r/exjw • • 14h ago

Weekly Mini-Vent Megathread - November 22, 2026

1 Upvotes

What is this Megathread?

This is a dedicated space for short-form venting posts that do not meet the character limit for standalone posts.

Angry at your family, the Watchtower or the congregation? Having a REALLY bad day? Experiencing some big feelings and but don't have enough steam to make a long post about it? Welcome to our weekly mini-vent thread, the place where you can let it all out- in little bites.

Note: Standard sub rules still apply here, so please report any content that breaks the rules.

-------------------

If You are Considering Harming Yourself:

Please stay with us. Know you are safe and among friends and we will do whatever we can to help.

If you are inside the U.S., text "CHAT" to 741741. You'll be connected to a trained Crisis Counselor from Crisis Text Line. Or call the National Suicide Hotline at 988.

If you're not in the U.S. please click here for a comprehensive list of hotlines organized by country and additional resources.

If you are LGBTIA+ and need to talk, please contact the LGBT National Hotline at 1-888-843-4564 or find them online here.


r/exjw • • 6d ago

News The Rumor Mill: News and Gossip - November 16, 2026

15 Upvotes

What is this Megathread?

We get quite a bit of speculation, questions on upcoming updates, and general JW gossip in our sub. As part of our community engagement poll you folks voted for a special home to house shorter posts devoted to this type of exchange, so here we are!

Got a juicy piece of gossip from your KH or your JW social circle?  Want to ask a quick question about an upcoming announcement, or change? Heard a rumor from the WT or about something going on in bethel? This is what the weekly rumor mill thread is for. Just remember not to share anyone's PII, and we're golden.

Please Remember:

All the sub's rules still apply, so remember not to use these threads for activist drama or rumors about the personal lives of activists.

Have a Lot to Say?

This megathread is intended for submissions that are too short to be stand alone posts. If you have a rather lengthy comment, we might prompt you to spin it off into its own post for more engagement :) 

Welcome to the Rumor Mill, everyone. Gossip away!


r/exjw • • 7h ago

Humor Does anyone else find it funny how JWs use science to prove the Bible, but reject science when it contradicts their beliefs?

92 Upvotes

*note: this probably applies to other branches of religion too lol*

I find it quite funny when JWs will tell you to trust in the bible, because it is "harmonious with science", but then convince you to ignore and reject scientific evidence when it contradicts with biblical statements of theology.

For instance, they will harp on about how in the bible it spoke of the water cycle, which scientists apparently didnt discover until recently. (im sure that's false too lol), or how it says the earth hangs upon nothing! How did those bible writers know about gravity before Newton!

But then when science is contradictory to the bible, let's say evolution.. well suddenly we have to ignore and reject that evidence, because its "created by satan" and is very clearly false because the bible says so!

I love circular logic.


r/exjw • • 1h ago

HELP My PIMI husband took both our kids to the meeting tonight, and I’m surprisingly upset

33 Upvotes

I’m currently fading, while my husband is still PIMI. He usually attends meetings alone, sometimes taking our 13 year old son, who gets to decide whether he wants to go.
Tonight, however, he took both our boys, including our 6 year old.
Here’s the thing: our youngest didn’t actually want to attend the meeting. My husband promised him he’d download Roblox for him if he went.
And for some reason, this really upset me.
I was sitting at home alone, knowing all three of them were at the Kingdom Hall, and my immediate thought was, “I’m not liking this.”
It’s not about being left alone. I wouldn’t have cared if they’d gone somewhere else together. It’s specifically about my youngest being there.
He’s a child who struggles with rigid rules, expectations, and being told what to do. I genuinely don’t think the JW environment is a good fit for his needs.
And what bothers me even more is the feeling that my husband is taking him there for appearances. Almost like he’s trying to show the congregation that even though his wife has stopped attending, he’s still bringing his children.
I can’t know for sure if that’s his motivation, but that’s how it feels.
And bribing a 6 year old with Roblox to attend a religious meeting just doesn’t sit right with me.
I absolutely believe my children should be free to develop their own beliefs. But I don’t think offering rewards to get them to attend religious meetings is the same as letting them choose freely.
Am I being unfair to my husband? Am I overreacting because of my own feelings about the religion? Or would this bother you too?
I’d especially love to hear from anyone navigating parenting with a PIMI spouse while fading.


r/exjw • • 11h ago

JW / Ex-JW Tales Learned family members are leaving

147 Upvotes

Been out for awhile. Nearly my whole living family is in. Multiple (overlapping 😆) generations worth. Today I found out several of my family members just left or are poised to leave very soon. Very best news I’ve had in a long time. I never would have held out any hope. Turns out it was a culmination of many factors different from person to person but the blood change was the nail in the coffin. My family has been tragically affected multiple times so I am not surprised. Anyway everyone wants to do some kind of family Christmas. Pretty cool.


