Saw a patient for an exam a little while ago, noticed a broken existing occlusal fill on 31 with moderate depth recurrent decay and tx planned a new occlusal. Did occlusal filling without incident. Patient calls back in roughly a week and says he’s in pain. Bring him back for no charge visit, check occlusion, small adjustment, re-cure with light. Patient calls back two weeks later, says it’s still bothering him. I suggested doing the filling again (no charge), this time without etch, patient agreed to try. When leaving he asked if he could have an endo referral “just in case this doesn’t work, to save me time in having to come back”. I gave him a referral.
The same day we redid the filling, he called back a few hours later and told the front desk “please tell the doctor that I think this new filling is working, it doesn’t hurt anymore.” I was pleased and thought that was hopefully the end of it.
Roughly a week later, the patient sent a one sentence email saying “well I guess I’m getting a root canal”.
The day we received the letter from the endodontist, he called and asked to schedule his crown right away. Front desk scheduled him for a couple weeks out. Then, within an hour of scheduling the crown, he sends a lengthy email stating that “this tooth was perfectly fine until you worked on it, so it’s clear to anyone that you did something wrong.” He then goes on to list all his expenses related to this tooth (initial filling, endodontist visit, gas, wear and tear on car, lost wages, etc). He stated I can either pay those expenses, or he is filing a board complaint against me. He says because I never made him sign anything specifically that says filling a tooth can cause a root canal, he has a clear cut case against me.
I am of course sending his email to our professional liability attorney, but I’m wondering if anyone else has any additional advice. The fact that he still wants to come in for the crown makes this even weirder and I really don’t feel comfortable doing the crown anymore after this.