

u/RJ815 5h ago

> insert [shitting one's pants for second place in a race] here.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

21

u/Alyusha 9h ago

Exactly this. There are bots literally fly hacking underground. How can a simple Z axis check not catch this? Players logged in for 24+ hours should be looked into no matter the situation. It's not healthy for 1 person to do this on a regular basis, and against the ToS to have multiple people using 1 account.

12

u/WeaponizedFOMO 8h ago

Lol Blizzard sending out wellness checks. Could be amazing PR, actually

→ More replies (3)

18

u/airwaters 9h ago

Yet they exist in virtually every online game? Even Riot's kernel anti-cheat, Vanguard, could not stop botting completely. No game are safe from rampant botting if there is money on the line, the botters will continue to adapt at whatever is thrown at them. You are severely underestimating the people that do these things for a living. RMTing in MMOs is a big industry with LLCs because it is not a crime to sell virtual items.

The only way I know of that botting is not a problem would be how South Korea handles it. By tying a SSN to an account, it would limit the amount of accounts being created and tie you legally by name. There is also laws to stop these kinds of things (to varying results). That's how much you have to do to stop bots, and it still does not deter the people that do not care about the law.

→ More replies (1)

•

u/BigBootyBear 4h ago

If you have a comp sci degree (I don't but I work in DevOps) I assume you can understand that on a fundamental level, all bot-banning heuristics are in effect bot training signals. A bot ban is indistinguishable from a reward function that corrects a model during reinforcement learning.

Every few months we need to come up with a new "im not a bot" test because the sheer data each of the previous challenges collected was used as a dataset to train the next generation of bots. And thats a problem the entire IT industry has, not just blizzard.

We are moving very fast into an era where purely technial moats against botting/AI/spam are at best disposable, and at worst useless.

7

u/HuskarlofOdin 7h ago

Brother, I grind mobs for 20 hours at a time every now and then, without using a bot xD

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (10)

•

u/A_Wild_Alex_Appears 4h ago

Believing it's impossible to ban bots is clinically untrue. But anything to continue feeding their sub cost.

4

u/Boysahne69 8h ago

The problem is Blizzard being incompetent at automating bans and being too cheap to employ a dedicated person hunting bots.

If you played WoW for years you can recognize a bot from miles away. Go to the hotspots where bots are (certain dungeons or farm routes) and ban everything that moves like a bot. I'm pretty sure a single full-time working person can easily get the bulk of the bots banned over a few weeks.

I'm also sure you could map certain behavior points of bots that are server-sided and get them banned this way as well. They're probably already doing something like this, but very badly.

3

u/Chuckfinley_88 9h ago

It's really hard to stop bots when bots pay $15 a month.

Almost impossible it turns out. So hard, that they indeed do almost nothing to combat it.

21

u/HarspudSauce 12h ago

Then what you do is flag bot accounts and move their characters to a layer just for bots that they can't get out of. Increase the respawn timers of mobs and resource nodes on that layer by three or four times. Bots aren't banned so blizz still gets their sub fee, the bots can still run around competing with only other bots for mobs/nodes on a 15 minute respawn timer, they have reduced impact on the economy since their ability to farm is reduced. Everyone wins.

52

u/Sadzeih 12h ago

If it was that easy to flag bots they would just ban them...

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (30)