r/exjw • • 7h ago

Venting Mum died, still waiting to be told

47 Upvotes

So my mum died over a week ago. My older (and an elder) brother told his son who is disfellowshipped, who text me the news, yet my brother still doesn’t think he has to tell my other brother and my sister! For context I’ve been out (not disf) since 2017. Mother was a very toxic person so decided to just not see her any more. My other brother and sister have never been Jws yet he still doesn’t have the compassion to tell them. The moral compass of Jws is simply shocking. In what world does he think this is acceptable behaviour?


r/exjw • • 6h ago

Venting I made a mistake of venting

37 Upvotes

I feel like JWs are so heartless to the point they don’t consider or care about your feelings. I found myself venting to a witness who’s in my congregation (PIMI)
about my suicidal thoughts. Last week I almost kms because my situation at home was draining me but I was slowly recovering by taking time off on weekends it’s helping until he made it worse.

So the brother will call him X told me he understands and wants to help me, and he suggested a shepherding call with the elders, I said no, I refused, I just wanted one person to talk to because I couldn’t handle it anymore. I made him promise we keep it between us and he said he’d keep his word. But he didn’t a week passed and I’m getting phone calls and check ins from elders asking how I’m doing and I told them I’m fine, and they kept insisting if they come and visit, I said no I didn’t want them to come they kept calling every hour I turned on dnd on my iPhone. Then I called X and asked him if he told anyone and he said, I looked so low and I was distant I wasn’t online WhatsApp he thought he’d call the elders to check on me. I felt so violated he told elders about my problem with my consent and I ignored him. Then just today he started interrogating me about my problem and asking me if I involved Jehovah in my prayers and then he said he wants to call again later to ask about my bible study.

I got so pissed off when he asked about my bible study it triggered my PTSD. I feel so stupid and I’m afraid those thoughts are gonna come back
I blocked him afterwards because I felt so betrayed, I used to think we were just casually close and we’d talk but now he is inspecting my life and mental health like it’s his job to make sure I’m perfect when he never brought solutions, he only sent those useless young people ask articles that never work

I wanted to let it out of my chest because I’m so angry at myself I feel like an upright idiot who doesn’t deserve life


r/exjw • • 8h ago

Venting “Imperfect When It's Us, Worldly When It's Them”

41 Upvotes

I’ve noticed something interesting about how Jehovah’s Witnesses explain people’s mistakes.
When a Jehovah’s Witness makes a serious mistake, the explanation is often, “Well, they’re imperfect. We’re all imperfect.” But when someone who isn’t a Jehovah’s Witness makes the exact same mistake, suddenly the explanation changes to, “Well, they are worldly, what do you expect from a worldly person?”

You see, you could interchange the words imperfect and worldly in the exact same sentence, describing the exact same behaviour, and both explanations would make perfect sense to most Jehovah’s Witnesses, depending on who committed the offence.

one person is simply a good person struggling with human imperfection, while the other is behaving exactly as you would expect a worldly person to behave.

What I find particularly interesting is that everyone is supposedly imperfect, yet the language of imperfection seems to be extended far more generously to those within the organization. Those outside it are not always afforded the same understanding.
It’s almost as though imperfection is a privilege reserved for insiders, while worldliness is the explanation assigned to outsiders.

You see, the issue isn’t really about human imperfection at all. It’s about who is allowed to have their mistakes explained sympathetically and who is expected to have their mistakes used against them.


r/exjw • • 2h ago

Academic Obscenities of the Bible - Man Hires His Own Step-Daughter as a Prostitute, and Then Through Her Pregnancy He Becomes Ancestor to the Line of David

12 Upvotes

This whole story can be read in Genesis 38.

This story is isolated to this chapter, so it has very little prior context. Maybe the only useful information is that Judah, the main character of this story, was son of Jacob, so he was very closely connected to the patriarchs of the Bible.

Judah married a Canaanite woman named Shua. Together they had three kids: Er, Onan, and Shelah. 

Judah arranged for his firstborn Er to be married to Tamar: Judah’s stepdaughter. God thought Judah’s son Er was wicked, so God killed him. Judah then essentially tells his son Onan: “Go have children with your now-widowed stepsister Tamar in place of your dead brother Er”.

Onan wanted the kids to be officially his, and not be a male surrogate for his brother. So he never provided all the ingredients to his stepsister to make a baby. God didn’t like that, so God killed Onan also. (Genesis 38:9, 10)

Judah then sent his widowed stepdaughter Tamar to live with her biological father, and he instructed her to wait for his own last living biological son Shelah to grow up first, and then marry her. The passage indicates that Judah was trying to circumvent God killing his last son Shelah by delaying the marriage. (Genesis 38:11) Tamar listens to him and moves to her biological father’s house. 

Later, one of Shua’s daughters died, who was unnamed in the passage. It seems as though it was not one of Judah’s biological kids, but one of his stepkids. Regardless, Judah had mourned, but was now recovered from it. He decided to go with his friend Hirah to visit his sheep shearers in Timnah.

Tamar, Judah’s widowed stepdaughter, heard that Judah was coming and changed out of her widow’s clothes, put on a veil, and sat on the path to Timnah. She did this so that Judah would have to pass her on his journey. The passage mentions that Shelah, Judah’s last son that he could offer for an arranged marriage was now grown up, but was not given to Tamar as a husband as promised. (Genesis 38:14)

When Judah saw Tamar alongside the road, the story says that he thought she was a prostitute. He approached her and asked if he could receive her services. He said that he doesn’t have the means to pay her right now, but will do so later. She asks for some kind of pledge, so he gives her his signet, cord, and staff. She then agreed to do the deed with him.

Later, Judah sent someone else to collect his pledge. However, they couldn’t find her. 3 months later, Judah heard a report that Tamar had prostituted herself. His reaction was essentially: “My daughter-in-law is a prostitute? Bring her to me and then burn her for doing evil!” 

Upon arriving, she said to him: “I have proof that it was you that hired me as a prostitute and got me pregnant. These are your signet, cord, and staff aren’t they?” Judah essentially replied: “Yeah you got me. Maybe we won’t burn you alive” (Genesis 38:24-26)

End scene

Interesting. Something that strikes me is that Judah takes a journey right after grieving the loss of his stepdaughter and says in his mind “You know what I need? I could go for a prostitute right now”. The purpose of his trip was to visit his sheep shearers, and where he stopped to hire a prostitute was not the destination of his journey. It’s as though prostitution was just a pit-stop in this process, a side quest that he decided to partake in for a night. 

Surely, we would think that God would kill Judah for not only hiring a prostitute while married, but impregnating his own stepdaughter of all things right? Well… no. God actually preferred earlier to kill Judah’s son Onan because he WOULDN’T impregnate his own stepsister. 

On the interaction between Judah and Tamar on his journey, the narrative claims that Judah could not recognize his stepdaughter because of the veil she was wearing. The transparency of the veil comes into question, but let’s just grant that her face was indistinguishable at first. What about further along in their interaction? She never takes off the veil and he just… never sees her face at any point? If the veil is a true obstacle, he apparently couldn’t recognize her voice either. I find it interesting how Tamar also does not seem to recognize her own stepfather before or during the services as a prostitute. The account doesn’t indicate that Judah was wearing any type of disguise, so what’s the excuse there? Even if she conveniently couldn’t recognize his face, she doesn’t at least recognize his voice? 

What about Tamar’s motives? She left her biological father’s house for the specific purpose of meeting up with Judah in the middle of his journey. She changed out of her widow’s clothes, into clothes that the story would later have Judah interpreting to be something that a prostitute might wear. She went to a specific spot and sat so that he would have to pass her. The story indicates that prostitutes weren't regular in that area, so prostitution doesn’t seem to be a pattern that she had, at least in that area. She dressed this way and positioned herself in this area for the purpose of seeing her stepdad, not to get random clients as a prostitute. (Genesis 38:21, 22) 

I find Judah’s later response to Tamar being a prostitute as at least a bit suspicious. As soon as he heard that his stepdaughter had prostituted herself, he asked for her to be burned. Had he known all along what he had done, and wanted to get rid of the evidence? Or was he hypocritical, not yet realizing that it was her that he slept with when he himself engaged in the very act that he was condemning: prostitution? 

Regardless of which it is, through the act of prostituting stepfamily came two children, one of which named Perez. Through Perez came the tribe of Judah. Through the tribe of Judah originated almost all “Jews”, as it comes from the tribe name. This specific people group were, as the Bible portrays it, God’s selected people. This people group created the line of King David, and a large portion of the Southern Kingdom of Judah. From this line, Jesus was said to have originated.

This man was a forefather to this later “great nation”. So it seems he received plot armor for his sins when his own sons who were not successors to the line of David did not recieve the same mercy.


r/exjw • • 4h ago

Venting Deeply disappointed 😞 😔 😪

18 Upvotes

I'm not sure how to share this story. I bumped into an old friend on Thursday afternoon at Costco. I was 13 when she and her husband started coming to our hall. They were high school sweethearts, he was Muslim and she was baptized.

She came back at 21 and was reinstated and her husband started studying with my Dad (newly appointed Elder at the time)

He actually was baptized with my brother and Me and maybe 5 others from the hall.

She and I were close, but she was the youngest sibling of 6. I was the oldest of 3. She grew up with an unbelieving Father and 2 brothers that never got baptized either. The other half was her Mom and 3 sisters who I knew, but not well until she came back.

This story will date me, but I just had the memory of her bringing me to see New Jack City and her thinking I would have a crisis of conscience and tell on us. Lol I never told until now. To make things better, my PIMI Mom knew I had liked a few songs from the soundtrack and came home with the cassette soundtrack. I was told not to show my Dad and the explicit lyrics sticker was right on the front. And to make things GREAT, the song that was biggest hit was Color Me Badd's, I Wanna Sex You Up! 🤣🤣🤣 (Yes, my Mom knew)

Alright getting back to my disappointment. She and I never got into it. There was a BIG disagreement with some others that I grew up with and her sisters. Her sisters were the scariest witnesses I ever met. One Sunday afternoon 2 of her sisters showed up in fight mode and neither of my parents were home and they wanted to talk to my Dad, but I suspect I was smart enough to tell them to wait and not invite them in. One of them lived around the corner from an unbaptized male bestie of mine and he called me one day about the stabbing of her next neigbbor with kitchen shears. Police weren't called and it had to do with the new boyfriend of the sister (whose family I grew up with) And then her other sister had started dating an MS who had a previous girlfriend in the neighboring congregation. This woman had such a grip on my friend and her BF, she had this then MS beat up this former GF and I can't even tell you.how many witnesses lived in that area and a few saw it and NOTHING was done.

After my folks got home, my Dad had those 2 women come in and about 5 other adults and there was this shouting match at my house with cussing and how my family got involved is beyond me. No other elders were involved and nothing was done, it just caused this rift and my friend and her husband were part of this pow wow and her sisters kept saying remember what Dad said (not a witness)

I found out that their Dad said not to trust white people. 🤔🥺😕

I know she knew that she could trust me, but her sisters hated me! May I remind you of my age, at this time I was 15, sisters were in their early to late 30's and telling certain people I was fast (I was so NOT) I just happened to be mature and didn't do anything bad so it upset them I suppose.

The last time I saw my friend was at an assembly in 2001, one year before my escape. Lol She was now divorced and had a little boy who is now 30! Funnier side note, he's the Mgr of the Costco we were at and she brought me over to meet him again.

Lots of tears and she brought up "The Truth" 🙄 I told her I was completely inactive and no desire to go back. I shared some of the things I have only shared with you all anonymously and with my therapist. And then she asked me about my parents. I had to open the wound and tell her they divorced after 31 years, and my Dad is now remarried and celebrated 19 years last July. Then I had to tell her who the woman was my Dad married. I said, who ever heard of an atheist that suddenly wanted to know about God and join a high controlled organization?! She nodded as if she was in agreement and she's like, but they're changing. Mind you she left again and so I think she's definitely POMI! Her Mom passed a long time ago and I was out when she died, so I didn't attend the service.

The blood issue came up and she seemed excited and I told her my friend died because she refused a transfusion! I said what will they say or do about the ones who are gone and they don't make it right?

I also shared a few things about my real relationship with my own Mother. It was nothing like hers. She was shocked! Which most are when I tell them. I know this is because it's certainly not becoming of a witness, but most of all, as a Mother.

I did end up having to tell her I was deprogrammed in 2021 and so there's really nothing else anyone could say to get me to change my mind. I also told her I was pushed to get baptized or hear I would be homeless at 18 until that day came.

My mom ended up calling me while we chatted and then of course I heard how it was Jehovah and she is so happy that we reconnected and her prayers were answered, so that I might have a friend again.

Every friend I had turned their back on me right after I was deprogrammed. One told me she didn't want to deal with my batshit Mom's crazy religion and the drama. I guess I should have looked at everyone as acquaintances my entire life. There were no lifetimes, just reasons and seasons, which is a very lonely place to live. The reality is, I have no friends, I have my puppy and that's it. I have to write a letter to my Mom to disclose this is it for me. I'm not going to keep my mouth shut to keep her comfortable and her repeated actions of telling people things about my life and crossing my boundaries only to be pissed when I call her out on it has set me ablaze! The disingenuous behavior around those in the congregation and the dog park with unbelievers is unbearable!

I woke up to a sub showing the POA medical directive and I am maddened at the mental gymnastics I have had to perform these last several months in order to get through a conversation to avoid conflict. I think it's time I start saying what happened and why my family sucks ass! If they really are PIMO and reading this, don't bother with me until I see full transparency.


r/exjw • • 36m ago

Ask ExJW JWs dont have an entrepeneur business culture

8 Upvotes

And this is not to praise entrepeneurs or businessmen like Elon Musk.

But JW seem to have no business culture.

Everything about being JW is about working as much as you can for the borg until god decides to have a rampage day and you are suddenly living in paradise

this is not only JW theology this is JW culture

do nothing do as lithe work money as you can

wait till god decides to drop metheorites everywhere

and this is why I was dicussing previously that Mormons seem to have a better business culture than JW

not encouraging to become one but makes sense the difference between them.


r/exjw • • 47m ago

HELP I told my JW mom how I’ve been having questions and is now emotionally manipulating me

9 Upvotes

TLDR: my over bearing mom asked if I was leaving and I was honest, then proceeded to try and emotionally manipulate me, along with preparing questions to ask an elder.

I (33 years old male) was over at my parents dropping some groceries off for my parents when I started talking with my mom. Nothing super special, typical how’ve you been, how’s your relationship, etc. Then out of nowhere she asks “Are you leaving Jehovah?” To which I responded that I’m having serious questions about the organization.

The thing with my mom is she’s incredibly nosy, overthinks a lot, and is a hard-liner JW, a Bible thumper. She has always demanded that I tell her everything and not to hold anything back, and if I didn’t give her an answer she thought I was holding back, she would press me for more, with my hard-liner stepdad backing her.

Anyways she tells me to do my research (as in go to the organization for answers) when I tell her of the research I’ve done from the bible, which brought me to the rehearsal of the Blood transition ban. I brought up how the GB went above and beyond what was written, and nowhere did it say that blood transfusions were wrong. She then proceeded to tell me that it was only for your own blood and not someone else’s blood. She then also told me that blood transfusions were whole blood and is cannibalism. I responded (respectfully) that 95% of transfusions were components and not whole blood.

She then goes into what I call “Jehovah panic mode” and began going off on how everything that isn’t from the organization is apostate material and that I need to meet with an elder (which I intend to do to press him for answers). I asked her how can everything be apostate? Because it goes against the teachings of the organization? I then brought up how they make huge changes (blood transfusion reversal, shunning, toasting) and she used the classic line “things will come to light as the light gets brighter” followed by her telling me I’m not willing to listen and that she’s used to having her heart broken.

I ended the conversation there because there’s no reaching hard-liners like that, so I’ve been working on things to ask the elder when I meet with him. Any insight to that would be great :)


r/exjw • • 5h ago

JW / Ex-JW Tales The Historical Inconsistency of 1919

18 Upvotes

Who Was Truly the Slave?

To assert that Jesus inspected and appointed a “faithful and discreet slave” in 1919, that slave would first have had to exist and function as such on that date. Yet the internal history of the movement proves the exact opposite:

• A Doctrine Centered on a Deceased Man: In 1919 (and until 1927, as the organization’s own publications acknowledge), the Bible Students believed that Charles Taze Russell (who died in 1916) was the faithful and discreet slave of Matthew 24:45. No “Governing Body” in the modern sense existed at the time.

• An Organization Divided in Two: In 1919, leadership was split between two entities:

• A Legal Entity: The board of directors of the Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society, presided over by Joseph Rutherford (who had recently been released from prison and was consolidating his authority).

• An Editorial Entity: A five-member editorial committee appointed by Russell’s will to oversee the spiritual content of The Watchtower—a committee that Rutherford progressively sidelined in order to centralize power.

• The Logical Question: If in 1919 those on the ground believed the slave was Russell (already deceased) and the living leaders were divided between a legal board and an editorial committee locked in conflict, whom precisely did Jesus select in 1919?

2. The Retroactive Self-Proclamation of 2013

• The Shift in Definition: Until 2012, official teaching maintained that the “faithful and discreet slave” comprised all anointed Christians living on earth at any given time since Pentecost.

• The 2013 Redefinition: In the July 15, 2013 issue of The Watchtower, a handful of men forming the Governing Body announced that the faithful and discreet slave was, in fact, exclusively themselves—a small group that emerged much later, as the term “Governing Body” as a distinct ruling authority only took shape in the 1970s.

None of the Governing Body members who made this announcement in 2013 had even been born in 1919.

They are therefore claiming—without eyewitnesses, without visible proof, and nearly a century after the fact—that Jesus appointed in 1919 a governing office that did not even exist in that form at the time.

3. The Paradox of the “Uninspired” Claiming Absolute Obedience

• The Official Admission: In the February 2017 issue of The Watchtower (p. 26), the Governing Body openly acknowledges that it is “neither inspired nor infallible” and “can err in doctrinal matters or in organizational direction.”

• The Logical Impasse:

• If these men are not inspired by God, how can they know with certainty what Jesus did in heaven in 1919? No vision, no angel, no miracle, and no Bible verse makes any mention of the year 1919.

• An uninspired claim regarding an invisible event amounts to mere human opinion. Yet believers are required to grant this opinion absolute trust and obedience, as though it were the very word of God.

r/exjw • • 8h ago

JW / Ex-JW Tales How did I end up inadvertently'witnessing'??

30 Upvotes

Help! Last night my husband and I (ex JW 10 years) were out for a meal with friends. They asked how we met, we gave our usual response of 'at church', they asked what church, we had to say we grew up JWs so they wanted to know more. One of them brought up about JWs don't accept blood, we explained how that's now changed and then I ended up having to explain why JWs don't celebrate Christmas, was right back in the past to when I used to have to tell people the reasons I didn't celebrate Christmas. Do we never truly escape???


r/exjw • • 18h ago

Activism + Advocacy Try this with a Jehovah Witness elder and watch his embarrassment

175 Upvotes

You: Would you say the organisation is transparent?

cultist: Yes

You: Would you say we don’t keep secrets from each other?

cultist: Yes

You: And we have nothing to hide?

cuntist: Not a thing

you: So can you give me a copy of Shepherding the Flock of God?

cunt: …

—————

And then, please come back here and share what they said to you.

I’ve been trying this with elders for the last few days and they seem to die of embarrassment each time.

it might not wake them up, it might even push them further into the cult.

or it just might plant a seed.

Either way, it’s a little entertainment in an otherwise boring cult.

FYI. This isn’t my idea, someone in the local area shared it with me - he’s recently helped wake up a few in several local congregations.


r/exjw • • 2h ago

HELP I am unsure where to go from here

9 Upvotes

Hello everyone, and thanks for reading. I’ll try and keep this concise.

Born and raised, always had many questions but baptised late teens to keep my parents happy. After a couple years doubts became much harder to leave be. For the last 10 years I have been seriously questioning and whenever I tried to find answers I just got more disillusioned. I have not regularly been participating for about 4 years and the last year or so I have not participated apart from a handful of meetings. The last couple weeks I have realised I cannot keep trying to make myself believe something I don’t believe. Since coming to that point I’ve felt a lot of freedom and a lot less depression. Oddly this has also decreased my CSA flashbacks drastically, I think because a lot of the abuser’s excuses for it were tied up with JW stuff. Anyway, I feel good about my decision. Actually more than good. I don’t feel suicidal for the first time since being five years old. But logistically things are tricky.
1)I rent from a JW. I’m actively looking for a new place as i know they want to rent to JWs so I feel guilty being here now. Is this guilt reasonable? Should I tell them when I find a new place this is why? I am unsure how to handle it.
2) so far I have only told a family member and two friends, one of whom has also left. The family member and friend who are still in where kind and said they didn’t agree but respected my decision and nothing about our relationships have changed. However the reason I chose those specific people to tell is because I pretty much knew they would react well. I’m really worried about hurting my other close friends, but it feels wrong to just pretend like nothing has changed.

Edit to add it’s not just friends, but I’m wrestling with telling my parents. My dad was the person who was abusing me when I was a kid so they’re both sort of complicated relationships, but I still don’t want to hurt them. And because we still talk it also feels strange keeping this massive change from them. I know the fact we keep in touch will be incomprehensible to some people and that’s ok, I’m not asking for advice on that situation specifically, more so from the JW angle, but I did think it was relevant to add as i feel I owe them a lot less than one might normally feel with parents, so the desire to tell mainly comes from this feeling I’m holding this massive thing back every time we speak


r/exjw • • 23h ago Bravo Heartwarming

WT Can't Stop Me I can’t be more excited to turn this in

Post image
261 Upvotes

Finally gained the courage to do this. I’m having my husband drop it off for me since he’s unfortunately still in. I’m almost free!!


r/exjw • • 4h ago

PIMO Life How did you figure out what YOU wanted after leaving the JW blueprint?

8 Upvotes

I recently ended a relationship with someone I genuinely cared about, and it has made me realize how much my idea of a relationship has changed as my life has changed.

She is still heavily invested in the organization, while over roughly the past couple years I’ve started questioning things and allowing myself to think more independently about what I actually believe and what I want my life to look like.

For most of my life, I was used to a very structured environment where there was already a framework for what a “good” life and a “good” relationship were supposed to look like. There was a path. You found a good person, supported each other, shared the same spiritual framework, and built your life around it.

A few years ago, I honestly think I would have been completely satisfied with that.

But my lifestyle and goals have changed dramatically. I’m dreaming much bigger now. I’m exploring different interests, meeting different kinds of people, pursuing things I’m passionate about and, for probably the first time in my life, really asking myself what I want my future to look like instead of assuming I already know.

That has changed what I want from a relationship too.

The person I was dating was genuinely kind, supportive, affectionate and caring. That’s part of what has made ending it so painful. There wasn’t some huge betrayal or obvious reason the relationship was bad. There was a lot about it that was genuinely beautiful.

But over time, I kept feeling like most of the momentum in the relationship was coming from me.

I was initiating a lot of the experiences, conversations, questions and direction. I started realizing that I didn’t just want someone who supported what I was doing or was happy to come along with my ideas. I wanted energy coming toward me too.

I wanted to be surprised by the other person’s ideas. I wanted them to introduce me to things I never would have discovered myself. I wanted disagreement and different perspectives. I wanted to hear what they wanted without always having to draw it out. I wanted to occasionally be the one following someone else’s curiosity or enthusiasm.

Basically, I realized I wanted shared authorship.

Not one person creating a life and the other person supporting it, but two people with their own curiosity, interests, goals and sense of direction who influence each other and create something neither of them would have created alone.

The difference in where we stood with the organization made me realize something even bigger.

I no longer wanted everything in the relationship to have to be understood through one predetermined lens.

For her, that spiritual framework is still very important, and I respect that. But I’m at a point where I need the freedom to examine that framework itself. I want to discover what I believe, what another person believes, what we value, and what kind of relationship works for us through actually knowing each other and experiencing life together.

I don’t want either person to have to become less of themselves for the relationship to work.

That has been difficult to accept because from the outside I had something good. Sometimes I felt crazy for not just being satisfied with the status quo.

And I still miss her a lot.

I’m not posting this to criticize her or her beliefs. If anything, the relationship taught me how much I value kindness, affection, attentiveness and having someone who genuinely cares about me. Those are things I absolutely want in my life.

But I learned that support alone isn’t enough for me.

I don’t only want someone who supports my fire. I want to encounter theirs.

So now I’m trying to figure out what comes next, and I’d especially appreciate advice from people who are further down this road.

For those who started questioning after spending most of their life inside the organization, how did you learn what you actually wanted once your life was no longer already mapped out for you?

How did you build friendships, community and relationships outside of that structure? How did you figure out what compatibility meant to you personally? How did your idea of a partner or marriage change? And how did you avoid immediately replacing one predetermined path with another?

Right now, I’m trying to let myself explore, meet people, pursue my goals, experience different things and allow my idea of a good life to develop through actually living it.

For those who have gone through something similar, what would you recommend focusing on at this stage?

What do you wish you had understood when you first started building a life that was actually your own?


r/exjw • • 11h ago

Venting Great tribulation anxiety

24 Upvotes

I still live with my JW family, because of difficult to explain circumstances we barely go to meetings (often just the Memorial/Assembly/Convention) and just watch on zoom. So I'm definitely still greatly affected by the religion but am probably able to distance myself more than the average PIMO. I'm 23 and haven't really participated in the religion since my mid teens, and for the most part haven't believed in it since my late teens or so. 99% of the time I've basically gotten rid of my fear of the end of the world and don't really think about it.

But I feel like once a year or so some major political event happens and I get really anxious and sometimes spiral for weeks. I'm not really sure what I can do about this. I feel like I've thought through why I don't believe in this anymore but still, at an instinctual(?) level I just get incredibly anxious. The recent example is the Trump/Xi/Putin thing, and as I'm typing this I don't have much fear about that whole event fortunately. But when I first saw it my heart sank and my chest hurt so much, I couldn't focus on anything that whole day. I think last year it was some of the Iran stuff that caused this intense fear. Before that it's been other random UN announcements throughout the years.

Probably mostly venting honestly, not sure if there's any solution other than just having more time outside of the religion, especially once I move out. But if anyone does have any advice I'm definitely open to it.


r/exjw • • 3h ago

Venting i feel like i cant escape this

5 Upvotes

Basically, i turned 16 a few months ago and as time passes i thought i would be more free. I told my mom at 12 that i didnt really identify myself with the other brothers and sisters and the community itself. Later I did more research and i came to the conclusion that i really didnt believe anything that they said.
I had this conversation with my mom so many times and she just tells me that i have to believe in what she believes.
As time passes i just grow more disgust to them and to their beliefs, yet i am forced to attend every meeting. I spend the meetings in the bathroom crying and throwing up because i feel that everyone there is disgusted by me, they stopped talking to me at 12 when my mother spread the word that i was having worldly thoughts, i feel that everyone there expects me to be something that I am not just because i grew up there.
I am currently with some brothers and sisters, they keep talking about how i need to be closer to Jehovah, i have had so many thoughts about ending my own life because i cant keep up with the thought that my own mother wont talk to me anymore when i step out of the congregation and i dont have any more family that talks to me beside my mother and my brother (he believes in it too and judges me too)
It gives me stomach pain just to enter that kingdom hall, some brothers look me with other eyes or give me too many kisses, but i cant talk about it because its just their way of showing brother love acording to everyone.
I am not active on reddit, this is my first time posting something, but i just need to talk to someone who understands this, i feel that everyone that i talk about it just thinks im overreacting.
Sorry if theres mistakes, english isnt my first language.


r/exjw • • 19h ago Bravo

Venting All Religions are cults and fairy tales meant to control you

105 Upvotes

It makes me sad seeing people here leave the JW cult and then proceed to look for some other religion in Christianity or anywhere else. Please educate yourselves beyond just this cult and realize that God doesn't exist and all religion is man made to control the masses. If you're sad about your life there is meaning in an infinite number of places in this world, but there is no meaning to be found in believing fairy tales. We are responsible for breaking the loop that humanity has been slaved by for thousands of years that is religion. Science is the only concrete and verifiable thing is this world, lets grow up please.


r/exjw • • 2h ago

Ask ExJW Since when did elders start using chat to prepare talks?

4 Upvotes

Okay, so my little brother has a part on Tuesday’s meeting with an elder from our congregation.
The elder sent him the script today so he could prepare, and I kid you not, that thing was SO obviously written by chat . 😭 Like, not even an attempt to make it sound natural or like something an actual person would say.
I genuinely had to laugh because aren’t these the same people constantly emphasizing the importance of personal study, preparation, and putting effort into spiritual activities? And now we’re apparently letting Chat do the spiritual heavy lifting? 💀It’s even funnier because this is an ELDER. Like, sir, you’re supposed to be setting the example here. 😭
Has anyone else noticed elders or other JWs using chatto prepare their meeting parts lately? Because I’m genuinely curious how common this has become.


r/exjw • • 10h ago

WT Policy PIMO's question for PIMI JW's: "Do you think we should copy the faithful slave's example?"

15 Upvotes

PIMI: "What do you mean?"

PIMO: "Over the past number of years they have been testing (1 John 4:1) and rejecting various literature truths & teachings (ftn.) as being incompatible with the Bible, so shouldn't we also closely examine what we currently believe?"

ftn. Only the G.B. is the "slave"; there's now no such thing as the 'evil' slave; no need to record ministry; no need to wear suit, collar & tie; women can wear trousers/pants; men can now grow beards; JW's can now accept blood components.

20 years ago, any JW voicing such opinions would have been disfellowshipped and branded an apostate! (Satan's seed)


r/exjw • • 11h ago

Ask ExJW Family Friend Died: Going Back In the Swarm

16 Upvotes

A family friend died and so I drove my 75 yo mom over to the house as soon as we heard. It was night time and dark and my mom should not drive when she is upset.

I know our family friend and the family. The man who died was very well loved and was a kind and generous man. The house was swarming with people, most of whom I’ve never met. They love my mom and she was eager to introduce me.

I am very short 5’0 on a tall day so it is easy for me to be physically overwhelmed by others simply due to the height difference. Plus the place was packed so personal space was hard to maintain.

All that said I realized I did a great job of being friendly and polite without being overly familiar.

It was striking to me how many people upon meeting me started to hug me while I smiled, said “nice to meet you” and offered a hand.

There was a time I would have just given in to the hugging. But this time I did not.

Is this a new trend to hug as much? Has it always been this way and I’m just now noticing??

At any rate, I was curious how I would do in a setting where I was the outsider. I did pretty good. I didn’t feel awkward and I maintained my boundaries.

All in all a good trial.


r/exjw • • 22h ago

WT Can't Stop Me David Splane said the flood came in 2370 BCE. Yet Egyptians built pyramids before, during and after the flood. Their culture was around the whole time.

118 Upvotes

The Egyptian Empire existed before the "flood" and after the "flood". The dating of the pyramids are:

The 1st Dynasty tombs at Saqqara (2920-2770 BC).

The Djoser pyramid (2630-2611 BC).

The Giza Pyramids (2551-2472BC).

A selection of 5th Dynasty pyramids (2465-2323 BC).

A selection of 6th Dynasty pyramids (2323-2150 BC).

A selection of Middle Kingdom pyramids (2040-1640 BC).

It amazes me how unqualified to teach anyone these GB members are, especially Splane. As a fellow Canadian, I am embarrassed he is one.

Not only did the Egyptian empire thrive, the land of "Israel" was part of Egypt after the Exodus for a few hundred years. The Jews didn't leave Egypt.

(Source: JW Broadcasting David H Splane: Do the Math)